Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

In wondering why UK can't adopt the Australian Healthcare system?

353 replies

chopc · 04/09/2021 09:07

I was talking to some friends abroad and in Australia about frustrations with our wonderful
NHS for both patient and doctor. One of them wondered why we can't adopt the Australian Healthcare system. I thought the same and checked with those using it in Australia, and I can't see any downsides to it ........

What is stopping the UK adopting the same system?

OP posts:
Oceanbliss · 04/09/2021 09:58

@A2M4 are you in Melbourne or Sydney? Because not every city in Australia is that good.

echt · 04/09/2021 09:57

Our GPs are gatekeepers to specialists and it can be hard to get referrals

As they are in Australia. And then you pay to have the referral letter sent again. Every. fucking. year. Like you suddenly didn't have cancer in 2002 and the specialist needs reminding. Hmm

Fucking rort.

Oceanbliss · 04/09/2021 09:55

I’m from Australia and believe me there are plenty of problems with our health care for both doctors and patients.

My dd needed urgent diagnostic test (not saying as don’t want to reveal too much on the internet) and our referral was knocked back repeatedly. We were unable to get bulk billed care for our child. We ended up having to go private even though we really can’t afford it. The waiting list for one simple test for diagnosis of a potentially serious health issue (not treatment, not surgery) was anywhere between 1 and 2 years at the public children’s hospital.

Waiting lists for treatment or surgery can be years. Going to the emergency department you could be waiting hours even over 24 hours sitting on a plastic seat waiting to be triaged. And it doesn’t seem to matter that it’s a child. I saw a very sick child vomiting and crying and still not getting treatment or a bed.

It also depends on where you live in Australia. Not every city has as many options as other cities. Then there is regional parts of Australia that have a lack of care. Some towns don’t even have any maternity care or hospitals equipped for giving birth at all.

We pay the Medicare levy in our tax to fund universal health care. But so many people are getting less care depending on where they live. They are paying the same Medicare levy in their tax though.

Funding for health care has been cut time and time again. There are less bulk billing doctors available now. Hospitals are understaffed, not enough beds etc.

Parking at hospitals is insanely expensive.

I’ve personally had excellent care and on the other spectrum very poor level of care.

If you are on the receiving end of medical negligence it is very hard to successfully hold them responsible.

Health insurance is expensive, confusing and doesn’t cover everything.

In saying all this, I was under the impression that the Uk’s NHS was better than Australia until I discovered Mumsnet.

A2M4 · 04/09/2021 09:55

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

FFSFFSFFS · 04/09/2021 09:54

To the posters who thinks finance isn’t factored into nhs decision making that’s ludicrous!!! Of course it is - and medical decisions are made on the basis of cost!!! Australian system
Is not perfect obviously but I think it’s better than the nhs system.

WhoNeedsaManOfTheWorld · 04/09/2021 09:53

From what I've read the German system seems pretty good.
Our GPs are gatekeepers to specialists and it can be hard to get referrals. They are also private companies who get the NHS budget.
Apparently in Germany you can refer yourself for physio or request a specialist, consultant appointment
If anyone here knows the system I would love to know how it is in practice
Our NHS is taken for granted but there is no political appetite for improvement because our government are only interested in privatised services. It is only public opinion that prevents a system like the US and who would want that?

echt · 04/09/2021 09:53

@MatildaOfFlanders

Because the NHS is basically a secular religion and to even suggest that it might not be the best model for delivering healthcare is tantamount to blasphemy.
Try another country's system.

Metaphor is the first retreat those who have no points to argue.

wonkylegs · 04/09/2021 09:49

I have a friend who lives in Australia and has the same long term condition as me and Australian healthcare for it is shit and expensive because it's not fully covered and the out of pocket expenses for him are huge. It means that despite being fairly well off he hasn't always been able to continue treatment and relies on pain relief instead as the costs run into tens of thousands
In contrast I have a prepayment card which means my meds on the NHS cost me £108 max a year. I have never been without treatment in the 20yrs + I have had this disease although the pandemic did make it harder to access.
I think it's another system which may be better for acute illness but chronic illness isn't looked after as well.

MatildaOfFlanders · 04/09/2021 09:49

Because the NHS is basically a secular religion and to even suggest that it might not be the best model for delivering healthcare is tantamount to blasphemy.

Remmy123 · 04/09/2021 09:39

I am truly grateful to the NHS and I have had very good experiences for serious health issues in my family.

