Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is this wrong after DM died?

306 replies

Ab4925 · 05/09/2021 18:24

Back in 2017 my landlord sold my flat and I moved back to live with DM to save for deposit for a house. Me and DM are very close.

Around this time a small local cat started to visit our house and me and DM found him very amusing as he’d jump through windows etc.. to visit us. We did not feed him but enjoyed his company.

This carried on until 2020, at which point in March 2020 I went away for a weekend to visit friends, and during my trip received a phone call to say DM had collapsed suddenly and die at 65.

The parademics told me the cat had sat her side and guarded her until we found DM and suggested we contact RSPCA. I told them no as he is a neighbour’s cat a few doors down and has a home.

That night the coroners came to take the body and for the first time I allowed the cat to stay as I was alone in the house and extremely distraught.

I awoke at 2am and the realisation of DM’s death hit me and I was about to completely break down in hysterics, when I saw two eyes staring back at me on the bed, and not wanting to frighten the cat I lay back down to sleep - the worst night of my life.

Two weeks later we went into lockdown during which time I bearly left my bed and I stank, not eating or washing etc…

The cat sat outside my bedroom window crying. Because of the cat I got out of bed and started functioning again.

Everyday since this cat has been my support animal and I do now feed him and treat him as my own.

I know this is bad but I was desperate and alone.

Now my home is being sold (not my choice) and Im moving 60 miles away because I can’t live here anymore.

I can’t face losing this cat - my best friend and only family - but I know his owners have children.

AIBU to ask them can I keep their cat? If you think I ANBU how would ask them?

I would never steal him.

OP posts:
Listener2021 · 06/09/2021 08:56

I am so sorry for your loss and understand that you have had a very bad time. However, in answer to your original question, yes, it's wrong.
Our little cat was great friends with an elderly neighbour, visited daily and was some comfort after husband died. But she was never fed, and we were happy to share her but would not have given her away. When our neighbour also died the cat took to visiting the people who bought the house, just the same. It was part of her territory. She gave up when they got a dog.
You really should not feed other people's animals.

Doomscrolling · 06/09/2021 08:56

You aren’t thinking what’s best for the cat.

The cat means the world to you right now because he’s being your support animal through your grief. You do not mean the world to the cat. You are a provider of a nice place to hang out within his territory, and get free food.

Territory’s far more important to a cat than people. When you move, he’ll look out for you for a few days because he’s used to his second hangout and snacks, then he’ll spend more time with his owners or visit someone new. He won’t be distressed, it’s not how cats are.

It you took him - even with permission - you’ll distress him. Your new neighbourhood might not be suitable for a cat who roams; traffic; other animals; outside safe space.

Bereavement is awful. I honestly feel for you and I have gone through the same recently when I lost my mum suddenly. Fixing your journey through grief to the presence of this cat in your life will hold you back rather than heal.

In your new home, think fondly of the wonderful animal who got you through your lowest moments. But let him go, rather than trying to cling to what’s gone.
Flowers

icedcoffees · 06/09/2021 08:56

[quote LST]@icedcoffees I'm disgusted by the amount of people who are just ok with the op to keep the cat. Utter twats [/quote]
It's grim isn't it?

That cat is someone's pet! You can't just keep it because it's cute and you feed it Hmm

Motnight · 06/09/2021 08:54

Op I am really sorry for your loss.

I honestly don't think that you should ask the owners to give you the cat. You are putting them in an awkward situation.

Good luck with whatever you decide.

NoIDontWatchLoveIsland · 06/09/2021 08:51

Yanbu to ask but be prepared, they may be really quite angry that you've done as much as you have to encourage the animal to visit and remain with you. I'd be fuming if it was me, but I would be sympathetic to your bereavement and hold back for the purposes of the conversation. I wouldn't just give you my cat though. Remember, it's likely they love the cat just as much as you and will have been paying its vet bills etc for years.

SquirryTheSquirrel · 06/09/2021 08:51

I'm sorry for your loss Flowers.

