Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the NHS isn’t fit for purpose?

207 replies

SpicyJalfrezi · 05/09/2021 18:52

It is in no way a criticism of individuals who work for the NHS. It’s the system. It isn’t working at all. I don’t really understand why we aren’t facing this as a nation.

OP posts:
BroccoliFloret · 06/09/2021 12:28

@HermioneWeasley

We are one of a very small number of countries with all healthcare free at point of delivery. Most European countries have an element of self insurance via mutuals so v affordable.

But nobody is prepared to discuss this massively widely used and successful model as they get up in arms about privatising the NHS.

Quite.

It's either NHS or American. No shades of grey in between. No discussion of a Dutch or German system, or French or Italian system.

Even breathe the assertion that you think the NHS needs totally reformed and the lefties are up in arms and just demanding more money is poured into it.

XingMing · 06/09/2021 12:25

@KenDodd, it's apparently less burdensome than one might think because the admin of submitting the claim with all its documentation is left to the claimant. The insurance receives the claim and processes a repayment.

user1497207191 · 06/09/2021 11:20

@BungleandGeorge

The pandemic has decimated health care across the world. Personally I find it bizarre that people are shocked by this. Since we fund our health service less directly through taxation and by paying less at the point of need than many it’s not too surprising we’re worse off than some. There’s a consultation about raising age for free prescriptions in line with retirement age and the amount of bad press it’s getting despite lots of chronic conditions and benefits claimants being free and prepayment certificates capping cost at about £10 a month.
The NHS was in a sorry state long before Covid though. The pandemic has clearly made things a lot worse, but it's not been "fit for purpose" for a couple of decades. Both my mother and father in law got appalling treatment in the late noughties at the height of Blair/Brown's spending - both suffered clinical mistakes and clinical neglect. Just look at the succession of NHS hospital scandals, or read the excellent "whistle in the wind" book about Lancaster hospitals by the consultant Peter Duffy which laid bare the management incompetence when dealing with crap doctors.
BungleandGeorge · 06/09/2021 11:15

The pandemic has decimated health care across the world. Personally I find it bizarre that people are shocked by this. Since we fund our health service less directly through taxation and by paying less at the point of need than many it’s not too surprising we’re worse off than some.
There’s a consultation about raising age for free prescriptions in line with retirement age and the amount of bad press it’s getting despite lots of chronic conditions and benefits claimants being free and prepayment certificates capping cost at about £10 a month.

user1497207191 · 06/09/2021 11:01

@user1497207191

My OH (cancer) had a full range of diagnostic tests when first diagnosed, i.e. full body skeletal x-rays, MRI scan, CT scan, numerous blood tests and bone marrow sample. Upon diagnosis the haematologist referred him to another hospital in the next town (same NHS trust), and the first thing the consultant wanted was ALL the tests to be done again as he said he couldn't get access to the first tests as "his system was different". The stupid thing was that some of the tests were done in the same hospital dept as the first lot, i.e. our nearest hospital. Is it really that difficult for test results etc to be transferred from one hospital to another within the same trust!
He said all he had was the referral letter from the first haematologist, and could access no other information at all, hence calling for all the tests to be repeated!
user1497207191 · 06/09/2021 10:59

My OH (cancer) had a full range of diagnostic tests when first diagnosed, i.e. full body skeletal x-rays, MRI scan, CT scan, numerous blood tests and bone marrow sample. Upon diagnosis the haematologist referred him to another hospital in the next town (same NHS trust), and the first thing the consultant wanted was ALL the tests to be done again as he said he couldn't get access to the first tests as "his system was different". The stupid thing was that some of the tests were done in the same hospital dept as the first lot, i.e. our nearest hospital. Is it really that difficult for test results etc to be transferred from one hospital to another within the same trust!

Pikamoo · 06/09/2021 10:57

I haven't read the full thread but I agree. The NHS is not fit for purpose. I live in Malaysia and the healthcare system here is good and something I wish we had in the UK - a public and a private system that function alongside each other. You can go private for pretty much anything and at a reasonable cost. Insurance is not astronomical either. Often your employer will give you insurance but you may have to pay a larger out of pocket charge if you go to one of the more premium private hospitals.

Interestingly I saw a video bemoaning the US private health system and the extortionate prices allocated to various aspects of pregnancy and birth. They contrasted it with the cost that the NHS allocates to the same aspects of pregnancy and birth (everything in the NHS has a cost, just we don't pay it directly). What I thought was really interesting was that the cost I paid in Malaysia for my pregnancy/birth was pretty close to the NHS allocated costs. I don't get why there can't be a private system in the UK with costs like that.

