Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think women can't have it all?

240 replies

0Cripes · 03/09/2021 23:30

I'm pregnant with DC3 and due soon. My boss recently announced he was leaving at the end of this month on a 9 month secondment. His role is a natural progression for me and he has been teeing me up for it for 7 years. However, someone will backfill his role and gain experience for 9 months that I won't have a chance to get, therefore when the permanent position comes up (my boss has no intention to return) I'll be at a disadvantage.
If I wasn't going on mat leave I would stand a very good chance getting this role. I am annoyed as I feel I'm now at a disadvantage and my career is suffering because I've chosen to have a child. I appreciate that I still have the opportunity to apply but I'm pretty sure I won't get it knowing I'll be absent for 6 months of it!
I know the timings are nobodies fault but AIBU to be annoyed at this and think it's so hard for women to have kids and a successful career?

OP posts:
Balonzette · 04/09/2021 09:42

No, I don't agree.

It's true in your specific situation, of course. Horrendous timing that an excellent career move would become available just as you're going on maternity leave.

But it's very much about the maternity leave, and noy about you being a woman or mother (in my opinion).

If this was two or, even better, four years down the line and DC was in school or had settled childcare, this wouldn't be the case.

I have young children and don't feel held back in my career, but I very much did when pregnant. When pregnant/on maternity leave, your career is on hold. As soon as the career restarts, so do the opportunities.

(I'm not saying there aren't other factors that can hold a woman back in her career which may be linked to having a child. But I don't think being a woman and mother means your opportunities and career progress need to stop.

anon12345678901 · 04/09/2021 09:39

@PurpleOkapi

I don't think anyone of either sex can take repeated 6-month leaves without it affecting their career progression. If I'm wrong, please tell me where you work so I can apply! Grin
Precisely. If you take time out of work repeatedly, it would be silly to expect it not to affect progression.
MindyStClaire · 04/09/2021 09:39

Women going back to work at 6 weeks postpartum so that their careers aren't disadvantaged by their biology is a problem, not a solution.

Despairing at this thread.

OP, that's thoroughly rotten timing. I'd make it crystal clear that you want the role, and shout from the rooftops that they should contact you if the position comes up while you're off even though you're on maternity.

anon12345678901 · 04/09/2021 09:36

You're choosing to have children though and as such choosing to take 9 months away from work. I'd expect anyone who was taking 9 months away to be at a disadvantage, whatever the reason.
It's not just a female issue, you could let your partner take paternity leave instead of you being off. Any person taking 9 months off could experience the same.

Heliachi · 04/09/2021 09:35

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

A1b2c3d4e5f6g7 · 04/09/2021 09:29

@FloconDeNeige

Op you are not wrong in the slightest.

This is bullshit.

I say that as someone who had severe hyperemesis to term and lost my job over it.

Choosing to have a third child and choosing to take long parental/maternity leaves can have consequences for careers. Yes of course, (most) women need to recuperate in the weeks after giving birth, but they don’t need 9-12 months to do that. It’s a choice.

As I said before, the workplace is unfair for women in loads of ways, but in this particular situation, a man planning extended parental leave would also likely be passed over. He’d need to make a choice as to what to focus on at that point in time; career or family.

I agree with this. My partners and my career are equally as important, so we are taking shared parental leave. In blocks, so we aren't out of the office for huge amounts of time in one go. If I can breast feed (hopefully I can), work gives me a pumping room, and I can come in a bit later and leave a bit earlier and catch up on anything later on on the evening.

I think its how you choose to set it up within your family which affects how much it'll impact which partners career. Ive been really glad to see a lot more men in our circles and amongst our colleagues take half the time off

PurpleOkapi · 04/09/2021 09:26

I don't think anyone of either sex can take repeated 6-month leaves without it affecting their career progression. If I'm wrong, please tell me where you work so I can apply! Grin

Metallicalover · 04/09/2021 09:21

Depends on your own perspective of having it all!
Everyone's lives a different, careers, partners etc.
If your definition of having it all is both working full time in high flying careers with children. I don't believe it's possible as something has got to give! Ie work will not get your 100% or your children due to childcare, Stress and exhaustion.
I work as a nurse and I see far too often that life is short and it's for enjoying as much as possible.
My definition of having it all is having a good work life balance, both me and my husband could have more money and better paid jobs but we wouldn't have the flexibility what we have now with hours and child care. I work part time (24hours over 2 days) with the option of working extra hours as and when. OH works flexi time so when I'm at work he works shorter hours and when I'm off work he works longer hours.

Heliachi · 04/09/2021 09:16

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

CattyMcNips · 04/09/2021 09:15

I think in a partnership you have to decide. My husband and I split our relationship so he works out of the home and I work in it.

Friends split it 50/50.

I don't know anyone where the husband stays at home but it does happen.

You need to choose the % as a couple and then go from there. Society doesn't choose it, you and your partner do.

