Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is this wrong after DM died?

306 replies

Ab4925 · 05/09/2021 18:24

Back in 2017 my landlord sold my flat and I moved back to live with DM to save for deposit for a house. Me and DM are very close.

Around this time a small local cat started to visit our house and me and DM found him very amusing as he’d jump through windows etc.. to visit us. We did not feed him but enjoyed his company.

This carried on until 2020, at which point in March 2020 I went away for a weekend to visit friends, and during my trip received a phone call to say DM had collapsed suddenly and die at 65.

The parademics told me the cat had sat her side and guarded her until we found DM and suggested we contact RSPCA. I told them no as he is a neighbour’s cat a few doors down and has a home.

That night the coroners came to take the body and for the first time I allowed the cat to stay as I was alone in the house and extremely distraught.

I awoke at 2am and the realisation of DM’s death hit me and I was about to completely break down in hysterics, when I saw two eyes staring back at me on the bed, and not wanting to frighten the cat I lay back down to sleep - the worst night of my life.

Two weeks later we went into lockdown during which time I bearly left my bed and I stank, not eating or washing etc…

The cat sat outside my bedroom window crying. Because of the cat I got out of bed and started functioning again.

Everyday since this cat has been my support animal and I do now feed him and treat him as my own.

I know this is bad but I was desperate and alone.

Now my home is being sold (not my choice) and Im moving 60 miles away because I can’t live here anymore.

I can’t face losing this cat - my best friend and only family - but I know his owners have children.

AIBU to ask them can I keep their cat? If you think I ANBU how would ask them?

I would never steal him.

OP posts:
LST · 06/09/2021 02:42

@me4real

Cats hate moving house because they are territorial, and find it incredibly stressful and distressing.

@Dillidilly It takes them a week to adjust or something and then they're fine.

It may potentially leave you to get back home

@Zombiemum1946 I know we do occasionally hear (because they're unusual) of cats travelling in a van or something, but usually they don't. It's 60 miles.

I'm a great fan of cats being house cats, otherwise they often get run over or disappear, or maybe both. If you do get to keep it I'd make it a house cat @Ab4925 .

It's good of you to not just take it. I think I would TBH. It's hardly ever at theirs, anyway.

Making a cat that is used to roam a house cat is down right cruel
PurpleSapphire · 06/09/2021 02:27

I dont mean to be harsh but I really dont think you should ask for the cat. (I actually can't believe how many people have told you to just take it). I do understand what you're going through as not so long ago I lost my mum too and my cats were a great comfort, especially at night when I couldn't sleep.
One of mine used to spend time at an elderly lady's house, I didn't mind but I suspect she locked him in on a few occasions as he normally comes back when I call him. This led to sleepless nights worrying something had happened to him.
If someone came to my door asking for my pet, i'd think they were barking mad, I have to be honest, and my answer would be no.
I'm not saying cats dont sense things, they do, he may well have sensed your grief and wants to be around you but that doesn't mean he isnt happy with his own family.
If you really must, i'd just ask if when you move would they mind sending you a little update now and then as he's been a great comfort to you, you never know, they might say you can take him but I wouldn't bank on it. There are lots of lovely cats in rescue centres who need good homes, its something to consider.

I am sorry for your loss, it's very difficult.

Darbysmama · 06/09/2021 01:12

I can understand why you’d want to keep the cat. Animals are healers. There is no harm in asking. Explain what you’ve written, that the cat spent your mother’s final moments being comforted by it and that the cat has helped you start to heal. Understand that they may just say no or could possibly be offended. But if that happens, what is the real harm? You’ll give the cat back, which would have happened anyway even if you hadn’t asked, and you’ll move and you’ll probably never see these people again, so it’s not like you’re risking a great friendship. It’s a low risk and possible high reward scenario. You only have a shot if you ask.

Snoozer11 · 06/09/2021 01:09

Strike up a conversation next time you see them. Tell them the situation.

If you don't talk to them you won't know how they feel about their cat. It may be that they're not too attached and you realise you can ask.

Or they might respond to the conversation with his much they love the cat and all the joy it brings the family. Then you'll realise the cat's loved and you'll likely have your answer.

Or just say you're moving soon and you really wish he could come with you. Tell them you'll miss him and that he's got you through this tough time.

But be light and breezy, don't be intense and emotional and perhaps use this time to brace yourself to say your goodbyes.

Coyoacan · 06/09/2021 00:57

You really don't need a poll. I know some people who accept that cats choose their own homes and a lot of people who don't. A poll won't tell you what kind of people your neighbours are.

TofuCat · 06/09/2021 00:32

One of my previous cats moved in with me after he decided he didn’t want to live with his current owner after she adopted a new cat. I think some cats make their own mind up where to live. I went round to give him back but he was straight back to mine. Eventually I just asked if I could keep him and she agreed.
I’d put a letter through the door explaining the cat helped you through a difficult time and how attached you are to him with contact details. Hopefully they’ll be happy the cat is happy. Or does he have a chip? You could ask the microchip company to contact on your behalf if the owners don’t respond the company will change ownership to you after a month.

Bythemillpond · 05/09/2021 23:46

I would write a letter explaining what you have said here.
I would mention that for years you didn’t feed him but he kept coming back

me4real · 05/09/2021 23:43

Cats hate moving house because they are territorial, and find it incredibly stressful and distressing.

@Dillidilly It takes them a week to adjust or something and then they're fine.

It may potentially leave you to get back home

@Zombiemum1946 I know we do occasionally hear (because they're unusual) of cats travelling in a van or something, but usually they don't. It's 60 miles.

