Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the NHS isn’t fit for purpose?

207 replies

SpicyJalfrezi · 05/09/2021 18:52

It is in no way a criticism of individuals who work for the NHS. It’s the system. It isn’t working at all. I don’t really understand why we aren’t facing this as a nation.

OP posts:
MySixEggs · 06/09/2021 15:13

That's interesting to see TheCountessofFitzdotterel, I wonder what it looked like pre Tory. I'm still not convinced, not that I think it's wrong, just need more information. I assume that excludes public health spending, which I'd like to guess no other country is as batshit to separate out.

JesusMaryAndJosephAndTheWeeDon · 06/09/2021 15:10

More than 56% of voters who voted in the 2019 general election voted for a party other than the conservatives.

Only two thirds of those eligible actually voted.

The voting system in this country requires reform too.

user1497207191 · 06/09/2021 15:07

@TheCountessofFitzdotterel

I am confident it’s underfunded because we spend so much less per capita than comparable countries.
Does that include the private treatments paid for by the UK population or is it just the cost of the NHS.

Presumably, the US comparative figures are what the population pay, either directly or via insurance.

The UK figure would be a lot higher if it included all the payments for private dental work, private scans, private podiatry, private operations etc.

TheCountessofFitzdotterel · 06/09/2021 15:04

I am confident it’s underfunded because we spend so much less per capita than comparable countries.

To think the NHS isn’t fit for purpose?
user1497207191 · 06/09/2021 15:04

@XingMing

Elsewhere, KenDodd you get a receipt on headed paper for professional services or test, or from the pharmacy for drugs; assemble the paperwork and submit it to be reimbursed the permitted amount. I presume (dangerous, I know) that not every alternative therapy is covered so you might not get your eg reiki treatments funded.
In this modern World of the internet, apps, etc., there's no need for any kind of paper based system. It should be an app based system where the service provider makes the claim directly to the insurer, approval/acceptance could be instantaneous, leaving the patient only having to pay the excess and anything not covered by the insurance. The payment by the insurance firm to the provider could also be automatic if within certain limits, etc., and with a slight delay if manual approval by a human for larger/repeated treatments is flagged up.
MySixEggs · 06/09/2021 14:55

But we DO have a costly and burdensome admin/financing system in the NHS. Next to a nearby hospital, there's a huge building which is the "business" unit of the hospital trust. There are huge numbers of admin staff dealing with the funding of the NHS between different trusts, different providers of NHS services etc. Virtually everything a clinical or medical worker does is "paid for" by making a claim, which then has to go through normal accounting/admin procedures involving multiple staff, leading to payments being made to the end service provider, i.e. the trust or private provider. Every operation, every surgical procedure, etc has a paper trail leading to the funding of it.

It's worse than that I'm afraid. NHS budgets are held locally for local people (great!) but it means the NHS is essentially split it two between commissioners and providers. Somewhere, there are a team of commissioners "commissioning" the local hospital to deliver A&E services to local people. Does this need commissioning? Would you be wandering the streets with a broken leg if these commissioners didn't exist? And then team of contracting staff making sure the hospital has a contract to deal with your broken leg. And it goes on.

Balonzette · 06/09/2021 14:53

100% agree.

MySixEggs · 06/09/2021 14:51

I'm not confident it is being underfunded, although I see why it's a popular opinion. Commissioning Support Units are working with hundreds of millions of pounds of the NHS budget with no accountability. I don't feel confident they offer value for money at all. And not to mention their dealings with private sector organisations which is completely kept out of the public eye.

XingMing · 06/09/2021 14:43

Elsewhere, KenDodd you get a receipt on headed paper for professional services or test, or from the pharmacy for drugs; assemble the paperwork and submit it to be reimbursed the permitted amount. I presume (dangerous, I know) that not every alternative therapy is covered so you might not get your eg reiki treatments funded.

Kendodd · 06/09/2021 14:16

And I assume the other systems also have that, in addition.

user1497207191 · 06/09/2021 14:10

[quote Kendodd]**@XingMing

@KenDodd, it's apparently less burdensome than one might think because the admin of submitting the claim with all its documentation is left to the claimant. The insurance receives the claim and processes a repayment.

