Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To start a thread about lovely MIL's?

119 replies

MeredithGreyishblue · 04/09/2021 11:48

They get slammed continually on here.

I'm sure some aren't pleasant but mine is LOVELY!

She's just called me, seconds after a parcel arrived. "It's from me. I read it and thought you'd like it too!" And it looks like I will!

She never oversteps. She never judges. She is incredible with the children. She's stepped in to help out when we needed her. She is fun, kind, warm and clever.

Anyone else feel really lucky to have gained a fabulous woman in their life?

OP posts:
Holly60 · 05/09/2021 06:42

@Lauraa7

This is like saying let’s start a thread for lovely husbands because they aren’t all abusive. People come on hear for support and a lot of MILs are difficult. YABU
This is primarily a board for women, therefore I think it’s appropriate to use this forum to champion other women. I don’t see someone writing positively and warmly about the strengths and attributes of another woman as a negative thing, and I don’t think you should either.
whateveryouwantmetosay · 05/09/2021 05:51

My MIL was lovely. Never overstepped. In fact, she did the opposite. She tried very hard to live to see her first grandchild born (she insisted it was a girl---she is), but cancer stole her away. Our dc know their nana and who she was, what she was like. My dd loves flower patterns just like her nana did. I'm sure she has part of her in her. 💖

Gingerlovesbiscuits · 05/09/2021 05:20

I had a lovely MIL. Always spoiling us all, always ready to look after the kids, always helping us out. Unfortunately, we very sadly lost her to cancer when my DC were very little and I have missed her ever since. I really hope she knew how much she meant to us all. Please tell your lovely MILs how special they are! X

SquarePeggyLeggy · 05/09/2021 05:05

My ex boyfriend (of many years ago) has the most amazing Mum. She is just lovely, I was much, much sadder to lose her. We’re still occasionally in touch 20 years later, and I’m not with him! She’s just like that, she takes on people and is lovely to them.

Kanaloa · 05/09/2021 04:59

I’m also happy to recognise mil as an important figure in our lives - I see many posters who are happy to let mil babysit for free etc but want her to but out when it comes to first day of school, Christmas, buying first shoes so it’s ‘their own little family.’ The way I see it you can’t have both a mil waiting to do you favours but disappearing when she isn’t convenient to you.

Kanaloa · 05/09/2021 04:56

DS’ was especially bad I meant! Not especially a c-section.

Kanaloa · 05/09/2021 04:56

My mil is a lovely person, she’s like a mum and a friend to me.

One thing (always upsets me when I read threads about this) she always does is treat all the kids the same. My oldest two are not her grandchildren but she treats them like the are, has them over for sleepovers and they never get the cheap token gift at Christmas/birthdays, always something thoughtful and especially for them.

When I had my younger two I had c-sections both times, ds especially and as was an emergency and I had some health complications. MIL came to stay both times because DH couldn’t be away from work for longer than a few days. She did basically everything (school runs, cooking etc) while I lazed about watching telly. Every time I said I can’t just laze about she would say you are working hard recovering and getting to know ds/dd.

It does go both ways though, my mil can pop by any time she wants and I don’t get worked up over small things. Just after lockdown ended she took both the girls out for the day and had their hair trimmed - I see some posters on here getting upset about these very things but I just saw it as mil doing me a favour, and I wouldn’t begrudge her coming over when she likes.

Newmum29 · 05/09/2021 04:22

Mine is a total joy. So kind and wonderful. My mum died when I was 21 so I’m even more grateful to have her in my life.

Darbysmama · 05/09/2021 00:44

I’ve had quite a journey with my MIL. When we first started out, things were rocky. My husband and I met when we were 21. It was December, and he gave me his number. I promptly threw it away. He’d come up to me and pulled out his number written on a piece of paper in his pocket. I was like “who is this creep walking around with his number written down for any random girl?” So I chucked it. Went on with my life.

A week or so later, I ran into him at a restaurant where I was with some friends for half off late night appetizers. He was also there with some friends. His buddy came up to me and he said “hey, why didn’t you call my friend? He saw you passing by and he liked you so much but he was nervous so he wrote down his number and tried to come find you to give it to you. He was bummed you never called.” Well, I felt like a jerk because I just assumed he’d had it written down for anybody, not just me specifically! Doi! 🤦‍♀️

We started dating (most romantic first date ever- ice skating the 2 of us with the rink booked just for us, and two weeks later he moved into my apartment. Fast? Heck yeah! But when you know, you just know (sometimes).

