Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to tell friend the moment has passed?

65 replies

AutumnBliss · 06/09/2021 18:39

Both Good friend and I turned 40 the same year. Hers was a few months before mine. We ended up going for a very expensive meal for hers and I spent a fair bit on her present. I made quite a fuss of her. I even made her a cake.

Then it was mine. She was on holiday when I celebrated it but she told me she had a gift for me and we’d celebrate some other time. I’ve seen her a good number of times since then and it has never materialised. That’s absolutely fine, I’m not a child, but she annoyingly keeps bringing it up e.g. “oh, I must bring your present”. She doesn’t live far so it’s not hard to drop it off.

AIBU to say the moment has passed and stop bringing it up. The main reason being that last month was my 41st and the moment really has passed. I don’t want to be still having this conversation when I am 60. I am a bit miffed that hers was a massive event but mine was unimportant but that’s fine, I’ve learned my lesson.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
TheyDoItOnPurposeLynne · 07/09/2021 18:20

Sounds like she's been a crappy friend but I must say that some people are uncomfortable with big birthday gestures.
I've got a friend who arranged a weekend of surprise outings and parties for my 40th and it was a lovely gesture buy I didn't ask for it!
I found the whole weekend quite knackering and at times overwhelming.
I've never been able to reciprocate that kind of generosity for her, maybe I'm a terrible friend.

WhereYouLeftIt · 07/09/2021 18:10

"she annoyingly keeps bringing it up e.g. “oh, I must bring your present”."

I would have to reply to that next time. Maybe -

  • Yes, you must.
  • You do realise that I'm 41 now?
  • Shall I just come back to yours and pick it up now?
  • You've been saying that for a year now.
  • Ahahahahahahahha! Like I believe you ever got me a present! Good one!
aalidfeie · 07/09/2021 17:12

I would swerve this person - I cannot stand that kind of thing. Either get me a present or dont, but dont keep going on about it like you have when you clearly haven't - it is beyond dull. She sounds selfish and a bit of dick.
As you get older you realise that you really don't need these people. Make room for more considerate friends.

Snoozer11 · 07/09/2021 13:46

@tempchecked

"Friends" can be highly overrated. That's why I don't have any lol. Learned the lessons big time. I'm older now and couldn't give a toss anymore.

Many are high maintenance, constantly late, break confidences, are users, unreliable,and all for a cup of coffee or a drink now and then.

Forgive me or shoot me now.

You've cracked it.
LagneyandCasey · 07/09/2021 13:29

I was all ready to say 'Cut her some slack, she's probably busy' until you said your 41st had come and gone!

She obviously doesn't value the friendship as much as you do.

Let us know if she ever turns up with it. Maybe she's also thinking the moment has passed and is saving it for your 50th Grin

HintofVintagePink · 07/09/2021 13:28

If the gift was that amazing she would have been banging down your door to hand it over, so she could rack up the ‘I’m a great friend’ points.

She possibly had a vague idea of something she might get you, but life got in the way and she never got round to it. There is no gift.

zingally · 07/09/2021 13:17

I'm still waiting for the "so sorry you're leaving" present a work colleague (and friend!) told me she'd got me, that I was going to LOVE...!

That was over 3 years ago.

LBirch02 · 07/09/2021 12:47

No YANBU OP. I got fed up with a friend as I felt she was generally selfish . This was a few years ago. I started pulling back - she sensed this and only then said “oh sorry I forgot your birthday” - I thought to myself it’s strange that only when I’m pulling back on the so called “Friendship” is she choosing to remember my birthday? It ended in a bitter row and we’re not friends now

AutumnBliss · 07/09/2021 12:22

As pp said op, it was presumably your choice to take your friend out for a meal

Well, yes and no. She wanted to go to this place to celebrate her birthday and asked us to join her. We didn't feel right in saying it was too expansive as we were all under the impression from her that 40th's were huge and to be celebrated in style.

Just her's so it happens.

OP posts:
Ultraopaque · 07/09/2021 11:31

@AutumnBliss

Her birthday cost me hundreds and I actually feel a massive mug.
Gosh. My friends and I never spend money like that on each other. A bunch of flowers or maybe a home made cake or chocolates or a bottle of wine with a card is sufficient.

As pp said op, it was presumably your choice to take your friend out for a meal. I am sorry she hasn't reciprocated in kind as you anticipated, but I think you need to forget about it. She may be out of pocket from her holiday. Or she may be just selfish. Either way, you need to decide if this is worth terminating the friendship over, or if you want to still be her friend, and act accordingly. And if she brings it up again fhs just let her off the hook graciously. Not in a million years would I lower myself by suggesting that I pop around to her house to pick up your "supposed" present. Seriously, having just lost a friend to cancer, there are far more important things in life to worry about.

TemptedToSleepInTheShed · 07/09/2021 11:17

That’s really poor form from her and you have every right to be pissed off.

I have the opposite going on at the moment. It was my 40th first and 3 months before it my friend said as it was a big birthday we should do something special, leave it to her she would organise something as a surprise. Which I thought was really very sweet of her. Not necessary at all, but thank you.

I gave a few ideas of things we could do; road trip to a new city to explore / train into London for shopping and a pub crawl / check out that restaurant for dinner that we keep meaning to go to but haven’t yet….. all suggestions met with “leave it to me”

One week before my birthday she tells me she hasn’t got round to arranging anything, sorry. We had not fallen out in this time or anything btw.

She was a bit upset about it all and I didn’t want my bday to be a cause of upset or stress (I wasn’t fussed about doing anything major in the first place!) so I said don’t worry about it, shall we go to [local chain restaurant that we be been to umpteen times before and always have a good time at] for dinner that will be nice.

We did. And somehow I ended up paying for both of us!

Her 40th is in a few weeks and she keeps on telling me how excited she is for her bday surprise from me…

I am actually planning something brilliant and putting in a fair amount of effort, and although I am excited to be doing it for her, I do think it’s a shame that this whole thing has been so one sided.

blubberyboo · 07/09/2021 11:10

Do you never go to her house?
I’d go round for coffee take a sip and then look round me saying

“ ooh I’m excited for my 40th birthday present”

You’ll know right at that moment if it was ever purchased - -or regifted to you at Xmas- -

GertietheGherkin · 07/09/2021 11:01

I'd call in unexpectedly and say you were passing by.

You could then say you can take your present, and save her a journey with it.

IrishCharm · 07/09/2021 10:48

You’re not a mug OP xx
Next time she brings it up be ready with some ridiculous sentence like
“Oh we’re well and truly so far down the river and round the bend you may well hold onto it for my 50th”
😂
Then either leave, go to the loo, put the kettle on, Hoover ……..
But point will be made and you keep your head held high x

sameproblem · 07/09/2021 10:28

I'm in the text and offer to pick it up camp. That will shut her up.

AuntieStella · 07/09/2021 10:25

If she was terminally disorganised, and she really was so used to tripping over your pressie in the hall that she doesnt 'see' it any more, you'd probably know this character trait?

Yes, it probably doesn't exist, and YANBU to ask her to refrain if she mentions it again.

whatwasIgoingtosay · 07/09/2021 10:17

This is not OK. She's a CF. I had a friend who would say, every year for several months, I must bring you your Xmas present. Then around Easter she would turn up with a scruffily wrapped present in Xmas paper - it was always either a diary or calendar! I took the hint after a few years and stopped giving her a Xmas present.

friendlycat · 07/09/2021 10:06

Yes it would annoy me too and I would want to put a stop to the comments going forward. I think I would simply say what you have ..
"I think that moment has passed now, don't you? Especially as I'm now 41."

Then I would just change the subject but note her reaction. Of course it's nonsense in this amount of time. She's had ample time to do something but has not bothered and somehow thinks it is OK to keep mentioning it as if that somehow makes it all OK which it doesn't. It just makes it worse.

Lanique · 07/09/2021 10:03

Yes I would tell her the moment has passed. In fact, I would go one step further and say, "please stop bullshitting me. I know you don't have a gift for me so let's stop pretending eh." But that's because I'm a grumpy 45 year old now with a very low tolerance for bullshit these days Wink.

billy1966 · 07/09/2021 09:58

Whatever she is OP, she isn't a good friend.

They really don't behave like that.

CF's do.

I can understand you feeling like a mug but it really isn't your fault.

She is just a dishonest, crass CF.

Sorry.Flowers

Pinkdelight3 · 07/09/2021 09:58

I wouldn't see it as being a mug. It's not like you didn't eat the nice meal. You got what you paid for and presumably had a nice time, so I'd recast it in your mind as that. If you hadn't been turning 40 that same year, there wouldn't be this expectation that you should get the same out of it or else you're a massive mug. You went (voluntarily) to a fancy restaurant for your friend's 40th and enjoyed it. That's one thing.

Your friend being lame about mentioning a gift that's never materialised is another thing. Tell her that moment has passed by all means and that sting of embarrassment should equal the sting of her being useless about it. But that's all I'd frame it as. Not build it into anything bigger to get bitter about.

3luckystars · 07/09/2021 09:49

You have not been a mug, you were just lied to and that’s not your fault.

There is no gift. What do you say when she says ‘oh I must drop over your gift’ ?

Next time don’t fill in the silence, just stay quiet. If she changes the subject say ‘what is the gift, I can’t wait to see it’ stay silent again.

Stay on the subject.

There is no gift. She will either cut you off completely or buy you something shite and resent spending her money on you.

I think that £100 was the best money you ever spent. It revealed all.

RicherThanYew · 07/09/2021 09:47

@tempchecked You're completely right. I had a large group of friends some years back but now I have 1 friend and then "acquaintances.

secular39 · 07/09/2021 09:44

Yep, I had a friend like this. I was just glad that I didn't spend no more than £20.00 on her birthday gift as I knew she would have never returned the favour and would keep saying "I will get you your present soon".

Notgoodatchoosingnames · 07/09/2021 09:42

I have a friend like this. I bought her a beautiful gift for her 40th (as I have done for all our friends 40ths) and she told me she had something for mine 6 months later that I would get next time I saw her. It hasn't been mentioned since. Neither has mine and DH's wedding gift. We've just celebrated our 6th wedding anniversary. Though she doesn't bring it up past the first time she mentions it. Then it's done.
She's also the last to pay you back if you've paid for something, last to get a round. And no she doesn't have financial worries. At all!

Swipe left for the next trending thread