So it is most costly and burdensome than not having it, as we currently have.[/quote]
But we DO have a costly and burdensome admin/financing system in the NHS. Next to a nearby hospital, there's a huge building which is the "business" unit of the hospital trust. There are huge numbers of admin staff dealing with the funding of the NHS between different trusts, different providers of NHS services etc. Virtually everything a clinical or medical worker does is "paid for" by making a claim, which then has to go through normal accounting/admin procedures involving multiple staff, leading to payments being made to the end service provider, i.e. the trust or private provider. Every operation, every surgical procedure, etc has a paper trail leading to the funding of it.

Kendodd · 06/09/2021 13:56

@XingMing

@KenDodd, it's apparently less burdensome than one might think because the admin of submitting the claim with all its documentation is left to the claimant. The insurance receives the claim and processes a repayment.

So it is most costly and burdensome than not having it, as we currently have.

user1497207191 · 06/09/2021 13:37

[quote BungleandGeorge]@user1497207191

I did say led, which isn’t quite the same as totally excluding everyone from outside the organisation. In discreet areas it can work well, what doesn’t work is someone from outside coming in and not listenigg no to staff because health care requires very specific knowledge to understand it. Have you ever worked for the NHS? Do you not think that those from within are the best to judge what works and what doesn’t? The NHS moved over to remote working overnight during the pandemic, it was simply a question of investment.[/quote]
No. I've never worked in the NHS. But I have been the "outsider" who's gone into various organisations over my professional working life of nearly 40 years. In my case, it was to implement financial based systems, i.e. stock control, job costing, budgeting/forecasting, financial reporting, internal controls, etc. Time and time again, I've seen grossly inefficient ways of working that the in-house staff are overly protective of simply because they know no different.

I was once on a project that lasted two years to implement a stock control/job costing system. The firm in question had tried (and failed) several times to implement a computerised stock/job control system and had decided to write their own software to do it, hence needing an accountant to work alongside the software developers to tell them how to incorporate the "money" aspects. At the first meeting I saw immediately why their previous software implementations had failed. They had a weird parts numbering system, about 15 characters long and a mix of letters and numbers and other special characters (like a modern password). They thought the numbering system was brilliant as you could tell everything about the part by deciphering the number. I thought they were bonkers, because any half decent stock control software database could do the same based on a random part number but with "tags" attached to give data such as material, length, width, angle, colour, etc. I told them so, but they insisted on keeping their brilliant parts numbering system. 2 years later, a few hundred K spent on software and they were no nearer to having a system that worked as the software designers just couldn't turn their part number system into a workable database. The firm got in a new MD who basically scrapped the in house software dept, bought a stock/job control software he'd used in a different firm previously, and TOLD the parts staff, procurers, design staff etc to use a simplified part number system. Within a couple of months, it was up and running and the "old" staff couldn't believe how well it worked! They'd wrongly believed that their firm was so "special" and unique, that they needed a special numbering system and that an "off the shelf" database couldn't possibly have worked.

It's all about having people who've worked in different environments who have a different view, based on different experiences.

BungleandGeorge · 06/09/2021 13:17

@user1497207191

I did say led, which isn’t quite the same as totally excluding everyone from outside the organisation. In discreet areas it can work well, what doesn’t work is someone from outside coming in and not listenigg no to staff because health care requires very specific knowledge to understand it. Have you ever worked for the NHS? Do you not think that those from within are the best to judge what works and what doesn’t? The NHS moved over to remote working overnight during the pandemic, it was simply a question of investment.

Cornettoninja · 06/09/2021 13:12

@user1497207191 and @BungleandGeorge I can see logic in both your points but would add, from what I’ve personally experienced, there’s a lot of little empire building that goes on in the NHS both from clinicians and non-clinicians. That’s not an inherently bad thing if it’s harnessed correctly but more often than not it’s left to take on a life of its own.

For such a large organisation it completely fails to make use of the large workforce and pool of talent it has and standardise operations. You could work in three different hospitals and they would all run in completely different ways and to different standards. It doesn’t work imho, largely because when something works particularly well there’s rarely knowledge sharing across trusts, certainly in the lower level clinical and non-clinical roles it’s rare for professionals to actively seek advice or mentorship from outside their own trust.

