Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Am I abnormal for not having close friends?

108 replies

Lovecup · 05/09/2021 08:29

I don’t know where to start with this although I reckon the way I am I very largely linked to my upbringing.

My mother suffered with her nerves and was always unpredictable, had a quick temper and eventually descended into alcoholism. As a child I never knew how she’d be (either smothering me with love or screaming at me) so I developed a thick skin around myself and didn’t like getting too close to people.

I have married and have two beautiful children who we cherish and I have broken that horrible cycle of my upbringing. I’m now 50 and realise I have few friends though. My husband and I are happy and over the years we’ve been friendly with parents of the children, had nights out and even the odd holiday but I’ve never looked for close female friends, the type that you share everything with etc.

I’ve come to realise I’m the problem, I just don’t crave close friends so I never keep up the effort to remain in contact. I’m pretty cutthroat in as much as if anyone slights me or does something I’m not happy with I will simply drop contact, no drama or fuss but there’s never a second chance. I’m polite etc but will never chase people for friendship.

We are friendly with our close neighbours and will BBQ and have each other over but that’s it. I look on FB (I have 500 ‘friends’ on there and I like them all) and all I see are groups of people getting together for birthdays, holidays etc especially now we are all older and children are off our hands. I’ve come to realise that I’m at fault, I’ve never made that effort to keep the friendships going, no fallings out just drifted away, when the kids were younger and we worked full time we never had the time to do it either but now they are grown we realise it mainly just DH and I.

Anyone else find they are the same. I know I am BU as I just don’t make the effort.

OP posts:
BooseysMom · 05/09/2021 20:18

I’m pretty cutthroat in as much as if anyone slights me or does something I’m not happy with I will simply drop contact, no drama or fuss but there’s never a second chance. I’m polite etc but will never chase people for friendship.

I'm exactly the same op. I could have written this apart from the bbqs with neighbours bit as we don't socialise with any of them. I used to have friends pre DS but they all melted away and now there's just the acquaintances at the school gates.
My upbringing was very similar.
Is it me? Not sure really. Maybe it's just life and people moving on. But like you, if I didn't have DH and DS, I'd have no one.

Recessed · 05/09/2021 20:10

I've learned though that getting close to people just isn't worth it and encourages them to have opinions about my lifestyle and choices.

This is what I think too. I do have one "best" friend from school who I don't see regularly as we live some distance apart, but we do share most things about each other's life. However having that type of relationship with one person is more than enough for me. My sister and her husband have a big group of couple friends and I would hate it. They're all privy to each other's business and all have opinions on it and I squirm at the thought of it and all the drama it inevitably invites. My sister is a bit of a drama Queen though so she thrives on it Grin I'm intensely private so it would suit me. I should make more of an effort to cultivate more casual friendships though as I love big nights out/weekends away and don't really have anyone to do that with anymore as I've sort of let friendships fall away since having DC and moving from old friends.

If you're happy with your situation it's totally fine. If you're lonely though and would like that more intimate style of friendship then try to take steps to change things.

MMMarmite · 05/09/2021 19:59

@Lovecup

This is the thing, I find with friends they keep wanting to ‘catch up’ over food or drinks and to be honest I can’t be bothered after working all day, I’m happy to go home, cook and chill with DH or on my own.

I know it’s me, I just don’t make the effort and without the effort you’ll get left behind.

This pretty much is friendship though. Not necessarily food and drinks, but regularly enjoying spending time together. If I don't look forward to spending an evening with someone, then they're not a friend.
HarrisMcCoo · 05/09/2021 19:58

@ChateauMargaux

Same here and I look at my Mum's life and think it is sad that she didn't keep friends and I wonder that despite having lots if friends that come and go, why my own friendships are not deep and long lasting.
I could have written this.
AudreyTattoo · 05/09/2021 19:57

Sometimes I think both DH and I are psychopaths!