For those who are wanting it to be private and paid for service, how about getting private health?

romdowa · 04/09/2021 09:39

I never understand why people complain so much about the NHS. Try coming to Ireland and experience our health system , it's abysmal. The NHS is the one thing I miss about the UK. Took me 4 months to get a surgery on the NHS that I was referred for in Ireland 4 years ago. To this day I haven't even received an appointment to meet with a surgeon 🤣🤣

PicsInRed · 04/09/2021 09:36

In NZ you pay an amount towards GP appointments (however these are still free if you are low income and also for children).

This "copay" system reduced wasted/unneeded appointments and meant less waiting for those in need, and appointments within days (or same day if urgent). Unlike here, I never found myself having to negotiate, beg or push to see a GP when really sick. Hmm

It's one NZ practice I'd strongly encourage the UK to adopt.

londonrach · 04/09/2021 09:36

My uncle lived in Australia and lost their house paying for cancer treatment for my aunt who sadly died. No way want Australia healthcare. I've only heard bad things about it!

saraclara · 04/09/2021 09:36

My friends and family in Australia find their system extremely difficult to navigate, and are generally very unhappy with it.

Skysblue · 04/09/2021 09:31

@WhoNeedsaManOfTheWorld I know what you mean, but also… I had years of serious medical problems and way too many times I was fobbed off by doctors telling me things were probably fine and to relax and perhaps consider counselling. Why? Because the medical investigations I needed were expensive to the NHS. Already there is no separation between medical decisions and financial considerations.

I have an ill dog. The vet recommends state of the art treatments for him which I can choose to buy or not, but at least she tells me that they exist and how to access them. My doctors didn’t tell me about state of the art investigations because it’s NHS policy not to do the ones I needed. Because of the cost difference which was only about £200 and which I’d have been happy to pay myself to stop the pain!!

My own medical problems got worse and worse until I went private where some simple tests (that the NHS wouldn’t do for me because of cost) identified the problem. Ironically the problem was by then so major that I needed 3 expensive surgeries, which the private doctor did, but the NHS had to pay for. So their penny pinching on investigations ultimately cost them money anyway.

I don’t know what the answer is but it is not the NHS.

IMetABoyCrazyForTea · 04/09/2021 09:31

Every healthcare system will have pros and cons, and some people and situations to whom it is less well suited. There is no perfect healthcare system for everybody.

Whenever there is a discussion about different healthcare systems, the negatives of other systems are quickly pointed out, although of course our current system has negatives too. It makes makes discussion about other options politically difficult.

Politically it is easier to tinker around the edges, rather than have difficult discussions about what we want to fund and how that should be paid for.

From speaking to Australian doctor friends, it's nicer to work there, you generally get much quicker access to appointments and treatment, however it does cost the individual more than the NHS and it's also not perfect. Which seems to broadly be what my doctor friends in most other wealthy countries say about their respective systems.

If a Politician proposed a system where we need to pay more, that would generate a lot of negative headlines, even if the upshot was that people would get quicker care.

MissTrip82 · 04/09/2021 09:27

I work in the public health system in Australia. I have experience working in the private system and do not work in it any longer (despite vastly higher wages) as I consider it so unethical.

There are many, many downsides. You need to read more widely.

echt · 04/09/2021 09:25

And you have to pay for ambulances.

Jaysmith71 · 04/09/2021 09:24

Because any system involving any amount of insurance component, even when this is not-for-profit, will carry an additional layer of bureaucracy and be more expensive.

That is not to say the NHS could not be improved.

Purplewithred · 04/09/2021 09:24

What is the system in Australia?

echt · 04/09/2021 09:24

In Australia, you are penalised in terms of tax if you don't take out private healthcare. It kicks in at $90,000 pa for a single person.

The private health "providers" are a minefield to navigate.
They're not cheap, have a list of exclusions (cataracts) as long as my arm and you still have to pay excess.

NantesElephant · 04/09/2021 09:23

* I can't understand why you would want the person who is advising that you require/don't require surgery to benefit financially from that surgery. I prefer financial benefit/medical decision making to be totally separate. *

Absolutely this. When I needed medical care in the US, the local urgent care center ordered tests for me that were not medically necessary. Putting profit before care. I found it really unethical.

Eyesofdisarray · 04/09/2021 09:23

In the NHS
Oops posted too soon

Eyesofdisarray · 04/09/2021 09:22

It might make people appreciate it more if it wasn't 'free'.
It's so unwieldy it's easy to use and abuse.
And so much money is wasted

BroccoliFloret · 04/09/2021 09:20

Because the NHS is a sacred cow which shall not be changed ever. It is not acceptable politically for any party to say they think the NHS is broken and should be changed. All people working in the NHS are practically saints and cannot be criticised.

Swipe left for the next trending thread