Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel like being a mum is easier than being a wife?

120 replies

BrownBrownHi · 04/09/2021 21:06

And to think marriage requires more commitment than having kids?

If you have a child your identity remains the same as always, your goals, your dreams, aspirations don’t have to be any different than before you had them, you are always the same person you always were before having children, and you don’t have to change your name or have your identity become Mrs Someone, only thing that changes really is that you have an additional person or more people to take care of other than yourself.

Meanwhile when you marry, your goals are no longer your own, you job/career plans have to be carefully adjusted so they can match his because in a marriage you always have to compromise on everything, where you live, where you work, what type of house to buy and where and women end up compromising the most. You lose a lot but gain very little. Which is why I think marriage rates keep declining throughout the years because women have realised there’s not much to gain from being married and it’s not guaranteed to be a lifelong commitment anyway. It’s a lot of hard work for no real reason. AIBU?

OP posts:
Rainbowsew · 05/09/2021 08:53

Absolutely the opposite here!
I love my children but my identity has completely changed since having them. The responsibility is huge, my career was sidelined for a bit and I'm probably 10 years behind my peers, as a result the plans of what I "could have done" have been adjusted, I don't mind this btw but I'm not who I would have been had I not had kids.

DH and I had similar goals/plans etc which he still talks about but I don't think are feasible now we have children. We haven't moved for example because of their schooling.

Identity is more than your name which you don't have to change just because you marry. Plenty of people I know, particularly doctors keep their names on marriage.

LargeBouquet · 05/09/2021 08:51

You have some deeply weird ideas about marriage.

ActonSquirrel · 05/09/2021 08:51

If you have a child your identity remains the same as always, your goals, your dreams, aspirations don’t have to be any different than before you had them, you are always the same person you always were before having children, and you don’t have to change

Wow.

One of my best friends said she felt utterly erased when she had her baby.

She couldn't be herself. As soon as she got up in the morning, it was time to be a mum & it stayed that way until she went to bed. No time for anything for herself.

When she was in a relationship with no children, she was who she was. Her identity didn't really change.

Blueleah · 05/09/2021 08:47

When I got married I didn’t change my name. Literally nothing changed except I was entitled to inherit his money and pensions if he died. My child, on the other hand, ruined my body and stopped me going out in the evening, prevents me working full time, ruins my weekends because I have to do boring child activities, and my freedom and health literally disappeared overnight.

GoodnightGrandma · 05/09/2021 08:47

I think that some women get to a point in their lives, typically around 50, when they look back and wonder why they gave up their independence etc for kids who have now flown the nest, and a husband that they have to consider/compromise with.
I think it’s the loss of the cosy mummy oestrogen factor, it pulls off those rose tinted glasses.

WhyOhWhyOhWhyyyy · 05/09/2021 08:45

If you have a child your identity remains the same as always, your goals, your dreams, aspirations don’t have to be any different than before you had them

I think this is only true if your goals and aspirations were already centred around family and motherhood. If your aspirations involve career, travel, etc then I think you really do have to adjust them much more for children than for a husband.

andyindurham · 05/09/2021 08:41

I've tended to find that it's not too hard to be an adequate parent. Nor is it to hard to be an adequate spouse.

Doing both at the same time, however ...

Comedycook · 05/09/2021 08:36

@Runrigdan

Do you actually have children op? Not judging, it's a genuine question.
I want to know too...come on op, tell us!
Xtraincome · 05/09/2021 08:35

Would like to know if OP is married and has kids?

Being a mother is a more important job than being a wife. Being a wife to a good man like my DH I would not have to change anything, but to be a mum you must change. But, I do think that a few generations ago, your house and husband were something which defined you more, as long as you procreated it was fine, but kids were secondary as you did less with them- see numerous threads on here about parenting from grandparents generation.

Being a mum changes everything about you and you must allow the change to be just half decent at it.

If I never had kids and was a wife not a mother, I would have a personal trainer, buy the best quality and healthiest food with no cost spared, holiday where I liked with DH and hold conversations from start to finish with him too.

I also have a wonderful DH who's a great father, so it could vary depending on circumstances.

Runrigdan · 05/09/2021 08:16

Do you actually have children op? Not judging, it's a genuine question.

