Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the NHS isn’t fit for purpose?

207 replies

SpicyJalfrezi · 05/09/2021 18:52

It is in no way a criticism of individuals who work for the NHS. It’s the system. It isn’t working at all. I don’t really understand why we aren’t facing this as a nation.

OP posts:
InvisibleDragon · 07/09/2021 11:36

I just moved to Edinburgh. All our local GPs register new patients only in a fixed window each week and take a limited number of new patients (eg 10 new patients per week. You must come to register between 11 and 11.30 on Thursday).

Tried to register last week. Arrived exactly on time and was turned away, as there were already the maximum number of people waiting. Finally registered after I went back this week, arriving 2 hours early. I wasn't the first in the queue either and the first 6 or so of us all arrived more than an hour early after being turned away in previous weeks.

It feels like the NHS is on its knees. This kind of rationing of the service is a really bad sign.

TheWayTheLightFalls · 07/09/2021 11:29

@OnlyTheLangOfTheTitberg surely a neater/cheaper solution would be a note on the pharmacy system / consultant letter certifying that you need x at y interval? I presume that isn't an option or you'd have done it.

OnlyTheLangOfTheTitberg · 07/09/2021 09:58

IMO very cheap over the counter drugs shouldn't be available at all on prescription

Just to chip in here: sometimes there are valid logistical reasons for this. I get paracetamol on prescription. The reason for this is because the quantity I am prescribed for my chronic condition would be virtually impossible to buy OTC, as there are strict restrictions on the amount an individual can buy at any one time. I don’t have the mobility or the money it would cost in travel to trawl round 5 or 6 pharmacies and supermarkets every four weeks to buy the amount of paracetamol a pain consultant has determined I need.

MySixEggs · 07/09/2021 09:04

Do CSUs still exist? They were so unremittingly awful when I worked for one I kind of assumed they’d been abolished. Well, there’s a huge saving right there if they’re still in business.
Unfortunately so. And I don't reckon they're going anywhere anytime soon!

ripples101 · 06/09/2021 20:32

It no longer matters how much money is budgeted for the NHS. Management will be the ones creaming it off the top, before that money goes to where it needs to go. NHS management now largely consists of non medical professionals, who are making sure they are earning as much as possible.

The problem isn’t the amount of money it gets. The problem is the amount of money that management wastes.

Covid has just exacerbated this. More and more I’m thinking that we were sold down the river with the “save the NHS” reason for lockdown. The intent really seems to have been - lockdown to enable them to “change the NHS”.

Because that is what has happened. It has changed, and it will never go back. More and more services will be cut. Management will get richer and richer. And the public will be asked to pay more for the “privilege”.

seymoursmyman · 06/09/2021 20:22

@XingMing

The healthcare spending of the USA's population averages out at £8,000 per head per annum... but it is NOT spent by the Federal or State governments. It is spent and funded by individuals and their employers' health insurance programmes.
Federal spending is 3100 USD so working the same as the uk. Considering that is such a limited amount of the costs incurred by the population as a comparison it's still shocking. The £8000 includes the amount the us population and employers pay in insurance premiums.
MercyBooth · 06/09/2021 19:56

They have been moaning like fuck that people have put on weight in lockdown. They even have a NHS advert running about it. And now they want another one?

Butterflywing · 06/09/2021 19:49

Did you know that many people who saw their GP did not have a medical condition at all, but had a catalogue of other conditions like loneliness and sadness ( from losing their partner, or job, for example).

That is why social prescribing has been brought in, to signpost people to community resources and voluntary groups.

There is a lot of physical and emotional ill health caused by poor living conditions, lack of suitable housing, poor nutritional choices, lack of exercise, a lack of a robust support network like friends and family and lack of money.

A huge toll on the nation's health is from poor or stressful working conditions or domestic environment.

It might surprise some to learn that the biggest killers are cultural and often stem from lifestyle choices from living in that particular culture, which is why there are variations between different countries as well as different parts of the country such as rates of heart disease, dementia, domestic violence and diseases related to alcohol, smoking, obesity and rates of accidents.

However, asking people to take more responsibility about the choices we make, what we eat, what we drink, who we hang out with, who we choose to live with, how we choose to spend our time, is not something that a democratic country can do.

How can a doctor tell someone not to eat so much as it will cause heart disease down the line or diabetes?

How can a doctor tell someone to lose weight or the sheer weight of fat on someone',s frame is going to give them painful joints down the line?

People generally don't want to listen to public health announcements. People generally say when asked not to eat so much that they hardly wait anything when the reality is if they were taken to somewhere like Yemen where there was a true famine they would lose weight soon enough.

So for the most part, there are psychological reasons why people make the poor choices they do and that is something the NHS is ill equipped to deal with.

You will never get good physical health in a nation without good pyschological health.

To get good psychological health you need to have strong communities, strong families, a kind and thoughtful inner circle, a good job and a good environment in which to live and bring up your family.

Only then would the NHS be able to function as intended.

XingMing · 06/09/2021 19:47

The healthcare spending of the USA's population averages out at £8,000 per head per annum... but it is NOT spent by the Federal or State governments. It is spent and funded by individuals and their employers' health insurance programmes.

Blossomtoes · 06/09/2021 19:08

@MySixEggs

I'm not confident it is being underfunded, although I see why it's a popular opinion. Commissioning Support Units are working with hundreds of millions of pounds of the NHS budget with no accountability. I don't feel confident they offer value for money at all. And not to mention their dealings with private sector organisations which is completely kept out of the public eye.
Do CSUs still exist? They were so unremittingly awful when I worked for one I kind of assumed they’d been abolished. Well, there’s a huge saving right there if they’re still in business.
seymoursmyman · 06/09/2021 19:08

The nhs could be fit for purpose if funded correctly

The uk government spend roughly £3000 per head on healthcare

The USA spends £8000 per head.

