Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Disparity in pay between workers doing the same job? Is this allowed?

66 replies

Payproblems · 05/09/2021 10:34

We work in the public sector, but I found out a colleuge asked for more ££ and got it.

Now they are advertising the same role but for higher pay.

My colleuge doesn't pull their weight or do their job properly and everyone else on the team knows this so the fact they are earning more then me has really upset me.
Then I see the same job being advertiser but for more than money again I feel upset.

However this is the public sector, is this usual practise? Will it be normal to have people doing the same job on all different rates?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Payproblems · 06/09/2021 21:24

True sink girl, I just don't want know, budget's? Only certain budgets allowed, I don't have know.

Big

It
But if I had any sort of business I wouldn't allow new people to earn higher than old people.
Unless it was skills based.

It's creates bad feeling and it is demoralising.

Thankfully I'm not childish and do love my job but I could slack back like my colleuge whose getting paid more and does less.

OP posts:
SinkGirl · 06/09/2021 20:22

How could they justify saying no? They’re literally hiring brand new people on a higher rate than you. There’s no justification for that unless they’re asking for experience or qualifications you don’t have!

Payproblems · 06/09/2021 20:11

Ok really greatful for three tips I felt on a high after this great review and I do enjoy working there but I feel a plunge after hearing about this pay disparity and the sudden realization that their loyal employee who is bottom rung in the office will actually be the "lowest paid" when they get their new workers in!!

There is a high turn over in my role and they are really struggling to get people, another reason why I feel... Why not also look after the one you've got.

I do understand however it's still a business and they won't dish out money but I still find it upsetting.
I've got some tips and a few reasons to ask and if they are reluctant I also have some amo for push back.

I do really like working there though so I don't want to do myself out of a job and if they insist I can't have more ££ I'm not sure what I would do...

OP posts:
thing47 · 06/09/2021 13:45

I ask my immediate peers. I'm the only woman in the department and I've spent years fighting for equal pay.

I SO agree with this, EBearhug. Admittedly I'm not public sector, but ime the only reason employers tell you not to discuss salaries is because they are underpaying somebody somewhere and want to keep doing so.

The best way to counter this is to be reasonably open with your colleagues, at least in ballpark terms. A lot of the time, the people who benefit from secrecy are the employers not the employees.

Alpinechalet · 06/09/2021 09:00

@SW1amp In the CS it is accepted practice if roles are advertised at a higher rate externally you apply to get the higher rate.

Obviously have the conversation first.

ChazsBrilliantAttitude · 06/09/2021 08:55

They have given you all the evidence you need by offering the role at a higher salary. Just go in and ask. Don't ask for the same pay as the role given your experience (unless it is the top of a salary band) ask for more. Oh and don't be pathetically grateful if they offer you something - you deserve to be paid more - they are not doing you a favour by paying you the same as your colleagues. (I don't mean be chippy or rude - simply that they ought to be paying you fairly and so you can be professionally satisfied at a fair outcome and courteous but don't feel that it was a gift from them - you earned it).

GrandmaSteglitszch · 06/09/2021 08:54

Make your case based on your glowing review and the post being advertised at a higher salary.
Don't mention your lazy, greedy colleague.

Hoppinggreen · 06/09/2021 08:53

@Payproblems

Wow. What's go stop me resigning and re joining?
Well they would have to re employ you
Excelthetube · 06/09/2021 08:52

The main point is it’s out of your comfort zone to ask for more and it wasn’t out of their comfort zone to ask for more.

I wish more women would have the confidence and self assurance to ask for what they are worth, and be taught as a young person it’s good to do. This is where the problem lies.

EBearhug · 06/09/2021 08:47

Usually, people don't resign until they have applied, been through the interview process and got another job.

ShrimpBarbarian · 06/09/2021 07:15

@Payproblems

Wow. What's go stop me resigning and re joining?
Nothing

But would they rehire you?

Darbysmama · 06/09/2021 07:09

You have to ask for a raise, plain and simple. Did you really think they would just hand out raises? Of course. Paying less for the same work is better for their bottom line. They’re not going to tap you on the shoulder and say “hey, you haven’t asked for a raise, here’s one anyway just because.” Sorry if I’m coming off rude, but I just think it’s odd to be feel slighted you didn’t get something you never even asked for. And it’s really unfortunate because it seems like nobody ever conveyed to you that you have a right to ask. My suggestion is to do a deep dive on the internet researching some strategies for asking for a raise. It’ll feel somewhat uncomfortable and maybe awkward, but if you go in confident and have a reasonable pitch then you’ll most likely be successful. The fact is, with the process of hiring, dealing with HR, training someone new, maybe or maybe not having that new hire work out, possibly having to re-do the whole process, etc., they’re more inclined to keep good employees even if it means paying more. But you have to actually ask!