I'm a great fan of cats being house cats, otherwise they often get run over or disappear, or maybe both. If you do get to keep it I'd make it a house cat @Ab4925 .

It's good of you to not just take it. I think I would TBH. It's hardly ever at theirs, anyway.

k1233 · 05/09/2021 23:36

With moving, I moved multiple times with my cats and they were fine. I'd keep them inside for a week, maintain routine and they were fine.

Zombiemum1946 · 05/09/2021 23:33

You could ask but, even if they say yes, there's no guarantee that the cat will be okay to leave it's current territory. It may potentially leave you to get back home. Cat or no cat, I would strongly suggest grief counselling. I hope things go well for you .

k1233 · 05/09/2021 23:30

Can't say my cats have ever abandoned me because someone else was feeding them. One used to go next door, waltz into their kitchen and help herself to their cats food. Food she wouldn't deign to eat at home of course.

I certainly would have noticed if she'd not been home all day for a long time. I can't see any harm in explaining why puss is so dear to you and that he seems to like you quite a bit and asking if they would consider rehoming him with you.

LizzieW1969 · 05/09/2021 23:27

I would definitely ask, as long as you’re prepared for them potentially saying ‘no’, which they might well do. OTOH, family circumstances change sometimes and cats don’t adjust, for example if a baby comes along.

Either way, you won’t know if you don’t ask. But keep it breezy and light.

Staffy1 · 05/09/2021 23:24

@icedcoffees

I'm really sorry about your mum.

But if someone wrote me a letter saying they wanted to take one of my cats I would think they were bonkers - you can't just ask someone if you can take their beloved pet to the opposite end of the country.

The cat comes to you because you feed it, let it in and give it attention. If you moved, it would just find someone else to get food and fuss from.

I know you love the cat but he/she isn't yours to keep. The cat has a family who are probably upset that he's not coming home anymore because you keep letting him into your house and feeding him.

Please stop and let him go back to his family.

But she has said it came for three years and spent all day there before she started feeding it, so it’s not about that.
Staffy1 · 05/09/2021 23:20

Aw, I hope you get to keep him, he’s chosen you as his family.

Coachradley · 05/09/2021 23:17

How old is the cat? Because the cat will also die eventually.

username4s · 05/09/2021 23:11

I would ask them OP I think writing a letter explaining is a good idea. It completely depends on their circumstances and how close they are to the cat. Everyone is different my DM is very attached to her animals and there is no way she would say yes. But I also know some people who aren't like this with their pets and might consider your circumstances and agree. I have a friend who I didn't realise even had a cat for about 2 years until I saw it stroll in her house.

GratedRed · 05/09/2021 23:05

I think writing a letter is a good idea as it means they can think and digest not react.
They know their cat is gone all their waking hours and might have already accepted it has another home. Write what you’ve told us, tell them what a special cat it is and thank them for allowing them to comfort you.

MadeForThis · 05/09/2021 23:02

I would send the letter. Even if the initially say no, if the cat is very sad after you leave they will have a way to contact you if they change their mind.

Idontbelieveit14 · 05/09/2021 23:00

Sorry to be blunt but I have been the cat owner in this situation and my neighbour has literally stolen him. She’s been absolutely awful saying he must not be happy at my house if he goes to hers but then admitted she’s been spoiling him with food. He does not come home at all now and it’s been very upsetting for my children. You have been through a lot and I’m very sorry for your loss but you don’t know what the cat means to that family either he may have helped them through tough times too.

Dillidilly · 05/09/2021 22:57

I think its really important to remember this isn't a cat who will be staying in his own territory, just with a new owner in an adjacent house.
He will be moved away. Cats hate moving house because they are territorial, and find it incredibly stressful and distressing.
This will probably not be a happy experience for the cat, and I think the OP would find it very distressing too.

thoughtso · 05/09/2021 22:54

My 1st cat (rescue) I never would have entertained the idea of someone else having him - not in a million years, he was my best pal and I loved him so much, but we had a very close relationship and I can't imagine him loving another person as much as me.

My current cat (also a rescue) if she would be happier with another owner (and obviously choosing to be with them) then yes I'd happily let her go and I could rescue another cat!

I know some people move without their cats.

Good luck op x

ShuddaBeenMe · 05/09/2021 22:52

Just write a note with your number on, but be very prepared for them to say no.

I'm very sorry about your mum Thanks

LST · 05/09/2021 22:43

@tenredthings

I'm going out on a limb here. Cats choose their owners. They are very indépendant and we don't own them. The fact that this cat has chosen to spend all its time with the Op suggests he wants to be with her.
The op still needs to ask the owners
icedcoffees · 05/09/2021 22:43

I'm really sorry about your mum.

But if someone wrote me a letter saying they wanted to take one of my cats I would think they were bonkers - you can't just ask someone if you can take their beloved pet to the opposite end of the country.

The cat comes to you because you feed it, let it in and give it attention. If you moved, it would just find someone else to get food and fuss from.

I know you love the cat but he/she isn't yours to keep. The cat has a family who are probably upset that he's not coming home anymore because you keep letting him into your house and feeding him.

Please stop and let him go back to his family.

HoneyItAlreadyDid · 05/09/2021 22:22

Just ask, OP. Cats do this. I think if it was a major issue they would have already have spoken to you about the cat. One of our cats did this with a family down the road. He was happier, the remaining cat was happier and the family he joined loved him.

I’m so sorry about your DMum.