Don't be so dramatic! You mean sociopaths (JOKE Grin).

Friends and extended family can melt into the background a little when you have small children, I think. You also probably need to feel this way a bit to consider emigrating. Assuming emigrating is a good thing for you and your DCs, you will prioritise their well-being, so maybe that's why you've started to compartmentalise a bit.

Armchair psychology by Audrey 🧐. You are welcome.

Amboseli · 05/09/2021 19:50

@Lovecup I'm the same. I can switch off my feelings. I'm perfectly happy with DH and DCs. I've got a couple of people that I do consider to be close friends in that I can tell them absolutely anything without being judged.

But, we are planning on emigrating in the near future and I just don't think I'd miss these friends and DH says the same of his friends. We don't think we'd miss our respective families (DCs excepted) so are they really friends?

Sometimes I think both DH and I are psychopaths!

CoRhona · 05/09/2021 19:33

@Lovecup I think if you retreated from your female friends and then went back to them (like with your DH) you might find those friendships last too.

It's unreasonable to expect people may not (inadvertently) upset you at some point but it's where you cut them off that there's no going back from that.

I just think it's really interesting that you haven't done that in your marriage but you have with your friends.

Mary46 · 05/09/2021 19:28

I def agree. I have a friend did everything with husband. You need your own interests.. I do meet friends. Tried keep work ones going but once I left it tended to fizzle out. Pity.

Lovecup · 05/09/2021 19:23

@CoRhona

I’m not sure, i have made it abundantly clear to DH that I won’t put up with any shit, he knows I wouldn’t tolerate it. We don’t argue much, if he pisses me off I just retreat from him. Perhaps we aren’t as happy as I think. I feel indifferent to everything. I find I can switch off my feelings really easily.

OP posts:
BiscuitLover09876 · 05/09/2021 19:10

Is there a particular reason you've started to question it?

The only thing I would say (and I know this sounds awful) but what will you do if when DH dies? I think it's important to keep people around you and build up a network if you can. Nothing false or over the top, but really do value ans be there for those you do see, such as your neighbours and parents of your children's friends. It might be good for you and your self esteem, but also protect you in the future, especially when they children have all grown up and gone.

I say this in the nicest way.

LookAtMoiPloise · 05/09/2021 19:05

@EarPlugAfficionado

I’m like this and I suspect I’m on the spectrum to be honest.
Yes, me too.

I just find it so hard to connect with people; I've never really had more than one friend.

CoRhona · 05/09/2021 17:53

@CoRhona

What is the difference between your DH irritating you and that not being the end of the relationship, and women who do and are then cut off?
@lovecup I'm interested in the answer to this, is there a specific reason?
EarPlugAfficionado · 05/09/2021 17:40

I’m like this and I suspect I’m on the spectrum to be honest.

MareofBeasttown · 05/09/2021 17:35

@SeriouslyISuppose the version of female friends I see on MN seems to be more like the Real Housewives of Beverley Hills than anything else! This is not to say that I haven't had friendships that have gone bad. Of course I have. I am nor giving up on making them though.
Maybe my DH is just not as interesting as some of your DH's :) After over a year of WFH, I would like to meet people other than him. And there are some things I can only discuss with other women.

SeriouslyISuppose · 05/09/2021 17:27

@MareofBeasttown

I don't think most of the posters in this thread want any friends if you don't actually want to ever meet them over coffee or drinks or dinner or anything! I mean, what else are friends supposed to do?

Which is fine. You can define your normal, if that is what you really want to do. But why then wistfully hanker after them? Hmm. I wouldn't want to be friends with anyone who quite clearly doesn't need or want friends. As a foreigner, I find the British attitude to making friends a bit odd, esp on MN. It's so grudging and suspicious.

It is like you are all out to immediately brand friends as " users" or "drama queens". Odd for a women's site which is supposed to foster connections.

