Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel sad that all other kids were given something by visiting relatives apart from my son?

156 replies

mummabubs · 06/09/2021 12:06

I will completely own that I am delightfully hormonal following a recent birth and there is also a little bit of a backstory with me feeling like my firstborn is treated differently by other members of my DH's family compared to the other grandchildren already, which I guess is relevant to this. But big girl pants on, I am more than happy to be told I'm being unreasonable!

This is all beautifully outing, but I don't have the energy to try and change details... DH's aunt and uncle visited us at my in-laws' house over the weekend, we haven't seen them for about 2 years now due to COVID and their visits being an annual thing anyway. DSIL, BIL and our two nieces were there too. (Hope that all makes sense!) We have a 4 year old DS and a 15 week old DD. DH aunt is renowned for being 'blunt' as she puts it, and in usual form breezes into the room, coos over our DD saying how beautiful she is and follows this up with "I really like girls, but I can't stand boys, never have". She then says how she likes babies but doesn't like children. Arguably quite tactless, but I politely laughed this off and told my DS to cover his ears. They brought out a lovely gift for our DD which is very kind of them and we genuinely appreciated it and thanked them. Then goodie bags come out for my two nieces who are 4 and 7, nothing big but a token something for them both. The conversation then moves on and it becomes really clear that there is nothing for my 4 year old son. To be clear, the gift for DD was an item of baby clothing so definitely not something that could have been a joint gift for her and DS.

To be honest I didn't expect a gift for DD at all and it was very kind of them, but I was left feeling really quite sad later that my DS had been left out given his cousins were then given something too. Equality amongst the children is important to me (which is where the backstory of me already feeling like he's not shown as much interest as the girls is relevant). DH aunt has always been open about being blunt in what she says and does and attributes this to her cultural upbringing, although my feelings on this are that her brothers (so my FiL included) are not like this at all and if I'm honest I think it's just rude. I'm feeling brave, AIBU to be feeling sensitive about the situation or was it likely a complete oversight on their part and I'm just looking for ways to validate my feelings of him being treated differently?

Thanks all.

OP posts:
prsphne · 06/09/2021 15:28

I’m blunt, but I’m not cruel. I don’t particularly have the inclination to sugar coat what I’m saying and I don’t take the time to ‘guess’ what people are thinking, nor do I expect to them to guess what I am thinking.

I would NEVER in front of a little boy say I didn’t like boys or children. That’s not blunt, it’s rude and mean.

I might also accidentally overlook buying a gift for someone if my intentions weren’t to buy a gift for everyone, eg if I saw something for the girls of the cuff and then got the new baby a present (I would like to think I’d notice that I hadn’t bought for just one though!), but being “blunt” I would have no issue at all at being called out on what I’d done - other than being mortified I’d left a child out, not because of you calling me out on it.

If she is blunt, be blunt back. Let her know you/DS are upset about being left out and she should keep her opinions about him to herself and treat him equally.

DuckbilledSplatterPuff · 06/09/2021 15:25

@saraclara

What she said is way worse than what she did. I appreciate that you were caught on the hop when you laughed it off, but seriously?' "I don't like boys" in front of your four year old? That's horrific. And if a great uncle said that about girls in front of a daughter, I suspect that you'd have found it harder to laugh it off.

I would be absolutely blunt back at her. I normally avoid confrontation, but I'd absolutely contact her after the fact, with an email or a call. Start off by acknowledging that she says herself that she's always blunt, and so you're sure that she will appreciate you being blunt in return. Then tell her that her saying that in front of her great nephew was entirely unacceptable and hurtful, and that you trust that she will, in future, keep those thoughts to herself, treat him with kindness, and when it comes to gifts and gestures, with equity with his cousins.

This
AmyDudley · 06/09/2021 15:21

I think with 'blunt' aka rude and nasty people, if you call them out at the time they may well say something even worse, that would be really upsetting for a child to hear. I think in future if you know Vile Auntie is going to be around be ready to not accept a gift for your DD if she hasn't brought one for your DS. And be ready to say 'what a horrible thing to say, how nasty and unkind' if she makes remarks about not liking boys.
But actually I'd just try to avoid her as your poor DS will definitely notice as he grows older. And you can say 'Auntie is a cow ignore her' as many times as you like, he will still feel hurt unless you prevent the unfairness. (I doubt she'll change, horrid people generally don't, so avoidance is probably only solution)

Lipsandlashes · 06/09/2021 14:53

You are definitely not being unreasonable and she is frankly disgusting. How an adult could do that to a child is absolutely beyond me.

