Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the NHS isn’t fit for purpose?

207 replies

SpicyJalfrezi · 05/09/2021 18:52

It is in no way a criticism of individuals who work for the NHS. It’s the system. It isn’t working at all. I don’t really understand why we aren’t facing this as a nation.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Blossomtoes · 07/09/2021 22:00

And it wasn't the Tories who started the daft reforms. Blair/Brown did a lot of damage in the noughties as they embraced and developed the artificial "internal market" in the NHS and the crazy GP contract changes. Despite Labour trebling the NHS spending, it was still a basketcase organisation

Thatcher introduced the internal market, the Langley reforms in 2012 compounded them. The NHS improved massively under Blair, then Cameron impoverished it and threw all the progress away. Anecdote doesn’t trump statistics.

www.kingsfund.org.uk/sites/default/files/field/field_publication_file/health-ten-years-labour-government-achievements-challenges-may2007.pdf

Payproblems · 07/09/2021 21:37

Bad bad bunny, it will always be a basket case until its lifted out of politics and stops being a football to bounce around.
Our hospital was dire under labour.

We need a crack team to asses the best things about all the health services and do it. Then chuck money at it.

Payproblems · 07/09/2021 21:34

Because we are not allowed to critise it like a strange stalin cult.

OnlyTheLangOfTheTitberg · 07/09/2021 21:13

I don’t think anyone is unaware or doubts there are better systems than the US one that involve a comparatively small co-pay, like the Dutch or Belgian systems.

The problem is that the current crop of Tories don’t seem interested in the latter. They’ve made it quite clear a US-style sell off would be their preference, probably because it offers the most potential profit.

That’s why many posters jump to the worst case scenario, because that’s the one most likely to be on offer if privatisation of the NHS continues under the current administration. Not because it’s the only other option in the world.

BungleandGeorge · 07/09/2021 20:05

At what point was NHS spending trebled?

Badbadbunny · 07/09/2021 19:50

@alreadytaken

The system worked fine when it was properly funded and had less government interference. Then the Tories decided to introduce daft "reforms" and deliberately run the NHS into the ground.

We dont need a new system, we need a change of government.

No, it really didn't. And it wasn't the Tories who started the daft reforms. Blair/Brown did a lot of damage in the noughties as they embraced and developed the artificial "internal market" in the NHS and the crazy GP contract changes. Despite Labour trebling the NHS spending, it was still a basketcase organisation.

I had a lot of dealings with it in the late 00's with my mother and father in law, different hospitals. The lack of organisation was ridiculous. FIL had been waiting months for a cancer operation, was prepped on the morning, and waited. By mid afternoon, the nurses did some ringing around to be told the cancer surgeon was on a course that week, planned for weeks in advance, but no one had thought to cancel the operation, despite the "admins" knowing he wasn't going to be there! Same with my mother, her "care" was a complete fiasco, she had an appointment at Manchester Christies for radiotherapy, turned up on time, only to be told it had been cancelled the week before - the cancellation letter came through her letterbox a couple of days later, postmarked the date of her cancelled treatment. Those are just a couple of incidents - there were many, many more, and that was cancer treatment which should take priority, but staff just didn't seem to care, just blaming "the system" etc.

So, no, it's been a basketcase for longer than the last decade of Tories. It was a basketcase during Labour's years of throwing money at it.

marmaladehound · 07/09/2021 19:34

@alreadytaken

The system worked fine when it was properly funded and had less government interference. Then the Tories decided to introduce daft "reforms" and deliberately run the NHS into the ground.

We dont need a new system, we need a change of government.

The problem with a new government other than the current options been pretty weak right now! Is that all governments, labours Blair included, only see the NHS through to a medium term at most. We either need to totally de politicise the running of the NHS so that long term planning can happen or have it managed cross party.

It really needs a radical overhaul. The system does not work for the needs of society in this day and age. Society has changed so much over the last 50 or so years, needs are just not the same. The NHS has not evolved well with these changes and management in the NHS constantly knee jerk reacts to every problem. There is very little long term planning within the NHS either. Working in it just feels like crisis management to crisis management and has done for years. It's just going to get a lot worse now.

alreadytaken · 07/09/2021 19:09

The system worked fine when it was properly funded and had less government interference. Then the Tories decided to introduce daft "reforms" and deliberately run the NHS into the ground.

We dont need a new system, we need a change of government.

Badbadbunny · 07/09/2021 18:59

@Blossomtoes

The artwork is usually loaned via a charity.
The case I'm talking about isn't small paintings/ornaments. It's a huge modern art statue firmly fixed in place outside, plus a modern art pattern attached to the entire side of a 4 story maternity unit.
marmaladehound · 07/09/2021 18:32

Agree. I have worked in the NHS for 22 years. Pre Covid the NHS just about had its head above water, JUST. Now it's sinking, it really feels very broken where I work. And I really don't think there's a quick fix solution. It needs a total overhaul.

pointythings · 07/09/2021 18:17

@Blossomtoes

The artwork is usually loaned via a charity.
Quite. Or it's done by local GCSE or A level art students. Or it's by local artists using hospital corridors as exhibition space, and it's for sale. But carry on slating the trivial little things, why don't you?
alpinia · 07/09/2021 18:05

Having used the healthcare systems of a number of, mainly European, countries as a resident I have to add to the calls that there is more to healthcare than a free NHS or a bankrupting US system.

