Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think women can't have it all?

240 replies

0Cripes · 03/09/2021 23:30

I'm pregnant with DC3 and due soon. My boss recently announced he was leaving at the end of this month on a 9 month secondment. His role is a natural progression for me and he has been teeing me up for it for 7 years. However, someone will backfill his role and gain experience for 9 months that I won't have a chance to get, therefore when the permanent position comes up (my boss has no intention to return) I'll be at a disadvantage.
If I wasn't going on mat leave I would stand a very good chance getting this role. I am annoyed as I feel I'm now at a disadvantage and my career is suffering because I've chosen to have a child. I appreciate that I still have the opportunity to apply but I'm pretty sure I won't get it knowing I'll be absent for 6 months of it!
I know the timings are nobodies fault but AIBU to be annoyed at this and think it's so hard for women to have kids and a successful career?

OP posts:
ActonSquirrel · 04/09/2021 07:54

Also as previous posters said you chose to have 3 DC. 3 year long maternity leaves would set anyone back. No one made you do it.

But you don't need a year off work everytime. You can have it all if you go back to work after 3 months or less.

CounsellorTroi · 04/09/2021 07:54

It was your choice to have a third child. If you’d stopped at 2 you would still have kids and a successful career. I think you’re being a bit entitled tbh.

mynameiscalypso · 04/09/2021 07:53

@Faevern

YANBU

Women can never have it all, it's an urban myth generated to keep us in our box and beat us with, as demonstrated even on mumsnet.

Men do not ever have to make a choice to return to work within weeks of giving birth. And even though both partners want and plan a baby, women do the hard part and make the most sacrifices.

I think the point that a lot of posters were making is that nobody can have it all - every decision you make has consequences and for everyone, those decisions and what they decide to prioritise are going to be different. I think the mantra that anyone can have it all is damaging.
ActonSquirrel · 04/09/2021 07:53

One of my colleagues recently took only 13 weeks off for mat leave.

That used to be the norm.

You don't have to have a year off. 🤷🏼‍♀️

Overthebow · 04/09/2021 07:53

Thing is though that you’re having three children and therefore three maternity leaves. Taking that much time out of your career is going to hold you back a bit compared to your colleagues who don’t choose to do this. It’s not unfair, it’s a choice to have children, a choice to have three and a choice to take a long mat leave.

If you really want this opportunity then take one months mat leave and go for the job.

NoIDontWatchLoveIsland · 04/09/2021 07:52

Its temporary op. Most women are done with the actual baby production part by age 40 for biological reasons. There are then a clear 25 years where you can develop your career.

You can have both a family and a career. What you can't really do is have a young family whom you are focusing on AND be at the the pinnacle of a glittering career, at exactly the same time, whether you are a man or a woman.

Faevern · 04/09/2021 07:48

YANBU

Women can never have it all, it's an urban myth generated to keep us in our box and beat us with, as demonstrated even on mumsnet.

Men do not ever have to make a choice to return to work within weeks of giving birth. And even though both partners want and plan a baby, women do the hard part and make the most sacrifices.

FloconDeNeige · 04/09/2021 07:46

You’ll need to take a shorter maternity leave OP and convince them of this in advance.

I’m in Switzerland and maternity leave is 3 months here, which I am perfectly fine with. If you want to take more time, that’s up to you but it’s a choice with associated consequences.

There are a myriad of different ways in which the world and workplace are unfair for women, but this particular situation is not so clear-cut. A man in the same position as the OP who was planning 9 months of parental leave would also likely be passed over for this role too.

Essentially, the timing here means you can’t expect to simultaneously be on ‘extended’ parental leave and on a temporary work secondment for promotion. A man couldn’t expect to either. You’ll have to compromise somewhere.

YouMeandtheSpew · 04/09/2021 07:44

I know what you mean OP. I’ve experienced something similar. I think the difficulty is that often the best career opportunities present themselves in your 30s or early 40s, which is also the time a lot of women are having children. And taking any length of time, whether that’s 3, 6, 9 or 12 months, out of the workplace during that time is a serious impediment to progression.

