Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the NHS isn’t fit for purpose?

207 replies

SpicyJalfrezi · 05/09/2021 18:52

It is in no way a criticism of individuals who work for the NHS. It’s the system. It isn’t working at all. I don’t really understand why we aren’t facing this as a nation.

OP posts:
XingMing · 05/09/2021 19:31

While the NHS is free, it becomes an option for the elderly and lonely and bored. Which is why the phone receptionists are dragons: my SIL reckoned she got timewasters just wanting someone to chat to, the same 15 people day in and day out.

MooseBreath · 05/09/2021 19:26

I am willing to pay for health insurance, but not if the current rate of taxes stays where it is. The thing about the US is that they pay less in tax and then need to fund their own healthcare (not saying I agree with it, but that's the system). A Tory government will not only say we need to now pay for medical care, but they won't reduce our current taxes and will use the money to line their pockets and those of their mates.

I do think healthcare should be subsidized by the government. I don't think everything should be free at point of care. A lot of people waste resources by not taking care of themselves at home before ringing a GP, and the government spends tax money foolishly on contracts that aren't cost-effective. It all needs to change.

Cornettoninja · 05/09/2021 19:26

I have no issue discussing alternatives to the NHS but I’m not sure there’s a quick fix or whether massive changes could happen without a referendum (which I suspect is unpopular amongst those milking it and their connections for everything it’s worth).

If anything remotely resembling the NHS comes out the other side of covid I’d be surprised but I’m not sure there will be anything left to rebuild an alternative with.

XingMing · 05/09/2021 19:22

The NHS is losing its trained staff wholesale to Australia and NZ, people that we have all contributed to training. I have no problem helping to train the profession, but I think they should not be able to emigrate or resign for a few years after completing the training.

Mintjulia · 05/09/2021 19:20

I can't fault them. They have provided everything my family has needed for the last 15 years.

They've provided good maternity care, delivered DS safely, they cared effectively for him when he had swine flu as a baby, they've provided his df with a hip replacement, they've provided great dental care for us both for the last decade, they've provided an HPV vaccine for DS, the ambulance service came to ds's call when I had a bad reaction to something earlier this year.

111 has always been there when we needed it. Plus regular smears and mammograms. My GP even saw me within a couple of hours when I found a lump.

I can't believe I'm the only one.

cardibach · 05/09/2021 19:19

I totally disagree @Mamainthemaking
That way lies the US system. British health care is much cheaper than that if you take all expenses into account. It is possible for the NHS to work, but it needs serious funding and some discussion about elective procedures.

XingMing · 05/09/2021 19:19

Truthfully most of the world has universal medical care funded via work and insurance, and it works well. In the US it's controlled by the medical establishment, so while the treatments are cutting edge, it is also very expensive. But most of Europe gets by with better health outcomes overall with a small co-payment commitment that isn't enforced for children, the elderly or the unwaged.

HermioneWeasley · 05/09/2021 19:18

We are one of a very small number of countries with all healthcare free at point of delivery. Most European countries have an element of self insurance via mutuals so v affordable.

But nobody is prepared to discuss this massively widely used and successful model as they get up in arms about privatising the NHS.

Hardbackwriter · 05/09/2021 19:18

@Bookridden

There seems to be a real crisis with GP appointments. I don't know what the short term answer is (longer term, I hope the govt are getting a lot more doctors trained). I am reluctantly beginning to wonder if a service that's free at point of use is sustainable in light of demand and developments in medicine. If we could find a way to protect people on a low income, some sort of insurance scheme might be preferable?
The problem with a system that doesn't charge people on low incomes is that it means that most users still won't be paying but you'll have gained a lot of admin and lost a lot of goodwill. Look at prescription charges - 90% of prescriptions aren't paid for. People often say that charges should be introduced for other things, like GP appointments, but not for pensioners - but then that's a bit pointless as you're not charging your (by far) heaviest users.
Kiwirose · 05/09/2021 19:15

Well it has been chronically underfunded for years and there are a shortage of trained Drs and nurses. the number of acute hospital beds per person has decreased too so it is much smaller that nit was. However in terms of value for money and efficiency per £1.00 spent it is right up there - America is the most inefficient system in therms of value for money.

Mamainthemaking · 05/09/2021 19:15

The NHS is a product of its own success. By providing absolutely all healthcare free at the point of access, people are living longer and with an ageing population it’s unsustainable.

People are worried that if we talk about introducing payment for parts of the service that’ll it’ll become like the US system, but that is the other extreme.

I think we as a society need to rethink how we look at healthcare. Private policies are as low as £30p/m, (granted for young and healthy). However people are completely unwilling to pay that, but are happy to pay £50+p/m for a phone contract.

