Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Not to buy the most expensive home I can afford?

87 replies

libertybonds · 04/09/2021 09:07

Background:

I'm a single mum. I earn a decent income, and could earn much more if I didn't handle pretty much all of the child caring responsibilities for my daughter. She is about to start school and I expect at least another year of covid school closures etc.

My ex pays the CMS maintenance every month, but sometimes threatens to withhold funds. He was also fired less than a year ago. He bounced back pretty quickly.

That's all to say that there is a chance I could earn a lot more in a few years' time, but it's not guaranteed. I also probably can count on the CMS funds, but I'm fearful of doing so.

The housing options within walking distance of school are a small flat that is easily affordable, or much more expensive houses that would be harder to maintain and require updating. The flip side is that theoretically I could add value to a house, and I'm probably overpaying for the flat due to the insane property market (I have an accepted offer).

The traditional advice is to buy the most expensive home you can afford. AIBU to buy the smaller flat, when I could afford more? It has outdoor space where my daughter could play (but no private garden, just a patio) but is pretty small.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
KhoshkaKatya · 05/09/2021 18:52

Good idea to leave yourself some slack.

Save the difference in mortgage payments each months and then if you want to you can upgrade in the future without extending your mortgage so much. But you’ve also got an emergency fund to dip into

2bazookas · 05/09/2021 18:39

@BoredZelda

Mortgage borrowing limits and compulsory deposit requirements were set in steel by lenders and VERY much tougher than today.

Yes, but the change began in the 1980s with deregulation. Banks began to offer mortgages, MIRAS was introduced, more competition came in to the market. The early 80s was when my boomer parents bought their first home. There were restrictions but the LTV wasn’t that much different. The checking of affordability was a bit more strict, but with the introduction of endowment mortgages in the early 80s, it was way more affordable to pay an interest only mortgage. The problems with these didn’t come to light until the late 90s.

One of the main differences with now is that at that time there weren’t the same fixed rate introductory offers which encourage people to buy at a level which can lead to a big jump in the future.

Both fixed rate offers and endowment mortgages were designed to entice people who couldn’t really afford it, to buy bigger properties than they could easily afford so it isn’t quite accurate to say things were wildly different for boomers buying property.

I AM a boomer; bought my first property in 1971 with a 25 yr endowment mortgage. It's a myth EM's were a cheap way to borrow.

An endowment mortgage charged monthly payments of the loan interest, plus compulsory life insurance, plus the endowment policy.

libertybonds · 05/09/2021 17:22

Yes, in London. I can't change areas for a number of reasons.

OP posts:
BoredZelda · 05/09/2021 16:14

Mortgage borrowing limits and compulsory deposit requirements were set in steel by lenders and VERY much tougher than today.

Yes, but the change began in the 1980s with deregulation. Banks began to offer mortgages, MIRAS was introduced, more competition came in to the market. The early 80s was when my boomer parents bought their first home. There were restrictions but the LTV wasn’t that much different. The checking of affordability was a bit more strict, but with the introduction of endowment mortgages in the early 80s, it was way more affordable to pay an interest only mortgage. The problems with these didn’t come to light until the late 90s.

One of the main differences with now is that at that time there weren’t the same fixed rate introductory offers which encourage people to buy at a level which can lead to a big jump in the future.

Both fixed rate offers and endowment mortgages were designed to entice people who couldn’t really afford it, to buy bigger properties than they could easily afford so it isn’t quite accurate to say things were wildly different for boomers buying property.

BoredZelda · 05/09/2021 15:58

The traditional advice is to buy the most expensive home you can afford

I have never heard this advice. I’d buy the property that best suits your needs, and put any spare money in savings. Trade up in size as you need it.

We stretched ourselves to the limit when we first bought this house because we needed the space and needed to be in a particular school because of DD’s disability. It was pretty hairy for the first few years, but is much more affordable now as we have moved on in our careers.

2bazookas · 05/09/2021 15:39

[quote libertybonds]@VeganVeal unfortunately, interest rates don't really have anywhere to go but up at the moment[/quote]
Exactly. and for whoever said "I think the whole "buy the most expensive house" thing is a baby boomer hangover when they were guaranteed pay rises/pension/job for life and stuff that doesn't exist today. You could hardly be more wrong.

Mortgage borrowing limits and compulsory deposit requirements were set in steel by lenders and VERY much tougher than today. For which enforced caution we thanked god , when mortgage interest rates hit 17 %.

Bells3032 · 05/09/2021 15:39

My sister bought the most expensive house she could afford and constantly stresses about work and finance.

We looked at doing the same but decided (wanting baby in the near future) that we would rather have a safety net of savings. We also quickly realised that there was always stuff to do in a house and it always costs more than expected so was glad we didn't stretch ourselves too thin. We don't stress about money and just enjoy life and that's more important to me than having the biggest house possible

maddening · 05/09/2021 15:34

I would buy the house, based on the fact that flats are less in demand due to covid and that where you do work to improve the house you can add value.

episcomama · 05/09/2021 15:20

Another vote for the flat. We just moved to a different city, and made a tidy sum on our sale. One of the lessons we learned from Covid is just how much we value "doing" things. Meals out, weekends away, holidays. So we actually decided to downsize and buy a cheaper house than the one we sold. Mortgage is ridiculously manageable and we are topping up our savings (ready to spend when delta buggers off!)