It's not lack of taxes, it's lack of funding.

In one of the only "free" healthcare systems worldwide we spend just under the median average worldwide.

Dontevenstart · 06/09/2021 18:56

Get lost Tory bot

Aggy35 · 06/09/2021 18:51

I disagree based on personal experience.Very grateful for the treatment I have received.

Badbadbunny · 06/09/2021 18:34

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Cascascascas · 06/09/2021 17:23

@SpicyJalfrezi

The NHS is amazing.
We need to pay more tax

I lived in The USA and health far to crazy expensive due to over capacity and the cost of drugs will freak you.

Works well in Switzerland but costs 500£ a month!! Insurance

So the nhs is great!

XingMing · 06/09/2021 17:00

@user1497207191 (I think it was you), the main difficulty with shifting to an internet/app-based system is the presumption that everyone has a smartphone, which cuts out a lot of the elderly people who are most at need of medical intervention. My DMIL could not even deal with an automated voice menu for five years before she went into residential care.

XingMing · 06/09/2021 15:56

A retired GP acquaintance/interviewee (2004-ish) who started practicing in 1959 explained the difference in the treatment landscape in terms of cancer diagnosis. Their view was that if they had to break the news, there was very limited treatment available and end of life morphia would be the GP's best and final offer. Antibiotics in their relative infancy (but no MRSA either); no vaccines for measles, polio etc.; smallpox was not eradicated, TB was rife in poor communities, and there was no oral contraception. The NHS has pioneered medical innovations and techniques that keep people alive far longer than 65 plus two or three years that were normal.

MySixEggs · 06/09/2021 15:38

HeartsAndClubs Interesting stance, I certainly see where you are coming from. The trouble is that infertility is a medical issue, and IVF improves people's quality of life. Which is something the NHS offers in lots of different ways. I'm at that age where many of my friends are having knee problems, and it's almost exclusively those who have spent their entire teenage and adult life exercising a lot. There is no medical reason they need their knees fixing. We don't just treat people on death's door. Essentially, I'm saying there is a much bigger question around non-essential and semi-essential treatments.

user1497207191 · 06/09/2021 15:38

@HeartsAndClubs When the NHS was created it was based around the times we were living in. Now we have significantly more conditions which need treating and people think the NHS is a bottomless pit and that their own condition is more important than the next one.

Whilst I agree to some extent, the fact is that NHS spending HAS increased substantially over the decades to cover the expanding population, expanded range of treatments, etc.

In 1959, NHS spending was 3% of GDP. That had over doubled to 7% by 2019. That's a percentage of GDP so is already adjusted for inflation, population growth etc.

Blair/Brown trebled NHS spending over their 13 years in power. That should have been more than enough to modernise it, fund it and form a solid base for the subsequent decade or two. Yet, it was already running out of money a decade ago, due mostly to unaffordable commitments made by Blair/Brown on top of the 3 fold increase in spending.

HeartsAndClubs · 06/09/2021 15:27

The problem with the NHS is that people are living longer and conditions have increased and people think that the NHS should cover them all.

When the NHS was created it was based around the times we were living in. Now we have significantly more conditions which need treating and people think the NHS is a bottomless pit and that their own condition is more important than the next one.

Look at fertility treatment for instance. Not just IVF but the whole raft of testing/treatments. When the NHS was created fertility investigations didn’t exist, and as such they weren’t budgeted for. Now we have testing and HSG’s and blood tests and IVF and the increase in neonatal care because IVF babies are often born earlier if they are e.g. multiples, and obviously the people who are struggling with those conditions feel that they should be treated.

But what has to give for that to happen?

Plastic surgery, counselling, various rehabilitation programmes, and that’s before we get to conditions which already existed but which are suffering because A, other treatments have entered the arena, and B, because even advances in those treatments have meant that treating even life-limiting conditions has increased in cost.

We need to start having honest discussions about where the NHS draw the line at what should and shouldn’t be treated. And IMO treatment should start with existing conditions. IVF absolutely shouldn’t be covered under the NHS IMO, we need to work on dealing with existing lives not creating new ones. Obviously if someone has paid for IVF then the same facilities would be available to them as to any other pregnant woman, but IVF is not economically viable when you consider that it has a low success rate, and is cost prohibitive.

HAving a baby isn’t a right. Having the opportunity to be treated for and survive serious illness is.

user1497207191 · 06/09/2021 15:19

@TheCountessofFitzdotterel

I am confident it’s underfunded because we spend so much less per capita than comparable countries.
I wonder why it doesn't show Spain, Portugal, New Zealand, Italy, Israel, Greece etc who spend less than the UK??
User135644 · 06/09/2021 15:19

*new

User135644 · 06/09/2021 15:19

Keep voting Tory and public services go to shit. What else is knew?

MySixEggs · 06/09/2021 15:14

The UK figure would be a lot higher if it included all the payments for private dental work, private scans, private podiatry, private operations etc. Prescription charges... £9 a time has add up to some serious money!

lannistunut · 06/09/2021 15:14

@JesusMaryAndJosephAndTheWeeDon

More than 56% of voters who voted in the 2019 general election voted for a party other than the conservatives.

Only two thirds of those eligible actually voted.

The voting system in this country requires reform too.

This will be made worse by the current election-rigging bill.