Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I don’t want to resent my sister. Parent favouritism?

187 replies

DontWantTheRivalry · 05/09/2021 11:41

Named changed for this post so it can’t be linked to my other threads….

My sister is 43 - I am 39 and we have a brother who is 36

My sister has two sons aged 14 and 16 and she split with their dad about five years ago - it was an amicable and joint decision. He has since married (not had any more children) but he continues to see his sons often and pays more maintenance than his CMS contribution dictates. He’s very decent when it comes to financially supporting his sons and he often gives them money for extras and pays for the school uniforms and their hobbies and sports costs etc.

My sister has a job where her take home pay is about £1’400. On top of this she receives benefits (not exactly what or how much) and she also gets given £150 a month by one of our family members to “put towards her living costs”. And of course, she has the maintenance payments too (and extra) from her Ex.

Her rent is £700 and then she obviously has the bills and food costs.

As an aside, my sister doesn’t know that I know about the monthly £150 she gets given from our relative.

She has a great social life, is out most weekends, always has new clothes, frequently ordering take-outs, getting Ubers everywhere, always spending money on something, city breaks with her friends every few months etc - you get the picture. Fair enough, she must have a nice amount of excess money left after her rent and bills and can obviously use it as she likes.

However, last month our parents decided that as some of her benefits will stop over the next two years when the boys leave education, they want to use all their savings to buy her a house so she doesn’t have to worry about any rent or mortgage costs. We are talking about £200k worth of savings.

My sister is obviously over the moon and they have started looking at houses.

I love my sister very much but I’m struggling to not feel resentful about this.

So not only will she have a nicer house of her own, she will be rent/mortgage free for her foreseeable future and so her financial situation will massively improve as well as being given her own property. It seems like such a huge thing to be given seeing as she’s hardly in a dire financial situation that she needs to be rescued from.

I see some horror stories on here about sibling favouritism and I always feel aghast that parents can treat their children so differently. Our parents have always bailed her out for as long as I can remember, she never has to take responsibility for herself because she has this expectation/entitlement that our parents will always financially assist her. It’s been like this for the last two decades so it’s almost conditioned into her that the pattern will continue. I know this is probably the fault of our parents and not necessarily hers.

Our brother is clearly pissed off but he’s not one to talk about his feelings.

I haven’t said anything to my sister or our parents but I’m struggling to not feel hurt.

AIBU to feel like this?

OP posts:
NoSquirrels · 05/09/2021 18:28

There’s no going back really as it seems to be a forgone conclusion now.

I have accepted I can’t change it - I just don’t know how to move on from it

You can speak up - it’s very defeatist to say it’s a forgone conclusion etc. Perhaps they genuinely haven’t considered the implications of this. Have a discussion. I can’t think why you wouldn’t.

BreadInCaptivity · 05/09/2021 18:23

@DontWantTheRivalry

My dad just phoned me but I couldn’t bring myself to answer the phone. It will just be for our usual weekend chat but I can’t talk to him like this very thing is okay.

I honestly don’t know what the answer is. They’ve made their choice, they’re already looking for houses so it’s not like things are in the early stages. There’s no going back really as it seems to be a forgone conclusion now.

I have accepted I can’t change it - I just don’t know how to move on from it Sad

Nothing is done until they've bought a house.

Frankly I don't understand your reluctance to speak to your parents about it.

They currently have no idea how you feel and the consequences of this (frankly ridiculous) plan that are already starting to manifest by you not wanting to pick up the phone.

You've got nothing to lose by talking to them because if you don't your relationship is soured anyway.

I simply don't think there is a way of getting past something like this.

It's not about the money. It the total lack of regard for the feelings of the less favoured children - something that stings all the more when the gift in this place is utter overkill wrt your sisters financial circumstances.

RandomMess · 05/09/2021 18:22

There is nothing wrong with telling your parents that you are hurt they are buying your sister a house when you and your DB get nothing and if your sister has money to go out partying every weekend she has money to save towards buying a house herself.

NoSquirrels · 05/09/2021 18:19

Speak to them about it.

Mum, Dad - why are you buying sister a house outright? You’re leaving yourself with no money in retirement and you might need it. Wouldn’t it be better to help her with a deposit so she can get a mortgage? You haven’t given brother or me any money to get on the property ladder so it seems a bit weird.

Zombiemum1946 · 05/09/2021 18:19

This is extremely unfair and also short sighted. Your sister is unlikely to be able to afford the upkeep unless her income and commonsense increase drastically. How is she supposed to furnish the house ? Are they paying for that as well? I'd query whether your parents have thought this through without the rose tinted glasses. Your parents are relatively young, and if all their savings are going into this, will have no financial cushion either and maybe your sister needs to be reminded of this. As angry as you maybe about this (and I would bloody furious ) an open and honest conversation may need to be had that explains in simple terms why they're doing this and what are the longterm plans for when your sister hits problems. Most importantly they need to know how much this hurts you and your brother.