Agree completely that kids care/value their surroundings much less than the adults. My kids each have their own room, as well as a "den" which is much smaller than our old place. They simply don't care.

gwenneh · 05/09/2021 15:13

We've never bought the most expensive home we could afford. We've bought ones we could afford on a single salary if necessary.

Our home is very small compared to some in our social circle, but if either DH or I couldn't work for any reason we'd be OK. When I unexpectedly wound up pregnant with DD, maternity leave was not an issue and we were fine on the reduced income. When DH was furloughed in 2020, we were still able to pay the mortgage.

I prefer that to the larger house.

VestaTilley · 05/09/2021 15:11

YANBU. Financial security every time.

If your career continues to improve you can trade up to a bigger house further down the line. You’re being very prudent- your DD is lucky to have you.

You sound like an excellent Mum and are doing the right things.

serialname · 05/09/2021 15:10

I'm guessing you are in London as those prices are mad. I would avoid flats - services charges, unexpected bills, neighbour disputes.

Could you get a three bed house that is liveable now and
Plan to update in a few years. I. E. As long as it has a working bathroom and kitchen, out off upgrade till your income improves.

Alternatively move somewhere cheaper

Driftingblue · 05/09/2021 15:05

Stretching your budget to the limit is rarely wise. If the home meets your needs and you will be happy there that is what matters.

We could easily afford a more expensive home, but we just don’t need one. We have a wonderful neighborhood, access to great schools, and plenty of space for our family. We also have savings and can afford some luxuries.

libertybonds · 05/09/2021 15:00

@VeganVeal unfortunately, interest rates don't really have anywhere to go but up at the moment

OP posts:
VeganVeal · 05/09/2021 14:58

I've always bought the most expensive I could afford, saves moving every few years, which in itself is very expensive.

I did me ok, in fact more than ok, interest rates went from 8% to 1.5%. Mortgage free at 50 with a big fuck off house

libertybonds · 05/09/2021 14:58

No, there are no middle options. The very cheapest 3 bedroom house in walking distance i can get my hands on is £535kish, quite small, and needs loads of work. The flat is £470k. There is basically nothing in the middle, I have been looking for over a year.

OP posts:
Givemethatknife · 05/09/2021 14:29

@Randomuser9876

I think the whole "buy the most expensive house" thing is a baby boomer hangover when they were guaranteed pay rises/pension/job for life and stuff that doesn't exist today.

Is there not a happy medium house that doesn't stretch you to the limit but offers more space and development opportunities than a flat?

That would be a better investment... I'm temporarily living in a flat and there's not much space for dc (obviously depending on the flat!).

Yep this.

Find a medium - a bit further away for a terrace/semi house w a garden or a garden flat will be better with your child, but don’t go giving yourself no wriggle room.

Randomuser9876 · 05/09/2021 14:21

I think the whole "buy the most expensive house" thing is a baby boomer hangover when they were guaranteed pay rises/pension/job for life and stuff that doesn't exist today.

Is there not a happy medium house that doesn't stretch you to the limit but offers more space and development opportunities than a flat?

That would be a better investment... I'm temporarily living in a flat and there's not much space for dc (obviously depending on the flat!).

41sunnydays · 05/09/2021 14:13

I think the buy the most expensive house was valid years ago when jobs where secure and people bought young. Now days with house prices so high and job insecurity I would not buy the most expensive

Curtyain · 05/09/2021 13:37

No I won’t buy a flat having bought a flat.
Service charge, ground rent, lack of personal garden, no storage, noise from other flats.

32inchtv · 05/09/2021 13:23

Ours is quite a lot less than our max budget but it gives quite a lot in security knowing that if needed I could cut down work or take a pay cut or some time out if I wanted to without being forced into debt

TiddleTaddleTat · 05/09/2021 13:17

I mean, all the above is irrelevant if you can't afford a house. But if you can, I think I would be very wary of buying a flat.

TiddleTaddleTat · 05/09/2021 13:15

Hmm based on your updates OP I'd be even more wary of buying a flat if you could afford a house. Surely there are options that aren't complete doer uppers ?
Flats can be much harder to sell in future. Relative of mine has been trying to sell hers for 2 years even at a loss. No luck and had to rent it out.
The service charge increases are inevitable. Freeholders can change.
There can be huge bills that seem to come out of nowhere for roof, windows etc.
If you had a house you could decide when to do these repairs, negotiate cost etc.
What if there is a dispute with other shared freeholders re repairs. Could be a legal nightmare.

Penistoe · 05/09/2021 12:09

I think the buy the most expensive house thing is currently outdated. As others have said materials and cost have drastically gone up. However I wouldn’t think a small flat is less likely to have issues. A flat doesn’t know it’s a flat Grin. It’s a very large house with certain rooms allocated. So will have all the issues that come with a house. Potentially at a cost split between multiple people but not always.

stripedbananas · 05/09/2021 12:03

Personally if you can afford the house buy it.

I'd always buy a house over a flat.

If the choice were between 2 houses then yes I'd buy the cheaper one.