Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To keep saying it’s impossible to overfeed a bf baby

206 replies

bigBigbaby · 04/09/2021 10:07

To my HV?

My 13 month old is really big!! Jumped up to the top centile line (was on the 25th a birth).

Ebf till 6 m. Eats healthily and actually quite small portions (I think)
Has a small bottle of milk after bath each day as we introduced that as part of bedtime routine from 8 months

Breakfast each day is porridge (1oz milk, dessert spoon oats, chopped berries and 3-4 slices mashed banana )

Lunch is usually a sandwich and veg sticks or a savoury pouch, and a yogurt.

Dinner is a small portion of whatever we have.
Small bottle after bath

She drinks water with meals but is breastfed mid morning and mid afternoon before naps and in the night this is what I’m being told is making her so heavy and that I need to cut the feeds but I’m disagreeing I think there are still benefits to having breastmilk but I’m being told those are cancelled out by the negative effects of being ‘obese’ at a young age

I just don’t agree I think once she’s running about more she will slim down surely ?

OP posts:
00100001 · 04/09/2021 10:50

I really can't see how you're overfeeding your baby.

I'd personally but out the pouches, as there's literally no need for a baby to have purees, especially at this age.

bigBigbaby · 04/09/2021 10:49

@Marchitectmummy

Its hard to say without knowing the portion sizes but it sounds a lot and i think its unusual to jump so far up the scale, I have 5 daughters and they all stayed pretty much on the percentile they were born on. I don't think panic but maybe do try to reduce either the amount of bottle or the portion sizes.
I added the porridge amounts to my op , the sandwich is 1 slice of bread (and is usually houmous or chicken in)

Dinner is just whatever we have so for example if we have salmon potatoes and veg she will have 2-3 broccoli florets, 2 new potatoes and a third of a salmon piece
For bolognese she has 1 dessertspoon of bolognese, a dessertspoon of pasta, a dessertspoon of grated cheese and some salad pieces chopped up so that’s some kind of indication of amounts it’s not a huge amount I don’t think

She has ‘dessert’ after lunch only which is always yogurt I use plain as she’s always eaten plain but that’s a couple of dessertspoons

OP posts:
BunnyBerries · 04/09/2021 10:48

If she's nearly walking I wouldn't worry too much. Once they're away, you can't stop them Grin I just assumed the night bottle was expressed milk - I've not used formula but it might possibly have extra sugar? After 1 we just introduced a small open cup of regular milk at night (a straw can help make it a novelty to converting to open cup which is a great tip, they can learn to sip from one at that age!)

MRex · 04/09/2021 10:48

I never limited breastmilk and DS got quite chunky before crawling, that's quite normal from what I've observed though he stuck to his centile whereas you say your DD hasn't. What is less usual is to not be crawling by 13 months, so she's eating a lot of solid food but not getting the exercise her peers are getting. The first focus should be on helping her to crawl so she can start to burn off some of the fat.

3 big meals is a lot for 13 months, they should be small meals with tiny snack of fruit or something if needed in between. At this age you want lots of food variety so it really shouldn't be porridge every day, sorry if I've misunderstood and you were giving just one example, but it's actually very hard to understand her diet from your OP with elements like "small portion of whatever we have" as the portion size and content could be anything. Most people's under 11 eat a small portion of whatever the parent has, but hopefully much more than your DD!

EmeraldShamrock · 04/09/2021 10:46

I'm not sure. He is 13 months it might fall off him as he grows.
My DS was huge with fat rolls at 13 months born 99centile.
He wasn't overeating, DD ate the same at his age and was a slim baby.

Pissinthepottyplease · 04/09/2021 10:45

At 13 months your toddler is having breast milk, formula? and food so yes it’s possible to be overfeeding. It’s impossible to over feed an ebf baby which your toddler is not.

liveforsummer · 04/09/2021 10:45

I'd also suggest that if she is eating well at nursery but not at home it's because she's filling up on milk instead

bonbonours · 04/09/2021 10:45

I have never heard of bf making a baby overweight even when they are eating food too. Personally I would rather get rid of the evening bottle than the bf as it has so many other benefits comfort etc.

HavelockVetinari · 04/09/2021 10:44

Some HVs are shit, and really have it in for BF. Go to your GP.

bigBigbaby · 04/09/2021 10:44

@00100001

Does she feed herself?

Do you stop when she shows signs of being full (eg turning head away from spoon)

I feed her the porridge and she will say no and shake head if doesn’t want it rest of meals she feeds herself
OP posts:
liveforsummer · 04/09/2021 10:43

As everyone has said you cannot over feed a enf newborn, having said that my comfort feeder was a wide as she was tall by 3 months and it took til about age 4 to begin to start slimming up. You can absolutely over feed a potentially toddling baby on 3 meals plus snacks a day. I'd certainly keep an eye on it. Height and weight should be in proportion so it won't just be that she's small making her 'look' bigger

bigBigbaby · 04/09/2021 10:43

@BunnyBerries

Sorry posted too soon! I've never used pouches either, so check if they have a lot of sugar in them?
It’s just the veg or savoury ones not fruit or anything if she has fruit it’s fresh with breakfast or as dessert like grated apple / chopped berries etc

I think maybe if I decrease the formula at bedtime over a few days and replace with water perhaps that might help

OP posts:
MauveMavis · 04/09/2021 10:43

The issue is that she is having the calories from her meals and then the calories again from feeds morning and afternoon.