Obviously for single parents it will be different and this is just broad strokes for people in partnerships.

BigFatLiar · 04/09/2021 09:15

The concept of 'have it all' is nonsense and simply causes a lot of issues and dissatisfaction.

Someone has already said what is 'it'. You can't be a SAHP and work on an oil rig. Bit extreme but just saying you make your choices in life and sometimes making one choice restricts or excludes another. If you were self employed pregnancy is still a big issue or would you expect your clients to put their project on hold for 6-9 months while you have a baby. You mentioned that you felt you had a good chance of getting your managers job if you weren't pregnant, but there's no guarantee. They could simply advertise and bring someone in from outside or promote one of your colleagues who probably thinks they're just as capable.

You can't really have it all as you must prioritise somethings in your life. You want children focus on being a parent then on your job. You want to be a career woman focus on your career and put children on hold until you can afford to have an aupair/nanny to raise them for you.

Faevern · 04/09/2021 09:13

[quote Jangle33]@Faevern my DH does just as much child rearing and also works part time. We split evenly. So you are perpetuating the men are useless stereotype which is unfair and unhelpful.[/quote]
Don’t be daft where did I say men are useless, where did I even imply that 🤷🏻‍♀️

Your DH may share everything evenly but he didn’t carry the baby or give birth, he didn’t have to make a choice to return to work while his body was recovering from childbirth. That’s just a fact.

Heliachi · 04/09/2021 09:12

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Flyingantday · 04/09/2021 09:02

Slight tangent to the OP but it has been mentioned in PP - there are more subtle and practical motherhood penalties than not being able to take a job role because of planned mat leave, people saying only take 2/3 weeks, that almost assumes a woman can work up to her due date and not go (up to 2 weeks) overdue.

I had a fairly physical job and couldn’t go beyond 37 weeks, i may have been forced to go sooner due to SPD but managed to limp to the end. You could easily use 5-6w plus mat leave before baby even arrives. Add on 6 after for a caesarean. That’s not to mention time off for antenatal visits before the birth and potentially adaptations to pump milk afterwards if you come back early. I have known women try to hide/play down these things because as soon as your pregnancy becomes noticeable, there is a shift in perception so however focussed you are and however soon you plan to be back at your desk, other people write you of as an inconvenience. They don’t offer you a promotion after one child because they anticipate the second. Even childless women are subconsciously discriminated against for the perception that they are the right age and stage to have a baby soon, whatever their plans.

I have also found a motherhood penalty in terms of poorer pension contributions, interest going up on my student loan while I’ve been off (DH meanwhile has paid his off) no break or reduction for professional fees or costly cpd requirements (I noticed this was reduced for covid but not for mothers).

You definitely can’t have it all, and I feel that although having a child is a joint venture - women bear most of the physical, financial and career burden. I think if you are married and see everything as joint income (pension etc) and you want to be home with your kids, then within the existing framework you can be content with your lot.

However for those women who really want or need to advance their career and earnings, to feel penalised by parenthood and particularly watching potentially less qualified, less motivated coworkers leapfrogging you because they have a wife at home doing all the child rearing, must be jarring.

Hekatestorch · 04/09/2021 09:00

And interestingly not one mention by PP’s that it is, on balance, much better for the baby to be at home with it’s mother for at least a year, if not longer. There needs to be so many changes for women to be able to be a parent and not disadvantaged in their careers in the UK.

Its complete impossible to think that a child needs to be with it mother for the first full year but also expect a womans career not to be impacted. There's never going to be a time that can happen.

A work place moves on a lot in a year. You take 12 months off and then the next 1-2 months catching up. Then do it again a few years later and then again.

Opportunities can and should be offered to people on mat leave. But, like in ops case, if a role needs covering and she isn't at work at that time, it can't be offered to her. And therefore she is at a disadvantage.

And that is the choice. Having a career isn't the be all and end all. But if the Op wants to be available for every opportunity that comes up she can't take a long mat leave.

No one can take 3 years out of the work place and it not impact their career at all.

BazWazzycantdance · 04/09/2021 08:59

You can just take two weeks mat leave and return? And have husband have parental leave?
You can have ‘it’ all- but it is difficult and you’ll have to compromise on everything. As previous poster mentioned- it depends on what your definition of ‘it’ is. I’ve got a successful career, a happy home with DD and hubby. But I’ve had to make choices. Unfortunately that’s life.
Having baby in nursery/childminder at a young age is difficult but doesn’t do them long term harm. I was raised in A different country with a nanny and yet I’m still incredibly close to my parents. It’s just emotionally very hard and youve got to follow head and logic rather than the heart and emotion.short term vs long term goals? whatever you chose, make sure you are absolutely happy with the choice and don’t second guess yourself. X

LibrariesGiveUsPower45321 · 04/09/2021 08:57

Well men can’t have it all in that sense either - they can’t take 9 months off paternity leave and get the same career progression.