If you can't adopt this cat, do consider adopting a rescue cat. It won't be the same cat, of course, and it won't have the precious link to your mum. but from experience of the death of beloved, elderly cats, if you adopt another you do learn to love a new cat. A cat, whichever cat it is, will give you that sense of being needed and that reason to get up and feed it, and so on. And you would be giving a loving home to a cat desperately in need.

diddl · 06/09/2021 08:43

You have been through, well are still going through a devastating time Op.

But I still think you would have a bloody cheek to ask someone else for their cat because of it.

I think you are reading too much into it all & I'm sure that the paramedics didn't help by saying that the cat "guarded" your Mum.

MrsScrubbithatescleaning · 06/09/2021 08:43

Contact the owners and explain the situation.

Years ago, a lovely ginger cat started visiting us regularly and staying in the garden. He had a collar on so I attached a note to his collar with my phone number. The owner rang a couple of days later and said she had two cats and a two children and this cat didn't like being in the house with the children but the other cat was perfectly happy there.
She asked if I'd like to keep the cat and so he came to live with us. He was such a lovely boy.

bellabasset · 06/09/2021 08:32

I had to feed an ndn's cat in my house due to them leaving for emergency repairs. He still visits daily and he lap sits, a most affectionate cat. He was very good with my elderly cat whom I lost a few months ago. But his owners love him dearly. So be prepared for them to say No if you ask.

Sitting next to me is a little 4 year old cat who was abandoned with 5 kittens and fostered by the local rescue. She's becoming the companion my elderly cat was whom I'd had for nearly 20 years. You could get to know a local private rescue when you move and even adopt a kitten. I have a large garden and mine runs in and out during daylight hours

Dillidilly · 06/09/2021 08:11

@lyntheyresexpeople beautifully put.

@Ab4925 it's clear you care very deeply for this cat, and he's given you great comfort at a terrible time for you. You say that since March last year you have treated the cat as your own. Does this mean you have insured him, given him monthly flea treatments? What would you do if he became unwell? Have you registered him with a vet? There's a lot of responsibility and expense that goes with having a cat.

Ab4925 · 06/09/2021 08:04

@Coachradley He’s been visiting for 4 years and was quite small when he first started coming. I think he must be around 5.

OP posts:
lyntheyresexpeople · 06/09/2021 07:53

Op, let me start by saying I am very sorry for your loss.

In regards to the cat, this may sound harsh but he won't be distressed when you leave. He would be more distressed if you took him, as cats are extremely territorial. He comes to you because you're home, fuss over him and feed him, which you are aware you shouldn't ever have done, and must stop doing so now. He isn't your family op, he is someone else's. As attached as you feel to this cat, he's with you because you're giving him attention, nothing more. You absolutely cannot ask someone to take their cat, when you have already been feeding him and encouraging him away from his home. He isn't yours. Whilst I absolutely sympathise with your heartbreak, it's not fair on the cat or it's owners to ask this of them. I would absolutely say no way if it was me.

If you love this cat as you say you do, you'll do what's best for him and leave him at his home. You can rescue a cat when you move and you will have a bond with that one too, even more so probably as it will be yours. Best of luck 🤞

Ab4925 · 06/09/2021 07:49

@bobandhisburgers the doors or windows are open at the back. He is free to come and go and goes to the toilet outside in the garden. If the windows are shut he bangs on the window for me to let him in.

OP posts:
JustLyra · 06/09/2021 07:33

@TofuCat

One of my previous cats moved in with me after he decided he didn’t want to live with his current owner after she adopted a new cat. I think some cats make their own mind up where to live. I went round to give him back but he was straight back to mine. Eventually I just asked if I could keep him and she agreed. I’d put a letter through the door explaining the cat helped you through a difficult time and how attached you are to him with contact details. Hopefully they’ll be happy the cat is happy. Or does he have a chip? You could ask the microchip company to contact on your behalf if the owners don’t respond the company will change ownership to you after a month.
This would happen far less if people stopped feeding and encouraging other peoples cats.

Nobody would dream of feeding and encouraging any other pet that wasn’t theirs into their houses, yet folks are always saying “oh this cat chose me” - every cat (and Fox) in the area would choose people that fed them the nicest good.

