Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I'm so sick of people buying multiple properties for BTL

522 replies

flashbac · 06/09/2021 10:02

So the landlord next door has hoovered up another house on the street for BTL. A nice house that wasn't even on the market but they managed to get their mits on it. Yes I know I sound bitter because I am! I'm so fed up of investors hoovering up all the houses. There should be a limit but with most of our government being BTL landlords nothing will change.
I'm sick of the increasing gap between rich and poor.
now runs and hides because reckons half of MN have a BTL or holiday home

OP posts:
Journeyofthedragons · 06/09/2021 12:53

@supermoonrising

If the housing market/rental market was hurting the pockets of Tory MPs and their donors, they’d be knocking it down and starting again. As it is of course, as a group which is mostly in the top 1-10% of British wealth (with their donors and supporters in the media and elsewhere in the top 0.0001%), they all benefit massively from the status quo: IE spiralling house prices, shite rentals … and above all a continuous, gradual but steady upward transfer of wealth from the bottom 50% of the UK to the top 5% of the UK. Understand that and then the rest is just details and small print. It’s class warfare but it’s also now generational warfare, though at some point the Tories may need to change strategy as I’m not sure how many dirt poor renters in their 40s and 50s in 2030/40 will be voting Tory. But they can always blame the immigrants, which usually does the trick.
👏👏👏👏
I'm so sick of people buying multiple properties for BTL
Greyrootszerohoots · 06/09/2021 12:53

I’ve rented from some excellent landlords and some awful ones. The awful ones have always been through letting agents, who IMO are an even bigger problem. Ripping off both parties and taking on landlords who simply shouldn’t be landlords.

Feel very fortunate to now own my own home and would never aspire to a second property on principal.

supermoonrising · 06/09/2021 12:53

@DynamoKev
People don't make these connections or else there couldn't be so much Tory

There isn’t that much Tory support. About 1/4 adults voted Tory for their last landslide. The centre-left vote was 1.5 million bigger than the right wing vote. More people in the UK hate Tory policies than support them but FPTP doesnt recognise nuance.

wednesdayweather · 06/09/2021 12:51

They are stuck paying extortionate rent (my partner and I pay almost £300 a month more in private rent than a mortgage would cost us)

Well, this is because most landlords are amateur landlords. They have bought the property as an investment, so they have a mortgage to pay and on top of that they have to pay for all the repairs and maintenance to the property, have to cover void periods (when they still have the mortgage to pay), have to pay to make the property compliant with legislation and pay for all the regular safety checks, paying for landlord insurance (not cheap), quite likely paying for letting agent fees (about £100 a month), so it is not surprising that rent is more than the mortgage when you have a lot of amateur landlords with a full mortgage and all these additional costs. Apparently the average profits for landlords are 5%.

That's why we need a professional landlord sector run by companies who are maintaining properties across generations and therefore not thinking in terms of a 25 year mortgage that they need to cover plus all the considerable additional costs of renting a property out.

supermoonrising · 06/09/2021 12:49

There are low marriage & birthrates in Taiwan, Romania, Italy & Japan, too. Is that also due to BTL

I’m sure cost of living and general life stress is certainly a factor. I know that for sure in the case of China/Taiwan and Japan. I’ve heard similar from colleagues in Spain.

thecognoscenti · 06/09/2021 12:49

Totally agree OP. I think BTL should be severely restricted. I would also ban the buying of holiday homes - they ruin communities.

Myusernameisnotmyusernameno · 06/09/2021 12:48

I totally agree. I'm renting and would love to buy this house once we get a mortgage and do it up a bit but I don't think our LL who owns about 20 houses would consider selling it. It's in need of modernisation so I think once we move out he'll do the work and rent it for more whereas he could sell to us for a profit and we could have a house to make our own. I understand it's not his problem but still.

Weirdlynormal · 06/09/2021 12:48

If there were more controls on rentals the market would fall off a cliff.

DynamoKev · 06/09/2021 12:48

@supermoonrising

If the housing market/rental market was hurting the pockets of Tory MPs and their donors, they’d be knocking it down and starting again. As it is of course, as a group which is mostly in the top 1-10% of British wealth (with their donors and supporters in the media and elsewhere in the top 0.0001%), they all benefit massively from the status quo: IE spiralling house prices, shite rentals … and above all a continuous, gradual but steady upward transfer of wealth from the bottom 50% of the UK to the top 5% of the UK. Understand that and then the rest is just details and small print. It’s class warfare but it’s also now generational warfare, though at some point the Tories may need to change strategy as I’m not sure how many dirt poor renters in their 40s and 50s in 2030/40 will be voting Tory. But they can always blame the immigrants, which usually does the trick.
People don't make these connections or else there couldn't be so much Tory support.
the80sweregreat · 06/09/2021 12:48

Yes, I remember the arguments that owning a property was the thing to aspire to and why shouldn't council home owners have one ? It was the huge discounts that were unfair though : my parents and in laws friends and families bought and sold them on as soon as they were able to and moved to much ' nicer' areas.
Hardly anyone wanted to stay in the areas that the ex council homes were actually in and had the cheek to moan about the ' sink estates' they left behind!

lockdownmadnessdotcom · 06/09/2021 12:47

Oh wrong thread! Sorry!

lockdownmadnessdotcom · 06/09/2021 12:47

And ok, so some of you are so amazing at your jobs, your bosses overlook your diabolical timekeeping. Fine - especially in the era of home-working, it must be easier to get to your desk on time.

But how do you meet work deadlines?

DynamoKev · 06/09/2021 12:47

@DocAutumn

Aw, just let the rich people have everything because they can afford to pay for it.

Also, with buy to let mortgages often requiring miniscule or no deposits and the tenants paying rent that more than covers the mortgage these rich people often aren't even investing any money in the properties they end up owning.

