Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Toddler breastfeeds through the night. Feels like torture sometimes. AIBU to night wean?

36 replies

Peridotty · 05/09/2021 14:09

15 month old likes to breastfeed in the night. She will wake up crying 4 times in the night. It takes me a few seconds to breastfeed her back to sleep so that’s what I have been doing to get some peace. But she sometimes comfort sucks for an hour and it’s just torture because I can’t sleep when she is sucking. When I unlatch her she wakes up and cries. My husband and I are both exhausted!! We haven’t slept more than 3 hours in a stretch since she was born.
AIBU to night wean? Her dad will be in the room with her holding her for comfort if she wakes up if required and I’ll sleep on the sofa. I feel cruel but things are unsustainable right now!!! Any experience of night weaning a toddler?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Peridotty · 09/09/2021 12:39

Thanks to all the replies. We started night weaning 5 nights ago and so far she has not had any breastmilk until the morning. First night was a bit hairy- my husband had to hold her throughout the night and she cried on and off. Second, third and fourth nights she cried less. Fifth night she managed to sleep from 8pm all the way to 4.30am without waking up!!! Amazing!

OP posts:
EmeraldRaine · 05/09/2021 18:49

Hark at babies not needing to breastfeed at night past six months shock Given the small size of their stomachs and the fact that breastnilk provides their fluid as well as calorie intake I'd be amazed if this was true for more than a minority.

Maybe not 6 months, but by 15 months she can just as easily get any nighttime fluids she needs in the form of water. Easier, in fact because the op doesn't need to be involved with providing it past giving her dd a bottle of water at bedtime.

Darkstar4855 · 05/09/2021 17:44

I did what @89redballoons did and it worked surprisingly well. Mine was a bit older, had a bit of raging the first couple of nights, after that would happily settle with just a cuddle. Total game changer.

CecilyP · 05/09/2021 17:23

YNBU, I wanted to give up night feeding but didn’t know how. Then I had to, and found a cuddle and a bit of a rock got DS back to sleep just as well. He was 19 months and if I’d known it would be that easy, I would have done sooner.

Plenty of advice out there for beginning breastfeeding, precious little about stopping!

Chatty987 · 05/09/2021 17:12

YANBU. Night wean for sure.

FelicityBob · 05/09/2021 17:09

Of course YANBU
I went back to work on nights when my DS was 13 months. Felt cruel to be kind but it did the trick

Somethingsnappy · 05/09/2021 17:07

[quote underneaththeash]@Outfoxedbyrabbits that's not a proper peer reviewed article, it's of very limited value.

There are quite a few proper studies which show that there is an increased risk of caries in babies who are bf for over 12 months, there are also some which say that the increase is due to other factors.
If you read through some of the articles here.

pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/?term=breastfeeding+caries

OP I'm not surprised you're knackered. Time to stop![/quote]
The article is a summary of peer reviewed studies and research though, so is a valid and interesting read.

Outfoxedbyrabbits · 05/09/2021 17:05

@underneaththeash

that's not a proper peer reviewed article

No, it's a blog post. The two dozen or so references for the information in it are at the bottom of the page.

underneaththeash · 05/09/2021 16:45

@Outfoxedbyrabbits that's not a proper peer reviewed article, it's of very limited value.

There are quite a few proper studies which show that there is an increased risk of caries in babies who are bf for over 12 months, there are also some which say that the increase is due to other factors.
If you read through some of the articles here.

pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/?term=breastfeeding+caries

OP I'm not surprised you're knackered. Time to stop!

loopyapp · 05/09/2021 16:44

Anyone done this as a single parent with 3 older ones, two of which have additional needs?

17m DS4 still feeds a LOT over night and utterly loses his shot 0-60 in 0.5 seconds if I don't immediately permit access to a boob. He is inconsolable and does not back down. At all.

No the children don't go to their dads over night we use a nesting method of co-parenting and he finds any form of forced development leaps abhorrent so wouldn't facilitate night weaning before DS is ready. He does come over a few days a week at 6am to take over and let me sleep. He also does at least one tea/baths/beds routine a week.

I'm on my knees but not sure how or even if its possible in my situation to make this easier.

Oh to add DS's 2 and 3 have their own issues and if DS4's night time wailing wakes or disturbs them I end up with an adhd 10 year old wandering the house all night and a spike in epileptic seizures in the 6 year old as his epilepsy is worsened by sleep deprivation.

Any ideas?

meetthewildes · 05/09/2021 16:36

This is the thread that I needed to read today - I really need to night wean my daughter, who is nearly three. 😐 The night-time comfort sucking is the WORST.

