Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the NHS isn’t fit for purpose?

207 replies

SpicyJalfrezi · 05/09/2021 18:52

It is in no way a criticism of individuals who work for the NHS. It’s the system. It isn’t working at all. I don’t really understand why we aren’t facing this as a nation.

OP posts:
Namenic · 05/09/2021 22:09

The nhs has been underfunded so much that it operates inefficiently.

Eg
You need well staffed rotas to run clinics/services. If people leave (due to overwork, retirement, other opportunities) you have a gap. For emergency rotas this gap need to be filled - by v expensive locum agencies, which get a cut. Existing staff overworked, which means they are more likely to leave. I met people who became agency nurses so that they could have a semblance of family life (as both parents were nurses and hospital would not give them flexibility with shifts).

No decent IT service download an image taken at another hospital? Do another scan.

Covid exacerbates this.

Justanotherlurker · 05/09/2021 22:01

There is a reason why even more socalist governments haven't followed the UK model, it's easy to say it needs more funding and pretending the rich should pay more.

Labour wouldn't want to be in power to introduce the nordic model, thats the situation we are in while MN is filled with 24 hours to save the NHS style posts on every election. It's become a sacred cow which cannot be critisiced in any shape or form.

Whycangirlsbesonasty · 05/09/2021 22:00

It costs the UK £163,000 to put each student through 5 years of medical school (this is after taking account of tuition fees paid. Medicine is a highly oversubscribed subject. I can’t see why asking graduates to either work for a set period of time for the NHS or repay the training costs isn’t anything but fair.

garannenee · 05/09/2021 21:57

An A&e doc friend I knew went to NZ. She was working all hours & couldn't afford to save as her rent was shocking.

ExpulsoCorona · 05/09/2021 21:47

@XingMing

The NHS is losing its trained staff wholesale to Australia and NZ, people that we have all contributed to training. I have no problem helping to train the profession, but I think they should not be able to emigrate or resign for a few years after completing the training.
Tuition fees are pretty high now for medicine. By the time the trained staff leave the UK, they have already paid off the cost in overtime and goodwill. Junior doctors work way over their contracted hours and get nothing for it apart from a worsening in their contracts and a kick in their teeth. Of course they'll leave.
LynetteScavo · 05/09/2021 21:46

@XingMing

While the NHS is free, it becomes an option for the elderly and lonely and bored. Which is why the phone receptionists are dragons: my SIL reckoned she got timewasters just wanting someone to chat to, the same 15 people day in and day out.
That tells me we've not got society right, as a whole. If out elderly and vulnerable weren't lonely they would be looking for human interaction at the GPs surgery.
Jemand · 05/09/2021 21:43

@TheHouseILiveIn

Can't we use the £350M a week we are saving by not being in the EU?🤔
Grin
CallMeMabel · 05/09/2021 21:40

@colouringindoors

The government is underfunding it in order to make it unfit for purpose. Then they can make us pay for it and we will all be grateful. Fuckers.

This.

Yes, this!!
garannenee · 05/09/2021 21:38

It needs funding properly and it needs managing correctly.

But in reality what does this look like?

rubbletrouble · 05/09/2021 21:37

I think the NHS is a service that we need to fight to keep, it would be such a massive failure if we let this service die.

It needs funding properly and it needs managing correctly.

garannenee · 05/09/2021 21:35

I have found the NHS fantastic particularly in emergency care but also rubbish & inefficient.

Justanotherlurker · 05/09/2021 21:34

It needs reform but the age old meme of any reform means a US style healthcare has been pushed from anti tories for 30 years, yet unironically another meme is that we should follow the nordoc model which has a strict insurance model with limited access for immigrants and payed GP visits.

It isn't the right that is holding up the discussion that is needed, it's the vocal left who are trying to determin the talking points. When the vocal left get past the talking point of increasing funding to save the NHS we will get somewhere, as it is, it's an easy oppostion scoring point

arethereanyleftatall · 05/09/2021 21:34

I read threads like this, and it just isn't my experience at all. Mine is this...

Dd just been to hospital for 2 broken arms. Absolutely and utterly brilliant service. Doctors and nurses, all of them, and there were a lot, all lovely, professional, friendly. None seemed tired or burnt out. In fact, I was kind of flabbergasted by how good it was - can I get you a cup of tea, what would you like for dinner etc etc

Every time I've needed a doctor over the past say ten years, (amd it's not often, maybe once per year for one of us), phone is picked up, appointment has always been for same day.

Dd1, nhs saved her life when she was a baby with bronchiolitus. We were rushed through. Again, brilliant service.

My step father, incredibly unhealthy and doesn't help himself whatsoever. Same day appointments, he's been kept alive when he wouldn't have been with a plethora of drugs.

I'm not doubting anyone else experiences at all, I've just never had bad service.

Kendodd · 05/09/2021 21:31

Shortage of hcp has been an issue since I was a child. Successive governments just haven't trained enough, and I agree they should then have to work for the NHS afterwards or repay the full cost of the training. I think governments have decided it's cheaper to import doctors than train them.

I think criticism of the NHS as the moment is a bit unfair. In that early this year we had 40,000 people in hospital with covid while simultaneously delivering the biggest vaccination programme in history. To expect other services to be unaffected by this just isn't realistic.

