Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Not to buy the most expensive home I can afford?

87 replies

libertybonds · 04/09/2021 09:07

Background:

I'm a single mum. I earn a decent income, and could earn much more if I didn't handle pretty much all of the child caring responsibilities for my daughter. She is about to start school and I expect at least another year of covid school closures etc.

My ex pays the CMS maintenance every month, but sometimes threatens to withhold funds. He was also fired less than a year ago. He bounced back pretty quickly.

That's all to say that there is a chance I could earn a lot more in a few years' time, but it's not guaranteed. I also probably can count on the CMS funds, but I'm fearful of doing so.

The housing options within walking distance of school are a small flat that is easily affordable, or much more expensive houses that would be harder to maintain and require updating. The flip side is that theoretically I could add value to a house, and I'm probably overpaying for the flat due to the insane property market (I have an accepted offer).

The traditional advice is to buy the most expensive home you can afford. AIBU to buy the smaller flat, when I could afford more? It has outdoor space where my daughter could play (but no private garden, just a patio) but is pretty small.

OP posts:
idontlikealdi · 04/09/2021 23:24

We lost our stupidly large house when I was growing up in the 90s recession. I would never want to be in that situation with my kids. We have a modest house and a great lifestyle knowing the lifestyle can be given up if needed.

libertybonds · 04/09/2021 23:10

This is all very helpful, as it seems like most posters agree that my preferred course of action is a sensible one.

No, there aren't any houses within price range which would be suitable. I'm determined to have a 3 bedroom property.

I do worry about whether there is enough living space in this flat, but my daughter is getting older and she will have a reasonably big bedroom to play in, plus the outdoors when it's nice outside.

OP posts:
MrsToadlike · 04/09/2021 13:44

Yeah I agree with your idea OP, don't stretch yourself to your limits. What happens if interest rates rise etc? Some leeway is really important for piece of mind.

We did not stretch ourselves anywhere near the maximum limit we could borrow; we still bought a place that is ultimately home.

LivingLaVidaBabyShower · 04/09/2021 13:31

Based on what you've written i'd go for the flat.

We went £300k under max budget and we manage, but its a bit tighter than i expected and i am happy we bought under budget. We were in a flat which was easy/cosy. Our new house is edwardian semi and is about 4-5k a year in maintanance. The garden is also w.o.r.k.

IceCreamAndCandyfloss · 04/09/2021 13:17

I would never mortgage to the max, life isn’t guaranteed and all sorts of things can and do go wrong. Plus we wanted to save for the children’s future and for them to have opportunities as children to do activities, travel etc.

Getawaywithit · 04/09/2021 13:14

OP I am a mortgage free single parent but with a large semi detached house. It is an old house and is shockingly expensive to maintain. I would have struggled with a mortgage on top but I receive no maintenance and never have. I would personally go for the cheaper option knowing I could handle a short period of unemployment or illness or the maintenance stops. I would also save the difference between the cheaper and the more expensive option every month to build up some savings to help handle potential problems like prolonged illness. This has massively helped me have some peace of mind as a long term single parent.

2bazookas · 04/09/2021 13:07

In your shoes I'd go for a ground floor 2-bed flat with its own front door and sole access to a private garden.

If it had knobs on, it would have two bathrooms.

That will give you and DD security, each has a private bed and bathroom and outside space; plus suitable for a cat/dog.

That would suit you both right through her childhood, teens, and young adult years when she's a student or has a job.

You can have guests to stay by doubling up, or a sofa couch.
Look for a kitchen big enough to eat in.

MauveMavis · 04/09/2021 12:54

I've owned flats since I bought my first property in 2002.

I'm now mid 40s. I find myself googling houses all the time.

I'm just getting a bit sick of living in close proximity to other people and their (or their tenants) selfishness). I would think about this when looking at flats.

We went through a phase when our bin store was a total disaster with people piling recycling up on the floor and we got rats.
Last week someone got their new kitchen delivered and the delivery blokes dragged all the stuff across the natural stone floor in the foyer which has scratched really badly. I'm prepared to bet that they weren't allowed to drag the kitchen units over the wooden floor inside the flat and damage that...

However, knowing that your home is truly within your means is a good place to be. So I'm basically sitting on the fence getting splinters in my arse.

VickyEadieofThigh · 04/09/2021 12:40

@Coulddowithanap

I've never heard of anyone saying buy the most expensive house you can afford. What if interest rates increase?
It used to be the norm for people to be told this back in the 1980s when I was first buying, partly because there was tax relief on your mortgage in those days.

It was nonsense then and it's nonsense now. I bought an easily affordable property each time and was entirely mortgage free (paid off the balance of the mortgage) by the time I was 42. I cannot begin to describe to you how incredibly freeing that is!

SMabbutt · 04/09/2021 12:35

How much difference is therebetween the house and flat when you take the service charge into account? How quickly do flsts sell in normal market conditions? How long ca you realistically stay in the flat - your dc is growing so look at older kids and try to imagine it. What restrictions would you have for friends visiting or sleepovers? Arw there any 1 bed houses that might be affordable and if you went for a house would you have to push to your max, which I wouldn't want to do. Are any affordable houses liveable just not how you would want it or would you need to do major work?

Do a SWOT sheet or list of pluses and minuses for each option considering how you would cope if interest rates rose. Also what if house prices fell sending you in to negative equity meaning you couldn't move.
Everyone has different priorities so only you can know what your best option is but you are already thinkong about it sensibly so I'm sure you will come to the right decision.

Didiplanthis · 04/09/2021 12:00

We would have been utterly stuffed had we bought the most expensive house we could afford. We had good well paid very secure jobs. But life happens. In our case a child with additional needs. It meant the money we hadn't been putting into a vast mortgage and were saving instead ( at the time for school fees ) can now be drawn on to support me working part time and paying for my child's therapy.