Enidcat5 · 06/09/2021 07:29

I am so sorry for your loss. This cat has been such a comfort to you, which is lovely.

Unfortunately it's not your cat. Cats are opportunist animals and will go where they find what they want (I work in animal welfare). Although you did not initially feed the cat you let it in and gave it shelter and attention, therefore it kept coming. It now comes for that plus food.

For years I suspected my cat had another place she was going, as she would disappear for hours. I found out later my neighbours were letting her in for food and cuddles. I was 12 and would spend ages in the garden worrying and shouting for her.

Before you go give the cat a huge cuddle and say thank you and goodbye. Once you've moved you can get your own cat.

I'm so sorry, you do sound like you're struggling and it's totally understandable. Lots of love to you op.

To those suggesting she just take it - cats are property by law therefore this would be theft.

Sadsammy · 06/09/2021 07:26

F

MumofSpud · 06/09/2021 07:20

Also as I am sure others have said if you ask and they say no, this means that the cat is much loved so this should comfort you a little?
Please update us - I woke up this morning and your thread was the first thing I thought of! Thanks

LST · 06/09/2021 07:19

@icedcoffees I'm disgusted by the amount of people who are just ok with the op to keep the cat. Utter twats

Dillidilly · 06/09/2021 06:38

@LST exactly.

icedcoffees · 06/09/2021 05:37

@arcof

Let the cat stay overnight. As you say if he's not been home for months in the day, surely they cannot be that attached to him. Does he even go home at night do you know? He may never actually go home anymore. Definitely ask, nothing to lose
Or maybe they're really upset because their beloved cat has disappeared because a neighbour keeps letting it in, fussing and feeding it?

I currently cat sit for someone with multiple cats and one hasn't been home for weeks. He does it regularly and when he comes back he's clearly been very well fed elsewhere Hmm but the owner has children who get really upset because kitty doesn't come home anymore.

There are pictures of the kids who clearly love the cat and he clearly loves sitting with them and being fussed by them.

I really can't believe the number of people saying it's acceptable to do this to another family. The cat has a home and a family who feed him, pay for his insurance and vet bills etc. Let him go back home.

If OP wants a cat there are thousands in rescues all over the country. She can't just take someone else's!

icedcoffees · 06/09/2021 05:29

But she has said it came for three years and spent all day there before she started feeding it, so it’s not about that.

Yes - because she let it in and gave it attention and company.

You can't just ask to take someone's cat to the other end of the country because it's cute and you've grown fond of it!

Suzi888 · 06/09/2021 04:35

I’m so sorry for your loss. Flowers

Cats seem to choose their owners and the cat has chosen you. I’m not suggesting you steal the cat, but how often do his actual family see him…. What @Saz12 says sounds like a good suggestion.

Catflapkitkat · 06/09/2021 04:09

My friend adopted two cats from a shelter, she was told they were a bonded pair but in her home it was clear the 'bond' had been broken or it had never been there. The male cat terrorised the timid girl until he began hanging out with the retired couple next door. My friend suspected they seducing him with treats but didn't say anything as they were a sweet couple who would happily look after the cats if ever she went away etc.

.A few years down the line, my friend married was planning a new life by the coast. The retired couple were devastated about loosing the male cat and asked if she would consider letting him stay with them as they had become so close to him.

It was arranged on a trial basis, a month. They kept in touch - still do. The girl cat is much more relaxed. The male cat is adored by the retired neighbours.

It can happen. They can only say 'no'

arcof · 06/09/2021 03:57

Let the cat stay overnight.
As you say if he's not been home for months in the day, surely they cannot be that attached to him. Does he even go home at night do you know? He may never actually go home anymore. Definitely ask, nothing to lose

50ShadesOfCatholic · 06/09/2021 02:49

A letter is a good idea.

Just preface it by saying, look I realise this will sound odd and I sincerely hope you are not upset or offended by this. It is a genuine and heartfelt request but I will fully respect your decision of course.

This assures them you won't steal the cat and that you have considered it from the pov.

Do it. You have nothing to lose.