Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do toddlers really *Have to go to nursery/pre school?

139 replies

Turnthefanoff · 05/09/2021 16:38

If you don’t work so it’s not a necessity they don’t go, does it matter if they don’t? Are they losing out if they don’t?
Started my Ds at pre school this week, he’s cried the whole time, much happier at home and with friends on play dates, I’m wondering if I don’t need to, why am I sending him 🤷🏻‍♀️Is it pressure from society that they should be in pre school? Or is it beneficial for them to go?

OP posts:
peachesarenom · 05/09/2021 21:51

It might just not be the right place, try another maybe?

undermycatsthumb · 05/09/2021 21:40

OP if he was 3 in July then it depends whether you plan to start him at school aged 4 or 5. If 5 then you could leave nursery a year and start nursery age 4. If you plan to start him at school age 4 then a year of nursery probably wouldn’t hurt.

I really regret sending my DS to playgroup when he wasn’t ready to be away from me. There was no rush really but because it had been the right thing for his sister I thought it would also be the right thing for him, and it wasn’t.

Skyla2005 · 05/09/2021 21:27

You have only given it a week ? Of course they don't have to go but it is very good for them to have some independence away from their mum which they don't get from a play date.

elbea · 05/09/2021 21:10

@rubbletrouble www.familyandchildcaretrust.org/long-term-study-following-4500-children-links-childcare-better-outcomes

It just takes a quick google really.

pointythings · 05/09/2021 21:03

Pumper my two benefited immensely from being in nursery. And we're middle class as anything. They came into school confident, academically ahead of the game and with great social skills. It's served them well through their entire school career.

Pumperthepumper · 05/09/2021 20:59

@rubbletrouble

There definitely is new research, as I said, I can send you some if you’re interested on learning more.

@Pumperthepumper I would be interested on a few links please as I've never seen it linked outside of deprived households.

Sure, here you go:

dera.ioe.ac.uk/8543/7/SSU-SF-2004-01.pdf

pointythings · 05/09/2021 20:59

The only thing I would say is that starting them at nursery means they will get all the usual illnesses before they start school. So if you're thinking of going back to work when they start school, and they haven't been to nursery at all, expect some tricky childcare for ill child situations. If you're not working, that isn't an issue.

My two were in nursery full time from 6 months because I worked full time so I can't comment on any of the other scenarios.

rubbletrouble · 05/09/2021 20:48

There definitely is new research, as I said, I can send you some if you’re interested on learning more.

@Pumperthepumper I would be interested on a few links please as I've never seen it linked outside of deprived households.

kowari · 05/09/2021 20:47

@Turnthefanoff

He turned 3 in July
I think it is very beneficial for three year olds thr year before school. For toddlers (one and two year olds) then mothers groups are enough if childcare is not needed.
rubbletrouble · 05/09/2021 20:45

It does benefit them, there are loads of studies on this. The benefits tend to rely on various factors though - such as group size and qualifications of the staff - and it generally trails off by age 7 anyway. So, it depends.

Where are the loads of studies showing it benefits kids in general, just a couple out of the loads would be interesting for me to read as the ones I seen only shown it was of a definite benefit to kids from deprived homes ?

pastabest · 05/09/2021 20:43

@LidlMiddleLover

No they don’t at all Nursery is for the parents not children's benefit.
Yeah, that's totally why the government funds 15 hours a week preschool education for every 3 year old and some two year olds

Do you really think it's because they think parents could do with a few hours off in the week?

Or perhaps it's because there is evidence children that age benefit from it...

rubbletrouble · 05/09/2021 20:40

No they don't need nursery or preschool, especially if they mix with others on play dates like you say and you are doing bits of teaching at home.

If you want them at home with you, keep them at home with you. They already go to school so young as it is, a bit more time at home won't do them any harm at all.

Rapunzel91 · 05/09/2021 20:37

My friend who teaches reception and year 1 says she can tell who's kids have gone to nursery/preschool and those who havent. Those who have gone usually have it easier than those who havent as they are used to the routine and structure and often more independent.

