Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Ear syringing on the NHS

242 replies

Spidey66 · 06/09/2021 07:04

Also posted in health.
Went swimming a few days ago, and now my ear is blocked. Its painful, im deaf, and it's ringing. I've been putting olive oil drops in it and if anything its worsening.

I've had this before, and whats always sorted it has been syringing.

I went to a minor injuries/walk in yesterday because the pain was getting worse to be told the NHS no longer do syringing. The NICE guidelines now recommend micro suction for blocked ears but this is only done privately. Instead the NHS will refer to audiologists for hearing aids.

Hearing aid referrals for blocked ears? Come again? I'm only deaf for want of a brief intervention!

This is ridiculous!

Should ear syringing or an alternative be available on the NHS? Yabu = no go and pay for it. Yanbu= ear syringing or an alternative should be available on the NHS

OP posts:
Aprilinspringtimeshower · 06/09/2021 15:08

[quote Seasonschange]@aprilinspringtimeshower

Did you miss step 3 of my post? I didn’t say no one should be treated I said where appropriate people should try homecare first.[/quote]
And my point was that this is not what’s happening. GPs have been given “permission” to lump serious chronic ear blockage in with their guidance not to treat as it is a minor issue and loss of equipment/practice at local surgeries. Leaving people like me with serious issues not being taken seriously

irresistibleoverwhelm · 06/09/2021 15:06

I’ve had glasses all my life so I’m in the same position, but ear syringing or microsuction carries a significant danger of perforating the ear drum, so as a medical pride cure it really isn’t quite the same as getting glasses, though I appreciate your point. You can also get eye tests and glasses vouchers on the NHS too, if you are in certain categories.

Spidey66 · 06/09/2021 14:58

@DrWhoNowww
You could say, though, that once you have the glasses, contacts are a luxury. Just being devils advocate there.

Some eyecare is free though....my eye checks are (my brother has glaucoma) and I'm having free treatment for my cataracts.

OP posts:
Eve81 · 06/09/2021 14:56

I work in the community and up until recently, was providing this service.

It’s really awful to say but we just didn’t have the time. It would take up near to 3 hours on one patient over two visits. Unfortunately, because it is not life threatening l, we had to prioritise patients who were at risk of infection or complications.

I honestly do not think people comprehend how chronically understaffed and financed the NHS is, this is an ongoing problem before covid. Ministers like to gloss over the problem as to not alarm the public but it is just on its knees with no chance of recovery.

I am sad to say, I have just invested in private health care. It is seriously worrying how services are being cut.

skodadoda · 06/09/2021 14:55

@bunnybuggs

This has been the case for so many years (at least the last 5) - so I cannot understand why you are getting so worked up about it. I have difficult shaped ear canal and do my own wax-softening and gentle syringing (believe me as you get older this becomes more of a problem). Some patients are unable to see medical staff face to face for serious problems and you want your ears seen to. YABVVU
It’s varied from area to area. I had mine syringed no more than two years ago at the GP. This time I had to go to Specsavers and pay for micro suction. You’re very dismissive of the deafness, pain, and often dizziness that comes with intractable earwax. We’re not ‘getting so worked up about it.’
DrWhoNowww · 06/09/2021 14:49

@CorrBlimeyGG

The NHS is expected to offer everything to everyone, no wonder it's struggling.

The NHS is expected to provide essential healthcare, that's far from everything to everyone.

Depends on your definition of essential though doesn’t it?

I pay £30 a month to spec savers for contact lenses that I literally could not function without.

I then spend another £400 every 18 months on new glass (that I need to be able to see all enough to find my contact lens case)

Should the NHS pay for those? Or should I just accept not being able to see? My bad eyesight is no more my fault than someone’s blocked ears, why should they be covered under the NHS when eye sight isn’t?

I know it’s not a race to the bottom but I do find the outrage over paying for basic ear care astonishing when people who need eye care have been shelling out for decades.

user1497207191 · 06/09/2021 14:48

@skodadoda IME audiologists will not examine ears for hearing aids if they’re blocked with wax!

Exactly, I ended up in a vicious circle between the GP surgery and audiology because of ear wax. GP referred me for a hearing aid. Audiology appointment was wasted because the audiologist told me to go back to the GP to get the wax removed. GP wouldn't do anything about the wax and told me to go back to audiology and tell them to do it. And so it went on!

skodadoda · 06/09/2021 14:46

@VladmirsPoutine

I think this is a good demostation of how free health care made us lazy.

True. I'd go so far as to suggest that given most people have a knife and a fork and a bottle of vinegar in their kitchens we should also at least try and do surgery on ourselves before resorting to surgeons in hospitals.