By 1 I would expect a baby to be down to minimal day time milk. The bulk of their calories should come from food. ( i know milk is a food , but I think this is the clearest way to express this).

00100001 · 04/09/2021 10:43

The reason to get rid of bedtime bottle is for her teeth.

Either have it earlier (say before bath) so you can brush teeth just before bed. Or as you suggested, swap it for water. (Or just go cold turkey)

CallieOpie · 04/09/2021 10:42

All 3 of mine were ebf til 6 months and became giant top percentile chubsters before 4 months - they were all in toddler sized nappies from 4 months due to the massive ebf thighs. I kept breastfeeding while they started solids, and at 1 year old they were all still massive. After they started walking they all gradually slimmed down and are all v slender older kids now.

If your baby became chubby when ebf and is still just carrying the ebf weight OP, then i think it is likely to be absolutely fine and they will slim down when they start moving around.

I would be very wary of any advice to stop breastfeeding. I am not an expert but my understanding is that ebf breastfed babies are generally very good at regulating their appetite/food intake when they start solids, and that continuing to breastfeed for as long as it works for you is likely to provide lots of benefits to your baby.

If your HV is not a trained breastfeeding expert / counsellor, I'd get a second opinion from someone who is.

bigBigbaby · 04/09/2021 10:41

@BunnyBerries

I bf for over a year, and my baby jumped from 25 centile to 75 by 8 months. At 1 year though, after natural movement and eating regular food, it was 50 centile.

You may not be over feeding but the extra weight while being small/short already may be limiting how much exercise she can get unless walking (I think 13 months is average for learning to walk

Yes she’s nearly there with walking I don’t think it’ll be long at all !
OP posts:
00100001 · 04/09/2021 10:41

Does she feed herself?

Do you stop when she shows signs of being full (eg turning head away from spoon)

BunnyBerries · 04/09/2021 10:41

Sorry posted too soon!
I've never used pouches either, so check if they have a lot of sugar in them?

BunnyBerries · 04/09/2021 10:40

I bf for over a year, and my baby jumped from 25 centile to 75 by 8 months. At 1 year though, after natural movement and eating regular food, it was 50 centile.

You may not be over feeding but the extra weight while being small/short already may be limiting how much exercise she can get unless walking (I think 13 months is average for learning to walk

bigBigbaby · 04/09/2021 10:40

@workwoes123

Bf my two until 3 and 4 yrs old.

I agree with the others that the «you can’t over feed a bf baby» only strictly applies as long as they are ebf. Once you introduce ff (even one a day) and / or solids, it’s not the same.

Where I would disagree is the advice that bfs should be actively dropped. She’s still really young. Personally I’d focus on bf and drop or pull back on other things, starting with the ff. are you letting her feed herself at mealtimes? If so, she’ll be better able to regulate her overall intake than if you were spoon feeding.

Yes and she often throws quite a lot of the food !! It’s not big portions and she usually never finishes it all except her porridge

Perhaps I should start phasing out the bedtime bottle instead till it’s a drink of water?

OP posts:
ReeseWitherfork · 04/09/2021 10:39

Guess not crawling may have had an impact?! Not sure. I don't think you should dismiss what the HV says, but that doesn't mean you need to make any drastic changes, just keep an eye on it. My son probably had a similar diet at 13 months but had months of walking under his belt too, which I assume does make a difference.

SheWoreYellow · 04/09/2021 10:38

Do you have a tape measure? I’d measure her myself and then look in the red book to see if her height and weight are roughly in line.

Or the charts are here
www.rcpch.ac.uk/sites/default/files/Girls_0-4_years_growth_chart.pdf

bigBigbaby · 04/09/2021 10:38

12.2kg (I think they said about 26lb ) and I have no idea of length

OP posts:
00100001 · 04/09/2021 10:37

@bigBigbaby

The only sugar she has is from her vitamin liquid which mixes in with her milk but it’s only 5ml or could that be a problem it contains ‘raw cane sugar’
The amount of sugar in that will be negligible.

She'll be having more from the milk, berries, banana yoghurt (unless it plain?)Etc

workwoes123 · 04/09/2021 10:37

Bf my two until 3 and 4 yrs old.

I agree with the others that the «you can’t over feed a bf baby» only strictly applies as long as they are ebf. Once you introduce ff (even one a day) and / or solids, it’s not the same.

Where I would disagree is the advice that bfs should be actively dropped. She’s still really young. Personally I’d focus on bf and drop or pull back on other things, starting with the ff. are you letting her feed herself at mealtimes? If so, she’ll be better able to regulate her overall intake than if you were spoon feeding.