Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I don’t want to resent my sister. Parent favouritism?

187 replies

DontWantTheRivalry · 05/09/2021 11:41

Named changed for this post so it can’t be linked to my other threads….

My sister is 43 - I am 39 and we have a brother who is 36

My sister has two sons aged 14 and 16 and she split with their dad about five years ago - it was an amicable and joint decision. He has since married (not had any more children) but he continues to see his sons often and pays more maintenance than his CMS contribution dictates. He’s very decent when it comes to financially supporting his sons and he often gives them money for extras and pays for the school uniforms and their hobbies and sports costs etc.

My sister has a job where her take home pay is about £1’400. On top of this she receives benefits (not exactly what or how much) and she also gets given £150 a month by one of our family members to “put towards her living costs”. And of course, she has the maintenance payments too (and extra) from her Ex.

Her rent is £700 and then she obviously has the bills and food costs.

As an aside, my sister doesn’t know that I know about the monthly £150 she gets given from our relative.

She has a great social life, is out most weekends, always has new clothes, frequently ordering take-outs, getting Ubers everywhere, always spending money on something, city breaks with her friends every few months etc - you get the picture. Fair enough, she must have a nice amount of excess money left after her rent and bills and can obviously use it as she likes.

However, last month our parents decided that as some of her benefits will stop over the next two years when the boys leave education, they want to use all their savings to buy her a house so she doesn’t have to worry about any rent or mortgage costs. We are talking about £200k worth of savings.

My sister is obviously over the moon and they have started looking at houses.

I love my sister very much but I’m struggling to not feel resentful about this.

So not only will she have a nicer house of her own, she will be rent/mortgage free for her foreseeable future and so her financial situation will massively improve as well as being given her own property. It seems like such a huge thing to be given seeing as she’s hardly in a dire financial situation that she needs to be rescued from.

I see some horror stories on here about sibling favouritism and I always feel aghast that parents can treat their children so differently. Our parents have always bailed her out for as long as I can remember, she never has to take responsibility for herself because she has this expectation/entitlement that our parents will always financially assist her. It’s been like this for the last two decades so it’s almost conditioned into her that the pattern will continue. I know this is probably the fault of our parents and not necessarily hers.

Our brother is clearly pissed off but he’s not one to talk about his feelings.

I haven’t said anything to my sister or our parents but I’m struggling to not feel hurt.

AIBU to feel like this?

OP posts:
billy1966 · 05/09/2021 16:28

Your parents are really dim if they think someone so selfish to take money from an 87 year old is going to step up and be so altruistic as to be their carer if needed.

Highly unlikely IMO.

ChargingBuck · 05/09/2021 16:25

She just doesn’t care. Where’s her conscience? I just don’t understand it.

If you spoke with her about it, & asked her about the unfairness to you & DB, what would she say?

DontWantTheRivalry · 05/09/2021 16:23

Thank you everyone for all your thoughts.

I just feel so lousy about it all.

I feel resentment and jealousy towards my sister and I feel so bloody angry. It’s just made me feel so mad.

I feel like just leaving them all to it and stepping back to be honest.

The money she takes each month from one of our relatives is 87 years old……and she just takes it. I could never, ever do that. She just doesn’t care. Where’s her conscience? I just don’t understand it.

OP posts:
billy1966 · 05/09/2021 16:20

YANBU to be upset and you do need to communicate to your parents that you would like to know why.

IME giving a huge inheritance to one favoured child and expecting elder care is deeply flawed.

IME it has caused huge strife and the favoured child has not hesitated to sell their home and move away.

In the one case I know the parents have never heeled the rift with their daughters and don't see them even though they live very close by.

Their brother accepted the family home and built a small two bed for the parents in a corner of the large site tucked away.

Within 5 years he accepted a job across the country and sold the family home for a profit.
He visits very, very occasionally.

He was ways about himself and his sisters weren't suprised, but they have not relented and they have raised their children without their parents involvement.

Really sad and mortifying for their parents.

But the parents brought it upon themselves and have no one to blame but themselves.

Your parents need to be told that if they choose the path of massively favouring one child above the others, they need to accept the consequences.

The consequences will be that you will be very hurt and feel VERY wronged.

The rest is in THEIR hands but they can't say it wasn't spelt out to them.

Flowers
BreadInCaptivity · 05/09/2021 16:18

OP you absolutely need to speak to your parents.