A month later, I met his parents at a birthday dinner. They seemed nice enough, but I’m generally on the shy side, so I didn’t really open up much. Shortly after that, he proposed. We started dreaming of a winter wedding since I love winter, Christmas, December was when we met, and ice skating was our first date.

Well, the Army had other plans. We planned an entire wedding in under a month before he deployed to Iraq for a year. Luckily I am not a bridezilla type! It was beautiful and you never would have known it was planned in under a month for under 5k with nobody going into debt for it. Anyway, I digress.

His family had always been super nice to me. I could tell they were good, kind people. They were a little shocked by the speed of things, but they never said anything mean and they seemed to trust their son’s judgement. But, as soon as my husband deployed, his mom began to have a little trouble letting go. The dynamics shift when you get married, and the wife comes first. Compound that with a deployment, and it was a huge adjustment for her. If he was able to make a call, it was going to be to me. If he could video chat, it was going to be with me. Same with letters. Even getting information from the Army. They contact the spouse, not the parent. So everything was being relayed through me and I think it was a sudden change for her and she felt sort of displaced. I understood where she was coming from.

But then we had a tiff. He was able to come home on a two week leave. During that leave, I got my driver’s license. I was 21 but I’d never learned. I was in foster care, and crappy foster parents don’t teach kids how to drive. They’re not risking their car or paying to put them on the insurance. And I went to college in the city so I lived on campus then took the bus when I got an apartment. We bought 3 driving lessons but after the first 1 the driving teacher said I was ready to take the test and he wouldn’t charge me for the rest. So I took the test and passed. My husband’s parents had his car until then, because clearly I couldn’t drive and wasn’t using it before that. Well when he asked them for the car back because I’d gotten my license that’s when sh* hit the fan. They flat out refused, and when he asked why— his mother said it was because she didn’t trust me and thought I might just steal his car. Absurd. Rude. Pi*ed me off.

Luckily my husband is a good man, and he stood up for me. He put his foot down and said it was his car, his decision, and I’m his wife and they can either accept me or they can kick rocks. Well, they gave the car back and things simmered down. That was 14 years ago. Never an argument since then.

Since then, I’ve been very close with my MIL. I honestly think that in every marriage there needs to be a moment where the husband (I apologize for only referencing hetero marriages, I’m just going off my own experiences, that’s all) makes it clear that the wife is his main priority now. Once that happens, the MIL can start the process of letting go a bit, and everyone can have a healthier relationship. If not, then there’s going to continue to be this power struggle for the main woman in his life. And don’t get me started on mama’s boys who refuse to stand up to mommy for their wives or run to mommy for every little thing. Those marriages are usually doomed!!!

I talk to my in laws more than my own family, and I’m closer to my MIL than my own mother (which isn’t saying much lol). They’re good people and they raised a good son. We lived with them when our lease was up and we started house hunting (because it’s so hard to find a house let alone one that is available at the same time your lease is up!). I cooked for them, cleaned for them (they didn’t ask, just me showing my appreciation), went on walks, bike rides, and did workouts with his mom. We’d talk for hours. Of course covid decided to strike shortly after and real estate basically shut down, no house showings, no people moving, etc. So what was supposed to be a short time of house hunting because a lottttttt longer. Four people, two dogs, two cats in one tiny house… I was glad when things opened back up and we moved into our dream home. We are 45 minutes away from them now, and I really do miss them. But we still call and text every single day. Very lucky to have them!

saraclara · 05/09/2021 00:36

You’re lucky. It’s not a virtue to have a decent MIL, it’s luck.

But that's the whole point!

A post about lovely husbands would be horribly twee because it would be self congratulatory."look how well I picked!".