More people in the UK need to use the private system to take the pressure off the public system. Like my parents - my mum's routine mammogram kept getting cancelled but instead of being able to get it done privately she's just waited and waited despite being well off and having private health insurance! And my brother, he has private health insurance but when he got a ski injury he insisted on getting it sorted via the NHS rather than using his insurance. I just don't get it.

Kendodd · 06/09/2021 10:57

The social insurance model requires everyone including pensioners with an income above a modest level and employers to contribute a %, and the insured claims back the cost of appointments, tests and medicine. The insurance is non-profit and because it's universal

That sounds like a massive amount of extra admin and cost that our system just doesn't have. Can you explain why it would be preferable and better?

XingMing · 06/09/2021 10:45

There's a distinction to be drawn between the COMMERCIAL health insurance model that operates in the US and the SOCIAL health insurance models that are used in Europe, Australia and NZ.

The US model is fairly nakedly money-making, as are most of the hospitals, and I'd be the first to agree that this is not a road we should consider emulating. I worked in NY for a non-profit company that provided health care coverage (including a health maintenance organisation alternative similar to the Israeli system) to school districts, universities and educational institutions, so it's not even the only version used in the US. Medicare/Medicaid covers the old and unemployed but is only a safety net for emergencies, which is where the hardship comes in.

The social insurance model requires everyone including pensioners with an income above a modest level and employers to contribute a %, and the insured claims back the cost of appointments, tests and medicine. The insurance is non-profit and because it's universal, the risks are spread across the population. I believe that there's no wiggle room for insurers to exclude pre-existing conditions, and that maternity and children are always fully covered. Dental and optical extension cover is fairly common, especially optical in France.

Forrestttheout · 06/09/2021 10:25

@TheVolturi

How much is health insurance does anyone know? Like they have in America for instance, do they pay a set amount and then pay per Dr's appointment /hospital visit or is it all covered? Here, with the NHS, especially at the moment it seems like you've got to battle to get seen for anything.
Not in the US but in a country where public healthcare is awful and anybody who can afford it has private healthcare in a US style system. I paid 500$ for this years insurance, it would have been about 700$ if I had chosen to pay monthly but instead I paid upfront and got a discount. This insures me up to 1million$ for inpatient treatment or outpatient treatment following an inpatient diagnosis. Any outpatient treatments I have to cover myself so visits to the GP, nurse, minor injuries etc. Basically the insurance will cover me if I have a major accident, need surgery, get a serious illness. There is also an excess of 750$ to pay before they will cover anything. My DP has a much better policy as he gets a discount through work he paid 1000$ premium but that covers inpatient with 250$ excess and outpatient with a 50$ excess. Both policies exclude maternity (would be a 6 month holding period if we where to add) and also exclude with no option to add on complications caused by contraception, mental health treatment or physical treatment as a complication of mental health (they won't help if you self harm, try to commit suicide etc.) The NHS needs some serious reforms but the US system is not the answer. I am lucky that I can afford to pay out of pocket for GP visits, blood tests etc. Many people can't and end up relying on overstretched charities, poor government options or bankrupt
Kendodd · 06/09/2021 09:49

As for our very elderly, I think families have unrealistic expectations sometimes.
I heard somebody on the radio a while ago complaining that their 89 year old mother was 'allowed' to die from covid. This person (not a medic) was angry that her mother wasn't put on a ventilator in hospital when admitted. She described her mother as 'fit as a fiddle' while also saying she'd been living in a care home with dementia for the last two years.

Kendodd · 06/09/2021 09:42

The procurement baffles me

I think the NHS is actually brilliant at procurement and its size is a real strength in this. Its able to get drugs and medical devices much, much cheaper than the open market, so much so that some American manufacturers and politicians are real pissed off about it. I agree that there are some anomalies though. IMO very cheap over the counter drugs shouldn't be available at all on prescription, neither should things like gluten free foods. Although, even banning low cost drugs has its problems. We have really shocking and shameful levels of poverty in the UK, it's very possible a mother of a sick child wouldn't have even £1 to buy medicines for them. Nearly 90% of prescription in England are free.

garannenee · 06/09/2021 08:58

The procurement baffles me, they should be able to get it cheaper than the supermarkets as they are placing huge quantities

Tinpotspectator · 06/09/2021 08:52

Nudge theory in action.

TheWayTheLightFalls · 06/09/2021 08:30

And things like - as reported on MN - reluctance to dole at paracetamol or stronger because it costs £10 on the NHS but 35p at Tesco is absolutely wrong and seems like no human with a brain has looked into procurement. I suspect there is more to it.

