Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To keep saying it’s impossible to overfeed a bf baby

206 replies

bigBigbaby · 04/09/2021 10:07

To my HV?

My 13 month old is really big!! Jumped up to the top centile line (was on the 25th a birth).

Ebf till 6 m. Eats healthily and actually quite small portions (I think)
Has a small bottle of milk after bath each day as we introduced that as part of bedtime routine from 8 months

Breakfast each day is porridge (1oz milk, dessert spoon oats, chopped berries and 3-4 slices mashed banana )

Lunch is usually a sandwich and veg sticks or a savoury pouch, and a yogurt.

Dinner is a small portion of whatever we have.
Small bottle after bath

She drinks water with meals but is breastfed mid morning and mid afternoon before naps and in the night this is what I’m being told is making her so heavy and that I need to cut the feeds but I’m disagreeing I think there are still benefits to having breastmilk but I’m being told those are cancelled out by the negative effects of being ‘obese’ at a young age

I just don’t agree I think once she’s running about more she will slim down surely ?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
EarlGreywithLemon · 04/09/2021 18:29

I don’t think you’re giving too much food at all. And I find health visitors are often very badly informed when it comes to extended breast feeding (anything after six months in fact). Our daughter wasn’t even one and the health visitor was effectively guilting me for breastfeeding her! I basically ignored her and all is well - DD is 21 months, still breastfeeds at night (we co sleep), I give her similar amounts of food to what you give your daughter, and she’s a good weight. As soon as they become more mobile (crawling/ walking) the jam-roly-poly phase goes away and they lose a lot of the fat. It’s completely normal.
A few other points: children under 5 should take a supplement containing vitamins A, C and D every day, unless they have more than 500ml of formula a day. www.nhs.uk/conditions/baby/weaning-and-feeding/vitamins-for-children/
A mix of refined and wholemeal carbs is best for toddlers - it’s true that having only wholemeal carbs is not good for toddlers, but a balance is what’s needed- you don’t need to ditch wholemeal altogether. Here from the NHS, look at paragraph 3: www.nhs.uk/conditions/baby/weaning-and-feeding/young-children-and-food-common-questions/
If I was to ditch anything I’d ditch the formula but give as much breast milk as she wants and as you want. If you’re happy with it it’s great. can’t tell you how helpful it’s been for us that DD is still breastfeeding when she went to nursery and started getting colds and other bugs - I never have to worry that I can’t keep her fed or hydrated if she’s off her solids.
I think you’re doing really well OP and wouldn’t worry.

Booknooks · 04/09/2021 17:03

To be fair brown bread isn't recommended at that age due to the fibre content.

Plumtree391 · 04/09/2021 17:00

Ditch the health visitor, op.

EatYourVegetables · 04/09/2021 16:22

I was giving her seeded bread as she loved it but the hv said no I had to switch to white bread as under 2 seeded or brown bread has too much fibre and she needs carbs from white bread ?? Is this not ok then or not correct I’m so confused !

Ok that just sounds so fucking stupid that I would at this point stop listening to anything this person has to say on nutrition. Seeded bread has healthy fats, white bread is essentially sugar. Ffs. The recommendation is for small kids to not eat too much fibre as it stops them absorbing food. If the concern is that your child is too big, getting them to switch from high fibre to high sugar food is… questionably intelligent.

HVs are very different. Some are wonderfully experienced and practically extremely helpful. Some are judgemental cows who don’t know shit.

Additionally, if your child was weighed only twice - at birth and now - then it’s not really the case that they’ve been slim their entire life and are suddenly obese. One or both measurements might be wrong.

I’d carry on, probably dropping the FF.

bigBigbaby · 04/09/2021 16:13

@MRex

I think the HV is giving you too much detail in the advice. You can give any liquid child vitamins, it doesn't need to be ones in formula, and you can certainly give any bread. Ditch formula, if you're knackered then offer a bit of normal cow's milk. If you get poo issues then address the quantities of food types for excess fibre, but a good range of food is best and seeds are great. You can print off really good charts for the mix of foods e.g. images.app.goo.gl/gsFCH6RGZM4C65G96. If the proportion is correct then your DD can work it out from there. Focus on trying new foods as often as possible with meals shared between the three of you, that's a good way to reduce fussiness later. As I said before, I'd really just focus on getting her moving, then she'll slim down naturally. Crawl with her, make obstacle courses she can roll around but are easier to crawl, roll a ball so she has to reach about, walk her around holding fingers, help her crawl upstairs, go to playgroup and watch all the other little ones getting stuff so she gets ideas (and jealousy) etc.
Thankyou these are great ideas I feel so much better now because I think I was getting confused but also maybe the HV advice wasn’t as up to date as the advice I’ve got here so I have a plan now and I’ll definitely try and get dd moving more Thankyou !
OP posts:
MRex · 04/09/2021 16:04

