Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Upset by triggering photos

267 replies

ChockaChick · 05/09/2021 08:32

A lady in a group I’m in lost her twins at 20 weeks. Today is a significant anniversary for her and she has posted a photo of them on her personal newsfeed.

I have also suffered from loss and waking up to dead baby pictures really wasn’t what I needed this morning. I want to tell her to put them behind a trigger warning.

That would make me a nasty insensitive bitch though, wouldn’t it? She has every right to mark the anniversary as she chooses. She wasn’t protected from suffering at all so why should she have to protect others from it?

OP posts:
GlittercheeksOakleaf · 05/09/2021 12:05

I'd be devastated if someone referred to the one single solitary picture of my darling daughter as 'offensive'. She's just a little baby who never got to stay and live her life, not something disgusting.

Maybe the solution is that everyone should add a trigger warning to everything? Everything has the potential to trigger someone, somewhere.

loveyours · 05/09/2021 12:04

*I lost my mum at a young age. Before you post a picture on Mother’s Day or just generally about what a lovely mum you have, can you put a trigger warning please because it upsets me to see people living their lives with their mums.

See what a ridiculous suggestion that is?*

////

As I say, I lost a sibling young. It can be upsetting to see but I wouldn't need a TW for siblings posting together.

But a normal commemoration of an older person isn't the same as a person who is actually dead in the photo, so yes, I think a TW, just two words, is not a big ask.

Photos are totally fine, it's your baby who is real and your want acknowledged and remembered. I just don't get the absolute refusal to put two letters before when it's such a sensitive thing.

We see mothers and daughters, happy siblings and families everyday, but imagine from the perspective of mother who also suffered a stillbirth, logging on to Facebook and unexpectedly seeing a picture that reminds you of the one you lost. It is a bit different

DifficultPifcultLemonDifficult · 05/09/2021 12:04

Personally my grief does not trump someone else’s.

By reporting someone's photos you're making your grief trump someone else's.

OmgIcantbelieveshedidit · 05/09/2021 12:03

I agree with the OP. Personally my grief does not trump someone else’s. I find pictures of dead babies upsetting. I’m not saying grief needs to be private. But a trigger warning before viewing pictures is essential. I’ve had 5 m/c and these type of pictures are highly traumatic for me and I had ptsd. Someone’s else grief doesn’t have the right to cause offence and upset. If it was me I would report it direct and explain why.

Formaldeheidi · 05/09/2021 12:01

@aSofaNearYou

*I lost my mum at a young age. Before you post a picture on Mother’s Day or just generally about what a lovely mum you have, can you put a trigger warning please because it upsets me to see people living their lives with their mums.

See what a ridiculous suggestion that is?*

I think the sad reality is this is just not quite the same as posting pictures of someone deceased.

But you don’t get to decide. That’s the point.
Waitingforthecowstocomehome · 05/09/2021 12:01

Sadly nothing seems to be private anymore. Seems like such an inappropriate thing to post.

cuparfull · 05/09/2021 12:01

Oh get a life!! Triggering doh? It's about her not about you.

Just watch the recent 9/11 TV programmes and get some perspective in life. There is always someone off much worse than yourself. Grieve in private and let her do whatever gives her solace.

AccidentallyOnPurpose · 05/09/2021 12:00

@aSofaNearYou

*I lost my mum at a young age. Before you post a picture on Mother’s Day or just generally about what a lovely mum you have, can you put a trigger warning please because it upsets me to see people living their lives with their mums.

See what a ridiculous suggestion that is?*

I think the sad reality is this is just not quite the same as posting pictures of someone deceased.

Why?
RoomOfRequirement · 05/09/2021 12:00

I hope everyone saying to report or that she needs to hide them, or add filters and warnings because it might upset someone does the same every time they post a photo of their living children and happy families. I find that triggering and upsetting when my precious girl doesn't get to be here on Earth with me.

AccidentallyOnPurpose · 05/09/2021 11:59

@loveyours

*To those suggesting a 'trigger warning'

You know us bereaved parents love our babies just as much as you love yours right?

