Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To keep saying it’s impossible to overfeed a bf baby

206 replies

bigBigbaby · 04/09/2021 10:07

To my HV?

My 13 month old is really big!! Jumped up to the top centile line (was on the 25th a birth).

Ebf till 6 m. Eats healthily and actually quite small portions (I think)
Has a small bottle of milk after bath each day as we introduced that as part of bedtime routine from 8 months

Breakfast each day is porridge (1oz milk, dessert spoon oats, chopped berries and 3-4 slices mashed banana )

Lunch is usually a sandwich and veg sticks or a savoury pouch, and a yogurt.

Dinner is a small portion of whatever we have.
Small bottle after bath

She drinks water with meals but is breastfed mid morning and mid afternoon before naps and in the night this is what I’m being told is making her so heavy and that I need to cut the feeds but I’m disagreeing I think there are still benefits to having breastmilk but I’m being told those are cancelled out by the negative effects of being ‘obese’ at a young age

I just don’t agree I think once she’s running about more she will slim down surely ?

OP posts:
BunnytheFriendlyDragon · 04/09/2021 11:34

But yours isn't a breast fed baby. She's a one year old eating 3 meals a day, and having milk as well. Sounds like quite a lot of milk.

This.

YABU because of course it's different if they are not only on breast milk

Rainbowsew · 04/09/2021 11:33

If you phase out anything I'd phase out the bedtime bottle. At 13 months she doesn't need a bottle or the extra milk. If she wants/needs milk she'll take it from a cup.

Breast feeds won't be adding to her weight as you say most will be comfort sucking.

I think it sounds like HV wants you to give up the breast feeding and she is using the weight gain as a reason. Which I don't think is very ethical.

MrsLargeEmbodied · 04/09/2021 11:33

how long do you intend to breastfeed?
do you have an end date in mind?

bigBigbaby · 04/09/2021 11:33

@FortunesFave

Why is she having "vitamin liquid"? Especially one with sugar in it! Her diet is varied....what's your reason for giving a one year old baby vitamins? With added sugar!

All vitamins are best consumed through actual food.

It was the one recommended to me by the hv she said it had to be put in the milk and that I needed to be careful she didn’t get iron deficiency as it’s common in breastfed babies
OP posts:
MrsLargeEmbodied · 04/09/2021 11:32

i would listen to HV
she knows about babies/toddlers/preschoolers.

georgarina · 04/09/2021 11:32

@bigBigbaby

The HV said the food intake / type of food is not concerning her at all as it’s predominantly savoury except breakfast but she thinks it’s the breastfeeds, I didn’t realise the over feeding only applies to ebf under 6m but then it’s confusing thst if you can’t over feed a baby who is only having breastmilk why after 6m is breastmilk the reason for weight gain if baby is still breastfed.

I think it’s hard as well as I don’t know if she’s feeding and getting 1 oz from me or 10 oz !

The milk isn't the reason for excessive weight gain after a baby is no longer ebf, the milk plus food is too many calories combined. HV is apparently of the opinion that the milk should be cut down but it's up to you whether you cut down milk, food or both - or whether you feel there's a chance your baby is just hungry and will lengthen out.
GintyMcGinty · 04/09/2021 11:31

I would cut the bottle of milk after bath rather than the breastfeeding.

Viviennemary · 04/09/2021 11:30

It does sound quite a lot of food for a one year old. But I agree with tslking to the HV.

Mamabear2020 · 04/09/2021 11:28

I feel like I'll be in the minority here but I wouldn't worry about it as long as you know her diet is healthy. My first was born 25th centile for weight and was 98th by 1 year old. He's always been 25th centile for height. As soon as he started running around his weight started levelling out and he's gained very little in the last year. I think he's probably around 50th centile for weight now but I know what he eats and there was no way I was restricting food in a child so young. We did cut the night breastfeeds in favour of water not long after he turned one, but that was more out of concern for his teeth than his weight.

Jigsawtrain · 04/09/2021 11:28

@FortunesFave

Why is she having "vitamin liquid"? Especially one with sugar in it! Her diet is varied....what's your reason for giving a one year old baby vitamins? With added sugar!

All vitamins are best consumed through actual food.

Vitamin D supplements are recommended for all breast fed babies and formula fed babies who are having less than 500mls/day
00100001 · 04/09/2021 11:27

@TheSquashyHatOfMrGnosspelius

Almost everything she is eating is carbs.
.... Except the yogurt, the veg, the milk... Whatever she's having for dinner etc.

