Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Not to buy the most expensive home I can afford?

87 replies

libertybonds · 04/09/2021 09:07

Background:

I'm a single mum. I earn a decent income, and could earn much more if I didn't handle pretty much all of the child caring responsibilities for my daughter. She is about to start school and I expect at least another year of covid school closures etc.

My ex pays the CMS maintenance every month, but sometimes threatens to withhold funds. He was also fired less than a year ago. He bounced back pretty quickly.

That's all to say that there is a chance I could earn a lot more in a few years' time, but it's not guaranteed. I also probably can count on the CMS funds, but I'm fearful of doing so.

The housing options within walking distance of school are a small flat that is easily affordable, or much more expensive houses that would be harder to maintain and require updating. The flip side is that theoretically I could add value to a house, and I'm probably overpaying for the flat due to the insane property market (I have an accepted offer).

The traditional advice is to buy the most expensive home you can afford. AIBU to buy the smaller flat, when I could afford more? It has outdoor space where my daughter could play (but no private garden, just a patio) but is pretty small.

OP posts:
Ozanj · 05/09/2021 12:02

I would buy the most expensive house I could afford if there is add to add more gains in the future.

Lipsandlashes · 05/09/2021 12:01

[quote libertybonds]@Lipsandlashes it's share of freehold. Service charge is £1600 per annum. I've asked my solicitor to enquire about these types of issues, but the buildings generally are in decent repair.[/quote]
Unfortunately with flats these type of issues won’t come up until it’s too late - your solicitor won’t be able to protect you against an increase in service charges, new roof, installation of security gates - basically anything the maintenance company decides on. Just be careful.
DH and I lived in a flat for our first home and the service charge doubled over night to £500 a month. We were ok because we both had a decent wage coming in but many were absolutely fucked. One young guy who lived there was at our door shaking and asking how he was going to afford it all.

libertybonds · 05/09/2021 11:55

@Lipsandlashes it's share of freehold. Service charge is £1600 per annum. I've asked my solicitor to enquire about these types of issues, but the buildings generally are in decent repair.

OP posts:
Lipsandlashes · 05/09/2021 11:52

Have you taken into consideration the ground rent and service charge payments on the flat? How long is the lease? Are the maintenance company reliable and do they maintain the flat and grounds to a high standard? These are all very important things to take into consideration when buying a flat. You will never stop paying for it - if the flats need a new roof, for example, your payments will increase.

shouldbeworkingmore · 05/09/2021 10:54

It depends on individual circumstances & don't forgot lending legislation changed after 08 so banks will only tend to lend you what you can actually afford. If your mortgage is 30% of your income it makes a difference if that income is 2k or 6k.

Newmumatlast · 05/09/2021 10:53

@Coulddowithanap

I've never heard of anyone saying buy the most expensive house you can afford. What if interest rates increase?
I have heard it alot but haven't done it. Too worried to not have a really comfortable buffer and we overpay instead
FrownedUpon · 05/09/2021 10:48

We’ve never bought the most expensive house we could afford. If we had, we’d be working another 20 years to pay off the mortgage. As it is, we can retire very early with no mortgage & plenty of money to travel.

libertybonds · 05/09/2021 10:44

The flat is share of freehold btw

OP posts:
ittakes2 · 05/09/2021 10:39

Land is what goes up in value not bricks and mortar so I would buy the house if you can afford that without a stretch.

M0rT · 05/09/2021 10:34

I think you are right going for the flat if it will suit you size wise until your DD is a teenager.
It's three bedrooms so not going to fall into that "trapped in lockdown" bracket for resale and hopefully by the time your thinking of selling lockdowns will be a distant memory.
Also the utility of gardens depends very much on personality of adults and children in the home.
I live in an area with lots of young families and most of the children play out on the green space with their friends.
It's only in hot weather that paddling pools etc are put out in the gardens.
I'm in the garden a lot and only a handful of days in summer do I hear children in their gardens.
I can't physically do much gardening so if I was very house/garden proud the long grass for much of the summer and patio with weeds growing up would bother me and be just another job on the long list of jobs to sort.
Also money managers recommend thirds, a third of your income for housing, a third for living and a third for the future.