I think the HV is giving you too much detail in the advice. You can give any liquid child vitamins, it doesn't need to be ones in formula, and you can certainly give any bread. Ditch formula, if you're knackered then offer a bit of normal cow's milk. If you get poo issues then address the quantities of food types for excess fibre, but a good range of food is best and seeds are great. You can print off really good charts for the mix of foods e.g. images.app.goo.gl/gsFCH6RGZM4C65G96. If the proportion is correct then your DD can work it out from there. Focus on trying new foods as often as possible with meals shared between the three of you, that's a good way to reduce fussiness later. As I said before, I'd really just focus on getting her moving, then she'll slim down naturally. Crawl with her, make obstacle courses she can roll around but are easier to crawl, roll a ball so she has to reach about, walk her around holding fingers, help her crawl upstairs, go to playgroup and watch all the other little ones getting stuff so she gets ideas (and jealousy) etc.

Overthebow · 04/09/2021 16:04

Too much food, not good

Overthebow · 04/09/2021 16:04

It doesn’t seem like your giving too much good. My similar age DC eats a lot more than yours in a day and weighs 10kg. It’s probably the not crawling, if she’s just sat there not active then she won’t be burning it off. She’ll likely slim right down when she starts walking.

bigBigbaby · 04/09/2021 15:27

@FuckPilledLatteplus

Vary the diet more instead of giving sugary vitamins to your dd. I’d leave the bread out of the diet. The chicken or hummus is fine as a meal on its own for a 1 year old.
I was giving her seeded bread as she loved it but the hv said no I had to switch to white bread as under 2 seeded or brown bread has too much fibre and she needs carbs from white bread ?? Is this not ok then or not correct I’m so confused !
OP posts:
LittleBearPad · 04/09/2021 15:25

Is she wanting to be bf as much as she is in the day or are you offering due to habit?

My DS was quite clear by 13 months when he wanted a feed!

She may not actually want all the milk she gets and whilst the formula should be first to go perhaps see if she asks for feeds (if this isn’t what you’re already doing)

Megan2018 · 04/09/2021 15:20

You don’t need to see a HV. Most are useless, I was lucky with mine as they ignore the charts here and rarely weigh.
DD went from 0.4 centile at birth to 95th centile at 18 months. But she was a late walker. Once she got more active she’s back to 50th.
Centiles are largely bollocks.

Plumtree391 · 04/09/2021 15:17

I've read all your posts, op, and honestly can't see anything wrong with the amount of food and milk (bf and bottle), your daughter is having. It seems quite normal to me and mine was having a lot more to eat at that time but was running around and inclined towards being skinny (not so skinny as an adult), so not a problem.

All babies are individuals. What were you and husband like as babies? I know I was very chubby and didn't walk until 15 months, neither did I crawl. My husband was a big one too.

A daughter of a cousin was quite fat, didn't walk until 18 months and grew into a gorgeous, normally sized and clever little girl; her mother was apparently the same. Her sister was quite the opposite size wise.

One thing that stood out from your posts was 'HV'. Honestly, the health visitors come out with all sorts of conflicting information based on what they read (and even worse if they have children of their own). If your girl is happy and healthy, not clinically obese, don't worry too much. Follow your instincts.

Regarding bottle - I have seen children far older than yours with a bottle and sometimes a dummy. They outgrow it, one day she will reach for a cup or glass.

JeVoudrais · 04/09/2021 15:14

For everyone criticising about vitamins, it's NHS guidance to give babies and small children multivitamins unless having over 500ml a day of formula.

www.nhs.uk/conditions/baby/weaning-and-feeding/vitamins-for-children/

YouMeandtheSpew · 04/09/2021 15:12

Yes ! She said I need to be aware that she is in the obese category and that could affect her long term and she advised to cut night feeds as tbey aren’t needed after 9m and she will re weigh her and see where she is in 4 weeks

I just don’t understand her comments. I didn’t think there was an ‘obese category’ for children under 2. If you look in the red book and on the NHS website it’s very clear that BMI isn’t suitable for use on under-twos. And some children - like my own - are born on the 99th centile or above it. They aren’t obese.

If she’d said she was concerned about how your daughter had crossed multiple centile lines in a year that might make a bit more sense, but that isn’t what she said.