But no, its definitely not a must if you dont have to send them. Desperately applying for part time work so I can stop working full time and have my DD in nursery full time. Enjoy your time with your little one,maybe seek out some forest schools to go together and more structured groups so he gets the practice?

RedMarauder · 05/09/2021 20:35

@icedcoffees the parents don't have to be middle class to do that.

TartanJumper · 05/09/2021 20:33

@LidlMiddleLover

No they don’t at all Nursery is for the parents not children's benefit.
Rubbish. The nursery hours are a PITA- can't get much done 9-12 by the time you get home and have to set off again. Nursery teaches children so much- sharing/taking turns, new experiences, socialising, etc.
RedMarauder · 05/09/2021 20:33

@LidlMiddleLover

No they don’t at all Nursery is for the parents not children's benefit.
If this was true some councils wouldn't fund 15 hours for 2 year olds with specific needs.

Whether it is a benefit or not to put your child in childcare depends on what you do with them at home.

I know children who are/were fine at school who never went to nursery, had a childminder or any other OFSTED registered carer before they started school. However I know their parents and what their parents were teaching them.

TartanJumper · 05/09/2021 20:32

Of course they don't have to, but IME, it's much better for them to go.

Definitely give it a few more weeks, and speak to the staff to see how he is once he's inside. He also doesn't have to go every day, if it's too much for him.

Pumperthepumper · 05/09/2021 20:26

@LidlMiddleLover

No they don’t at all Nursery is for the parents not children's benefit.
Nonsense.
LidlMiddleLover · 05/09/2021 20:24

No they don’t at all Nursery is for the parents not children's benefit.

Thebig3 · 05/09/2021 20:22

If its only been a week I would definitely preserve. I have seen many children start school in reception who have never been to any previous childcare setting and have really struggled with the adjustment of starting school and being away from their parents.

What will you do next September when he starts school if this is the same reaction?

RampantIvy · 05/09/2021 20:15

I had to be with DD as her carer when she first went to pre-school. All the kids who cried when their parents left were absolutely fine after a very short while.

Can you ask the staff if your son settles after you have gone?

elbea · 05/09/2021 20:04

@icedcoffees yes, but the benefit to speech/movement at age 3 isn’t linked to income. It’s obviously general and doesn’t apply to every single child but in general there is some benefit.

One interesting things they found is that children who stay home with parents but go on lots of outdoor trips with their parents have worse movement skills. Attributed to time in the pram whilst on the outings compared to children at nursery running around and exploring.

Blueroses99 · 05/09/2021 19:53

@Turnthefanoff

He cried and was saying ‘But I want my mummy’ 😢usually very excited and confident and independent. Should I wait a little longer to see? I feel terrible sending him if it’s upsetting him and we don’t really have to! I imagined he’d love it, not be upset
Yes wait longer for him to settle in. I also didn’t have to send DD to nursery but chose to so she could experience a different and more structured environment, and to socialise eight other kids. She adjusted after a few weeks and loved going there. If I’d pulled her out after the first few teary days, she would have missed out in the long run. Wait until October half term before making any decisions.
shouldistop · 05/09/2021 19:47

I think it's beneficial from age 3. Ds1 cried at drop off for almost 2 weeks but settled fairly quickly after I left. He absolutely loved nursery and it really benefitted him, he's started school now and it's just a shame he missed out on 6 months of nursery with the lock downs.

icedcoffees · 05/09/2021 19:47

[quote elbea]There is a benefit to children going to nursery at age 3 generally, it linked to better speech and movement development.

There is a clear benefit to children from deprived backgrounds going to nursery earlier (hence the 30 hour funding for children from poorer backgrounds).

eprints.lse.ac.uk/68047/1/Anand_Development%20and%20happiness_2016.pdf[/quote]
But isn't the deprived backgrounds thing because those children generally wouldn't get much interaction or learning at home?

Whereas if you're home with an (I hate to say it) educated middle class SAHP who takes you to museums, playgroups and activities with other children, the difference between being at home or at nursery is probably much much smaller.