MercyBooth · 05/09/2021 21:28

‘The NHS should be a safety net for people that can’t afford healthcare

Yep Totally Then we can have the usual suspects don their morally superior cloaks and denigrate NHS users in the same way that they do to benefit claimants and/or social housing tenants. ............oh wait that has already been happening over the past 18 months.

Akire · 05/09/2021 21:28

I don’t know why aren’t more 8h shifts. People could work more days a week and not feel like work days are complete right offs working 7-7 and out the house 13-14h a day then collapsing in a heap. Some people would prefer longer days but can’t do more harm than everyone constant wrecked. Flat out 12h shifts or nothing means many people just leave.

Brollypackedforscottishholiday · 05/09/2021 21:25

Rang 111 tonight... It suggested I try the online app. Which suggested I ring 999 for advice.. Over a cut finger...
Tried the actual phone call version. On hold for 1 hour and 15 mins.
Then advised a GP will ring back.
That was at 7. The dc with the cut is now in bed..
Why advise ringing 999 for advice? Isn't that the point of 111? Told to clog 999 over a cut finger!!

garannenee · 05/09/2021 21:24

It's not palatable but we also have an ageing population which puts a huge pressure on a "free system" because people haven't actually put enough in the system & we have less workers.

By 2030, one in five people in the UK (21.8%) will be aged 65 or over, 6.8% will be aged 75+ and 3.2% will be aged 85+ (ONS, 2017b).

It's terrifying

Bollindger · 05/09/2021 21:23

There is a Youtube, USA v UK hospitals.
I am sure an US citizen would LOVE to have out NHS.
UP to $40.000 to Give birth.
$40 to do skin to skin, with your baby,

AluckyEllie · 05/09/2021 21:21

I’ve worked in the NHS for over 10 years now as a nurse and recently left ICU to go into a 9-5 as it was becoming unbearable.

The staff shortages are my biggest concern- even if the NHS goes private how will they get enough staff to suddenly have a world class service? A fifth of nurses employed in the NHS are over 55. That means 20% of current nurses will be retiring in the next 10 years. The nursing bursary has stopped- when I trained a large proportion of my class were mature students doing their training post children etc, and could only afford it because of the bursary. We relied heavily on Europe for nurses and those numbers have plummeted due to Brexit.

www.google.co.uk/amp/s/amp.ft.com/content/f2ace7d9-59ce-406c-9db6-a844e6806e05

garannenee · 05/09/2021 21:20

I've used the French system a few times & found that very good

Shortstop2 · 05/09/2021 21:11

One of the biggest problems for the NHS is it is run more like a charity than a proper business. What I see constantly is staff who are struggling either physically or mentally taking long term sick leave while paid full pay for 6months and half pay for another 6 months. The team can't recruit any new staff because of this so the team are left carrying the workload which puts them under too much pressure and leads to more absence. Bad behaviour and incompetence are swept under the carpet, no one can be sacked because of the risk of a costly grievance. Private companies would never allow these sorts of issues.

Charlotte2020 · 05/09/2021 21:04

They nhs is up and down depending g on the service. I've used it a fair bit, for emergency care it is superb- from going to a&e one afternoon with tingling I was assessed and having spinal surgery within 4 hours. I'll be forever grateful. The physio afterwards wasn't nearly enough, I got out a credit card and went private for that (worth every penny but I'm still in debt now)
My c-section was great aswell- although the aftercare was so poor I'd look into private if I had another baby.
It's over the past few years the cutbacks have been really obvious. Although I'm an existing patient, getting an appt with my neurologist took a year. Same with my spinal consultant- should've had a check up for my concerns in may and im still on the waitlist for an appt.
there's just not enough staff. And sadly one doctor/physio/healthcare professional can only look after so many people at a time

MrsSkylerWhite · 05/09/2021 21:03

Mintjulia

I can't fault them. They have provided everything my family has needed for the last 15 years.

They've provided good maternity care, delivered DS safely, they cared effectively for him when he had swine flu as a baby, they've provided his df with a hip replacement, they've provided great dental care for us both for the last decade, they've provided an HPV vaccine for DS, the ambulance service came to ds's call when I had a bad reaction to something earlier this year.

111 has always been there when we needed it. Plus regular smears and mammograms. My GP even saw me within a couple of hours when I found a lump.

I can't believe I'm the only one.“

I had brilliant cancer treatment 5 years ago.

My 88 year old MIL lay on her kitchen floor with a life threatening injury, in agony with nothing but paracetamol, for over 10 hours waiting for an ambulance just days ago.

It is not working.

KnottyKnitting · 05/09/2021 20:58

My DD (23) has a really horribly painful throat at the moment - she can barely drink. Called GP Saturday. The emergency GP service said to call 111 or go to A and E. was on hold with 111 for over an hour. In the end we contacted a private local GP who diagnosed a serious throat infection, strong painkillers and antibiotics. Last time this happened she was on the verge of sepsis... thank God we have the money for private.

Friend has stage 3 cervical cancer which has spread. Radiology appt cancelled last week. (Supposed to be having treatment 5 days a week for 6 weeks...) no word of when this will start.

During the week we can't get anyone to even answer the phone at my GPs. Impossible to get an appt.

DH had a medical as part of his work. Found a potentially serious heart issue but no symptoms. GP said he could be waiting months for NHS and suggested he goes private. His dad, grandad and great grandad all died of heart issues in mid/ late 40s so a significant possibility of genetic issues.

DH And both my parents have had amazing treatment on the NHS prior to COVID. It's just soooo shit now.