🤣🤣🤣
skodadoda · 06/09/2021 14:43

@Spidey66

Oh and of course I understand that treatments change and evolve and that if ear syringing is now not seen as safe it should be replaced with something more up to date and in line with evidence based practice. If micro suctioning is the way forward, it should be offered routinely on the NHS. That's why I said in my OP 'ear syringing or an alternative should be offered.'
This!
badgerswitharms · 06/09/2021 14:39

I'm not going to comment on the NHS, I work in the NHS and it's not fit for purpose. It's terrifying.

I've suffered from repeated blocked ears all my life, worsened by swimming if I don't wear my ear plugs. I bought a squeezy bulb irrigation thing, quite literally life changing. I wash them out once a fortnight with warm water in the shower and I've not had blocked ears for months. So much more comfortable than microsuction or syringing. Honestly I can't extol how amazing it is, I used to wake at least once a month with painful blocked ears.

skodadoda · 06/09/2021 14:38

@mummyh2016

Check your local pharmacy, ours does it for £35 and did it there and then.
Which pharmacy was this 😀
skodadoda · 06/09/2021 14:35

Here’s a link to an earlier thread.

www.mumsnet.com/Talk/_chat/4245458-in-agony-from-ear-wax-build-up?msgid=108053820#108053820

skodadoda · 06/09/2021 14:34

It could help if lots of you completed this RNID questionnaire:-

rnid.org.uk/get-involved/campaign-with-us/take-action-if-nhs-ear-wax-removal-services-arent-available-in-your-area/

I had the same as OP. Paid £55 at Specsavers. Ear drops just don’t fix it for me.

skodadoda · 06/09/2021 14:25

@Otherthanetta

YANBU. I have tried olive oil drops several times and it never ever works and I’ve stopped using it because nearly every time I use them I end up with an ear infection to go with my blocked ear. Referral to an audiologist for a hearing aid for a blocked at is so ridiculous it’s almost laughable and shows what a poor state the NHS is in.
IME audiologists will not examine ears for hearing aids if they’re blocked with wax!
ittakes2 · 06/09/2021 14:21

I am sorry but a few days of the drops is not always enough to shift things. The website says 3-4 days. www.otexear.com/range/ear-drops
My GP has also just told me my ear is blocked and to use the drops or get private suction. There is a huge variation in prices so worth shopping around.
GP also said ear wax is particular to people and common so yes I would love someone to pay for my suction - but there are lots of ailments common to people where would the list stop?

Blueleah · 06/09/2021 14:17

I've just paid close to a grand for a root canal, and crown privately, having been advised by my NHS dentists that it was unlikely I could get treatment to save the tooth on the NHS
Cost me £700 for fillings. I couldn’t even get an NHS appointment. NHS dentistry is basically non existent now.

DynamoKev · 06/09/2021 14:16

I've been having similar problems since my teens. I'm 55. I know by now what does and doesn't work. Drops and olive oil doesn't. Syringing does.

Sometimes we know our own bodies best.

I am 59 with the same issues. Every time I used to be able to get my ears syringed I used to have to listen to the olive oil lecture - even though I had tried olive oil and any number of ear drops repeatedly.

Getting my ears syringed was like getting new hearing. Now no longer available but I got told off by my GP (in the olden days when you could actually see a GP) for doing my own.

impressivelycunty · 06/09/2021 14:14

Irresistiblyoverwhelm have you tried a Clear Ear clinic? I've taken my child there and they were happy to microsuction - they usually have an audiologist who is specifically trained to treat children.

Blueleah · 06/09/2021 14:14

Lots of little things are no longer available on the NHS. Ear syringing. Painkillers. Cough medicine. Removal of skin tags and small cysts etc. Allergy medication and support with special diets. Toenail cutting for the elderly who can’t reach. My mum is on warfarin and I’m terrified to cut her toenails in case I cut her and she won’t stop bleeding, or maybe she gets an infection due to diabetes and loses her toe. But I have no choice because the NHS doesn’t cover it any more. And I paid £500 to have a cyst removed from my cheek because it was unsightly but not causing a problem so the NHS wouldn’t cover it.

irresistibleoverwhelm · 06/09/2021 14:05

I had microsuction done at a GP clinic a couple of years ago - but it may be that policy has changed to save money/time.

Currently going through a Process trying to get DD back on her paeds microsuction referral as private clinics won’t do kids and it’s only done via hospital paeds ENT in my area. Poor girl can hardly hear at school, drops make little difference but the waiting lists are super long.

user1497207191 · 06/09/2021 14:04

@Seasonschange Do you go to the doctor every time you have a cough/cold and ask for antibiotics? Or do you home treat and only seek medical attention if some red flag appears?