The NHS should be a safety net for people that can’t afford healthcare or who’s insurance won’t cover the treatment. That way the NHS will be sustainable for the future.

That’s my very humble opinion having worked in healthcare for 10 years. Just an opinion.

lannistunut · 05/09/2021 19:13

@TheHouseILiveIn

Can't we use the £350M a week we are saving by not being in the EU?🤔
Angry fucking lying brexiteers Angry
TheHouseILiveIn · 05/09/2021 19:10

Can't we use the £350M a week we are saving by not being in the EU?🤔

Timeforabiscuit · 05/09/2021 19:07

I'd love it if the nhs was structured around a whole system approach, rather than each diagnostic little department - few people have only one thing wrong with them these days and it might help being treated like a whole person rather than an anatomical feature. The gp used to be your care co-ordinator and first point of call - now I think virtual appointments could be far more efficient.

Marcee · 05/09/2021 19:07

@MrsTerryPratchett

The reason is that the alternative being offered is an American system. And people aren't stupid enough to want that. So the NHS limps along, being slowly killed so that eventually anything will be better.
Agree, there are much better alternatives.

But people don't want to pay for their healthcare

Bookridden · 05/09/2021 19:06

There seems to be a real crisis with GP appointments. I don't know what the short term answer is (longer term, I hope the govt are getting a lot more doctors trained). I am reluctantly beginning to wonder if a service that's free at point of use is sustainable in light of demand and developments in medicine. If we could find a way to protect people on a low income, some sort of insurance scheme might be preferable?

hopeishere · 05/09/2021 19:06

As has been said on here before the NHS is a sacred cow. Any time alternatives are discussed it's a USA system or NHS as the only options. But there are bound to be other options!!

I'm in NI and it is truly shocking here. Years for a first appointment let alone treatment. But everyone is resigned to it being crap.

OrangeTortoise · 05/09/2021 19:04

I would favour moving to the system used in some European countries which involves some charges at point of care. But def not the appalling US system.

Akire · 05/09/2021 19:03

I agree it’s the same thing year on year. Staff always shattered and burnt out and never enough pandemic or no pandemic. At what point do we get more people in jobs and get point where basic needed surgery don’t have years waiting.

It’s already becoming norm to see Private GP over phone or certainly for anything urgent, same with emergency dentist. Even people that wouldn’t ever considered “going private” just see a way of getting things done. We end up the poor having wait years and anyone with money can take their pick. I know that’s always been case for very well off but now even those lower incomes will throw it on credit card because waiting in pain for months is just awful.

Had guy on news other day needed gall bladder operation. He was in hospital 6m symptoms so bad and they still hadn’t operated when he finally went home. Surely what it costs would have paid for itself many times over.

Medicine is always in demand at Uni so let’s seriously move places and get plans for 10y down the line and see some action. I really worry older I get and lack of options I will have.

Tal45 · 05/09/2021 19:02

Hasn't been fit for purpose for a very long time, Covid has just made it a total disaster. I'd recommend getting private healthcare to anyone who can afford it, you can't rely on the NHS even for serious things right now.

Hardbackwriter · 05/09/2021 19:02

@TheCountessofFitzdotterel

I think we’re not facing it because we don’t trust the Conservative government not to respond with changes that would make it a bit better but much more expensive, harder to access and involve big profits for their mates.
That can't be the case for most people, since a majority of voters elected the conservatives in the last general election and the polls say they'd win again of there were another election tomorrow.
Hardbackwriter · 05/09/2021 19:00

@helpfulperson

But then when you look at other countries health care systems users say much the same. The current thread on the Australian system is interesting.
I've never lived anywhere but the UK, but people I know who use the French and Belgian systems seem to have nothing but praise for them.
PicsInRed · 05/09/2021 19:00

The clever solution would be to see what works vs doesn't work here vs in other socialised health care systems and then keep the good and fix/replace the bad... but the single implied alternative on MN always seems to be "current NHS vs 100% privatised".

polkadotpjs · 05/09/2021 18:59

I agree too and I'd like to see tax rise to pay for improvement and even possibly a bit of a system like Germany (based on not much actual info but talking to colleagues there- that said they're still waiting for vaccines, some of them)
I feel so sorry for staff working in a system without the money it needs to get it organised properly - meaning the correct number of staff and sorting out the admin side. I have the utmost respect for all staff and wish you had it better

TheCountessofFitzdotterel · 05/09/2021 18:58

I think we’re not facing it because we don’t trust the Conservative government not to respond with changes that would make it a bit better but much more expensive, harder to access and involve big profits for their mates.