Porcupineintherough · 05/09/2021 18:19

If they wanted her on the housing ladder they could just give her a deposit and she could pay the mortgage. She doesnt need a whole, gift wrapped house.

You have to speak up or walk away OP. This will destroy your relationship w your parents anyway if you try and pretend it's not happening.

juice92 · 05/09/2021 18:17

*likely to be quite some time

juice92 · 05/09/2021 18:16

Maybe there is another reason they are doing this, perhaps they want to buy your sister a house to live in the hope of escaping care home fees in the long run. At 66 and 69 it is in unlikely to be quite some time before they need to think about it, but sometimes the conversations/ideas take place years in advance.

That being said if that was their intention they should be making it clear to you as such a big gift to your sister would - quite rightly - make you feel like she was being favoured.

I have a sibling who regularly gets handouts from my parents and although I don't want or need it, sometimes it does sting a bit.

DontWantTheRivalry · 05/09/2021 18:12

My dad just phoned me but I couldn’t bring myself to answer the phone. It will just be for our usual weekend chat but I can’t talk to him like this very thing is okay.

I honestly don’t know what the answer is. They’ve made their choice, they’re already looking for houses so it’s not like things are in the early stages. There’s no going back really as it seems to be a forgone conclusion now.

I have accepted I can’t change it - I just don’t know how to move on from it Sad

OP posts:
billy1966 · 05/09/2021 18:06

@Disfordarkchocolate

I don't think I could stay silent; about this and the £150.

Then I'd take a massive step back from everyone but your brother. There is no way your sister is going to step up and help your parents when they are older. Not only is it not in her nature your parents won't want to burden her either, that will be you.

This.

The expectation that your parents do this and life continues on as normal is hugely unrealistic IMO.

Your parents age and they burden you whilst feckless sister has the life, subsidised forever by them?

Self respect is the issue.

In my last post where the daughters completely turned their back on their parents 10 years ago it was due to self respect.

They had been reared in a home where the son was king and the girls just got on with it.
Well as children they accepted it as that was the way things were and they had no choice.

However as adults they could speak up and state clearly their problem with what their parents proposed to do.

Their parents disregarded them and went ahead.

The went low contact as was their right.

They have NO DOUBT their brother sought a job at the other side of the country so as not to be caught with any caring duties.

He sold their fine home and they will spend their remaining funds on care as their 3 daughters have zero contact with them now, nor do their 10 grandchildren.

The inheritance was the icing on a bitter cake of their brother being a spoiled child.

It's very sad for the parents as they age to know their precious son doesn't give a shit about them and their three daughters have ben alienated by their actions to such an extent.

I think anything other that an even split would have to be okay by the children honestly.

I would be devastated to think our actions would cause a split amongst out children.

Even split is the safest route.

ChargingBuck · 05/09/2021 17:29

@adoreyou

If they wanted to make it "fair"

Could they not buy a property and put it in all 3 of your names?
Your sister can then live there... Possibly pay a reduced "rent" to you and your brother?
That's the only way I can see them being able to do it without causing serious upset.

If they go ahead OP, as currently planned, I don't blame you for being upset and would find it very hard not to say something!

Oh god no no no no NO!

Can you imagine the bother & stress the sister could cause with this arrangement?

& what happens years down the line, when OP or DB want to sell the shared property that their sister is a part-owner of & sitting tenant in?

How do you think that will go, with the form the sister has for selfishness & entitlement?

Disfordarkchocolate · 05/09/2021 17:28

I don't think I could stay silent; about this and the £150.

Then I'd take a massive step back from everyone but your brother. There is no way your sister is going to step up and help your parents when they are older. Not only is it not in her nature your parents won't want to burden her either, that will be you.

1FootInTheRave · 05/09/2021 17:24

Your sister is a scrounging leech.

I'd be very very upset with all of them tbh and would have to voice it.

adoreyou · 05/09/2021 17:21

If they wanted to make it "fair"

Could they not buy a property and put it in all 3 of your names?
Your sister can then live there... Possibly pay a reduced "rent" to you and your brother?
That's the only way I can see them being able to do it without causing serious upset.

If they go ahead OP, as currently planned, I don't blame you for being upset and would find it very hard not to say something!

DontWantTheRivalry · 05/09/2021 17:16

Also - do you respect them as people in the sense of being capable adults good with finances etc? Because you are presenting them as very thick individuals who despite knowing their daughters income and lifestyle, seem to think she’s on the bones of her ass

I think my parents are being very thick. They are kidding themselves, or in denial or something….I have absolutely no idea why they think my sister is in dire straits.

All her social media profile does (which both parents can see) is show how she’s off out every weekend and spending money.

It feels like my parents have lost their minds.

OP posts:
HeckyPeck · 05/09/2021 16:56

I would speak to them too OP.

If she's earning well and in a stable job why can't they just gift her the minimum deposit she needs to get a mortgage? They could then give the same gift to all their children without causing resentment.