TheWayTheLightFalls · 06/09/2021 08:27

It's a system that's run in a way not hugely compatible with people's lives and expectations now - from how long we live to health/obesity issues to the expansion in treatments available etc. The "yes you can have an appointment but it'll be at 11.45 on a Tuesday eleventy weeks from now and screw you if you're a train driver/zero hours worker/carer for a disabled DC, and you'll actually be called in two hours later because reasons" approach does not work and is infuriating to many.

I'm troubling the NHS quite a lot at the moment - pregnant, 3rd trimester with twins. So there are scans, consultant appts and MW appts at least every two weeks (I have two this coming week). They are very good at flagging up concerns and sending me off for further tests/monitoring. I feel very well taken care of. But I often find I'm waiting hours and hours to be seen. So a mixture really.

ChrissyPlummer · 06/09/2021 08:06

Haven’t RTFT but YANBU. They were truly excellent when DH had cancer three years ago.

However, reading the thread where they’ll refer to ENT for a hearing aid because someone has a blocked ear from swimming just demonstrates the insanity that appears when it’s not a life-threatening condition. What an utter waste of time and money, especially when a hearing aid isn’t needed in those circumstances and there’s a cheaper and faster solution.

ExpulsoCorona · 06/09/2021 07:56

@Badbadbunny when did the BMA do this? I don't remember this. Do you have a source?

Badbadbunny · 06/09/2021 07:49

@Kendodd

Shortage of hcp has been an issue since I was a child. Successive governments just haven't trained enough, and I agree they should then have to work for the NHS afterwards or repay the full cost of the training. I think governments have decided it's cheaper to import doctors than train them.

I think criticism of the NHS as the moment is a bit unfair. In that early this year we had 40,000 people in hospital with covid while simultaneously delivering the biggest vaccination programme in history. To expect other services to be unaffected by this just isn't realistic.

There was a time when the BMA refused to sanction an increase in the number of doctors being trained! It's not just been a matter of successive govts not wanting to train more doctors etc - there's been union opposition to doing it!
MrsSkylerWhite · 06/09/2021 07:39

cptartapp

The reality is there could be tens of 80 and 90 year olds in the area lying on floors, in roads, with chest pain, wandering confused, accidentally overdosed, unable to get out the bath, etc etc etc. As a district nurse I've seen it. Many of whom should really be in care but have insisted on staying unrealistically in their own homes, muddling on dangerously and dare I say, refusing to pay for help.
Of course that situation isn't unacceptable but the sheer volume of them is often unrealised by many.

All sound and valid points. We are where we are though and waiting hours for an ambulance in an emergency situation is unacceptable whatever the age of the patient.

lannistunut · 06/09/2021 07:38

@SophieHMS

The NHS has become a "keep everyone alive as long as possible" service. Personally - and doubtless this won't be a popular opinion - I think we need to accept that people die.

I'd like to see more explicit and overt and thus fairer rationing.

Hmm. People say this, but I'm not sure they really mean it if applied to themselves or their own child.

The UK system is already doing less than other countries' systems do. Our life expectancy is already lower than other countries - you want that gap to worsen? That's your aim for our health service - people dying earlier?

Do people really want a higher chance of dying early from cancer than in other countries?

Personally, I want to be aiming for good treatment, which needs proper investment.

cptartapp · 06/09/2021 06:53

The reality is there could be tens of 80 and 90 year olds in the area lying on floors, in roads, with chest pain, wandering confused, accidentally overdosed, unable to get out the bath, etc etc etc. As a district nurse I've seen it. Many of whom should really be in care but have insisted on staying unrealistically in their own homes, muddling on dangerously and dare I say, refusing to pay for help.
Of course that situation isn't unacceptable but the sheer volume of them is often unrealised by many.

MrsSkylerWhite · 05/09/2021 22:47

SophieHMS

The NHS has become a "keep everyone alive as long as possible" service. Personally - and doubtless this won't be a popular opinion - I think we need to accept that people die.

I'd like to see more explicit and overt and thus fairer rationing.“

Yes, of course people die.

In what reality though Is it acceptable to leave an 88 year old lying on the floor in agony for 10 hours waiting for an ambulance?

MammaSchwifty · 05/09/2021 22:35

Of all the systems to choose from, why the fuck would the tories lust after the US model (see graphic for how comparatively "successful" it's been over 40 years). Oh, could it be because it makes lots of money for private interests?

To think the NHS isn’t fit for purpose?
SophieHMS · 05/09/2021 22:21

The NHS has become a "keep everyone alive as long as possible" service. Personally - and doubtless this won't be a popular opinion - I think we need to accept that people die.

I'd like to see more explicit and overt and thus fairer rationing.