And babies/kids are supposed to eat carbs Confused

Derbee · 04/09/2021 11:27

I’m confused. Your thread sounds like your baby is EBF. But now she’s having 3 meals a day, breast milk, formula at night, and vitamin liquid with raw sugar? Maybe she actually is overweight?

FortunesFave · 04/09/2021 11:25

Why is she having "vitamin liquid"? Especially one with sugar in it! Her diet is varied....what's your reason for giving a one year old baby vitamins? With added sugar!

All vitamins are best consumed through actual food.

00100001 · 04/09/2021 11:25

@SloopB

Your baby isn't anything like an EBF baby and that is a massive weight for a 13 month old. I'd drop all milk except breast milk if you want to keep feeding. She definitely doesn't need formula.
When you say "drop all milk except BF" it makes it sound like she's giving her DD five bottles a day...she's having one at bed time Confused
GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 04/09/2021 11:25

Yes I think that saying means an ebf baby, not a baby/ toddler on solids who also has a bottle plus bf.

The fact that she’s having a bit of bm too doesn’t mean she can’t ever be over fed.

TheSquashyHatOfMrGnosspelius · 04/09/2021 11:25

Almost everything she is eating is carbs.

BungleandGeorge · 04/09/2021 11:24

I’m surprised that your hv didn’t say anything about the bottle of formula milk but told you to cut bf. The guidelines say to continue bf but that formula should be replaced by whole cows milk after 1 so perhaps she is just negative about bf. Personally I would do as you say and reduce the formula bottle. They can fill up really quickly from a bottle without realising they’re actually not hungry, I’d also swap over to a cup but maybe you’re worried she won’t sleep?

HurryUpAndWait23 · 04/09/2021 11:23

This information is absolutely useless unless you have a length for comparison.

Are you or your husband tall?

Millionnewnames · 04/09/2021 11:21

I had a daughter on the 5th centile. More meat on a jockeys whip. Still short and dainty now as an adult. I have a son who’s always been off the charts , just four and wears size one shoes and age 8-9 clothes. Both full term , bottle fed after a day of colostrum and weaned onto solids exactly the same way. Clearly share genes as facially identical and very alike except their size.
Natural variation. It’s a thing.
Please don’t worry too much. If the child is energetic and healthy she’s getting what she needs. Once she’s running and looning about on a bike and learning to swim over the next couple years the puppy fat will melt off.
I’ve never met my health visitor. If my child’s ill I see a doctor. I don’t actually get the point of them. Even as a teenage mum I used to be capable of researching anything I wasn’t sure about. I made reasonable choices as she’s still alive!
We’re conditioned to worry too much these days I think .

00100001 · 04/09/2021 11:20

It makes you wonder what HVs are even taught...they often spout such nonsense

Paddingtonsmarmlade · 04/09/2021 11:19

I’d reduce the bottle feed by watering it down.

Even the veg pouches can have quite a lot of sugar in them as they often contain pear/apple purée in. I’d cut these out for all but emergencies/outings if it makes life much easier.

Also sometime it’s easier to smile and nod with the hv. My one told me I had to make ds crawl (he only did for 2 weeks as he learnt to walk at 10 months) otherwise he wouldn’t be good at maths!?

Cuddlyrottweiler · 04/09/2021 11:19

I would have thought it to be the bottled milk that's the issue though, not the breastfeeding. My health visitor said that it's almost impossible to overfeed a baby and if anyone questioned DSs size to tell them to do one! He is big though, not fat just twice the size he "should" be. She said an overfed baby would be lethargic and not very active, which isn't DS at all. But he's a lot younger than yours so I don't know.

Try getting a second opinion from the gp?

jerometheturnipking · 04/09/2021 11:17

I wouldn't water down the formula. I'd make a smaller bottle and ask her to drink water from her regular cup first and then once she's had a drink of that, offer her her (smaller) bottle and take it away at signs of her being full if she's slow to finish it.

DownWhichOfLate · 04/09/2021 11:16

I’ve just checked my Red Books. One child went from 75th to 25th for weight when they started walking. The other went from 50th to 9th. So her weight may just drop as she becomes mobile.

bigBigbaby · 04/09/2021 11:14

@PeonyTime

It is possible to over feed an ebf baby - I've seen it done once when a silent reflux baby kept feeding as comfort, but just ended up taking in too many calories. Your baby isnt ebf. Yes, it's possible to overfeed her. That is a big jump in centiles. Over how long has she been crossing centile lines? Can you tie it in with, say, introducing solids, or introducing the bottle?
I have no idea as she wasn’t weighed at all literally birth and recently
OP posts: