Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I don’t want to resent my sister. Parent favouritism?

187 replies

DontWantTheRivalry · 05/09/2021 11:41

Named changed for this post so it can’t be linked to my other threads….

My sister is 43 - I am 39 and we have a brother who is 36

My sister has two sons aged 14 and 16 and she split with their dad about five years ago - it was an amicable and joint decision. He has since married (not had any more children) but he continues to see his sons often and pays more maintenance than his CMS contribution dictates. He’s very decent when it comes to financially supporting his sons and he often gives them money for extras and pays for the school uniforms and their hobbies and sports costs etc.

My sister has a job where her take home pay is about £1’400. On top of this she receives benefits (not exactly what or how much) and she also gets given £150 a month by one of our family members to “put towards her living costs”. And of course, she has the maintenance payments too (and extra) from her Ex.

Her rent is £700 and then she obviously has the bills and food costs.

As an aside, my sister doesn’t know that I know about the monthly £150 she gets given from our relative.

She has a great social life, is out most weekends, always has new clothes, frequently ordering take-outs, getting Ubers everywhere, always spending money on something, city breaks with her friends every few months etc - you get the picture. Fair enough, she must have a nice amount of excess money left after her rent and bills and can obviously use it as she likes.

However, last month our parents decided that as some of her benefits will stop over the next two years when the boys leave education, they want to use all their savings to buy her a house so she doesn’t have to worry about any rent or mortgage costs. We are talking about £200k worth of savings.

My sister is obviously over the moon and they have started looking at houses.

I love my sister very much but I’m struggling to not feel resentful about this.

So not only will she have a nicer house of her own, she will be rent/mortgage free for her foreseeable future and so her financial situation will massively improve as well as being given her own property. It seems like such a huge thing to be given seeing as she’s hardly in a dire financial situation that she needs to be rescued from.

I see some horror stories on here about sibling favouritism and I always feel aghast that parents can treat their children so differently. Our parents have always bailed her out for as long as I can remember, she never has to take responsibility for herself because she has this expectation/entitlement that our parents will always financially assist her. It’s been like this for the last two decades so it’s almost conditioned into her that the pattern will continue. I know this is probably the fault of our parents and not necessarily hers.

Our brother is clearly pissed off but he’s not one to talk about his feelings.

I haven’t said anything to my sister or our parents but I’m struggling to not feel hurt.

AIBU to feel like this?

OP posts:
TidyDancer · 05/09/2021 14:44

I think if it were viable, I would deadpan my parents with 'that's lovely you're helping us all with our houses, should we give you our bank details or do you have a chequebook?' And just wait for the reaction.

I would honestly only see this as near acceptable if the financial circumstances of the different siblings were obviously in stark contrast.

For example, I have a colleague whose dsis will get a lot more help from the parents as colleague has very rich ILs who have paid off her mortgage (and then some). The dsis and her DH don't have lots of money so will benefit more from inheritance to enable her to have a more comfortable life eventually. The whole family are aware and are supportive of this.

takehomepay · 05/09/2021 14:40

YANBU. Talk to your parents ASAP. Don’t accept this.

MrsKoala · 05/09/2021 14:39

How old are your parents? I know this isn't the point of the thread but I just thought I'd let you know that if one of your parents need care social services will more than likely see the gift as deprivation of assets and will expect your sister to repay the money or fund their care. It doesn't come under the 7 year IHT rule so it could be in 10 years.

Basically anyone older giving away huge chunks of money is judged as doing so to circumvent possible care costs. We had that with FIL and were liable for over £6k per month.

In regards to your resentment, I agree and I'd tell them how unfair they were being. I'd happily reduce contact/support based on how they'd treated me.

RedHelenB · 05/09/2021 14:36

Talk to your parents.

IceCreamAndCandyfloss · 05/09/2021 14:34

Very unfair. I’d go NC in the face of such unequal treatment with both the sibling and parents.

Your sister should be taking a second job, doing overtime etc if she can’t afford her lifestyle once benefits stop. The children must be old enough to not need childcare etc so no reason work hours are capped.

Curlyhairedassassin · 05/09/2021 14:34

Unfairness aside, even if, like they say, they won't need to go into a home, what are they going to use to fund their care in their own home if they only have a pension? It could be for many years. People seem to think that the state will pay for care in your own home, whatever your financial situation. It's just not the case, and many people get a shock when they realise how much it costs and that they have to pay for it themselves. They're not going to have any pot to dig into if they find their pension mostly gets taken up by their care costs.

I'd be really worried that they haven't got any backup savings to fund their old age properly, and be going at this from that angle. ie. asking if you and your brother would be expected to help fund their home care, because you simply won't be able to afford it as you will still be paying mortgage payments etc, unlike your sister. You could then ask if there is an arrangement with your sister for HER to fund their home care if needed, seeing as she won't have any mortgage payments?

JudgeJudyRocks · 05/09/2021 14:31

This is really unfair! My FIL has decided to help out my SIL with a large lump sum, because she really does need it. Even though me and DH are comfortable, he is giving DH the same amount, so that they are treated the same. That's how it should be imo! If they are gifting £200k, it should be split 3 ways.

Seasidemumma77 · 05/09/2021 14:30

My dm and dsf bought my home, to provide stability for me and my 4dc after my divorce. Its not a gift, on their death it still forms part of their estate, either I will need to have paid off the debt or my siblings inherit a share of the house. My siblings totally understand that my financial predicament means I've needed this help, and I know how fortunate I am to have been given this help.

Daleksatemyshed · 05/09/2021 14:18

I'm sorry Op, that's massively unfair to you and your DB. As you say, your parent's may well need care later on and the value of a house can soon vanish with the skyhigh prices the care homes charge. You really need to speak to your parents and explain that this would be not only unfair but possible financially risky, if it looks like they've delibarately stripped themselves of assets it could hugely effect their right to any benefits later on. Far better to have the house in their name just in case

HalzTangz · 05/09/2021 14:16

I don't understand why your sister couldn't get her own mortgage and the parents help out with a deposit, but equally give you and you brother the same amount. Then just split whatevers left 3 ways in the will

LunaBunaTuna · 05/09/2021 14:16

I totally understand why you would feel resentment as I am in a similar situation myself and a consequence have gone NC with my father.

If you are able to have a conversation with your parents, could you suggest that they help your sister to buy a house, paying a hefty deposit but leaving her with a mortgage of £700 per month, which she can well afford if that’s what her current rent is?

That way they won’t be using so much of their savings and they will be happy that your sister is no longer paying rent to someone else.

I don’t envy your position but you are going to have some difficult conversations. It may cause a massive falling out in the long run anyway but at least you will have got it off your chest. You need to rope your brother in to to back you up as this concerns him.

Monestera · 05/09/2021 14:16

I really don’t want any rivalry with my sister but I just can’t believe she’s allowing our parents to buy her a house without any consideration as to how it might make me and our brother feel. That’s always been her though - she’s quite selfish in some ways.

Really, this is all down to your parents' decision-making though. Why don't you ask them?

Is it a case that she's around a lot more than you and your brother? With the whole grandchildren thing, maybe they are just closer and share more? My sister is closer to our parents, she has children and I'm sure they give her a lot of support that I don't get (nor want).

ChargingBuck · 05/09/2021 14:14

[quote FannyBrice]@ChargingBuck sounds like a lovely thing to do, from her parents prospective 🙄🙄🙄[/quote]
Only if they are able to convince themselves that it's fine to hurt their other 2 childrens' feelings, which is pretty far from "lovely" no matter whose perspective it's from.

HeronLanyon · 05/09/2021 14:13

It all sounds very odd. What is needed and I’m really surprised your parents haven’t done this is for there to have been clear communication for all of you as to why the plan was and why and what it will mean for you and your brother. Obviously they can do what they want with their win money but it’s no good the whole family now relying on rumour and supposition.
For all you know they may be renting it to her or owning it as joint tenants etc. They may think they are cleverly protecting their money from care cost/iht (but they are still young!) and this route won’t work. Do they have any financial advisor do you know ?
Bloody hell families eh?

PumpkinPatch21 · 05/09/2021 14:07

If they aren't going into a home... Is your sister going to be the one caring for them? Because I wouldn't be doing if I was you not after the way they've treated you and your brother.

DontWantTheRivalry · 05/09/2021 14:02

OP has your parents said their will be nothing left for you and your brother, I presume your parents also have their own house, could it be that the sister gets 200k now but you and the brother get their house when they pass.

My brother guessed this would be the case. There house is worth about £200k so even if it went ahead me and my brother would get £100k each, so only half of what my sister has been given.

Plus, like I said to my brother, there’s no guarantee there will be a house to sell anyway as it may need to be sold many years before their passing to pay for medical or nursing homes fees etc. My parents are convinced they’ll never go into ‘a home’ but old age isn’t that predictable is it.

Like I said though, deep down this isn’t about the money, I don’t want or need it, I’m just angry about how unfair it is to me and my brother whilst yet again our sister holds her hand out and gets offered everything which she happily takes.