Many countries have truly affordable copay systems and they still manage to provide comprehensive healthcare to lower income households. There are many benefits to some of these systems, including the option to go directly to specialists such as gynecologists rather than wading through a GP referral.

At one stage I had (through work requirement) the most comprehensive worldwide health insurance policy you'd ever seen. Almost everything you could imagine, including alternative therapies like massage, was included plus full US coverage. Even that ridiculous policy for two adults cost me 'only' €150 a month, pre deducted from my salary.

Kendodd · 07/09/2021 17:28

Co paying, as in Belgium, might be one of the ways to go.

This is effectively what we have for dentistry (if you are lucky enough to be able to find an NHS dentist).
How's that working out for us do you think?

Blossomtoes · 07/09/2021 17:18

The artwork is usually loaned via a charity.

Badbadbunny · 07/09/2021 17:17

@Darnley

They can find money for ridiculous diversity training though.
And lots of very expensive artwork!
LittleMG · 07/09/2021 16:48

@TheHouseILiveIn

I'd like to know the thoughts of those who think it IS fit for purpose Confused
I know! I can’t believe so many people think it is? Have you rung 111 lately?
Blossomtoes · 07/09/2021 16:01

@Darnley

They can find money for ridiculous diversity training though.
Why would they need to? The NHS has one of the most diverse workforces in the world. This is just more Daily Mail bollocks.
pointythings · 07/09/2021 15:28

@Darnley

They can find money for ridiculous diversity training though.
House!
Darnley · 07/09/2021 14:21

They can find money for ridiculous diversity training though.

thegcatsmother · 07/09/2021 13:37

I would second that the Belgian system is very good. It is efficient, quick, and has a mix of private/public. When I fell and damaged my knee, I went to see the GP, who prescribed physio. I rang the physio (self employed), had my physio sessions for which I paid at the end, and reclaimed the cost.

Xrays/scans didn't just happen in hospitals. I went to what looked like a private house, but was in fact a clinic at the front, for a liver scan. Some GPs, in conjunction with a local hospital, funded a dedicated clinic where you could see cardiologists, dieticians, physios etc.

We need a reform of the NHS. There are other excellent systems out there. Co paying, as in Belgium, might be one of the ways to go.

PFI contracts need to be ended now. I think those companies have done very well from those contracts already.

peboh · 07/09/2021 13:03

@Cornettoninja

That’s the thing isn’t it *@peboh*. If treatment is put solely in the hands of private companies they will cherry pick the profit and flatly refuse to take on anything that dents their profits. The Hitchingbrooke/Circle fiasco should be a warning to us all. Privatisation is all very well but we’re not starting at a point of selling off a well run organisation. It’s a doer upper at best.

As an aside, I was chuffed to get private medical insurance in my new job and though I could finally get my back/joint issues properly assessed (joint issues are linked to another diagnosed condition I have). It was rejected point blank as pre existing despite only ever being managed by the GP/private physio and referral onwards being blocked.

It's a terrifying though definitely. When lockdown happened and so many people started questioning the nhs I did some research, and it appears the majority that will not touch a pre existing condition, and the ones that do the premiums are beyond anything I could afford to pay monthly. Of course if that happens we get on and have to, but it's not something I want to see.

That's so good for you, and I do think private has its merits for so many things like that where it isn't a priority within the nhs.

LukeEvansWife · 07/09/2021 13:01

The system is on its knees. Decrease in funding, increase in demand. I have several medical conditions and haven't been able to get an appointment for several months.

But I admit I did cringe when I was reading the "worst PFB moments" thread, most of which seemed to be instances where parents have rushed their children into the doctors/A&E for something completely innocuous. And then find it funny years down the line Hmm

Cornettoninja · 07/09/2021 12:44

That’s the thing isn’t it @peboh. If treatment is put solely in the hands of private companies they will cherry pick the profit and flatly refuse to take on anything that dents their profits. The Hitchingbrooke/Circle fiasco should be a warning to us all. Privatisation is all very well but we’re not starting at a point of selling off a well run organisation. It’s a doer upper at best.

As an aside, I was chuffed to get private medical insurance in my new job and though I could finally get my back/joint issues properly assessed (joint issues are linked to another diagnosed condition I have). It was rejected point blank as pre existing despite only ever being managed by the GP/private physio and referral onwards being blocked.

peboh · 07/09/2021 12:29

I agree, however the next step will not be ensuring the nhs is fit for purpose, it will be privatisation. For some that's not a major concern. For somebody like me with a DD and DH both with pre-existing conditions, it's a terrifying thought.

Cornettoninja · 07/09/2021 12:13

[quote TheWayTheLightFalls]@OnlyTheLangOfTheTitberg surely a neater/cheaper solution would be a note on the pharmacy system / consultant letter certifying that you need x at y interval? I presume that isn't an option or you'd have done it.[/quote]
Bit like a prescription then? Wink

Add to that there are restrictions on how much medication can be dispensed at any one time on prescription as well as buying otc. The best a doctor can do is issue a medication on repeat prescription, usually four weekly. There are good reasons for this (surveillance/monitoring) but it is a cumbersome system designed to work in one with more capability.

I think pharmacists should have more low level prescribing capabilities in general, once an individual has tried self care and otc options it’d be nice to have access to the next level of treatment without having to attend a GP surgery. I would like to be able to obtain antibiotics or oral contraception or certain children’s prescriptions without bothering the GP. I believe there are some but I’ve not come across one locally personally. Whether they’d want to take that on or not is another question.