Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to not want in laws taking over our new flat?

162 replies

Goodfry2024 · 05/09/2021 10:13

DH has worked for the last 5 years to save money to buy an apartment in Turkey. It’s nothing fancy but it’s a 2 bed apartment in a nice city. When we have enough cash to make the move, we’re planning to go over there and DH will quit his job here. The reason for moving is that it’s closer to his own culture than where we currently are We’ve sacrificed a lot. We’ve gone without buying ourselves new clothes, shoes and even not used heating in Winter when it’s freezing cold. On top of this DH regularly sends money to his mother and other relatives back home. DH dropped a bomb on me that he wants to put his younger brother, wife and their baby in the flat and we can go every year for holidays for 6 weeks. I didn’t know that this was his plan all along and I feel deceived and cheated. I don’t want these people in OUR flat, destroying something that we saved for and sacrificed comforts for. On top of that they are dirty people and I know they won’t keep the flat in good condition. Also, they won’t be paying any rent or any bills. I feel really weird about my DH providing for his brother and his wife. Especially the part about providing ANYTHING for another woman.

OP posts:
Baileyscheesecake · 05/09/2021 11:04

Are you sure he's not intending his brother to live there for just the interim years until he retires and you move out there to live? Otherwise it would just be empty for the weeks you're not holidaying there. Ask him what has happened to his retirement plans.

MoonahStone · 05/09/2021 11:01

The OP won't get back the money already spent if it's been used to purchase property in Turkey.

gottastopeatingchocolate · 05/09/2021 11:01

It seems that there could be some financial abuse going on, OP.

No pressure, but here is an organisation that might be able to help you, if you feel you need support:

www.mwnhelpline.co.uk/issuesstep2.php?id=14

Carboncheque · 05/09/2021 11:00

Whatever you believed it sounds like that was always your DH’s plan. It’s a natural extension of him supporting his relatives financially. If he could easily afford to do it then it might not be an issue but he can’t. You’ve gone without heating, curbed your spending and are living in a ‘shabby flat’ to save money to give to his family.

He obviously believes it’s something he needs to do and he’s willing to put their needs before yours. Does he put their needs before his own? You’ve mentioned the things that you feel you’ve sacrificed - clothes, shoes, going without heating, the place you live. Is he going without? Some people aren’t really invested in where they live - it’s just a place to sleep. What material things matter to him? Cars? Going out with friends? Tech? Has he gone without?

Supporting his family is a lifelong commitment. There is always going to be something they need. His mother, his siblings, their children. He’s not going to stop doing it. You need to decide what you can live with.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 05/09/2021 11:00

At least if you divorce him you'll get half of the cost of the flat back

Good luck with that; OP assumes it's in his name, but then she assumed he meant what he said about saving for their own place. Also, if there's the slightest hint of divorce, the money they've saved could easily "disappear" and end up with his family anyway

This sort of thing happens so often when someone marries into another culture, and really it's either learn to live with the compromises or divorce

Personally I'd go with the latter, but as said there could well be consequences if OP doesn't plan very carefully

KatherineJaneway · 05/09/2021 10:59

It would be a deal breaker for me. The lies and deception not to mention living frugally for years to benefit someone else.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 05/09/2021 10:56

The bit about the wife is odd though. Don’t say that but.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 05/09/2021 10:56

I think you do need to work out what happens to non U.K. assets if you get divorced. I agree with a pp that he seems on the face of it to be putting assets out of your reach, or trying to.

Greystray · 05/09/2021 10:55

I think you are being a bit odd to fixate on your BIL's wife and not your BIL - would you be happier if only your BIL lived in the property? - but you definitely are getting screwed over here.

It sounds like your DH is so enamoured with being the big hero and provider of his family that he doesn't care that his own wife has to go without.

First thing you need to do is stop sacrificing anything. If your DH can hand out homes, he can afford to heat his own, and clothe his own family.

Winter2020 · 05/09/2021 10:55

Your husband isn't concerned with either your comfort or your opinion. Is that something you can live with? If not leave him.

LakieLady · 05/09/2021 10:54

This would be an absolute deal-breaker for me. He has had you scrimping and scraping under false pretences.

Do you own the place you live in, OP, or is it rented? I'd be surprised if the UK courts could force the sale and split the proceeds of an asset overseas if you split, but if there are assets here they could offset the value of the Turkey property and give you a bigger share of the assets here.

He's put you in an awful position. I'd never be able to trust someone again if they'd done that to me.

Gonnagetgoing · 05/09/2021 10:54

I think the main thing here is trust. He’s betrayed your trust.

Please see a British solicitor about your rights and don’t let him and his family pull the law over your eyes if they try to pull the Sharia Law stuff. Had a friend mention this to me ages ago, Muslim and assumed as she was living in England and working and paying a mortgage that Sharia Law covered her assets and rights etc. I soon put her right and referred her to my then boss (solicitor)
when she decided for other reasons she wanted a divorce.

gingerbiscuits · 05/09/2021 10:53

@JustLyra

So your husband has conned you into scrimping and saving for a home that he never intended you to live in?

