Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I don’t want to resent my sister. Parent favouritism?

187 replies

DontWantTheRivalry · 05/09/2021 11:41

Named changed for this post so it can’t be linked to my other threads….

My sister is 43 - I am 39 and we have a brother who is 36

My sister has two sons aged 14 and 16 and she split with their dad about five years ago - it was an amicable and joint decision. He has since married (not had any more children) but he continues to see his sons often and pays more maintenance than his CMS contribution dictates. He’s very decent when it comes to financially supporting his sons and he often gives them money for extras and pays for the school uniforms and their hobbies and sports costs etc.

My sister has a job where her take home pay is about £1’400. On top of this she receives benefits (not exactly what or how much) and she also gets given £150 a month by one of our family members to “put towards her living costs”. And of course, she has the maintenance payments too (and extra) from her Ex.

Her rent is £700 and then she obviously has the bills and food costs.

As an aside, my sister doesn’t know that I know about the monthly £150 she gets given from our relative.

She has a great social life, is out most weekends, always has new clothes, frequently ordering take-outs, getting Ubers everywhere, always spending money on something, city breaks with her friends every few months etc - you get the picture. Fair enough, she must have a nice amount of excess money left after her rent and bills and can obviously use it as she likes.

However, last month our parents decided that as some of her benefits will stop over the next two years when the boys leave education, they want to use all their savings to buy her a house so she doesn’t have to worry about any rent or mortgage costs. We are talking about £200k worth of savings.

My sister is obviously over the moon and they have started looking at houses.

I love my sister very much but I’m struggling to not feel resentful about this.

So not only will she have a nicer house of her own, she will be rent/mortgage free for her foreseeable future and so her financial situation will massively improve as well as being given her own property. It seems like such a huge thing to be given seeing as she’s hardly in a dire financial situation that she needs to be rescued from.

I see some horror stories on here about sibling favouritism and I always feel aghast that parents can treat their children so differently. Our parents have always bailed her out for as long as I can remember, she never has to take responsibility for herself because she has this expectation/entitlement that our parents will always financially assist her. It’s been like this for the last two decades so it’s almost conditioned into her that the pattern will continue. I know this is probably the fault of our parents and not necessarily hers.

Our brother is clearly pissed off but he’s not one to talk about his feelings.

I haven’t said anything to my sister or our parents but I’m struggling to not feel hurt.

AIBU to feel like this?

OP posts:
LizzieW1969 · 05/09/2021 22:11

I agree with PPs that you should talk to your mum about this rather than letting it fester. They really are being very foolish in their decisions and totally unfair on you and your DB. (And your sister sounds very grasping and entitled.)

Monestera · 05/09/2021 21:55

I'm really glad you're going to talk this over with your mum.

billy1966 · 05/09/2021 21:52

OP,

So this is just the icing on the cake.

How any parent could be so shite as to insist birthday cake should be shared to prevent jealous is hard to understand.

It is the hallmark of utterly shite parenting and hence you are where you are.

They have always favoured her clearly and rewarded her selfishness.

You actually have nothing to lose by asking your mother to clarify and registering your deep hurt if the intend to go ahead.

If they do this your relationship will be hugely impacted whether you bring it up or not.

The sour taste will mean contact will be an open sore that will never heal.

Abitofalark · 05/09/2021 21:01

Good for you - glad that you are meeting your mum. It's better to talk in person rather than on the telephone.

Macncheeseballs · 05/09/2021 20:35

I would definitely bring it up with your mum, don't 'back off', terrible advice, good luck

RandomMess · 05/09/2021 20:31

I would tread carefully in case the arrangement is that DSis is actually meant to be paying your DP rent.

Chloemol · 05/09/2021 20:28

@Bethany7

IHT will only be payable over the thread hold of £325, however if the home is left to children it’s £500k, and if one dies before the other and doesn’t use all their IHT allowance it can be added to the remaining persons allowance

IHT may not be payable

BreadInCaptivity · 05/09/2021 20:14

Good luck tomorrow OP Thanks

Billybagpuss · 05/09/2021 19:54

Good luck💐

BlackAlys · 05/09/2021 19:49

*treated

BlackAlys · 05/09/2021 19:48

I hear you OP.
I've been treated differently to an older brother and because I was regarded as the more 'stable' and even tempered/rational, I was always the one who's feelings that were least considered. It's not really about the money - it's the way that you're not thought of being entreated equally. It hurts.