I’m very glad I left having children till my mid 30s because I’m earning much better and have more financial stability than I was in my 20s. But the flip side of that decision has been that it’s been much more difficult to pursue opportunities in the past few years and I haven’t progressed in the way I think I probably would have done if I hadn’t had children.

You can still apply despite going on maternity leave. They can’t discriminate against you on the basis that you’re taking leave.

I find the Daily Mail-esque comments about how the OP made a choice to have a child really odd. Of course it was a choice. She acknowledges that in her OP. The question is whether she should have to accept that choice will impede her career progression.

And as for going back after two weeks - yes, she could. Yes, women have no statutory right to paid maternity leave in the US (although it’s determined on an employer by employer basis - I work for a US employer and they offer 6 months fully paid maternity). But maternity leave is there for a reason - would that be the best thing for her and her baby’s short and long term welfare? Probably not. So she has to make a choice between her career, and her and her baby’s welfare.

user1487194234 · 04/09/2021 07:42

A friend of mine went back after 2 weeks Mat leave
She is very ambitious and driven and is right at the top of her profession
Her partner quit work and was the SAHP
There is always an element of personal choice
My DH and I both went down to 3 days when the children were born
We earned much the same and still do
No way I would have tolerated giving up my career
We possibly would have had more money if I had stayed home and my husband had focused on his career 100% but that wasn't for us

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 04/09/2021 07:41

Sorry but this is a ridiculous post- you can’t have a job when you won’t be there for 6 months- duh! Not to mention you are choosing to have 3 kids, you’ve overwhelmed yourself. Biologically shocking that men can’t have children!

mynameiscalypso · 04/09/2021 07:40

@gofg

We are happy in our marriage, money enough for what we want, not rich by any means, but you can't buy happiness with money or a better job.

What a very sensible response. How did we get to the stage where a great job is the measure of happiness? How did we get to the stage where everyone has to "have it all"?

This is so true. For my, having it all means having the freedom to choose (in the knowledge that different choices will have different sacrifices)
gofg · 04/09/2021 07:35

We are happy in our marriage, money enough for what we want, not rich by any means, but you can't buy happiness with money or a better job.

What a very sensible response. How did we get to the stage where a great job is the measure of happiness? How did we get to the stage where everyone has to "have it all"?

Hekatestorch · 04/09/2021 07:35

Depends on what 'have it all' means to you.

Can you have everything you want, exactly when you want it? No, because one can.

Can you have a full on career, spend as much time with your kids as a sahp, see your friends 2-3 nights a week, never miss a work night out, spend loads of time with your partner, hit the gym most day etc. No. Because, again, no one can.

People can feel they have it all, but other people will think they don't. I don't have the glittering social life with lots of nights out every month. But I do have a family and a good job. I have a fairly quite life and think I have all I want.

When I became a single parent and the kids were young, I couldnt keep my foot on the pedal with my career I needed to focus on my home life. Now they are older I can focus on my career again.

But even then when the kids were young I felt like I had it all. Because it was what I wanted and needed at the time.

Its absolutely possible to have a great career and move up and have kids. But you can't also get those months of experience, of you aren't in work. Any one taking a large amount of time off work, will miss out on something. You can have the career and kids. But you can't be there if you aren't there.

The more kids you have, the harder it tends to be and you do need support form either you partner or paid support.

Op if you want this experience, there's a choice you have to make. Either pass it up OR take a very short mat leave. It may be frustrating for you, but it is your choice. And there's no shame in deciding one or the other.

Bunnycat101 · 04/09/2021 07:33

I don’t disagree that you can’t have it all but in this specific situation it is just a timing thing. You’re not going to be there. If a man had taken a career beak to go travelling, he wouldn’t be around to take up the opportunity either.

WIS76 · 04/09/2021 07:33

@Thethingswedoforlove

Do you feel the same about men? I get it. But men are increasingly facing the same issues/ conflicts. And that has to be a good thing. Perhaps it is more than individuals can’t have it all? We have to make choices and do our best?
I work in a senior role and this is just not true, men don't take 12 months maternity leave then have 4-5 years of high absence due to childcare issues. With the pandemic many men have struggled to work out of the family home, but that's a different matter.
Mum21031608 · 04/09/2021 07:30

The concept of ‘having it all’ varies so much from person to person, as explained well by a previous poster.