This plan is absolutely insane for many reasons:

  • They are at an age where they are no longer in a position to replenish these savings. What happens if they need to fund emergency house repairs for example?
  • Whilst they do not intend to end up in a home they have no idea what the future will bring. That aside even if they may remain at home they are likely at some point to need some form of care. It might be getting someone to do cleaning/gardening or more intense than that. They will need to fund this.
  • They and you need to read up on deprecation of assets. If they need care those assets are liable to be recovered from your sister.
  • They are effectively disinheriting you and your brother in f the situation arises that their home needs to be sold to fund care. Yes it's their money and they are not obligated to leave you anything but do they want to be responsible for creating resentment and hurt by treating one child more favourably than the others?
  • No financial advisor would recommend a plan such as this. This perhaps is to your benefit as you could suggest they need to speak to a professional before embarking on this course of action.
  • if your sister can afford rent, she can afford a mortgage. Lending or even giving her a deposit is one thing. Buying a house outright is quite another and from what you've described totally unnecessary.
  • if you don't speak to them now this will just fester and as above it's a really bad plan for your parents even discounting the lack of fairness between the siblings.
TractorAndHeadphones · 05/09/2021 16:15

@Rosiiiiie

There could be more to the story that you’re unaware of. My dad bought my sister a beautiful 3 bedroom penthouse overlooking the sea. I was quite cross when I found out but when I talked to him about it he explained that she was essentially paying him the mortgage back, just at her speed and without interests. You just need to bring it up with them- see what they have to say.
I'd consider that similar though (unless he gave it to her as a loan legally). What if she decides to stop repaying - or he dies before she repays?

One of my aunts was like OP's sister - squeezed parents for all she could, but left it to other siblings to pay for parental care (this was in a foreign country). They never forgave her.

Billybagpuss · 05/09/2021 16:05

The other thing you need to work out before you speak to them is maybe what would be acceptable to you, if for example your parents bought a house and she stayed in it, either rent free or minimal rent? Would that work for you.

Do your DP realise that she loses the benefits when the dc are 18 because she shouldn’t need them anymore, they are old enough to get jobs go to uni etc. Buying a house is massively over solving the situation, they could give the dc an allowance to help through uni etc. Their argument that renting is throwing away good money, whilst true, cannot fairly be used when db is also renting.

ChargingBuck · 05/09/2021 16:02

It just seems to have come out of nowhere.

Seems that way, but unlikely.
Despite not bothering to see your parents as much as you do, when she does contact them, she's certainly effective in getting what she wants.

I would imagine she's been hinting/complaining behind the scenes, until parents cough up.

Are you going to ask your folks why they are favouring your sister, who has so much more disposable income than you do?
It's unlikely to change their minds, or the situation, but I suspect if you leave it & seethe, it is going to fester.

DontWantTheRivalry · 05/09/2021 15:56

To answer some previous questions…

In general I would say I’m closer to my parents than my sister is. I see them about once a week and phone them 1-2 times a week, whereas my sister has much less contact than that.

And the house she lives in is the same house she lived in with her Ex. They’d always rented as they’d never been in a position to save up for a large deposit and when they broke up he moved out.

My parents have never previously been bothered about her renting after the split…..yet suddenly, many years later it’s a problem and their solution is to buy her a house.

It just seems to have come out of nowhere.

I would understand it more if my sister was in a difficult financial position but she isn’t - I would love to have money to spend in the same way she does.

My brother has never been close to her, possibly because of the age gap, so he doesn’t feel as hurt as I do because he doesn’t have a particularly significant bond with her, but he’s definitely pissed off at our parents.

And as for our living situations, I have a mortgage with my DH and my brother rents with his long term partner.

OP posts:
Hikingforscenery · 05/09/2021 15:50

Perhaps your sister has some circumstances you don’t know about.
I wouldn’t mind if my parents gave my siblings something like this and nothing to me though as I don’t need it.
My parents have done their bit by paying for my education, needs etc an I am now in a position to take care of myself. Anything they give me now will be extra I am not expecting.

Rosiiiiie · 05/09/2021 15:42

There could be more to the story that you’re unaware of.
My dad bought my sister a beautiful 3 bedroom penthouse overlooking the sea. I was quite cross when I found out but when I talked to him about it he explained that she was essentially paying him the mortgage back, just at her speed and without interests.
You just need to bring it up with them- see what they have to say.

Billybagpuss · 05/09/2021 15:40

You do need to talk to them, ideally as a united front with dB or resentment will grow.

CinnamonJellyBeans · 05/09/2021 15:31

Don't allow your parents to cite "future care" as a reason for them giving your sister the house.

She will not be legally obliged to do it and even if she is willing, she may be unable to keep up with the demands of dementia or mobility care, so they could end up in a home anyway, which will erode the value of heir own house.

This is a disgraceful way to treat your family. It's not just inheritance for you; it's also for your children.

Dashel · 05/09/2021 15:27

I would have to speak to your parents and let them know how annoyed you were that they are treating you so differently.

In 5 years time, things could be very different, your sister could be married to a millionaire and you could be divorced, but giving her that house is final and they won’t be in a position to help you or your brother financially in the future if the need should arise

Roonilwazlib1 · 05/09/2021 15:17

Sorry to hear this OP, it really is hugely unfair.