Heruka · 04/09/2021 15:01

I think some hvs have their own personal opinions that are not quite what is recommended. Recommending you stop bf as your child is on top centiles is insane! And she’s not even walking! Sounds to me like she’s fine and just at the chunky stage. Centiles represent the healthy population - someone has to be at the top and bottom, and its moving off the chart either way that is concerning. Yes you can check height and keep track now but you have no idea how soon your child jumped the centiles - that commonly happens very early on and they may well have followed the line thereafter. Both my kids were born mid centiles and got to high ones quickly while bf, but followed their lines, never any concern. I think this hv is worrying you for nothing.

TheKeatingFive · 04/09/2021 14:56

I read somewhere that kids are good at regulating food intake until about the age of 3. Then they lose the ability to understand when they’ve had enough.

So a 13 month old that isn’t moving much yet, I wouldn’t worry about in the slightest.

BoredZelda · 04/09/2021 14:46

She said I need to be aware that she is in the obese category

I’m wondering how she could say that without a height.

Surely you have some kind of measuring tape, ruler, etc that you could measure her height?

Darkstar4855 · 04/09/2021 14:44

I breastfed my son at night until he was 2.5 and he was never overweight. He mainly fed for comfort at night so I don’t think he ever took that much milk anyway. I would take the formula out rather than stop breastfeeding if feeding is working well for you both. Alternatively you can night wean and just offer cuddles and water at night.

Milkbottlelegs · 04/09/2021 14:41

Why?

That’s the advice given for small babies when all nutrients come from milk. If you water down the formula they fill up on liquid with less nutrients. I don’t see how it’s really that relevant for older babies eating three meals a day and having breast milk but I’m no expert.

jackstini · 04/09/2021 14:38

Keep the bf, cut down on the bottle/other stuff
Breast milk is still really important up to age 2 - has the HV heard of the WHO?!

Jujujuly · 04/09/2021 14:34

@LadyDanburysCane

*Dinner is just whatever we have so for example if we have salmon potatoes and veg she will have 2-3 broccoli florets, 2 new potatoes and a third of a salmon piece For bolognese she has 1 dessertspoon of bolognese, a dessertspoon of pasta, a dessertspoon of grated cheese and some salad pieces chopped up so that’s some kind of indication of amounts it’s not a huge amount I don’t think*

To me they sound like quite big portions. My DS was born on 85th centile, went up to 95th (but matching height) when truly ebf then gradually came down once we started solids. Now 6 ft tall and skinny! At 13 months he would have had a quarter of a sandwich (so half a slice of thin cut bread) with some crudités for lunch followed by a small yogurt or some chopped fruit. He would have small portions of our food for dinner but much smaller than yours. Eg if we have salmon for our dinner we have one salmon fillet each so a third for a 13 month old seems a lot.

DD had even smaller portions but she was (and is) tiny (but healthy).

My 10 month old is 50th centile weight, 75th height and easily eats a whole salmon fillet, plus potato and greens for dinner. He also breastfeeds throughout the day and 3 times at night. But has been crawling fast since 6 months.

The portion sizes don’t sound problematic to me at all, nor the bf. If I were you I’d drop the formula and just wait until she’s been walking a month or so and reassess. Not crawling or bum shuffling by 13 months is pretty late.

Milkbottlelegs · 04/09/2021 14:34

she advised to cut night feeds

This is completely different to telling you to stop Breastfeeding altogether, which is what a lot of posters seem to think you were told.

If a baby has 3 good meals a day, a bottle of milk before bed and then guzzles milk for half the night, then IF there is a weight concern (I don’t think any of us can judge having not seen the child and with no idea of height) then assuming no issue with portion sizes then I don’t think it’s incorrect to conclude the milk drunk through the night could be part of the issue.

No 1 year old needs three meals a day and to feed through the night. Some wake ups at that age are normal, but the OP suggested frequent feeding through the night.

addictedtotheflats · 04/09/2021 14:19

What you have described doesnt look like shes being over fed at all. My 13 month old was having 3 meals a day, was still bf on demand anywhere between 4-8 "feeds" in a 24 hour period and had a 10oz bottle of cows milk before bed. He followed the 50th centile until he weaned down to 2 bf feeds a day then shot up to 75th centile after we dropped the milk feeds. Each baby is different, I had friends who ebf until 6 months like myself and our babies weights differed vastly (from 9th to 98th centile) they are all now 2 and similar in size. Id personally ignore the HV and continue what you are doing.

FreakinFrankNFurter · 04/09/2021 14:17

If your baby is 12.2kg at 13 months then she is between 98th and 99th centile for weight. You've said she is short so it does sound like she is probably overweight.

SeaHollyDaiz · 04/09/2021 14:10

Urgh health visitors are so obsessed with weight. Mine made me feel really bad as DS had shot up to 99th percentile at about 8 months. He was just a hungry boy. Back down to 75th at the next check and I didn't do anything differently other than follow his appetite. So he was just having a growth spurt at the time. Could be the same for your little one.