MrsScrubbithatescleaning · 06/09/2021 14:48

I can appreciate that it was your in-laws family so you’d be wary of being wrong footed. Must admit however, the idea of falling out with another family member or causing a fracas wouldn’t bother me at all.

I want my kids to see that I have their backs when others treat them like shit. I wouldn’t be rude and agressive but I would make my point very clearly so there’s no room for misunderstandings.

I think you need to have a serious talk with your DH about him putting his children’s feelings above his fear of not rocking the boat. My dad was a total people pleaser and I had no respect for him at all growing up. I’m sure your DH won’t want that to happen?

m0therofdragons · 06/09/2021 14:46

My aunt was/is the same - loves me because I have 3dds but she has two dds and 1 ds and treated them differently. She does love my db now because he has a Cambridge degree she can boast about. It’s utterly bizarre but I think it’s a mental health thing and she possibly has autism. We were always open about it in our family - auntie Sarah is a bit nuts and doesn’t like boys. It was a family “joke” but at the same time made very clear it wasn’t acceptable. Her ex husband is loved by us all and known as poor old Adam. Don’t give her much headspace. You can’t change her.

LizBennet · 06/09/2021 14:44

@MsTSwift

Also I do wonder if these “why didn’t you challenge at the time” types would he quite so brave themselves in real life! I am no shrinking violet as I’ve got older but no way would I have called this out in this scenario.
I agree, also agree with pp I wouldn’t have wanted my son to feel worse about it Sad
Tiredout123 · 06/09/2021 14:44

I'm angry for you! That's terrible. I've had similar issues with in laws and I wish I'd cut them out for my ds sake. My husband never would deal with it. Disgusting behaviour. People that treat kids like this surely can't be right in the head. Not v helpful, I know.

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 06/09/2021 14:42

People do tend to advocate NC at the drop of a hat but some things are incredibly damaging to the wellbeing of a child. The 'favourites' game falls into this category for me.

Were this a grandparent I'd allow contact to continue on the strict condition that it stops right now, and the very least of the hardball tactics I'd be inclined to use is to hand back all the gifts (and replace them for the other children at a later point, explaining why), and tell her forcefully that she does not get to play 'golden child' vs. 'scapegoat' games with my children. You are the parent: with the support (hopefully) of your DH you are perfectly within your rights to do this.

A PP said: You can't tell her who to buy presents for ffs.

True, but you as a parent can decline them and thus protect one of your children from being singled out for mistreatment. Exclusion is one of the worst forms of bullying - more damaging still when it happens within families - and you have every right as a parent to put a stop to it. And having just re-looked at your post this isn't even the children's aunt, but DH's?

Hell, no!

babybunny123 · 06/09/2021 14:40

Horrible old bag, there are no other words !!!

Clymene · 06/09/2021 14:38

That's not just rude, it's cruel. I don't think I would have said anything at the time either because she's not your aunt but I would let your ILs know you don't want to see her again and why.

mummabubs · 06/09/2021 14:37

@ThumbWitchesAbroad

So whose sister is she - MIL's or FIL's? And is whichever is the sibling similar in outlook, or do they not do this sexist favouritism?

I'm really irritated that they all just stood back and let it go, tbh.

I mean, I can understand to some extent why SIL didn't say anything as her kids weren't left out, so not her position to rock the boat - but the sibling of said Aunt should have pulled her up on it!

FiL's sister. She's got a strong narrative that FiL always got his way growing up (possibly where some of her anti-boy rhetoric comes from?) Truth be told my FiL is a very gentle and polite man so can't really see it myself! He avoids conflict even more than my DH does so doubt that he'd say anything, if he even noticed. There's a strong dynamic on my in-laws side of the women being loud and what they want they get sort of vibe.
OP posts:
MsTSwift · 06/09/2021 14:36

Also I do wonder if these “why didn’t you challenge at the time” types would he quite so brave themselves in real life! I am no shrinking violet as I’ve got older but no way would I have called this out in this scenario.

Bumblesbumbles · 06/09/2021 14:34

Totally unfair on your poor son. Surely it’s not hard to understand that children get excited by presents and will be hugely disappointed if they are the only one not to get one.

I had similar involving my children’s grandparents. They bought a beautiful present for my daughter (ca. £40) and didn’t have anything for my son so said maybe he could have an item (meant for v young child) she had got second hand. Her response was ‘he gets what he’s given’

mummabubs · 06/09/2021 14:33

I think you summed up the situation brilliantly @randomlyLostInWales (Love the username btw!)

OP posts:
saraclara · 06/09/2021 14:33

What she said is way worse than what she did. I appreciate that you were caught on the hop when you laughed it off, but seriously?' "I don't like boys" in front of your four year old? That's horrific. And if a great uncle said that about girls in front of a daughter, I suspect that you'd have found it harder to laugh it off.

