Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To keep saying it’s impossible to overfeed a bf baby

206 replies

bigBigbaby · 04/09/2021 10:07

To my HV?

My 13 month old is really big!! Jumped up to the top centile line (was on the 25th a birth).

Ebf till 6 m. Eats healthily and actually quite small portions (I think)
Has a small bottle of milk after bath each day as we introduced that as part of bedtime routine from 8 months

Breakfast each day is porridge (1oz milk, dessert spoon oats, chopped berries and 3-4 slices mashed banana )

Lunch is usually a sandwich and veg sticks or a savoury pouch, and a yogurt.

Dinner is a small portion of whatever we have.
Small bottle after bath

She drinks water with meals but is breastfed mid morning and mid afternoon before naps and in the night this is what I’m being told is making her so heavy and that I need to cut the feeds but I’m disagreeing I think there are still benefits to having breastmilk but I’m being told those are cancelled out by the negative effects of being ‘obese’ at a young age

I just don’t agree I think once she’s running about more she will slim down surely ?

OP posts:
moimichme · 04/09/2021 11:13

If she didn't crawl and she is now getting some more 'exercise' when cruising - as she starts to walk and then run, I bet she'll be all right. Breastmilk is still good for babies after 12 months and if you're feeling better, maybe drop the formula bottle at night and either bf then (night feeds might be slightly less frequent then) or give her water if she'll accept it.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 04/09/2021 11:13

Honestly, Id go on trusting yourself - some HVs are utterly obsessed with weight even in babies, though perhaps not surprising when you do see quite a lot of very overweight children.

My Gdcs were BF for well over 6m, carried on with milk in bottles at least twice a day, until well over 2. Both were extremely chubby babies - Gds especially was a little Michelin Man, with rolls of fat.
Might add that he lost quite a bit of it when in hospital for a week with severe bronchiolitis - IMO babies are intended to be chubby since if they get sick they can lose weight alarmingly quickly.

Both had slimmed down hugely by about 2 1/2, I.e. once running around a lot, and at now 5 and 6, both are super slim.

FreeBritnee · 04/09/2021 11:11

I can remember my hygienist regularly putting the fear of god into me re. breastfeeding post 6 months. She was telling me horror stories of children with rotting teeth who were all breast feed for too long 🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄. I continued to breast feed DC2 until he self weaned bang on 24 months and his teeth (as well as DC1) ate absolutely perfect. These bloody health professionals can be dangerous.

MargaretThursday · 04/09/2021 11:11

You can't necessarily look at the height and say that's a high centile too, because children that are overfed often put on the height early too.
It doesn't change their final height, they just reach it sooner.

I'd cut back on the formula at night and for meals stick with main meal followed by fruit.
It's the going up the centile lines that sounds as though there's an issue.
Try encouraging movement-will they walk round on a finger?

PeonyTime · 04/09/2021 11:10

It is possible to over feed an ebf baby - I've seen it done once when a silent reflux baby kept feeding as comfort, but just ended up taking in too many calories.
Your baby isnt ebf. Yes, it's possible to overfeed her.
That is a big jump in centiles. Over how long has she been crossing centile lines? Can you tie it in with, say, introducing solids, or introducing the bottle?

BFCfairy · 04/09/2021 11:10

@bigBigbaby

Hi Op I would ignore the HV opinion on bf unless she is a recognised expert in the field. HV although well meaning are not always the best resources on BF. Indeed very few people are.

Also charts on a smooth line to plot against... its not your babies expected line and don't take it literally.

Healthy eating is important as is BF.

I'd drop the milk bottle and let the bf continue with the healthy food. As 1) food offered is healthy and 2) bf is good regardless of age.

Alternatively reach out to the bf network lll or similar or find an IBLC on twitter or similar to tweet.

Best of luck and don't worry. It's an average of babies....

3girlsunder3 · 04/09/2021 11:10

I would think about dropping the bottle rather than the breast and also look at portion size for meals. Have you thought about not giving dessert? If it was me I would look at reducing the overall calories- not just milk which has many other benefits Smile

daytripper28 · 04/09/2021 11:07

I wouldn't be cutting back on anything!

SloopB · 04/09/2021 11:07

Your baby isn't anything like an EBF baby and that is a massive weight for a 13 month old. I'd drop all milk except breast milk if you want to keep feeding. She definitely doesn't need formula.

daytripper28 · 04/09/2021 11:06

I had 2 health visitors telling me my son (who was a chunky 1 year old - think Winston Churchill in baby form) was definitely going to be an obese child/adult if I didn't cut back on his milk immediately.

He is now 6'3'' and weighs 10 st 7lbs (under weight) and has ALWAYS been a skinny child and teenager.

I didn't cut back on his milk.

I'd be interested in what height you and the baby's Dad are, as that is quite possibly relevant.

bigBigbaby · 04/09/2021 11:01

I think my plan of action then is

-phase out the bedtime bottle (can I just water it down over a few days eg one less scoop of formula for a few days till it’s water the just give her her usual water cup after bath)

  • maybe try a different breakfast to porridge ? Something less ‘heavy’ ?