Lovely MILs are like winning a raffle. We don't get to choose a ticket, but know we're lucky when we snag a prize.

abw94 · 05/09/2021 00:21

I hate seeing MIL's being slagged off rotten on here. I lost my MIL in February and I'm still grieving. I miss her so much. We were really good friends, we spoke more than she did with my OH. She was previously a nurse so when my son was born two years ago I went to her for every bit of advice. Every time my son is ill or has something wrong my first thought is to phone her, I really wish I could. She once joined me at the out of hours doctors at 21:30 on a Friday evening as my son had a red mark (first time mom thought it was meningitis), she didn't question just met me there as I needed support, turned out to just be a rash, she must have thought I was crazy but she always made me feel like I was doing the right thing.

Sorry to ramble, protect your lovely MIL's at all costs!!

saraclara · 05/09/2021 00:10

@Lauraa7

This is like saying let’s start a thread for lovely husbands because they aren’t all abusive. People come on hear for support and a lot of MILs are difficult. YABU
People come here for all sorts of reasons. Not just for support. They come here to share good stuff and to celebrate too. Or to have a laugh, or a light hearted moan about a TV programme or celeb gossip.

This is a lovely thread, and though I'm normally not remotely sentimental, it's made me emotional in a good way. I've no idea why you'd post simply to rain on it.

We need all the positivity we can get right now, and all the posts about these lovely women have made me smile.

HyggeTygge · 05/09/2021 00:08

Oh, I didn't realise. Some people don't like their MILs. I therefore take back my previous post as it's clearly unreasonable. I'll flag it for deletion.

Lauraa7 · 05/09/2021 00:02

This is like saying let’s start a thread for lovely husbands because they aren’t all abusive. People come on hear for support and a lot of MILs are difficult. YABU

HyggeTygge · 05/09/2021 00:01

My MIL is brilliant, and has raised absolutely lovely (adult) kids. We're quite different, and we don't see them very often due to distance, but I appreciate her (and FIL) and my DH is extremely grateful to them.
She cooks wonderful food, is thoughtful and great with our kids.

Slackadder · 04/09/2021 23:52

And she was funny with a great sense of humour. We used to have a good laugh. I miss that

Slackadder · 04/09/2021 23:50

My mother in law was wonderful. So lovely. I cried more tears for her when she died than my own mother. She was so understanding and non judgemental. A world apart from my mother. She died far too young and her three grandsons have a void in life with her absence.

honeygriff · 04/09/2021 23:41

My ex MIl is a lovely human. Flattened by abuse and no longer allowed to see me at all. It was an awful time and she sobbed in my arms because she was so sad about not seeing us. Before this she popped in all the time. I keep up the contact she is allowed with my DD's. It's not easy as teenage girls have their own lives but do FaceTime once a week even though she's lucky if she can say a few words. I'll never forget all her kindness.

Gem176 · 04/09/2021 23:41

I don't have a mother in law as my partners mum died when he was only 17. Partners SIL tells me she was a wonderful, kind and caring woman.

We just had our first baby on Tuesday and named her after his mum.

Reading about all these lovely MILs has made me quite emotional. You are all so lucky. I wish I had the chance to know mine.

OhGiveUp · 04/09/2021 23:36

I loved my late M.I.L. She was intelligent, generous and had a heart full of love for everyone.
Amazing woman, I was devastated when she died.

akissbeforebed · 04/09/2021 23:36

Mine is batty as a box of frogs, frustrating, annoying, doesn't listen/can't hear, starts conversations half way through, expects you to know everyone and their second cousins twice removed, can't understand when you don't share her interests, etc.

I love her and wouldn't change her for the world.

NauseousNancy · 04/09/2021 23:27

Mine is constant, reliable, warm & loving. She loves us and we love her. She would be my number 1 call in an emergency, so calm and measured.

She would do anything for us. What more would we need?

loafcake · 04/09/2021 23:22

I wish I had a nice one! My MIL is a piece of work, but it's lovely reading through about all of yours!

Wickedwaterwitch · 04/09/2021 23:13

My beloved MIL is dead (Covid) and was one of the nicest people I’ve ever known. She was kind, non judgmental, funny, warm, loving and we miss her enormously.

Downsize2021 · 04/09/2021 23:06

My dh comes from the arse end of nowhere. It's freezing when the rest of britain has a heatwave and I've been bitten by clegs and have had four ticks. I say im never ever living there but every single time we stay with his mum and dad (and see the rest of his lovely family ) i think, I could live here. I lost my mum in my mid 20s and she knows this and since the first time we met She's been nothing but loving, kind and simply wonderful.