Nosferatussidebit · 05/09/2021 08:16

I couldn't disagree with you more!

polkadotpixie · 05/09/2021 08:13

Do you have children OP? I don't think me or DH changed a bit when we got married, it made literally zero difference to our day to day life whereas having children turned my life upside down, I'm a totally different person now

DeathStare · 05/09/2021 08:11

@BrownBrownHi

Interesting responses, I guess we see things differently Smile
I don't think you are seeing things differently. I think you are doing things differently. For example, there is no need to change your name when you get married and nowadays many (most?) women don't. There's certainly no reason to do so if you don't want to.

It sounds like your marriage involves you sacrificing yourself, your needs, your wants, your ambitions for your DH. This isn't about marriage in general. It's not about how marriage is seen. Instead it's about your marriage specifically and what you are doing in that marriage.

If you are losing your identity in your marriage then change what you are doing.

MiloAndEddie · 05/09/2021 08:02

Opposite way round for me.

My DH has only ever been supportive towards my career. I definitely didn’t feel any different after marrying him and I also didn’t feel other people perceived me differently after getting married.

I did think all of those things post DC though

Coffeeand · 05/09/2021 07:26

Well that’s total bullshit, unless you’re married to someone that doesn’t do what a husband should do.
Children, yes, they are a something else. But married?

anewchapterishere · 05/09/2021 07:08

It's both for me.

I sorely miss my independence from both a husband and children, I'm practically unrecognisable now.

Driftingblue · 05/09/2021 06:37

I would say it’s really the exact opposite of what you state op.

Simply being married requires only the simplest career coordination. Marriage does not require a name change. The financial merger provides economies of scale and efficiencies that benefit both partners.

Raising children together requires massive planning and decisions about how to handle careers, financial goals, schooling, etc. you must coordinate every aspect of your lives in order to make a household with children run.

DoctorSnortles · 05/09/2021 06:35

@ViceLikeBlip

I was a great wife until we had kids. Being both a mum and a wife feels like a lot some days. I'm not sure the wife bit is actually harder, but for me the kids come first, so being a wife is the bit I sometimes feel like I resent?
This is how I feel.
Sadiecow · 05/09/2021 06:06

Totally disagree!

Ohbeeryme · 05/09/2021 06:06

Hmm. I find your post totally the wrong way around. I see many more lose their identity when they have kids, priorities change, lives change. I didn’t change when I met my husband, just began sharing my life with him.

Darbysmama · 05/09/2021 03:49

If this is how you feel about your marriage, I can confidently say you’ve married the wrong person. When you get married, you marry that person for who they are. Not for who you want to make them be. That’s not how it works. Ideally you should have talked about your life goals before getting married. Either they align and you get married. Or they don’t and you part ways. Not this whackadoodle third option where you just stifle who you are and what you want. How did this even happen? How did you even allow this to happen? This isn’t normal at all and it’s not reflect of a true marriage. Get couples therapy or solo therapy if he’s unwilling.

LimeRedBanana · 05/09/2021 01:58

But isn’t it mutual, though? Once DH and I had children, they became the top priority and the most loved for both of us.
We still have a good relationship, but DD and DS are in joint first place for both of us, even when they’re being annoying teens.

Exactly - it’s mutual!

PumpkinKlNG · 05/09/2021 01:51

Opposite for me, if you are not getting on with your husband you can leave him, you can’t leave your kids, well you can but not many women do that do they, I find parenting extremely hard and it’s completely changed me as a person.

Cameleongirl · 05/09/2021 01:47

@CeeCeeDeeBee

I think it’s easy for me to love as a mum. I give my love freely and joyfully.

As a wife, though, giving my love has become more fraught since having DC. DH is no longer my top priority and I know he feels it.

@CeeCeeDeeBee. But isn’t it mutual, though? Once DH and I had children, they became the top priority and the most loved for both of us. We still have a good relationship, but DD and DS are in joint first place for both of us, even when they’re being annoying teens.🤣
LimeRedBanana · 05/09/2021 01:45

@Kite22

I'm with everyone else - it is the opposite of what you have put in your OP. What I can't understand is 1/5th of the votes are currently saying YANBU, when all of the posts say YABU.
The YANBU votes will be all the MNers that come on to complain about their drop-kick, ineffectual husbands, who make their lives soooo much grade than it needs to be.

I imagine being married to some of the specimens described on here would very much make you come to the conclusion that being a Mum is a lot easier than being a wife.