-in 4 weeks when weighed again get her height recorded as well

OP posts:
ithinkilikeit · 04/09/2021 10:59

Before people bash the HV for being anti BF OP has stated twice now that the HV encouraged the formula at night because the OP had PND and needed a break.

bigBigbaby · 04/09/2021 10:58

@rainyskylight

How mobile is she? My baby started getting quite chunky 5-7 months but then rapidly started slimming down once she started crawling. You say she never crawled? That could be a factor.
I’m starting to think that could be it she’s cruising about and is active and wriggly but maybe not crawling around all the time has meant she’s not burning off all the food
OP posts:
piglet81 · 04/09/2021 10:57

Forgot to add, I found mine would put on weight before a growth spurt or starting a new skill like cruising/walking. Once they’re properly walking they tend to slim down again.

bigBigbaby · 04/09/2021 10:56

@bonbonours

I have never heard of bf making a baby overweight even when they are eating food too. Personally I would rather get rid of the evening bottle than the bf as it has so many other benefits comfort etc.
The HV was so pro the formula from 8 m to give me a break but she said to give it plus the vitamin liquid as otherwise she wouldn’t get enough iron but I think from her diet and vitamins alone she should do now
OP posts:
rainyskylight · 04/09/2021 10:56

How mobile is she? My baby started getting quite chunky 5-7 months but then rapidly started slimming down once she started crawling. You say she never crawled? That could be a factor.

EatYourVegetables · 04/09/2021 10:56

I’ve just read the amounts and that’s less than my kids ate at the time. They are big and have always been, but as they were born high on the centiles no one worried about this. Now they are very slim and active, still pretty high on the centiles, and very tall. They ate like monsters till about 2, then slowed down significantly. For example, when DD was 1 and DS 3, often she would eat more than him. We try to put healthy food in front of them and then let them self regulate.

piglet81 · 04/09/2021 10:55

Many HVs are poorly informed about breastfeeding and I encountered several who were actively against it (especially beyond 12 months) so you may be experiencing the same. Personally I’d wean off the formula rather than the breastmilk - toddlers can have ordinary cows’ milk as a drink if they want it, so formula seems an unnecessary faff. I found breastfeeding to be a wonderful tool in parenting a toddler - past babyhood I think the real benefits are to do with comfort and regulation rather than nutrition (which is obviously also still valuable) so I wouldn’t give up if you don’t want to.

Whywonttheyhelpme · 04/09/2021 10:54

Her diet sounds fine but you are effectively feeding your DD twice. She isn’t EBF any more and you can’t play by those rules.

Breast milk obviously has calories otherwise EBF babies wouldn’t survive. From your post you say you feed twice + before naps + night time feeds too. Let’s say you are up twice in the night + two naps that equals 6 breast feeds, 1 bottle plus 3 solid meals a day. That’s a lot for a 13 month old. You really should be reducing milk intake rather than food if she is carrying excess weight.

trippingflip · 04/09/2021 10:53

Breastfeeding just gets so much flak. If there's anything to remove from a child's diet, breastmilk should be the last on the list.
Your baby can be overfed now that its weaned but breastmilk is not a culprit.
Whether or not you want to do anything about your kid's diet is up to you. Your baby sounds normal to me but I'm on the otherside of the Internet.. large babies usually skinny out when they start moving.

LittleBearPad · 04/09/2021 10:52

I wouldn’t stop the bf though consider dropping the night time ones first.

EatYourVegetables · 04/09/2021 10:52

…105th centile for height…

That’s literally impossible. Centiles of height are an indication of what percetage of children of that age have a smaller height. So eg 95th centile means that if you lined up all the children of that age by height, 95% of them would be below your child and 5% above. In that context, 105th centile does not exist.

OP, I would review the sugar in the lunch and dinner, and if you are content that they are healthy and that you are letting DC self regulate, I would leave it.

Whatever you do do not kick out breastfeeds, fruit or veg.

MushroomQueen · 04/09/2021 10:51

I highly doubt it's the breastmilk more likely the bottles of milk alongside solids and not moving much. My 7 year old was like that and was very chubby 1 year old as he didn't walk until 15 months. He slimmed right down and is v tall (9 year old height) still heavy and still loves milk
But fairly in proportion. Breastmilk digests so quickly I can't imagine it's causing significant issues

LittleBearPad · 04/09/2021 10:51

I’d think dropping the ff at bedtime would be more use and bf her if you are happy to.

I’d also give her water at meal times so she gets used to it and a cup.

I wouldn’t stop the though consider dropping the night time ones first.

RavenclawsRoar · 04/09/2021 10:50

I wouldn't stop breastfeeding. Breastfeeding actually helps to reduce the risk of childhood obesity. I'd probably do away with the formula as it's not necessary and once she's walking, which it sounds like is right around the corner, make sure there's lots of running around and activity in the day. Both my bf dc were chubby and slimmed down once they got to toddlerhood. I think it's a common trend.