Where are you finding zero deposit BTL mortgages?
Flatdisco · 06/09/2021 12:47

I totally agree with you op

supermoonrising · 06/09/2021 12:46

If the housing market/rental market was hurting the pockets of Tory MPs and their donors, they’d be knocking it down and starting again. As it is of course, as a group which is mostly in the top 1-10% of British wealth (with their donors and supporters in the media and elsewhere in the top 0.0001%), they all benefit massively from the status quo: IE spiralling house prices, shite rentals … and above all a continuous, gradual but steady upward transfer of wealth from the bottom 50% of the UK to the top 5% of the UK. Understand that and then the rest is just details and small print. It’s class warfare but it’s also now generational warfare, though at some point the Tories may need to change strategy as I’m not sure how many dirt poor renters in their 40s and 50s in 2030/40 will be voting Tory. But they can always blame the immigrants, which usually does the trick.

salviapages · 06/09/2021 12:44

Either something needs to be done to make ordinary working people more able to buy a home for their families, or there needs to be much stronger renters rights.

I'd love to have a few children but I'll never be able to buy a home big enough for a family, not without tens of thousands for a deposit at least. But renting is so unstable, you can be told to move out with little notice, if an appliance breaks you're at the will of a slow landlord to sort it, rents can increase by quite a lot, it's hard providing a stable home for children when you rent in the UK. Both options are bad and I don't think that a stable home for my children should be so difficult when I work hard.

IveGotASongThatllGetOnYNerves · 06/09/2021 12:44

Maybe some form of rent control could be an option

lljkk · 06/09/2021 12:44

The UK is a strange place. Adults in their 30s cannot afford to live on their own, yet you have people asking why people aren’t getting married and having babies.

There are low marriage & birthrates in Taiwan, Romania, Italy & Japan, too. Is that also due to BTL? Confused

Nosferatussidebit · 06/09/2021 12:44

Now rent is often way, way above the cost of a mortgage on the same property.

I've known this to be the case. I've only ever paid more mortgage than the equivalent rent. Current house -£1500 mortgage. Same house across the street, £1200 rent.

Nosferatussidebit · 06/09/2021 12:42

Selling off the council homes was the most destructive thing to happen in the 1980s.
I know many became millionaires from it , I know it was popular and a vote winner and I appreciate that it was seen as inspirational

And the argument back then was "everyone should be able to own their own home" same as this thread. It was short-sited then (selling off council housing) and suggestions to curtail private landlords now are also sort sighted.

BreatheAndFocus · 06/09/2021 12:41

I agree, OP. The only way BTL would be ok is if the rent was capped and kept low. I wouldn’t mind so much then.

I find it shocking how much house prices have risen over 25 or 30 years. It used to be that even a relatively low paid job would allow you to buy a cheap house - and there were plenty about because the lower prices kept the housing market buoyant. When my ex-H and I bought our first house our mortgage was around the same price as our rent. Now rent is often way, way above the cost of a mortgage on the same property.

Journeyofthedragons · 06/09/2021 12:41

Pure supply and demand capitalism is fine for things like fizzy drinks, vehicles, cinema tickets but it doesn’t work for the essentials of life

Co-signed

youngandbroken · 06/09/2021 12:40

YANBU. If there were enough houses to go around then yes fair enough but there isn't and it means that those in lower paid jobs such as serving staff, cleaners, care workers, nursery staff, delivery drivers, shop workers and so many others who all work very, very hard for long hours and very little pay can never hope to own their own homes. They are stuck paying extortionate rent (my partner and I pay almost £300 a month more in private rent than a mortgage would cost us), we have no hope of getting a council house because there are none and no hope of ever saving a deposit despite the fact that we can more than afford a mortgage and would be better off financially, as well as in a more stable position for our children. We would jump at the chance to be able to actually call somewhere home but like many others we will never get that opportunity and it is only going to get worse for future generations. Apart from those who will get a very large inheritance of course and so the cycle of the rich getting richer while the poor get poorer continues.

Nosferatussidebit · 06/09/2021 12:40

The first two would help with the third point. Tenants should be able to treat a rented property as their own - currently most tenancy agreements prohibit putting up so much as a picture hook without written permission, never mind repainting or having a pet. I believe that the continental renting system is more like this, hence why people are happier to rent. All the time renting is a) insecure and b) the shitty choice, people will stretch themselves to buy. The flip side of tenancies being more secure is that when a tenant does need to leave, the landlord shouldn't have to go through the ridiculous hoop of section 21 notice/tenant won't leave because the council won't deem them homeless if they go voluntarily/landlord has to get a court order.

The reality in UK is though that whilst landlords can stipulate what they like in a contract, virtually none of it is enforceable. And whilst you may say they can evict you - it's actually very hard and expensive and takes a long time and certainly wouldn't be done because someone repainted, hung a picture or even had a pet. An inspection would have to show serious damage for the landlord to consider the eviction process. Accidental landlords are more likely to try it, but often get it wrong and spend lots of money for nothing. And now that deposits are protected, it's really quite hard for a landlord to withhold it if the tenant disputes it (which is easy and free).

the80sweregreat · 06/09/2021 12:40

Selling off the council homes was the most destructive thing to happen in the 1980s.
I know many became millionaires from it , I know it was popular and a vote winner and I appreciate that it was seen as inspirational and I also appreciate that many politicians such as Tony Blair etc are also 'property millionaires' , but it was very short sighted and has led to today's greed and the general housing shortage.
It's just my opinion , many of my friends would t agree with me at all of course as they have benefited from its induction and will be much richer than i ever will be!
It's just sad that people on normal wages are finding it so hard to buy anything these days.
It'll only get worse too I think :(
Wished I had the answers though .