Blossomtoes · 06/09/2021 13:05

@XingMing

The NHS is losing its trained staff wholesale to Australia and NZ, people that we have all contributed to training. I have no problem helping to train the profession, but I think they should not be able to emigrate or resign for a few years after completing the training.
Not only that but we write their student debt off. Why there isn’t an obligation to work in the NHS for a minimum of ten years after qualifying, I’ll never know.
user1497207191 · 06/09/2021 12:59

@BungleandGeorge

Everyone thinks they have the answer. Personally I think it would be a lot more successful if led by people who actually work in the NHS, and largely led by those with clinical qualifications who’ve seen the care of thousands. Stop pouring money into ‘reform’ and management consultations and those from private companies who are clueless...
Trouble is that by only consulting "in house" staff, you don't have the same breadth of experience of what happens outside, in other industries, other environments, etc. It just becomes an "echo chamber" consisting of people with exactly the same experiences who know no alternative options.

Other organisations move much faster to bring in new ideas, new technology, etc., so their experiences should be factored in.

What is needed is a proper mix of in-house existing staff/management, together with external people bringing experience of what is achievable outside the NHS.

Peregrina · 06/09/2021 12:56

but the single implied alternative on MN always seems to be "current NHS vs 100% privatised"

This is it though. The current generation of Tories want to see the NHS privatised, not so that they can look around and copy the best of other systems, like the German one, but so that they can have the American system.

I say current Tories - MacMillan and Co realised just how popular the then relatively new NHS was and knew not to change it.

user1497207191 · 06/09/2021 12:56

@privateandnhsgp I'll be surprised if that reference is forthcoming. There's a very high likelihood that the comment was total bullshit. The BMA has no authority to stop or block training places.

I remember something about 20 years ago about a doctors' union objecting to increasing the number of training places. Too long ago for there to be any links via Google. I think it was big news around the time of Blair's botched GP contract.

BungleandGeorge · 06/09/2021 12:52

Everyone thinks they have the answer. Personally I think it would be a lot more successful if led by people who actually work in the NHS, and largely led by those with clinical qualifications who’ve seen the care of thousands. Stop pouring money into ‘reform’ and management consultations and those from private companies who are clueless...

TheHouseILiveIn · 06/09/2021 12:43

www.gponline.com/9000-medical-school-places-available-2021-cap-lifted/article/1724173

It's the government that cap the number of places at medical school

EgonSpengler2020 · 06/09/2021 12:36

When the NHS is good it's really good, Trauma centres being a great example. The problem at the moment, aside from the obvious problem that is Covid, is that we spread the money too thinly and therefore end up underachieving across the board.

What is needed is some really tough conversations by a cross party group in order to take politics out of it as much as possible and to decided what the NHS can offer long term and what services it stops offereing, which people will have to pay privately for, insure themselves for or go without. Then we need to choose what services we will continue to offer but with additional charges, and finally we need to focus on the basic services we do offer and excel in them. Most staff join the NHS to provide excellent care and it is the constant inability to do this though no fault of our own that drives down moral and sees staff leaving in droves, we need an NHS that lets us do our jobs well and enjoy doing it.

Also we need to rethink elderly care and social care and sort this out properly so that DGH arn't bed blocked with the chronically ill other than for those in short term acute crisis.

privateandnhsgp · 06/09/2021 12:34

[quote ExpulsoCorona]@Badbadbunny when did the BMA do this? I don't remember this. Do you have a source?[/quote]
I'll be surprised if that reference is forthcoming. There's a very high likelihood that the comment was total bullshit.

The BMA has no authority to stop or block training places.

XingMing · 06/09/2021 12:34

There needs to be a sensible (ha!) discussion of the options, starting from the point that we already have a fairly extensive range of clinical/medical and outpatients settings ready so the argument could centre on how we'd design it for the best and cost-effective health outcomes if we were starting afresh. It's worth noting that the EU accession countries did not adopt the NHS model.

XingMing · 06/09/2021 12:30

@HermioneWeasley, exactly!