Does “having it all” always have to mean it involves a sky rocketing career?

Sadly OP you are in a shitty position. It’s easy for people to say go back to work after two weeks but generally, mothers want stay with their newborns, which is a good thing.

My career has been on hold for the last 8 years whilst I’ve had my two children and made them my priority over work. I missed out on job opportunities and promotions as a result but that was the choice I made. My husband obviously didn’t have to make the same sacrifices and so his career has soared.

Of course women are at a disadvantage. They have to choose between going back to work really soon after childbirth and or being with their newborn which many woman biologically crave.

After 8 years of my career being on pause I have recently started my dream job, it’s everything I’ve ever wanted and something I’ve worked so hard for over the last 5 years.

Job wise I feel like I “have it all” but it’s come at the sacrifice of spending time with my children which I’m really struggling with.

Xyzzzzz · 04/09/2021 07:27

I’m in a similar position op but this time I’ve been asked to apply for a role but I’ve been encouraged that Mat leave shouldn’t stop me and what ifs have been discussed etc. Approach your employer and see what they say.

Aroundtheworldin80moves · 04/09/2021 07:27

I've known a few women 'Have it all'. They had Nannies. Full time, live in. With a Night nanny for the first few months.

Most of us can't afford that though...

MiddleParking · 04/09/2021 07:26

It sounds like you’re assuming you’re out of the running but haven’t explored it with the relevant people? You have to be noisy about wanting promotions!

MargosKaftan · 04/09/2021 07:25

But many woman do return to work after 6 weeks or so. Taking a year off is a very privileged position internationally/historically- and now we can have the other parent take part of that, not just hire a nanny.

Op - if this is something you want, work out if you can make it happen. Would your dp be happy to take a few months off? Could you do a mixtures of wfh and office to mean you are around baby even if someone else is doing the bulk of the care?

Noone can have it all, but men don't get to have it all either, having to return to work after a short break after having dc.

MilkywayMonarch22 · 04/09/2021 07:25

I had something similar while I was on Mat leave with DD. Missed a big opportunity that I would have got if I wasn't on Mat leave.

mynameiscalypso · 04/09/2021 07:24

@Mybobowler

Honestly finding these comments suggesting you return after a matter of weeks completely bizarre. Are they being facetious? Have any of these posters had children?? The early prenatal period is a point at which mothers and fathers are definitely not equal.

Three weeks PP, I was still bleeding heavily and struggling to establish breastfeeding. My daughter was waking up every 90 minutes and, because of the breastfeeding, I was the one attending to her. Six weeks PP, I developed PND which lasted for the next several months.

Yes, on paper, the OP has a choice about the length of her maternity leave, but in reality, taking an extended period of time off work following the birth of a child is something I would argue that most women need to do. I can't think of a single mother I know who would willingly return to work when her child is a few weeks old.

OP I'm in a very similar position and it feels really frustrating. I will be taking a shorter maternity leave than I did first time (5-6 months) but that's partly due to finances. I've had really open and useful discussions with my seniors about career progression and I'll be returning with a very solid plan to prepare for a promotion in the year after I'm back. It's a bit of a cold comfort after watching my perfect opportunity slip past while I'm pregnant and awaiting maternity leave, but it does at least give me a sense of control over my career! Could you do similar?

Plenty of people in other countries go back after a few weeks - 6 weeks is considered a long maternity leave in the US. In the UK, we're lucky enough that we have the ability to have a longer leave and we're used to people have 6/9 months plus but it's not necessarily the norm.
PlanetTeaTime · 04/09/2021 07:21

The people say men face the same thing are simply put, full of bs

Do they hell face the same thing

Rugsofhonour · 04/09/2021 07:20

This reply has been deleted

Withdrawn at the user's request

Swipe left for the next trending thread