Personally speaking, I have two recurring problems. One being a severe/chesty cough, the second being recurring ear infections. I'm in my late 50's now, and have had these problems since my 20's. I know my body. Every time one or other badly flares up, I have to go through the motions with the GP. I have to go through the "self treatment" first, which never works. Then, the GP finally relents and prescribes either a strong linctus (cough) or an ear spray. Inevitably they don't work either. Finally, on the 3rd or 4th appointment, they prescribe the antibiotics, which is what I knew I needed in the first place. When you've gone through this several times over a few decades, you do tend to know better than a random doctor who's never met you before and clearly hasn't bothered to read your notes as to checking what they did to cure it last time it happened!

Back in the 90's I was at a 2 GP practice, where you always saw one or other of the GPs. They got to know you. It was far better. I remember once when my cough flared up and the GP (who'd actually remembered my prior coughs and checked the notes) issued a prescription for the antibiotics straight away as he himself mentioned that normal cough remedies and the stronger linctus hadn't worked previously!

BigWoollyJumpers · 06/09/2021 14:01

I agree with pp's that in general people expect to much "maintenance" treatment from the NHS.

Locally we now go privately (as in book ourselves and pay) for mole/wart removal, ear suctioning, physio, podiatry, counselling and of course eye-care and dental.

user1497207191 · 06/09/2021 13:57

@StrangeToSee

Trouble is that GPs end up having to treat those things once they turn more serious. So them refusing to treat them at the early stages, with simple/cheap treatment, often causes more GP appointments and more treatments at a later stage!

Agree to some extent, but I also think people need to take more responsibility for their health instead of relying on the NHS to ‘fix’ everything. The NHS is at breaking point. People are literally dying due to delays in life saving procedures and treatment (lack of staff, lack of beds, lack of surgery slots etc).

It’s rare for blocked ears, sore throats, warts, veruccas, ingrown toenails etc to become serious. Provided you follow self help methods at home, buy the right treatments from the pharmacy and look out for signs of infection why would you expect a GP to treat it? Even simple eye infections can now be treated over the counter with antibiotic drops, without involving a GP.

The NHS nolonger has the time, funding or staff to carry out minor procedures like clearing blocked ears. Why SHOULDN’T we expect to pay £30 at Specsavers for microsuction? We pay for dental care, eye exams, glasses/contact lenses etc. Why should wax in ears be the responsibility of the NHS? In theory dentists should offer NHS treatment (though we still pay, like we pay for prescriptions) but in many areas finding an NHS dentist is impossible.

Sure £30 may be a lot to some people but if it’s the difference between being able to hear properly and waiting over a year to be seen by someone on the NHS trained in microsuction, is it such a hard decision?

I think it's the "stealth" approach that's the problem. NHS dentistry and ear suction has been removed by stealth, without consultation and without approval/knowledge of the general public. That's what people are talking about when they want a "proper" discussion about the future of the NHS. As it is, ear syringing has been taken away by GPs without any proper notifications etc - people who used to have it done at their GP surgery are suddenly being turned away, often without any proper explanation nor information as to where to go to have it done privately.
StrangeToSee · 06/09/2021 13:53

Trouble is that GPs end up having to treat those things once they turn more serious. So them refusing to treat them at the early stages, with simple/cheap treatment, often causes more GP appointments and more treatments at a later stage!

Agree to some extent, but I also think people need to take more responsibility for their health instead of relying on the NHS to ‘fix’ everything. The NHS is at breaking point. People are literally dying due to delays in life saving procedures and treatment (lack of staff, lack of beds, lack of surgery slots etc).

It’s rare for blocked ears, sore throats, warts, veruccas, ingrown toenails etc to become serious. Provided you follow self help methods at home, buy the right treatments from the pharmacy and look out for signs of infection why would you expect a GP to treat it? Even simple eye infections can now be treated over the counter with antibiotic drops, without involving a GP.

The NHS nolonger has the time, funding or staff to carry out minor procedures like clearing blocked ears. Why SHOULDN’T we expect to pay £30 at Specsavers for microsuction? We pay for dental care, eye exams, glasses/contact lenses etc. Why should wax in ears be the responsibility of the NHS? In theory dentists should offer NHS treatment (though we still pay, like we pay for prescriptions) but in many areas finding an NHS dentist is impossible.

Sure £30 may be a lot to some people but if it’s the difference between being able to hear properly and waiting over a year to be seen by someone on the NHS trained in microsuction, is it such a hard decision?

CoralFish · 06/09/2021 13:52

I get wax build ups occasionally. The first time I had it I was in France, and a lovely doctor cleaned it out by squirting water into my ear. When it happened in the UK, the doctor told me to use olive oil (apparently my FIL got into trouble for doing this when he went to the doctor with the same issue, so who knows if you are supposed to or not!)

Now I do it myself with this.