SW1amp · 06/09/2021 06:44

@Straighttalking1

Apply for the job
Don’t do this You will look passive aggressive and foolish

You need to have a grown up conversation with them about wanting a pay rise to match what they are offering for the new joiner

Straighttalking1 · 05/09/2021 20:01

Apply for the job

Payproblems · 05/09/2021 18:15

I was being facetious when I said I could resign then re apply.

I think I have another meeting soon so I will mention it then I think.
The role is exactly the same, the one advertised. And same role for the person who got more than me so can't imagine how or why they would say its a different role

OP posts:
Puzzledandpissedoff · 05/09/2021 14:43

What's go stop me resigning and re joining?

The fact that they might instead appoint someone even cheaper? (Plus, as PPs have said, that you'd lose continuity of service)

Why not just ask for a rise and then decide what you want to do?

EBearhug · 05/09/2021 14:35

How do you know what they earn? I find it odd that you'd ask, and that they'd tell you!

I ask my immediate peers. I'm the only woman in the department and I've spent years fighting for equal pay. A couple of years ago, my employer did a big pay review to fix the easy part of the gender pay gap, and I am finally on the same as my peers. The three of us do the same work, so should be paid roughly the same. I asked them,because there's no other way for me to know, and I said they were free not to answer if they weren't comfortable with it, but I was asking for reason equality. I think it's better for all of us to know what each other is on. (At least now we're about the same, anyway...)

Elouera · 05/09/2021 14:16

How do you know what they earn? I find it odd that you'd ask, and that they'd tell you!

Aren't you paid within a band and scale? How many years experience do you have at your level? Would this warrant going up a pay band?

I started a public sector role 2 weeks ago. When they sent me the pay, I queried this, because they'd put me on the lowest pay scale for that band- despite having 10+yrs at this level previously! I queried it, had to provide past past slips as proof of higher earnings, and was offered a higher banding and pay.

If you have the experience to warrant a higher pay, you need to formalise it in a letter to them.

girlmom21 · 05/09/2021 14:12

Ask for more money and if they say no ask if you can apply for the vacant position.

SinkGirl · 05/09/2021 14:09

This is the easiest scenario in which to ask for a pay rise.

You have noticed that they are advertising to recruit into the same role as yours, with a starting salary that’s higher than yours despite your two years of experience and service. Absolutely you should be asking, and it’s evident you deserve more so you should have no problem getting it!

NoIDontWatchLoveIsland · 05/09/2021 14:03

Where I work if my role was advertised at more than I'm on, I'd just go into my bosses office, wave it at him and tell him not to play silly buggers & that I expect a raise. The exception to that is if they hire someone with more experience or qualifications etc thus justifying the pay differential.

ConsulTremas · 05/09/2021 14:01

Have you actually asked for more money? You can hardly complain if not.

I earn more than one of my colleagues who does the same job because I negotiated my salary when I joined. I asked for more money to move (because my previous employer offered me more to stay) and they met it. I asked, and I got.

MrsToadflax · 05/09/2021 13:58

I understand it's out of your comfort zone, but if you don't ask you won't get. I would ask for a meeting with your manager/HR and say you've seen the recent job ad for your role at a higher rate. Say that you had a very positive review and have done x,y and z and would like the same level of pay as advertised. If they give an excuse about it being a new role blah blah, you've then got your trump card of your colleague also being paid more. You find it demoralising etc. If they can't up your pay now, ask for a clear plan of how you work towards it and a timeframe.

FinallyHere · 05/09/2021 13:47

Now they are advertising the same role but for higher pay.

Why would t you just apply for this new role?

It will come down to whether they can manage without you and his likely they think you are to get a better job elsewhere if you are not successful.

Have you honestly not made a case for your own pay rise. Maybe they think you will put up without a rise.

They also seem to think that you are motivated by praise rather than money. Is that true ? Would you be happy with the pay rise if it meant they never praised you again.

Not everyone cares about praise. Do you?

seaandsandcastles · 05/09/2021 13:32

@KatherineOfGaunt

A newly-qualified teacher can start on a higher rate of pay if they negotiate it.

As a retail worker straight out of uni, I found out the other young woman my age was on more pay for the same job. I'd been to uni for three years and she had been working in retail for three years.

I think it's just how it is. 🤷🏻‍♀️

Of course she was! She has experience… you had none.
Swipe left for the next trending thread