The only further discussions I’d have on that flat would be how it was going to be handled in our divorce.

Add in the fact that your “he bought it” comment seems to suggest it’s all, conveniently, in his name suggests financial abuse - he has stolen your contribution to that flat to house his brother.

Run.

This!⬆️
loopylindi · 05/09/2021 10:52

In some cultures there seems to be an unwritten acceptance that family members look out for each other in just this way. I have knowledge of 2 such situations (from different countries) with one of the family members living in GB and effectively subsidizing those left in their own country.

GiantHaystacks2021 · 05/09/2021 10:50

Think I'd divorce him and get my share of the goodies.

50ShadesOfCatholic · 05/09/2021 10:47

The split assets advice is all very well but does British law dictate what happens to a property in Turkey? Not going to be an easy one to solve.

What is in this for your husband? He's still living in a shabby flat. Is he thinking they will live there until you get there? Is it in both your names? Do you have proof of sharing finances throughout the marriage?

cookingisoverrated · 05/09/2021 10:47

So you've sacrificed like mad and even been cold through the winter ... so he could buy his distant family a home.

Fuck that. You've been had.

I'd be consulting a solicitor about a divorce and making a note of any marital assets, including that flat.

MrsPumpkinSeed · 05/09/2021 10:47

He's very very deceitful

Harlequin1088 · 05/09/2021 10:45

The audacity of this is utterly jaw dropping. I can't believe you've been freezing your ass off in a cold UK flat, scrimping and saving for a new home abroad only for your husband to essentially give YOUR flat to his relatives. This is absolutely disgusting behaviour and it really does seem like this was his intention all along. It appears you've been thoroughly duped OP and I would personally start to wonder what else he's lied about where your finances are concerned. I know it's easy to just say "divorce the bugger" but I really think you might need to book an appointment with a solicitor and start getting your ducks in a row. This whole shitshow where the flat is concerned is certainly financial abuse so that's more than enough grounds for an unreasonable behaviour divorce.

ChargingBuck · 05/09/2021 10:44

DH has worked for the last 5 years to save money to buy an apartment in Turkey.

This phrasing is so odd I have to clarify WTF is going on.
OP - may I ask, do you work?
If so, then surely you both worked for 5 years to buy this apartment.

Or have you not worked outside the home for 5 years as you have children?
In which case again - you have both been working for 5 years.

How does your husband respond when you express your disappointment about his plan to allow in-laws to reside in the apartment instead of yourselves?
How has it come about that all of this is his decision,with no input from you?

In short, what is going on in your relationship that DH thinks all the important life decisions are his to make, unilaterally?

Elieza · 05/09/2021 10:43

There is a strong culture in many countries where family abroad is expected to fund family back home.

It’s a pride and cultural thing.
A lot of times the men involved are very obedient to their parents. When they marry the wife is not the centre of her husbands world, she’s below his mother in the pecking order. So when the mother says jump the man says how high. The wife just has to accept it. As that’s what happens in the culture.

There’s another thread on her regarding the same type of thing, a man sending so much money home that he and his wife live in relative poverty and his non working lazy brother and wife who has five kids live off the money he sends back to his home country.

It’s nice to help family. But to lie about it is unacceptable. What he wants to do with his share of your joint money is his business. But you should still have your half of the monthly pay to do your thing.

For me that would be a dealbreaker. Is your marriage legally recognised in the U.K., ie a paper marriage not just within Islam? If so you and this is a deal breaker for you, I’d be considering divorce. I couldn’t live with a liar. That way you’d get half of everything including the house (although granted it’s more complicated than that and depends on a number of factors).

You either accept this culture and realise he can’t change its ingrained. Or you try and get him to be fair to you and watch him squirm and potentially hide more things from you. He may be able to change and tell the family he’s not a cash cow, some have per other threads. But it will be hard and his family will threaten to never speak to him again and be wailing down the phone about how terrible a man he is yada yada.

Perhaps he should give the flat to his brother and tell him no more money will be forthcoming for anything. Ever. And then you start again saving for a flat? Without having to send money home you should manage more quickly than five years this time.

But I’d imagine you’d need to keep an eye on finances as the minute the mother says she needs money he will be transferring it over like the “good son” he wants to be.

BeagleBeagled · 05/09/2021 10:42

Will you ever be his priority? Can you imagine what your life would be like if you did move there in the future? I think you need to prioritise yourself and maybe think about divorce and getting what you are owed. Don't live in the cold and dark for others who probably don't even think about you.

Kuachui · 05/09/2021 10:41

Also yes I'd be going to a lawyer explaining the situation and wanting 50% of the property cost back

Kuachui · 05/09/2021 10:40

Fuck that I'd be leaving. I wonder if he's using you, he's been very deceitful 🤔

pigsDOfly · 05/09/2021 10:40

Just say no. It's pretty simple.

Not really if the flat has been bought in just the OP's husband.

He's lied to you and tricked you into scrimping and saving and going without to provide a home for another couple.

This would be the end of the line for me.

I'd be booking an appointment with a divorce lawyer this week.

At least if you divorce him you'll get half of the cost of the flat back.