Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I'm so sick of people buying multiple properties for BTL

522 replies

flashbac · 06/09/2021 10:02

So the landlord next door has hoovered up another house on the street for BTL. A nice house that wasn't even on the market but they managed to get their mits on it. Yes I know I sound bitter because I am! I'm so fed up of investors hoovering up all the houses. There should be a limit but with most of our government being BTL landlords nothing will change.
I'm sick of the increasing gap between rich and poor.
now runs and hides because reckons half of MN have a BTL or holiday home

OP posts:
CBUK2K2 · 06/09/2021 16:30

What's more perverse than BTL is stamp duty, you actually get taxed for having the audacity to want to own a home for your family.

CBUK2K2 · 06/09/2021 16:29

@Tabitha005 A house builder needs to make a profit from a project for them to want to do it.

The affordable housing and taxes such as community infrastructure levy have to be added to the costs of the house builder which are ultimately paid for by the people who arent eligible for these subsidised homes. So yet again, this is an example of the "have a little's" getting screwed.

Between 5 and 20% of the cost of a new build home in taxes and subsidies such as this.

Journeyofthedragons · 06/09/2021 16:27

They could just bring in the type of rules you get in say France where the tenant has the automatic right to live there as long as they like and the annual rent increase is capped regardless of market conditions.

They have this in The Netherlands too, my landlord didn't know the rules and couldn't kick me out when they wanted to sell - after two years (when unbeknownst to them) I wanted to leave I wangled a reasonably large cash payout from them to vacate.

Sommernacht89 · 06/09/2021 16:26

@ supermoonrising
Yes, apparently in the last election it was the non working population of Britain that voted in the Tories,eg. Pensioners.I dont know many working people who vote Tory.

the80sweregreat · 06/09/2021 16:21

The whole ' an Englishman's home is his Castle ' thing doesn't help matters either.
We are brought up not to share things like resources etc. People want their own spaces and don't want to integrate that much.
Maybe a change is needed , but I think a lot of Brits would be a bit suspicious of a different way of living in a more 'communal ' type arrangement.

XingMing · 06/09/2021 16:20

And when we had that protected tenant legislation, before 1987, there was very little rented property because landlords had no control. Assured shortholds were introduced and landlords stepped up.

As I posted upthread earlier, some elderly relatives of slender means inherited 40 or so tenement houses, which they couldn't afford to maintain and from which they couldn't evict even the worst tenants. Rent controls were upheld by local councils to avoid adding to the pressure on social housing. This was long before Thatcher and the right to buy policy.

Iloveginger · 06/09/2021 16:16

That's one of the reasons we such huge waiting lists for council housing and private landlords can charge more. Without the private landlords there'd be even less available housing. One could even argue that if there is a surplus of privately let properties available this will drive rents down
No the reason that there are huge waiting lists for council properties, is because people want the security that a council tenancy offers, that is not available privately. They are trying to get out of over priced, often sub standard private housing.
A situation created by greedy 'feather your own nest' buy to let landlords.

3scape · 06/09/2021 16:16

The second (third, fourth) home double council tax could become standard.

Blinky21 · 06/09/2021 16:16

Would be nice if landlords invested to maintain their houses too, on my street the rentals are mostly eyesores, not fair on the tenants or the neighbours

ChateauMargaux · 06/09/2021 16:14

@elbea My point is that the distribution of land is unfair and the system (whether EU or UK government.. it all comes from our taxes) continues to support and uphold this disparity by enabling them to keep the land rather than selling it. They may well spend the money on the land but they have plenty of resources to pay for that out of their own funds.

Yes 'Greenpeace' haven't 'uncovered' this, they were bringing light to it.

And while there may well be environmental strategies involved in some land management, there are also significant environmental concerns around the management of land and its effect on flooding and carbon storage. These are not the green saviours of our land that some might like us to believe.

AllTheUsernamesAreAlreadyTaken · 06/09/2021 16:10

@NiceGerbil

Only read first few pages but I'm confused by the idea that certain things to do with this should only be available to the 'indigenous population'.

Who are they then?! I have no idea what is being suggested there!

I hoped they meant people who actually live in the uk (of any race, religion, nationality etc) instead of houses being bought by people who don’t live in the Uk or even visit the properties very often and being left empty for years as “investments”
MissConductUS · 06/09/2021 16:10

@Wherearemymarbles

They could just bring in the type of rules you get in say France where the tenant has the automatic right to live there as long as they like and the annual rent increase is capped regardless of market conditions.

That way a btl can be a liability not a cash machine as a tenant who has been there 15 years is likely paying well below market rate.

This has been suggested but Govt said no.

This would be a fine way to reduce the supply of rental properties.
BlueJag · 06/09/2021 16:09

@IceLace100 those properties normally have a low lease that's why they are sold to investors that pay cash.

Wherearemymarbles · 06/09/2021 16:07

They could just bring in the type of rules you get in say France where the tenant has the automatic right to live there as long as they like and the annual rent increase is capped regardless of market conditions.

That way a btl can be a liability not a cash machine as a tenant who has been there 15 years is likely paying well below market rate.

This has been suggested but Govt said no.

BlueJag · 06/09/2021 16:07

@DocAutumn where did you hear that? Deposit is normally 15%

NiceGerbil · 06/09/2021 16:02

Only read first few pages but I'm confused by the idea that certain things to do with this should only be available to the 'indigenous population'.

Who are they then?! I have no idea what is being suggested there!

XingMing · 06/09/2021 16:00

It's social housing, in Milan. If it can been done there, why not here?

londonrach · 06/09/2021 15:58

Yanbu. We tried to buy a house for several years and ever time it went to another BTL and it came up for rent. Finally one seller agreed to meet us aNd said wanted house to go to a family..we still here five years later....I suspect alot of the properties we put offers in the offer wasnt put forward...in fact in one I know it wasn't as the BTL paid less than we offered. The one I know our offer wasnt put forward we complained but despite having proof it wasn't worth it....