You can return at 2/4 weeks post partum and either get a nanny or your partner takes parental leave. You can bottle feed or express. I’ve got a couple friends who did this, and it’s the norm in many countries.

You have the choice of which is more important- immediate temporary career progression which will stand you in good stead for future roles, but guarantee nothing, or 6 months at home with the new baby.

Tough choice, but I made it, opted to stay at home for a year, it was tough but I’ve got my career back on track now and I’m thriving, amd I don’t regret for one second the time I was off with my babies.

CounsellorTroi · 04/09/2021 08:57

Yes, it’s a choice to have children but most men do not have to choose between having a family or a career and that is the issue here.

Well no, it’s not really the issue. The OP had a family already but feels it is unfair that she missed out on a promotion opportunity because she chose to have a third child.

You can have children and a successful career, you just can’t have as many children as you want and a successful career.

DrBlackbird · 04/09/2021 08:52

If anyone wants to suggest that the current system of presentism and long work hours also harms men and negatively impacts on their family ties and mental health, I’d completely agree, but that’s a different thread topic.

namechange7865 · 04/09/2021 08:49

One of the ways I've tried to "balance it all" (my definition of all being having kids, having a successful career, happily married, being financially comfortable and generally happy with all of that) was to stop at 2 kids. Having 3 kids is always going to sway your balance more towards your family, if you'd stopped at 2 you'd be available for this opportunity, we all know the impact maternity leave can have on careers so going out for an additional year is bound to have an impact and challenge the balance. That's not to say it can't be done but of course it'll be harder and of course around pregnancy/maternity when you are particularly bound.

That said, I'm sure there will be other opportunities, I've personally always changed employers to take up opportunities because it would take too long to get promoted if I stayed where I was. It will be a challenge with 3 kids but just because this opportunity might not be available doesn't want there won't be another.

DrBlackbird · 04/09/2021 08:47

Well I’m another Shock at many of these ‘it’s your choice buttercup so suck it up’ replies.

As if any man has to choose between his 3rd child or his career?! No acknowledgement by many PP’s of high, and limited, child care costs including the high costs of a nanny or the absolutely existing sexism that is structurally baked in to practically every workplace.

Jesus what happened to the sisterhood? Yes of course OP YANBU. Our market economy relies on two income earners and study after study after study demonstrates that it’s women who bear the brunt of this. Was no one paying attention to what happened in the bloody wfh pandemic?

And interestingly not one mention by PP’s that it is, on balance, much better for the baby to be at home with it’s mother for at least a year, if not longer. There needs to be so many changes for women to be able to be a parent and not disadvantaged in their careers in the UK.

Yes, it’s a choice to have children but most men do not have to choose between having a family or a career and that is the issue here.

IceCreamAndCandyfloss · 04/09/2021 08:46

This isn’t a woman issue as such, it’s just bad timing for you but you chose to have a third child and take a long maternity leave. If it’s a job you want then let your DH take the leave and you go back to work.

Ginger1982 · 04/09/2021 08:46

You've chosen to have a third baby though? You must have realised that would have some impact on your career? I don't think women can have it all.

Cyw2018 · 04/09/2021 08:43

@HTH1

You pays your money, you takes your choice.

I stuck at 2DC (pre-teen now) and took a much shorter maternity leave so could really go for it in my career. But I haven’t as the job is pretty well paid and I much prefer being PT to working round the clock (albeit for a significantly higher salary) and missing out on being the one to do every school pick up etc. This means my DC and I are extremely close and we still get to go on great holidays etc but our forever home is (at least for the time being) out of reach.

Apart from the immediate aftermath of childbirth, the only real difference for men is that they just don’t have the same emotions/expectations re spending time with their children over lots of time at work. I think most men would bung the kids into full time plus childcare without a second thought if it were up to them. Unfortunate timing but you now need to decide how much this promotion is worth to you vs a long maternity leave.

I think that's actually really unfair on a lot of men and perpetuates stereotypes, therefore doing nothing to help the problem for anybody.

My DH has WFH since DD was one (prior to covid and lockdown). He makes her lunch everyday when she isn't in preschool and bikes her to school whenever the weather is okay and he can fit it around his schedule. I think for a lot of men they and society perceive that there isn't a choice and just follow the status quo.

It all needs to change for everyone's sake.

TheWeatherWitch · 04/09/2021 08:42

Pay for a nanny or an au-pair and return to work the week after giving birth.

You chose to be pregnant, you chose to take maternity leave. The world doesn’t stop because you’re busy. You pay your money and you make your choices. You decide if maternity leave or promotion is the more important to you.

But don’t expect your job to wait around for you. Then again, don’t cry when you blink and you have three adult children and you can’t remember attending a sports day or a Christmas Carol concert. Yes, you can’t have it all, but neither can anybody else, men included.

Swipe left for the next trending thread