I would be absolutely blunt back at her. I normally avoid confrontation, but I'd absolutely contact her after the fact, with an email or a call. Start off by acknowledging that she says herself that she's always blunt, and so you're sure that she will appreciate you being blunt in return. Then tell her that her saying that in front of her great nephew was entirely unacceptable and hurtful, and that you trust that she will, in future, keep those thoughts to herself, treat him with kindness, and when it comes to gifts and gestures, with equity with his cousins.

mummabubs · 06/09/2021 14:31

@MrsScrubbithatescleaning

I can’t believe you didn’t say anything at the time as I definitely would have done. You need to send the clothes present back and make it clear why you’re returning it to her.

However, I also think your DH should talk to his brother or sister (whichever it is) and tell them what happened in case they didn’t see it for themselves. There’s no way I’d condone this appalling favouritism from a distant relative and I know my siblings wouldn’t either. I’d be asking my sibling to send back the nieces gifts and telling the aunt that all the family children should be treated equally or not at all.

It's a fair comment. I think at the time I was a bit taken aback as I assumed there would be something for him to follow so didn't say anything. And then it was 5/10 minutes later so felt like the moment had passed if that makes sense? Probably relevant is that DH can't stand conflict - I mean, no one enjoys it do they. His family don't really do communication that well and he actively goes out of his way to avoid saying anything that might upset the status quo within his family. The ironic side effect of all this is that there's lots of hidden conflict bubbling away under the surface from all directions. My family are different in that we feel able to calmly share when there's things we don't agree on or upset us and we know that if we upset eachother it doesn't mean the end of our familial relationships. I've offered to say things to DH's family on several topics in the past and he's asked me not to as he fears how anything seen as a disagreement would be perceived. Out of respect for his wishes and the fact it's not really my family I keep my mouth shut. That's worked fine until we had kids and things happen that may affect them.
OP posts:
MsTSwift · 06/09/2021 14:30

I think it’s unrealistic of posters to upbraid the op on not challenging this at the time. I mean really who would do that at a family gathering! Would be utter cringe and a shouting match / bad feeling would upset a 4 year old more than the lack of gift and would be a horrid memory for him. I would explain to him some grown ups can be mean and silly and we won’t be seeing her again. Returning the gift would make you look abit mental.

nokidshere · 06/09/2021 14:29

My mum has form for favouritism. She's got,away with it for years with my sisters children. I don't accept one gift (unless it is a birthday). She can treat both or neither.

ThumbWitchesAbroad · 06/09/2021 14:27

So whose sister is she - MIL's or FIL's? And is whichever is the sibling similar in outlook, or do they not do this sexist favouritism?

I'm really irritated that they all just stood back and let it go, tbh.

I mean, I can understand to some extent why SIL didn't say anything as her kids weren't left out, so not her position to rock the boat - but the sibling of said Aunt should have pulled her up on it!

Summerfun54321 · 06/09/2021 14:26

It’s not too late to tell your son that this particular aunt was cruel and that it’s not kind to exclude others. Let him know that what she did was wrong, we can’t always think on the spot to defend our kids. She sounds nasty.

lunar1 · 06/09/2021 14:25

I don't think you or your children need to spend any more time with her. I'd return your dd's gift.

Notonthestairs · 06/09/2021 14:21

Either you don't visit them next year or you get in advance warning in - "we treat our children the same, if you can't then it's best we don't see you."

randomlyLostInWales · 06/09/2021 14:20

How was this not raised at the time?

because OP was shocked and hadn't worked out how to handle the situation and felt at a disadvatange becuase it's her DH family?

because she didn't want to draw attention to the situation and upset her DS - and from her posts clearly hoped he hadn't noticed (though agree with PP he probably did)

As this is a rarely seen Great Aunty - I'd avoid all future interactions or try IL and/or DH to see if they'll intercede on your DS behalf - though whether I'd trust that would depend on how well that went.

Sometime mishandling a situation even when someone is clearly being a rude fucker can put you in the wrong in wider families eyes and make a situation much worse. So I think the OP waiting talking to her DH than asking on here how to handle going forward rather than blowing up in the moment is probably quite good way to handel situation as so much can depends on the family dynamics.

Miracle29 · 06/09/2021 14:20

@oakleaffy we had a teacher like that aswell she hated boys. My son needed extra help at the time and she was the one who was meant to be helping but he came home once and said he felt bullied by her as did a few other boys. We never understood why because she had sons herself! Makes my blood boil when people treat kids so differently.

Swipe left for the next trending thread