I agree. There’s a deeply odd attitude to friendships which is widespread on this forum, and the version of friendship that people say they don’t want — descriptions of ‘friendships’ replete with fights, exclusions, demandingness, unrepaid loans, bitching, time-consuming dramas and hen parties etc — is not something I’ve ever encountered in my entire adult life, which has involved a lot of moves and making new friends. And there’s also a huge suspicion of opposite-sex friendships, which in my circles are both entirely normal and unproblematic.

I’m also fascinated by how so many of the people who don’t have friends are married.

@Flawedperfection, wanting friends would be a really bad reason to have children. A large power of the point of being a parent is training your children for an independent life.

FatAnkles · 05/09/2021 17:16

My dad and his sister (DA) are loners. I'm a loner too. I get on with people well enough but I don't open up that much with them. My mum is hyper-critical of me, so I've tried not to do that with my daughter. But it's left me with anxiety. I keep myself to myself a lit

MareofBeasttown · 05/09/2021 17:11

I don't think most of the posters in this thread want any friends if you don't actually want to ever meet them over coffee or drinks or dinner or anything! I mean, what else are friends supposed to do?

Which is fine. You can define your normal, if that is what you really want to do. But why then wistfully hanker after them? Hmm. I wouldn't want to be friends with anyone who quite clearly doesn't need or want friends. As a foreigner, I find the British attitude to making friends a bit odd, esp on MN. It's so grudging and suspicious.

It is like you are all out to immediately brand friends as " users" or "drama queens". Odd for a women's site which is supposed to foster connections.

LBirch02 · 05/09/2021 16:19

No not abnormal at all. Some people’s relationships centre solely around there immediate family. Nothing wrong with that.

Lovecup · 05/09/2021 16:14

Thank all, I think I was feeling a bit wistful after seeing a few groups of people in parties, camping etc on FB over the weekend.

We get together with our neighbors (6 of us) for garden / house drinks and food probably every 6 weeks or so over the summer and again at new year.

We are the same with family, we only have one sibling each and rarely speak to them and never socialise. We don’t have any parents left.

I get on well with work colleagues but will try my best to avoid socialising with them. It’s all very well but as we are getting older I do wonder what we’ll do if either of us dies…

OP posts:
GoodnightGrandma · 05/09/2021 15:39

Perhaps we should all join the WI to make new friends !

Mary46 · 05/09/2021 15:37

Im around your age. I should prob make new friendships as between autistic kids or their own health issues they cant meet up. Our meetups would be odd coffee yeh does get you down at times. But not easy make new friends at 50

stepupandbecounted · 05/09/2021 15:00

Do you actually WANT close friends op?

Or are you just looking at SM and feel slightly wistful. With friendships come fun and lovely days, support etc but you do need to be prepared that they are not perfect, will def let you down at some point and are only human. I like the non perfect traits in my friends, I like them for all that they are, not my idealised version of them.

Flawedperfection · 05/09/2021 14:40

I honestly think that some people- social outcasts/oddballs etc have children just to have friends/company. And I say this as someone who identifies as being a bit of an oddball (v quiet, solitary, introverted, prefers the company of animals). If only I liked children but I am not maternal towards human infants and never will be.

romany4 · 05/09/2021 14:31

This is the thing, I find with friends they keep wanting to ‘catch up’ over food or drinks and to be honest I can’t be bothered after working all day, I’m happy to go home, cook and chill with DH or on my own

I'm nearly 50.
I feel exactly the same!

GoodnightGrandma · 05/09/2021 14:27

Your fourth paragraph resonates with me, I have never put up with people’s crap. My DH, on the other hand, will be friendly to people who don’t deserve it. Like neighbours who don’t offer to go halves when you change the broken fences, friends who have spoken about him behind his back ( saying he was an alcoholic when he was actually off sick with anxiety) etc.
I have good work mates and I enjoy their company, but when I’m home I don’t ‘need’ friends, but I’d like some.