Tabitha005 · 06/09/2021 15:58

[quote babbi]@Tabitha005 fantastic post[/quote]
Thank you. I get a bit passionate about housing!

Tabitha005 · 06/09/2021 15:57

@XingMing

Flats would be more appealing if they were planned like this bosco verticale
I love that design! Visiting my brother in Berlin recently, I was struck by just how many apartment buildings with balconies had made use of the space for growing plants, flowers and vegetables - in many case ENTIRE apartment blocks looking very much like that one in the photo of the link you've shared.

I've never seen such a big determination to make use of even the smallest balcony space to grow anything here in the UK - it was as though whole blocks had made some collective conscious decision to do it. We walked down one particular street in Berlin, full of fairly newly-built apartment blocks (there's a LOT of building going on in the city right now) where every single balcony was ablaze with potted plants and flowers, climbing roses and containers growing tomatoes, fennel, chilli peppers, cucumbers and other veggies. It honestly was a weird sight - quite literally took my breath away - because I've never seen anything like it in London. It can't just be that Berliners (and I include the huge population of non-German people who live in Berlin in that statement as there's definitely a certain, holistic vibe to some parts of the city) have some natural affinity for growing plants and flowers, but it sort of feels like there's some kind of unspoken, collective consciousness that's taken hold and by NOT doing it, you'd be the odd one out.

incognitodorrito · 06/09/2021 15:54

@flashbac

And that Homes Under The Hammer programme needs to p i s s off and die!
I really despise that programme - ingrate the way they renovate them as they all look like utter shit afterwards. Greedy bastards.
CanIPleaseHaveOne · 06/09/2021 15:51

@ComtesseDeSpair

The problem isn’t, per se, the tenure in which housing stock is held. The problem is that housing is unaffordable in many areas because we don’t have enough housing in the areas most people want to live. If we had enough housing stock then we wouldn’t need to worry about BTL landlords because the market would even out.

Should the government restrict the size of property each individual can own according to family size, because large houses with big gardens and garages and driveways take up a plot which could be used to build three of four more modest homes?

The problem is way bigger than BTL. Hedge funds buying vast amount of properties driving up prices, and controling rental stock/ price is a considerable problem in many countries including the UK. It is detrimental, and will only get worse unless legislation or regulation is put in place.
Plumtree391 · 06/09/2021 15:48

That sounds lovely, Misty.

I wouldn't like the communal courtyards because I have known a few places with them and you can get a lot of problems. Obviously the problems are not the fault of the architects, builders or owners but the people who live there but I have to say they would put me off such a place.

However the rest of what you describe sounds idyllic.

There are estates answering that description in some places. I browse Rightmove with the vague idea of moving in the not too distant future (but not far from where I am at the moment, just smaller and easier to maintain), and I see them pop up here and there. However there are obviously not enough of them.

I let a flat somewhere else, it was in the family and following a death, it has been mine. The tenants have been in for almost a year and have dreadful arrears on their rent. I gave them some leeway because of circumstances but there have been months when they've paid nothing at all. I'm still paying the mortgage and the flat is up for sale. The tenants, a young couple, have first refusal but I've heard nothing.

The estate agents told me that someone viewed the flat and the tenants told him they had no intention of moving out. Yet it was only let pending sale, was never intended to be long term. Their rent is £750 pcm and some months ago I offered to reduce it if it was more than they could afford.

You can't win.

babbi · 06/09/2021 15:47

@Tabitha005 fantastic post

Tabitha005 · 06/09/2021 15:45

@MistySkiesAfterRain

We need more decent flats. Population growth is not going away. People don't want the countryside built over. So we have to build up.

Not sky scrapers but 3-5 storey blocks with decent sized balconies (none of that juliette bollocks), quality fittings, built around communal courtyards, with a proportion of affordable rents which is good for social cohesion, ground floor family flats with large patios, separate bungalows.

Plus more investment in green public spaces and gardens, and more allotments.

Co-housing for older people - where everyone has their own individual apartments, but share lots of communal facilities such as gardens, laundry, allotment space (even tools, bicycles and cars) and a communal meeting place is one way of addressing the needs of an ageing population. Developers aren't building bungalows that meet this need, and many older people don't want the hassle or work involved in maintaining a garden, or handling their own building maintenance.

There are a few incredible developments of this kind in the UK - although we lag significantly behind countries such as Denmark, The Netherlands and Sweden in this respect, as well as many South American countries where cooperative housing has long been a huge part of the housing offer.

There's one particular development called 'OWCH' (Older Women's Co-housing) that springs to mind as a fantastic example of co-housing solutions for older peoples as well as a development called LiLAC for families and single people, as well as older people that really stand out as beacons for a different way of 'doing' housing.

I think we've become so used to doing the same things, with the same materials, the same style of housing and using the same unsustainable elements (developers still installing fossil fuel-driven heating systems, not including electric vehicle charging points as standard and using tonnes and tonnes of the most environmentally-polluting building substance in existence - concrete) here in the UK that we've got ourselves into a total rut.

The dependence on developers by English councils is a complete fuck-up that should never have been allowed to happen; councils having to shore up income shortfalls via the community infrastructure levy, so essentially greenlighting any shit old housing development that applies for planning permission was always a one-way ticket into the sewer of unsustainability as far as housebuilding was concerned.

I've read thousands of complaints from unsatisfied homeowners detailing flaws and serious defects with their developer-built homes - and that alone proves that volume development so often falls far short of the standards they would otherwise wish the general public to have of them.

Swipe left for the next trending thread