Have you thought about how you're going to broach it?

Your Mum may get so defensive - be careful.

DontWantTheRivalry · 05/09/2021 19:25

Thanks everyone.

I’m seeing mum over lunchtime tomorrow so I will have a chat with her about it. She is probably the most rational one out of the two of them so she is probably my best bet anyway.

OP posts:
DrManhattan · 05/09/2021 19:21

Problem is that its their money and they can do what they want with it. I agree with you and feel its morally wrong but I don't think they see it that way. I'd back off a bit xx

Brollypackedforscottishholiday · 05/09/2021 19:11

I would never be spending a single penny on any of them. Not one.
Backing away seems logical. You are ultimately a second thought...
Sadly op.

Bethany7 · 05/09/2021 19:04

Also O.P incase your parents are thinking that they will leave their house to you and your brother (assuming it is not sold for their care costs which is becoming more of the norm now) they are mistaken that you would get 100 grand each as the inheritance tax is 40 percent. (Ridiculous)
Your parents have not gone about this in the correct way at all plus if it's because they feel renting is a waste of money they should help you brother too. Your sister could be given a hefty deposit then pay the remaining mortgage herself. Same with your brother. And you should be given a sum of money to perhaps pay towards your own mortgage. That's what would be fair.

grapewine · 05/09/2021 18:54

Our birthdays are 10 days apart, hers being first. She’d get her presents and birthday cake etc just like any other child but when it came to my birthday 10 days later I had to share it with her. Everyone would buy her presents as well as me and I was always told my birthday cake was to share and we had to blow out the candles together.

This is a pattern then, favouring her. I'd have to say something, and then I would definitely take a huge step back. I don't think I could speak to them several times a week etc.

LittleOwl153 · 05/09/2021 18:47

Given your birthday comment - things are not going to change.

Take a massive step back OP.

Do you/your brother have kids? Next step will be treating the kids differently. Don't let their favouritism ruin their relationships too.

You need to disengage. Do not be dragged down by their care expectations as they get older. The golden child can sort that - after all you will have a mortgage to pay!

BreadInCaptivity · 05/09/2021 18:46

@KatharinaRosalie

I know how you feel but based on my own experience, there's probably nothing you can do. They will just say that well you already own a house, so what are you talking about? And of course they would also help you if you needed it, like your poor sister.. I mean sure you can try, but don't be disappointed if any talks don't give you what you want.

That's is of course a possible outcome.

However it's also possible her parents have not fully understood all the implications wrt their financial planning and the wider family fallout.

If she says nothing the plan will go ahead.

If she says something it it might not.

Her relationship with her parents and sister is soured regardless if she says nothing so she's got nothing to lose by talking to them.

At the very least she needs to suggest they speak to a financial advisor about divestment of assets and their own financial situation.

Spending all their savings at this stage of life is absolute madness and more so when reality is the recipient needs them less than they do (whether they appreciate that or not).

I'm pretty sure the OP's parents are absolutely clueless about the financial implications and naive about the impact on the relationship with their other children.

They need to understand this and if they choose to do it regardless then they can't be surprised by the consequences and neither can the sister.

I simply can't fathom the mindset of someone who'd willingly take all their parents life savings in this fashion, especially when her current lifestyle is hardly breadline.

It's beyond greedy. It's reckless, selfish and cruel.

There are ways for the parents to help her by giving her a deposit (if she can afford rent she can afford a mortgage). That money can then be deducted from any share of inheritance in the future.

I can see the merits of giving her £20k to get on the housing ladder but £200k to buy a house outright is overkill.

Chloemol · 05/09/2021 18:42

You need to talk to them. You need to tell them how your sister does have surplus income, that she does things you can’t afford. That if she is bought a house our right that leaves her with even more surplus income, whereas you have a mortgage to pay and your brother rent

She can find a job

You also need to tell them about the £150pm

Could you talk to that person? Let them know what’s happening and that she doesn’t need the money?