Rubyrecka · 05/09/2021 10:32

I have heard of the ‘buy the most expensive house you can afford’ sounds like it was made up by an estate agent! But the just I suppose is the property is an asset and therefore as long as u can pay the mortgage your asset rich but potentially cash poor. I’d prefer a balance, myself.

Flats won’t appreciate as well as houses and like you have already highlighted, scope to improve is limited.

Personally I would likely go with the house as you sound like your financially stable and can earn more if necessary. The house will give you a better return all round but like a pp mentioned, the costs of materials at present is absolutely ludicrous! We’ve just applied for a mortgage and the rates are really low at the moment so that maybe something to consider!

50ShadesOfCatholic · 05/09/2021 10:27

I think it's very wise to buy a cheaper home, just the peace of mind knowing you can afford it will be nice. And 800 sq ft is fine for two people especially with a thoughtful layout and clever storage. Tbh a 5br house for 3 people sounds excessive.

For me the deciding factors would be enough privacy and quiet which only you can judge, and also that the outdoor space was inviting and useable.

burnoutbabe · 05/09/2021 10:25

Buy the most expensive you can afford made more sense when house prices just went up and up.

And if the person has just started on a professional career where salaries rise quickly (ie lawyer/doctor/accountant) so you are only stretched for a short bit.

Also moving costs are big so you don't want to keep trading up.

I'd get the flat. I've had a flat for 20 years and it's fine. Now paid off as I haven't kept moving.

BiddyPop · 05/09/2021 10:24

It sounds like you are looking at it with a pragmatic mind, what can you manage now for this phase of your and DD's life and what might give you options in the future while having a reasonable quality of life in the meantime.

Just because you CAN potentially afford a bigger house, doesn't mean that you SHOULD, if it is not what you need at the present moment in time.

Taking on renovations might make good business sense, but is a lot of hassle and expensive. And if the flat means you can live in your means and decide whether or not to take on extra work rather than it being a necessity, then that seems sensible.

But is there some green space nearby that dd can play if you have no garden?

That's the only thing that strikes me as a point against the flat.

OnlyFantastic · 05/09/2021 10:23

A small child is not going to give a hoot whether they live in a house or flat

This is a kind comment and no doubt meant to be comforting to someone unable to live somewhere with any outdoor space.

However it's not really true unfortunately, as anyone who's experienced having small children without vs with a garden would say.

Theres not much I wouldn't compromise on to be honest to ensure a private garden. Especially during current times when no one knows if we're all about to be locked inside for the next 6 months again.

SnoopyLights · 05/09/2021 10:19

The traditional advice is to buy the most expensive home you can afford.

I haven't heard this, is it perhaps a variant of "Buy the worst house on the best street rather than the best house on the worst street?"

I would say to buy the more easily affordable property. Circumstances change, not always for the better. I do know people who have pushed their finances to the limit for the most expensive property and have lost it (and their relationship) when times got harder.

OnlyFantastic · 05/09/2021 10:19

I'll be honest op, I would never buy a flat at present.

Give it a couple more lock downs and it will either plunge in price or be impossible to get rid of in future should you want to.

Datsandcogs · 05/09/2021 10:17

I would buy a house every time rather than a flat. Neither option sounds ideal, I would compromise on something other than type of property.

libertybonds · 05/09/2021 10:15

@TiddleTaddleTat there isn't going to be a reasonably priced 3 bedroom house in walking distance which isn't a project.

OP posts:
libertybonds · 05/09/2021 10:14

I need a third bedroom. It's not negotiable.

OP posts:
TiddleTaddleTat · 05/09/2021 10:09

Tough one. I'd probably keep looking as a flat is generally much inferior to a house (noise, communal area repairs, leaseholders, service charge, shared or jo garden, etc).

Travis1 · 05/09/2021 09:57

I would never borrow to maximum
Budget. Always allow for real life. Personally I’d stick with the flat

LemonTT · 05/09/2021 09:48

I would ditch a third bedroom for a garden for my kid.

libertybonds · 05/09/2021 09:26

@idontlikealdi this is basically my nightmare

OP posts:
PrincessNutella · 04/09/2021 23:26

I think you're using your brain.