Just because they aren't in our arms it doesn't mean we forget, it doesn't mean we don't want to talk about them, or have people say their names.*

///

You have every right to share your baby and have them remembered but a trigger warning takes no effort to do, so I'd just put one on since it is a sensitive topic.

I do however think reporting is a bit mean. Imagine the mum living on to find her baby's pictures have been removed by Facebook. That would be bad.

It's not about effort , it's about emotions and meaning.

How would you feel if your beloved baby/child was considered a trigger? Maybe they're not pretty enough, maybe they have a disability, or maybe they're very smart or accomplished, or maybe they overcame something that someone else's child is still struggling/suffering from ,or maybe seeing them hurts people dealing with loss.

Do you have to stop and consider every time you post a pic of them if it might be upsetting or triggering someone else? Of course you don't. But you expect parents that have suffered loss to consider all that and make that judgement every time they make a post about their baby because it's "no effort"? What about the mental and emotional effort? The fact that you want them to consider their baby "triggering "?

aSofaNearYou · 05/09/2021 11:57

*I lost my mum at a young age. Before you post a picture on Mother’s Day or just generally about what a lovely mum you have, can you put a trigger warning please because it upsets me to see people living their lives with their mums.

See what a ridiculous suggestion that is?*

I think the sad reality is this is just not quite the same as posting pictures of someone deceased.

DifficultPifcultLemonDifficult · 05/09/2021 11:57

I get you, I personally wouldn't be upset by a posed deceased person, but I'd just err on the side of caution, just to consider everyone's preferences in a way that doesn't stop people being allowed to share pictures

We have already been through the worst thing a person can possibly go through, can you imagine on the birthday of your dead child, where you're suffering so much anyway, having to then consider everyone else and then click the button for 'sensitive content' or put a trigger warning on the photo of your baby.

Formaldeheidi · 05/09/2021 11:53

@loveyours

*To those suggesting a 'trigger warning'

You know us bereaved parents love our babies just as much as you love yours right?

Just because they aren't in our arms it doesn't mean we forget, it doesn't mean we don't want to talk about them, or have people say their names.*

///

You have every right to share your baby and have them remembered but a trigger warning takes no effort to do, so I'd just put one on since it is a sensitive topic.

I do however think reporting is a bit mean. Imagine the mum living on to find her baby's pictures have been removed by Facebook. That would be bad.

I lost my mum at a young age. Before you post a picture on Mother’s Day or just generally about what a lovely mum you have, can you put a trigger warning please because it upsets me to see people living their lives with their mums.

See what a ridiculous suggestion that is?

loveyours · 05/09/2021 11:53

@DifficultPifcultLemonDifficult

You have every right to share your baby and have them remembered but a trigger warning takes no effort to do, so I'd just put one on since it is a sensitive topic.

It takes no effort but why should we have to put trigger warnings up for our much loved children.

I find photos of children the same age my 2 would be upsetting, should everyone have to put trigger warnings on their photos for me?

I get you, I personally wouldn't be upset by a posed deceased person, but I'd just err on the side of caution, just to consider everyone's preferences in a way that doesn't stop people being allowed to share pictures

Formaldeheidi · 05/09/2021 11:51

Can I just say as well to posters generally, that the pictures taken of babies for memory making purposes are never “gruesome”. Doing this is actually part of my job and we work very hard to make the babies as presentable as possible. Personally, I have never taken a picture where a baby has looked anything other than sleeping. We’re actually very skilled at this.

DifficultPifcultLemonDifficult · 05/09/2021 11:50

You have every right to share your baby and have them remembered but a trigger warning takes no effort to do, so I'd just put one on since it is a sensitive topic.

It takes no effort but why should we have to put trigger warnings up for our much loved children.

I find photos of children the same age my 2 would be upsetting, should everyone have to put trigger warnings on their photos for me?

loveyours · 05/09/2021 11:47

*To those suggesting a 'trigger warning'

You know us bereaved parents love our babies just as much as you love yours right?

Just because they aren't in our arms it doesn't mean we forget, it doesn't mean we don't want to talk about them, or have people say their names.*

///

You have every right to share your baby and have them remembered but a trigger warning takes no effort to do, so I'd just put one on since it is a sensitive topic.