Guacamole001 · 04/09/2021 11:22

Freehold is a good investment. Leasehold less so.

ChazsBrilliantAttitude · 04/09/2021 11:12

We chose to spend a bit less on our main home and build up other investments with the spare money so we have longer term financial security.

DurhamDurham · 04/09/2021 10:40

I've never bought the most expensive house we could afford. I've always wanted to go on holiday, trip out, meals out etc and not to have to worry about mortgage payments.

Mortgage free at 47 which is a great feeling and would have been completely impossible if I'd always bought the most expensive house I could afford.

The flat sounds ideal and if you've got a good feeling about it go for it. Hope you're both v happy there Smile

something2say · 04/09/2021 10:35

Yes I'd go for the easily doable flat option too. Spare cash, no hassle. We are doing the exact same now, my mortgage payments will be £222 so we will be able to overpay.

Good for you and also, I salute your ability to be financially independent of your ex who sounds like he is entirely unreliable through meanness.

Underpaidsnackbitch · 04/09/2021 10:34

Having been in a similar situation to you, I would say buy the flat. I bought the house and i bitterly regret it.
It needs much more work doing than i initially thought (even though i had a full survey)
It's not just the monetary costs, it's the time costs too. Sourcing reliable trades takes time. If you do work yourself it takes up time, and trying to decorate / diy with a small child around is near impossible.
Also it impacts your quality time with your child too. Money spend renovating reduces the spare cash for days out and holidays etc.
A small child is not going to give a hoot whether they live in a house or flat. Spend your money making memories! Are there nice parks etc nearby? A garden may not matter.
Given the choice again I would spend less on a flat and bide my time until I was able to work more and afford to move somewhere larger.

lockdownalli · 04/09/2021 10:29

When I split from ex I bought a tiny house so that my mortgage was smaller, leaving me more money left over to support the DC who are now young adults.

In addition, this means I have been able to regularly overpay the mortgage, so I can be rid of it earlier, and go part time/semi retire at a younger age.

The only caveat I would have is that when I was looking at flats, some of the maintenance costs were HUGE, and actually made the monthly outgoings higher than the higher mortgage costs of a house. Also, with a flat, you continue to pay that maintenance charge once the mortgage is paid off.

I hope this is useful - good luck!

SciFiScream · 04/09/2021 10:21

It's all about balance. Buy the biggest you feel financially comfortable with.

But also have some awareness of what's easy to sell (for you in the future) and try to future plan for yourself now.

I'd buy a house, but only if I could afford it.

Flats need maintenance too and can be more complicated because you have to sort out how to share the cost with neighbours. (Or maybe that's just a Scottish thing?)

museumum · 04/09/2021 10:07

If you could genuinely live happily in the flat then it does feel great to not worry about money. We chose a home we’ll within our means.
In the other hand, having too little living space is itself stressful. So if the flat is very cramped then it might not be the best option. Think carefully about your lifestyle and how much space you need. Can you have friends over for dinner? Is there room to work / for homework? Can your dd have friends to play? Etc.

Annoyedanddissapointed · 04/09/2021 10:01

The traditional advice is to buy the most expensive home you can afford

Actually it isn't. No one should be doing that. That's how you end up fucked when any little thing changes.

You sure you are overpaying the flat? Where I am houses sky rocketed but flats stagnated few even dropped

Didiusfalco · 04/09/2021 10:01

It sounds like security is very important to you, and rightly so, you certainly don’t want to have to rely on maintenance from your ex. I would get a smaller place, build up some savings, enjoy not worrying about money and live life.
However saying that, I take it there isn’t a middle ground option of a little two bed house or similar?

2pinkginsplease · 04/09/2021 10:00

I’d rather buy smaller and have money for luxuries than buy a big house and struggle to actually live.

We live in a small house, we could afford to move but would rather have money to go on holiday, weekends away, treat the kids and actually live our lives rather than living in a. Big house tied to a huge mortgage.

violetbunny · 04/09/2021 09:58

I've never heard that. I deliberately bought less than I could afford. The plus side is that I'm on track to have paid off the mortgage in my 40s. I also didn't wanted to be trapped by my lifestyle. I didn't want the pressure of earning the same amount for the next X years.

flashpaper · 04/09/2021 09:57

When we applied for our mortgage, we were told that because the term of the mortgage went on beyond my children reaching 18, we couldn't count CM or CB as income for our application so you mightn't be able to use CM anyway.

I would go for a smaller, more affordable place. Your DD would probably appreciate more disposable income to do stuff than a bigger house. I don't think most kids actually care where they live, as long as they have their own space. I personally wouldn't like to be mortgaged up to my eyeballs.

Elieza · 04/09/2021 09:53

Tarting up a property costs money. So not only would you need the deposit and mortgage sorted, you’d need ready cash or credit card for tarting up and punting the big house. If you use credit then that costs extra if it takes longer than expected to pay it off.

It also means dirt and dust everywhere, potentially no kitchen or no bathroom for a few days. In my case no bath/shower for a nearly a month! How would dc be during that? It can be difficult.

The main way to make money is to do it yourself. Can you or your pals fit a kitchen or bathroom? If not you can still make money, just not as much. Plus every area has a ceiling price. So you need to tart your but not waste money. So you need to research your market. And work out if spending 15 grand on kitchen and bathroom is worth is when you deducts all the costs and estate agents fees etc to sell the house on.

Living in a bombsite for a year to make a ten grand profit may not be worth the hassle? Although if it makes you 50k…!

I think that you may be better with the small flat just now. Is there anything you can do to add value to that?