OP posts:
HalzTangz · 05/09/2021 13:56

OP has your parents said their will be nothing left for you and your brother, I presume your parents also have their own house, could it be that the sister gets 200k now but you and the brother get their house when they pass.

You need to speak with your parents and let them know how this is affecting you and your brother. It may well be they reassure you by saying their house will be yours jointly

Eesha · 05/09/2021 13:49

This happened with my ex and his siblings. It completely wrecked their family. One sibling despised the other for taking it. My ex was in the middle because he tried to not take sides. I would probably have a quiet word with your parents about it and whether it's fair to proceed. Surprised your sister is considering this. She sounds awful.

DontWantTheRivalry · 05/09/2021 13:49

I'd definitely need to be asking what the reasoning is here?

The reasoning is because they think that renting is throwing away money and so they want her on the property market…..but as she cannot afford that, they are just going to buy a house for her. And for the previous poster who asked, the house will be in my sister’s name. I.e it will be her house, not a house that they own which she just lives in.

In relation to another posters experience: I was always the more academic child growing up, I did better at school, in my A Levels and went to Uni etc, whereas my sister stopped bothering when she was about 14. She went to college after school but dropped out of two courses and so always just drifted from job to job in her twenties with no real aim or goal. She does have a stable job now but it’s one she fell into about 10 years ago and she has since climbed the ladder.

She’s always played the victim, constantly going on: “My sister is more clever than me and so she has a better job and wage than me” etc etc. Its like she wants pity, my parents feel bad for her and so throw money at her. It’s a little manipulative at times.

OP posts:
ThePlantsitter · 05/09/2021 13:48

Ouch! That would really hurt! I do think you need to say something, but be prepared for everyone to be very defensive and say you're being unreasonable. Take it from there. You're not being unreasonable.

I think when parents are prepared to be as uneven handed as this there must be an extra ingredient you don't know about, i.e some reason they feel extra responsible for her like she was ill as a baby or her parentage was unclear or something. I'm not saying that's what it is! But there must be something. It won't be that they love her more. I completely get that it would feel like that though!!

godmum56 · 05/09/2021 13:48

well don't resent your sister, resent your parents

SirVixofVixHall · 05/09/2021 13:46

@CaddieDawg

I think you need to have this out with them, so that everything is out on the table and you all know where you stand. It's hard to have these conversations so I'd ask what the plan is for the rest of your parents retirement,what happens if one needs to go into a home or something else that means they need the cash unexpectedly? Is sister to fork out for that since she'll be saving monthly without rent/mortgage payments? Or will they be living with her and that's why they are buying the house?

You haven't mentioned yours and your brother's circumstances, but it's not unreasonable to also ask why one DC is being treated like this and no provision for the other 2? If there are other grandchildren,why they aren't being thought of too? Nobody can predict the future.

At least with it all out, you may learn there's more to it. If not,then you know where you stand and you can be clear about how this makes you feel/impacts your relationship.

I agree with this. And I am glad that my parents treated us equally, as my MIL favours her dd and not my dh and it causes so much hurt.
2pinkginsplease · 05/09/2021 13:46

I would have to speak up. That is so unfair and will end up with you and your brother feeling resentful to your parent and sister.

Your sister is just as bad by accepting all this knowing that you and your brother are being left out!

2020nymph · 05/09/2021 13:46

@MrsKrystalStubbs

We have this in our family too. Divorced SIL gets money every month, car paid for and had mortgage paid off in full. But we don’t resent it, she is close by (we are many hours away) and is starting to have to step up massively with the PILS care needs. I’m sure your parents will expect the same OP. Don’t let resentment take over, it’s not worth it.

When DSis's relationship broke down my parents gifted her a substantial amount of money for her deposit so much so that her mortgage payment is 25% of ours. We also have huge childcare costs. Both our choices but money is tight.

They did mention that as I live 1.5 hours away, my DSis would be helping with their care when they are older. Dsis has since moved to the other side of the country and their was comments I would need to help. I have told them that I will help sort out their care when the time comes but I won't be doing it myself as it's a three hour round trip on the rare occasions we get good traffic.

Chloemol · 05/09/2021 13:45

YANBU and to be honest I would be sitting down with your parents and telling them how you feel

That she has enough income to splash the cash already, and in fact could be saving that for the future

That you don’t know what your future holds, what happens if you if you your job etc, would they be buying you a house so you didn’t have to find money for a mortgage or rent, same for your brother

I would be explaining that If they continue to help her in this way then it’s obvious they dint care about you or your brother and I would go LC or even NC

Then when they older and need help your sister can do it

I just don’t understand why parents would treat children differently