I do however think reporting is a bit mean. Imagine the mum living on to find her baby's pictures have been removed by Facebook. That would be bad.

SnoopyLights · 05/09/2021 11:46

I’m sorry you’re upset but the title literally has the word “triggering” in already so it’s pretty clear the content may be upsetting.

It has the word 'triggering' in it but it doesn't mention the subject or give any real clue to who might be triggered or why. I wasn't expecting a thread about baby loss or so many insensitive comments when I opened it.

Branleuse · 05/09/2021 11:45

you cant say anything about it really. Its not as if she has got other pictures to choose from. These are her babies and if you dont like what she posts, then you can unfollow her or defriend her. Youve seen them now though and its made you feel really emotional and reminded of your own bereavement. Thats hard for you and im sorry. Its hard for both of you

TheNarwhalBalloon · 05/09/2021 11:45

I think she should use a filter, there will be plenty of people upset by this and her grief doesn't trump other people's losses and vulnerability...

However, I don't think you should say anything about it, sorry.
I would mute her unless she's a very good friend and you felt you could broach it sensitively. But she may just hear a rejection of her lost babies and a message that her grief is not acceptable.

WimpoleHat · 05/09/2021 11:44

Oh, that’s rotten for you, OP. Just unfollow her, though. Telling other people what they should or shouldn’t post is always a massive can of worms. Presumably if she still wants to get in touch with you directly about anything, you can - you just won’t get a shock like that again from her.

Plumtree391 · 05/09/2021 11:43

@Cactusandmarshmallows

No to clarify regarding the 29 y/o - it was a photo of his body

Good points about him having been in other photos by pps

I've never heard of anyone doing that. There are photos available of deceased rulers lying in state with people filing past to pay their respects but it isn't generally done.

I was with my husband and my mother when they died and will always remember that but I wouldn't even have thought of photographing them, never mind sharing the photos. There are nice photos on the net of my husband, when he was alive and happy, which my son put up.

I would photograph a baby but not to make public. That's something would normally only share with those closest to you.

DifficultPifcultLemonDifficult · 05/09/2021 11:43

To those suggesting a 'trigger warning'

You know us bereaved parents love our babies just as much as you love yours right?

Just because they aren't in our arms it doesn't mean we forget, it doesn't mean we don't want to talk about them, or have people say their names.

Can you imagine the uproar if you had to put a trigger warning every time you shared a photo of your kid in case it upsets a bereaved parent? Every school photo, every thread on here, every birthday, you had to think how your photo or story will effect those around you, because I guarantee the photos and stories you share will make someone sad.

These photos are all we have of our children, we shouldn't have to hide them away to make others comfortable.

Op now you know she shares photos of her children, and how that makes you feel, hide her feed from your Facebook, or defriend her. Please don't report her pictures.

anon12345678901 · 05/09/2021 11:41

I would unfollow her but don't message her. Her grief is hers, and it's not up to her to take others people's feelings into account when posting. People who post scan photos, bump updates etc don't take into consideration those who cannot get pregnant although it maybe triggering for them.
These are her children and she has every right to put a picture of them, regardless of if you like it or not.

loveyours · 05/09/2021 11:38

Nope. Sharing photos is not a dangerous or potentially offensive act and no one who has suffered loss should have to tiptoe around the feelings of others, regardless of whether they have also suffered. There is something really insidious about this whole 'I'm sensitive and you have to warn me' malarkey. We all suffer and trying to protect everyone from everything means that most people just stay silent and suffer alone.

I have to agree. It wasn't anything gruesome that was posted, it was two babies posed for a photo who happened to have passed away

I have experienced grief, my sibling died as a young adult. It can be upsetting to be reminded. And I think that's the real issue here, the reminder, rather than the content of the picture itself

Posting your deceased child -albeit at 20 weeks old- cuddled up to you or swaddled is not the same as someone posting a car wreck, or an actual death. It's just a person with no life In them. And in the case of very young babies, it's completely acceptable for parents to post their own children, though they should add a TW to be considerate