Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Not to buy the most expensive home I can afford?

87 replies

libertybonds · 04/09/2021 09:07

Background:

I'm a single mum. I earn a decent income, and could earn much more if I didn't handle pretty much all of the child caring responsibilities for my daughter. She is about to start school and I expect at least another year of covid school closures etc.

My ex pays the CMS maintenance every month, but sometimes threatens to withhold funds. He was also fired less than a year ago. He bounced back pretty quickly.

That's all to say that there is a chance I could earn a lot more in a few years' time, but it's not guaranteed. I also probably can count on the CMS funds, but I'm fearful of doing so.

The housing options within walking distance of school are a small flat that is easily affordable, or much more expensive houses that would be harder to maintain and require updating. The flip side is that theoretically I could add value to a house, and I'm probably overpaying for the flat due to the insane property market (I have an accepted offer).

The traditional advice is to buy the most expensive home you can afford. AIBU to buy the smaller flat, when I could afford more? It has outdoor space where my daughter could play (but no private garden, just a patio) but is pretty small.

OP posts:
LipstickLou · 04/09/2021 09:53

A small cottage then or terrace?
We are moving shortly. We over stretched ourselves a few years back and I only have one child at home. I am looking at a three bed plus study and wouldn't want a 5 bed with all the maintenence. We are good at renovation but don't need unused rooms. Look at a few things, sleep on it. Then make a list of pros and cons.

caughtinanet · 04/09/2021 09:34

I've never heard that you are meant to buy the most expensive house, that crazy especially given all the unforeseen events recently. Who is it that says that?

Buy the one that makes you feel most comfortable with all the aspects

libertybonds · 04/09/2021 09:31

To answer some questions presented:

The flat is not new, but has recently been renovated. It has three bedrooms, but is small to me at 800 sq ft, compared to the 2000sq ft, 5 bedroom house that i lived in during the marriage (which my ex kept).

I won't get a lodger under any circumstances.

OP posts:
bigbaggyeyes · 04/09/2021 09:25

My dad always used to say buy the most expensive you can afford. I get his logic but when you're a single parent I don't necessarily think it's a good idea.

When i split from my ex I bought a house I could easily afford, it was one less thing to worry about. It was in a lovely area, within walking distance of the primary school, just not a very pretty house, think 1970s grey box. But it was easily affordable, so it took the pressure off me financially, I could also treat the kids to holidays and save. Once I was settled I over payed on the mortgage and put money into a pension. If I'd have stretched myself to the limit I think I'd be stressed to hell with no disposable cash, this way I had a buffer with my mortgage company and felt ok about money. I'm now in a great position financially, earn a lot more, I'll be able to retire in 10 years, kids are in secondary school and I'm about to move into a small, but gorgeous cottage in a place I love with a large amount of equity from my grey box, and a small mortgage. I found I never really wanted the big, 5 bedroom house, just something small and pretty

Porcupineintherough · 04/09/2021 09:24

I have heard the "buy the most expensive house you can afford" thing. I know people who have done very well on the property market following it. But I also know people who have lost homes or where meeting the monthly mortgage payments was a source of constant stress.

Anyway, I think you have 2 potential choices. A 3 bed house with a lodger to help pay the mortgage, or the flat (you could always move in a few years when your dd is in secondary and no longer needs childcare).

Upamountain43 · 04/09/2021 09:24

Key to me is that you have stated you are buying a 'home' not a 'house' as many.people would say.

This suggests you are considering where you would rather live and have the best life rather than any potential money making you could do.

You will make the right decision

FannyBrice · 04/09/2021 09:22

Whatever you think the house will cost to renovate treble it, then treble it again
Materials and labour have gone through the roof, there is so much demand
I'd stay within my comfort zone for the time being

whoami24601 · 04/09/2021 09:22

We deliberately chose a house that was much less than our maximum budget because I don't cope well with debt. Glad we did as a few years ago DH unexpectedly lost his job and it was one less thing to worry about. I'd say if you're at all unsure of your income go for the flat.

LipstickLou · 04/09/2021 09:21

It depends on your age and profession. If your work is always in demand that helps in assessing risk. If you bought the house could you let out a spare room to help with costs and save for repairs? Flats can take much longer to sell as not everyone wants to pay a service charge and ground rent. I would look for something where you can add value. Again that is hard with a new flat. Don't over stretch yourself but look at all options. Houses often have hidden space such as lofts which could be converted if your income goes up.

MaudebeGonne · 04/09/2021 09:13

Honestly, I'd chose the flat. You are a busy woman anyway, why take on another project that is going to drain your time and energy. Much better to have a cosy flat, that doesn't need a load of work, is quick and easy to clean and isn't going to cost a fortune to heat and furnish. You can move up the ladder again in a few years when you are more certain of your finances.

Coulddowithanap · 04/09/2021 09:11

I've never heard of anyone saying buy the most expensive house you can afford. What if interest rates increase?

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 04/09/2021 09:11

Weve never bought the most expensive thing we can afford. I like that we can comfortably afford to overpay on our flat (we have 2 dc) and be mortgage free sooner.

I would he really stressed if my mortgage repayments were large.

You dont have to stay in the flat forever - even 5-8 years might see you even more comfortable in terms of income and you could move again.

My main thought when buying somewhere has always been "will this be easy to sell when the time comes" - so far so good.