If they still insist on helping then that would be it for me, I would start to withdraw and would not provide any support to them as they get older. Your sister can do it

MrsToadflax · 05/09/2021 18:39

Op everyone is telling you to speak to your parents, so why don't you? Call your dad back and when he says 'how are you doing?' just say, 'tbh dad I'm feeling hurt that you're giving your life savings to sis. Bro feels the same. We feel totally left out and that yet again you're throwing money at sis when all of us could benefit from some financial security.'

Whether they change their mind or not will be very telling. I would suggest they give sis money for a deposit, not a full house purchase. She should be saving not letting others fund her lifestyle. Don't be walked over OP. At least say your piece and leave the ball in their court.

DontWantTheRivalry · 05/09/2021 18:39

OP I get how you’re feeling. On older sibling of mine used to ban my parents from celebrating my birthday with me because she would get jealous if she wasn’t invited. Then they used to go and celebrate her birthday in secret, oh but she used to tell me about the secret afterwards with glee. I pulled them up on it and they replied with you know how volatile she can be so we did it for an easy life…

Not the same as your situation I know….

Funnily enough, birthday celebrations were always an issue during our childhood.

Our birthdays are 10 days apart, hers being first. She’d get her presents and birthday cake etc just like any other child but when it came to my birthday 10 days later I had to share it with her. Everyone would buy her presents as well as me and I was always told my birthday cake was to share and we had to blow out the candles together.

I was so upset by it every year….apparently it’s because they didn’t want her to get jealous.

I remember memories of that from when I was about 6 years old. My birthdays were always ruined.

OP posts:
Abitofalark · 05/09/2021 18:38

On the face of it, it would have made more sense for them to have given her and her then husband a deposit for a mortgage years ago. Even now, your brother hasn't a house either and it's not clear why they don't give him a deposit and give her a deposit and retain some of their savings. That would also make sense against any potential claim of deprivation of assets - helping two children get on the housing ladder is a very normal thing to do and not a ruse to get the state to pay for care.

The point of difference they may see between you is that she is on her own and you both have the security and support of partners.

They more than likely regard you as 'sorted', having both partner and house but given that you have a good relationship with them, you are well placed to have a conversation about it, pointing out a couple of things they may not have thought of. They're thinking along a certain line that makes sense to them and probably don't realise how emotional it is for you, although family money is always about emotion.

KatharinaRosalie · 05/09/2021 18:31

I know how you feel but based on my own experience, there's probably nothing you can do. They will just say that well you already own a house, so what are you talking about? And of course they would also help you if you needed it, like your poor sister..
I mean sure you can try, but don't be disappointed if any talks don't give you what you want.

Oldbutstillgotit · 05/09/2021 18:31

Well this has dredged up some memories. My DB was always the Golden Child with DM and when my DTB died aged 5 it was like my DM put DB on a pedestal. While my DF was alive I coped but after he died the favouritism was blatant.
DM said that her estate would be divided equally . It wasn’t. It emerged that she had signed over the house to DB shortly after DF died . He also was given a large sum of money .
I ended up with £10000 whereas if DM had kept her word I should have had nearly £200000. Keeping in mind she died 30 years ago so it was a LOT of money .
I sat in the lawyer’s office absolutely dumbstruck , my DB said nothing .
I got up and left . The lawyer phoned me later and said that DM insisted that was to happen.
It goes without saying that relationship with my DB is difficult. It wasn’t just about the money it was the fact I felt so inferior, so sidelined so unloved .

Missusblusky1 · 05/09/2021 18:28

OP I get how you’re feeling. On older sibling of mine used to ban my parents from celebrating my birthday with me because she would get jealous if she wasn’t invited. Then they used to go and celebrate her birthday in secret, oh but she used to tell me about the secret afterwards with glee. I pulled them up on it and they replied with you know how volatile she can be so we did it for an easy life…

Not the same as your situation I know but having it out with them could cause more hurt, I don’t think you’ll get the answer you want. I’ve stepped back massively from mine now and it appears they haven’t noticed…! At least you have your brother to speak to about it though. I’m not sure what the answer is but I feel for you