DisappearingHelen · 05/09/2021 16:53

Hi Op.

My situation is a bit different but I thought I’d give you an idea of consequences of these things.
My brother has recently been favoured to the tune of several hundred thousand pounds. There are a bunch of circumstances that resulted in this but they’re long and dull.

At the time mum was talking about doing this I was a bit horrified at her giving away a massive chunk of wealth and so I spoke up and voiced my concerns in a diplomatic way and heavily caveated with ‘but at the end of the day it’s your money!’. My brother was awful to me about it. He bullied and manipulated and aimed fury at me accusing me of being money grabbing (the irony was entirely lost on him). My mum said she understood what I was saying but then insisted on going ahead with the gift. I told her I’d make my peace with it and stay out of it.

This was probably about a year ago. It’s all gone ahead. I have tried to get over my issues with the situation; not only the unfairness between siblings and concerns for mum’s long term financial needs but my resentment of her giving money to a bully of a man who is already pretty well off (he owns a property outright and earns twice as much as my pretty decent salary!). I haven’t been able to get over it. I don’t think I’ll ever be able to speak to my brother again. I’ve tried to stay in touch with mum but it causes me upset and stress every time she mentions anything related to the situation. I don’t think she meant to meant to cause an upset or basically send the message that she loves him more than me but that is the way it feels.

I barely see her anymore as I no longer trust her and it’s really sad. Perhaps you’re more resilient than me and won’t suffer as much but tread carefully if you do say anything or if you decide to say nothing. It’s bloody miserable either way I think and this could destroy the family ties you have. Be prepared for the worst and hope for the best.

Marni83 · 05/09/2021 16:49

@DontWantTheRivalry

And how is your relationship with your parents and sister?

I have a great relationship with my parents, I always have, which is why this has shocked me so much.

And as for my relationship with my sister, it’s always been fine. I’ve always thought her to have a selfish streak, but we’ve always got on absolutely fine. I can honestly say we’ve never had a fall out since we were teenagers.

I just feel knocked sideways by it all.

The fact that she is accepting this and revelling in it with glee is making me feel very differently towards her. I hate it. I always considered her to be one of my favourite people….and now, it just feels so different Sad

But you say this has always been the case So baffled you’re shocked

And if you have a great relationship

Then. Talk. To. Them.

Also - do you respect them as people in the sense of being capable adults good with finances etc? Because you are presenting them as very thick individuals who despite knowing their daughters income and lifestyle, seem to think she’s on the bones of her ass

ittakes2 · 05/09/2021 16:47

You should speak to your parents about it. Maybe the money is a loan or an investment they are thinking they are avoiding inheritance tax if you are in the UK? My parents loaned my single mother sister money so she could buy a house. They had her write into her will that the money was going to be shared by the other siblings.

grapewine · 05/09/2021 16:46

Taking money from her 87-year-old relative every month is so utterly selfish.

ChargingBuck · 05/09/2021 16:45

The fact that she is accepting this and revelling in it with glee is making me feel very differently towards her. I hate it. I always considered her to be one of my favourite people….and now, it just feels so different

Sweetheart, you need to tell her, not us.
We can't give you explanations, or solutions.
Your sister can.

DontWantTheRivalry · 05/09/2021 16:42

And how is your relationship with your parents and sister?

I have a great relationship with my parents, I always have, which is why this has shocked me so much.

And as for my relationship with my sister, it’s always been fine. I’ve always thought her to have a selfish streak, but we’ve always got on absolutely fine. I can honestly say we’ve never had a fall out since we were teenagers.

I just feel knocked sideways by it all.

The fact that she is accepting this and revelling in it with glee is making me feel very differently towards her. I hate it. I always considered her to be one of my favourite people….and now, it just feels so different Sad

OP posts:
Ukholidaysaregreat · 05/09/2021 16:42

Would it be worth speaking to your sister. She seems to have a very take, take attitude so she may not even understand where you are coming from. I would definitely talk to your parents. I would want them to know how hurt I felt and give them a chance to explain or maybe balance out the favouritism. What they did after you had spoken to them would then influence how I decided to react about it. It's possible at the moment that they think you and DBro are happy with the situation. I think it is very unfair and it is important to treat all your children the same.

BreadInCaptivity · 05/09/2021 16:35

@DontWantTheRivalry

Thank you everyone for all your thoughts.

I just feel so lousy about it all.

I feel resentment and jealousy towards my sister and I feel so bloody angry. It’s just made me feel so mad.

I feel like just leaving them all to it and stepping back to be honest.

The money she takes each month from one of our relatives is 87 years old……and she just takes it. I could never, ever do that. She just doesn’t care. Where’s her conscience? I just don’t understand it.

Well if you don't say anything you'll never know if you could have changed the outcome.

If you do say something and they ignore you then neither your parents or sister ought to be surprised if you back right off from them after that.

Marni83 · 05/09/2021 16:29

Take this issue out of the equation

Ans how is your relationship with your parents and sister?