I would speak to your parents about it but from the angle that you want to check they have enough to live off. If they live to a very grand old age they could have up to 30 years of life left, and as you said they may need care which they may not be able to cover and this could be viewed as deprivation of assets.

I'd ask them if the idea is that your sister is to provide any future care as otherwise you can't see why she is being gifted such a huge sum, which by your reckoning is 50% of their net worth which is a huge amount.

grapewine · 05/09/2021 15:13

And I would think a lot less of the sister taking handouts from family left and right, tbh. I don't usually go NC, but there would be very low contact if this happens, with the sister and parents.

Brollypackedforscottishholiday · 05/09/2021 15:11

I would start pleading poverty... Least then you know where you stand if you get nowt..
And hopefully dsis has plenty of loo roll.
Golden One becomes the bum wiper imo.

Abitofalark · 05/09/2021 15:09

I surmise that what's important to your parents is ensuring security for her and her children, following her divorce. Hence the house purchase. Do you and your brother own or rent? What happened to your sister's marital home on divorce? Couldn't that have provided a house and home for her and the children or at least some equity in it to use towards buying one, with a lump sum contribution from your parents so she'd have a small mortgage?

Even now they could give her a substantial sum so she could afford a mortgage to buy her own. They'd still have some money left which they might need in view of their age if all they've got is state pension rather than occupational pension(s) plus state. Might be worth mentioning to them that they and she need to be aware of potential care costs and local council claiming deprivation of assets if they give it all away - less likely to be able to make that claim stick if they were just part helping their daughter and grandchildren with a sum while retaining a good part of their savings.

grapewine · 05/09/2021 15:09

@PumpkinPatch21

If they aren't going into a home... Is your sister going to be the one caring for them? Because I wouldn't be doing if I was you not after the way they've treated you and your brother.
I mean, this.

I'd be so resentful at this. It's so OTT.

Motorina · 05/09/2021 15:06

I have been NC with my parents (and minimal contact with my brother) for 5 years because of this. Like you, I don't need the money. But the unfairness is hugely painful.

My parents apparently continue to insist that it's totally fair and I am wildly unreasonable. I don't begin to understand any of it and it does feel like they love me less than my brother.

Feedingthebirds1 · 05/09/2021 15:03

@DontWantTheRivalry

OP has your parents said their will be nothing left for you and your brother, I presume your parents also have their own house, could it be that the sister gets 200k now but you and the brother get their house when they pass.

My brother guessed this would be the case. There house is worth about £200k so even if it went ahead me and my brother would get £100k each, so only half of what my sister has been given.

Plus, like I said to my brother, there’s no guarantee there will be a house to sell anyway as it may need to be sold many years before their passing to pay for medical or nursing homes fees etc. My parents are convinced they’ll never go into ‘a home’ but old age isn’t that predictable is it.

Like I said though, deep down this isn’t about the money, I don’t want or need it, I’m just angry about how unfair it is to me and my brother whilst yet again our sister holds her hand out and gets offered everything which she happily takes.

But even if they don't end up using the house to pay for care home fees, you and your brother are only guessing that they will split the proceeds of their house between you. And given what you've said about their favouritism of your sister I would be very surprised if this was the case. At best they'll split it three ways, and may well leave a much greater proportion to your sister.
Tistheseason17 · 05/09/2021 14:58

Yep, I'd be pissed off, too.

I'm all for not expecting an inheritance but giving money unfairly whilst alive is a shitty thing to do.

HazelBite · 05/09/2021 14:51

Op your parents are far too young to diminish their savings like this. I am nearing 70 and have my state and occupational pension, it covers living but no luxuries (like holidays etc).
Yes provide a deposit if they feel they need to but she needs to prove she can afford the mortgage.
The other option (you will need legal advice) is to create a trust with all say grandchildren as beneficiaries and the trust purchases the house, (this would seem the fairest option to me) with your sister allowed to live in it during her lifetime.

The worry about all of this is how, financially, is your sister going to maintain this property? Will your parents be forever paying out for this too?

cptartapp · 05/09/2021 14:51

SIL got thousands for a house deposit and all her wedding paid for. DH got nothing.
We think a lot less of them and see them far less often now than we could do.
No going back from it.

GoWalkabout · 05/09/2021 14:49

I think you need to tell your sister, your parents and your brother. 'I think that by wanting to help dsis you are actually being thoughtless and unfair to me and dbro. I could sit here and get resentful without telling you why, or I could tell you how I feel so that we all know where we stand.' I would then decide how their actions make me feel about our future relationship. (As an aside, I was faced with being told about a smaller but similarly unfair inequality and unlike dsis I didn't try to hide my disgust - a further conversation was had as a result and the inequality was addressed. Family can take you for granted sometimes.