Are you starting tonight? Shall we both give it a go?

Peridotty · 05/09/2021 16:17

@Outfoxedbyrabbits thanks! Didn’t know this existed. Will check it out. Yes that’s what I thought about the tooth decay. I read an article somewhere that it actually prevents tooth decay.
@8times @sleepylittlebunnies Good to know. that’s probably what I will do. I have already dropped the number of times I breastfeed in the day since going back to work at 13 months. No engorgement issues yet.
@Soubriquet yes she hates dummies since she was born. We tried many types. But at her age I think she shouldn’t have a dummy as it’s bad for her teeth.

OP posts:
ButteringMyArse · 05/09/2021 16:00

Of course you aren't BU. She doesn't need to either have breastmilk or comfort suck multiple times a night, she just wants to. Other forms of nourishment and comfort are available. Her preferences don't outweigh yours.

Soubriquet · 05/09/2021 15:53

If she comfort sucks, have you tried offering her a dummy?

Mummybearroars · 05/09/2021 15:47

Extended BF multiple times at night caused dental decay for my toddler. I wish I had known about breastfeeding tooth decay, I would have night weaned earlier.

Outfoxedbyrabbits · 05/09/2021 15:45

kellymom.com/ages/older-infant/tooth-decay/

Link for anyone who'd like to read up on the evidence.

sleepylittlebunnies · 05/09/2021 15:44

None of my 3 were sleeping through the night consistently by 12 months, although I don’t remember how many times they woke. I returned to work 2 nights a week after a year’s maternity leave with each of them. I’d breastfeed them to sleep before leaving and when I got in from work in the morning. DH would offer a sippy cup of water and a cuddle when they woke, they didn’t bother waking for that after 2 nights and continued to sleep through.

I breastfed morning, nap time and bed time still and gradually stopped the morning feed, then the nap time feed so the last couple of months of breastfeeding was just at bedtime, before stopping altogether between 20-24 months. None of it was particularly planned but it worked well, no upset for them or me and no engorgement issues.

8times · 05/09/2021 15:40

Eldest (18mo) night weaned in own room with dad comforting, slept next to them in bed all night offering cuddles or water. While my heart broke in another room. She cried inconsolably for a week. But was done.
Second (also about 18mo) I did the night weaning. Slept in bed with them in their room. No tears. Offered cuddles. Or water. Also done in a week.
Depends on your child. Try doing it yourself if you're sure you won't "give in" , if that don't work call in some help. Either way hopefully will only take a few days.
Then you get some precious sleep (hopefully!) X

Outfoxedbyrabbits · 05/09/2021 15:40

OP, I would recommend you join the Facebook group Breastfeeding Older Babies And Beyond, they have some gentle weaning guidelines pinned at the top of the page.

Hark at babies not needing to breastfeed at night past six months Shock Given the small size of their stomachs and the fact that breastnilk provides their fluid as well as calorie intake I'd be amazed if this was true for more than a minority.

There is no evidence that breastfeeding at night causes tooth decay (it wouldn't be very sensible evolutionarily if it did!). It's not the same as bottled milk, which tends to pool in the mouth and can cause decay.

DappledThings · 05/09/2021 15:35

Absolutely do it. I night weaned at 8 and 9 months respectively and carried on feeding in the day till 14 months. I'd have been totally wrecked and frustrated being used for comfort feeding in the night.

Peridotty · 05/09/2021 15:34

@Bambooshoot i brush them before she goes to bed. I thought that breastmilk wasn’t very decay inducing if they aren’t sucking on it all night? Sorry to hear you little one had cavities. Did the dentist say it was due to BFing?

OP posts:
Peridotty · 05/09/2021 15:32

Thank you for all the replies!!

@89redballoons DD is pretty strong and can push my hands off my boobs if I’m tightly clasping on to them saying no! :-(
@Bobsyer it’s tough isn’t it!! yeah I have been back at work and need to get up at 6.45am three days a week. My husband has been a superstar and will take her if she wakes up at 6am just to give me a small lie in.

OP posts:
Bambooshoot · 05/09/2021 15:31

How are you managing teeth cleaning? Do not be me! I breast fed to sleep a bit longer than 15 months and my son ended up with cavities in his baby teeth and I feel like it was all my fault. When I weaned I just said he was a big boy now and milk was for babies and after a while of trying (basically I couldn’t sit down anywhere for a week or he’d be over like a shot!) he accepted it.

YeOldeTrout · 05/09/2021 15:29

I think I'm quite the Earth Mama... I night weaned at 12m. It was just my limit, I needed more sleep!!

Heliachi · 05/09/2021 15:22

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.