Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think women can't have it all?

240 replies

0Cripes · 03/09/2021 23:30

I'm pregnant with DC3 and due soon. My boss recently announced he was leaving at the end of this month on a 9 month secondment. His role is a natural progression for me and he has been teeing me up for it for 7 years. However, someone will backfill his role and gain experience for 9 months that I won't have a chance to get, therefore when the permanent position comes up (my boss has no intention to return) I'll be at a disadvantage.
If I wasn't going on mat leave I would stand a very good chance getting this role. I am annoyed as I feel I'm now at a disadvantage and my career is suffering because I've chosen to have a child. I appreciate that I still have the opportunity to apply but I'm pretty sure I won't get it knowing I'll be absent for 6 months of it!
I know the timings are nobodies fault but AIBU to be annoyed at this and think it's so hard for women to have kids and a successful career?

OP posts:
PegasusReturns · 04/09/2021 12:51

I don’t know ANY mums who are happy about career and pay progression after becoming a mum

I’m one and know plenty others. It probably depends on sector but I know the fact that I have DC makes no difference to my salary and progression.

Leibham · 04/09/2021 12:44

YANBU

NuffSaidSam · 04/09/2021 12:43

'I cannot think of anything more unappealing than feeling I had to leave a distressed baby just to have a fair crack in the work place.
I'm sure they would have figured it out before they starved, but they didn't want it and they didn't get it. Regardless of how many times we tried in different circumstances.
Even if they do accept a bottle, exclusively expressing can effect milk supply and can be time consuming/difficult to do in the work environment. It's one of the ways a woman is disadvantaged in the workplace as it falls to women'

Sure, all true.

My point was simply that all babies (apart from babies who need to be fed medically) can and will bottle feed.

There are a thousand choices around baby feeding, often very emotional ones and everyone must do what is right for them and their babies. But it helps, when making decisions, to be accurate about the options and babies can and will bottle feed.

lalafafa · 04/09/2021 12:43

The only women I know with successful careers and kids have had nannies from 3 months. Plus partners who earn ££££ too.

PickUpAPepper · 04/09/2021 12:41

The more competitive “the workplace” is allowed to become and the more separated it is from other survival needs and work, the more men will push women aside and demand we become their slaves

Dozer · 04/09/2021 12:39

I don’t know ANY mums who are happy about career and pay progression after becoming a mum.

Dozer · 04/09/2021 12:39

Fathers don’t face these penalties. V v few take long paternity and/or work part time.

The more DC, the harder it is. OP, in your shoes I’d apply for the temporary promotion and shorten your mat leave.

AlexaShutUp · 04/09/2021 12:36

YABU. Women can certainly combine motherhood and a successful career. It's all about the choices that you make.

I have a fantastic relationship with my dd and a great career. It has been hard at times and I have had to work hard to ensure that I have been able to spend time with her as well as work hard, but I know plenty of women who have managed to get this balance right. And as someone who had a desperately unhappy SAHM, it was always extremely important to me to be able to model a different way for my daughter so that she knows that it's perfectly possible to have both.

Siameasy · 04/09/2021 12:32

Yabu it’s biology and a choice to have a third child

Dogsandbabies · 04/09/2021 12:30

This exact thing happened to me. It is very disheartening. Especially as in the end my boss chose not to return and the full time role went to the man that backfilled the role.

My interview feedback was that he had more experience doing that specific role. Very disheartening.

ElliottSmithsfingers · 04/09/2021 12:28

Unless you were forced to have a child (a 3rd one) and are being forced to take full mat leave you are talking bollocks OP. There are other barriers for women but this is one of your making.

BeenAroundTheWorldAndIII · 04/09/2021 12:27

@NuffSaidSam

'Although just to add. Two babies and neither would accept a bottle, so it's not always as easy as just let dad do it.'

All babies will take a bottle if they have to. If the mum died/couldn't breastfeed the baby wouldn't starve to death and we don't have wet nurses anymore....they take a bottle. It's their instinct to survive!

I cannot think of anything more unappealing than feeling I had to leave a distressed baby just to have a fair crack in the work place. I'm sure they would have figured it out before they starved, but they didn't want it and they didn't get it. Regardless of how many times we tried in different circumstances. Even if they do accept a bottle, exclusively expressing can effect milk supply and can be time consuming/difficult to do in the work environment. It's one of the ways a woman is disadvantaged in the workplace as it falls to women
dementedma · 04/09/2021 12:27

I was back at work after a few weeks with each of mine. Had no choice. Its crap, but doable

PickUpAPepper · 04/09/2021 12:25

Fgs it didn’t take long for the ‘what about the poor menz’ gang to get hold of this thread did it? Was it started from that direction?? I’m very suspicious of these kinds of threads on this website now, in this time when women’s rights are going backwards.

No, women can’t “have it all” as op puts it in a system which is designed to have some groups slaving our guts out 24/7 for specified higher status groups. Yes women - and men for that matter - can combine having children and working, as they have done since evolution began, in systems that allow for that to happen. It’s relatively easier in flatter societies where work pays for the cost of living for everyone anyway.

Some things to think about - when did we start having a conflict between economic work for survival and raising children for survival? Why is it assumed that the same specialised economic ideas relevant to other survival tasks - growing food, building work, manufacturing - cannot and should not be applied to the survival work of having children? It has worked for thousands of years. Most of all, why have women in the past fought for the right to join men in working out of the home - for money, for independence, for status, for the right to join in public societal decisions that set our economic choices? In Britain these things are closely linked to going out to work, which is a strange equation. There is no way women should be en masse giving up all that!

There is interesting news about China wanting to raise the birth rate, but facing resistance from women who see that men just want them to become low status dependents to do that, and thankfully, have the sense to resist. theconversation.com/chinas-three-child-policy-is-unlikely-to-be-welcomed-by-working-women-162047
Different societies face exactly the same questions, over time and space, and make different choices. We all know about Afghanistan, the Taliban, and Islam’s solution of enslaving women to bear children. A better way for women is seen in Scandinavia. Currently Finland allows either parents to take unpaid leave from work until the child is 3, and it is not common in Scandinavian cultures for the burden of child raising to fall so heavily on the mother alone. Britain is, despite some of the anecdotes from a website centred on the well-off London crowd, very misogynistic on the whole. We have to be very aware and careful now about the assumptions we are making and what rights we are casually giving up for our daughters and granddaughters yet unborn.

Firstwelive · 04/09/2021 12:22

If you choose to work part time and children over work (not saying anything wrong, a perfectly valid and sensible choice) you need to cede some expectations at work, especially in the corporate world, and thus "having it all"

I've seen women back at work a month after birth. Not many choose to do so (again nothing wrong in that). It doesn't automatically guarantee they will make great strides in career but statistically if more women do so more will rise to senior leadership. It takes full time, multi decade effort to get to most senior positions.

Timing might be off but you can still choose to go for it.

I'm not UK born and find it is a cultural thing as there is this 'attachment' parenting concept that prizes and correlates happy children/families to the quantity of time hovering over them.

MindyStClaire · 04/09/2021 12:17

If the pp wants this opportunity, what else would you suggest.

As I said, I think she should make it abundantly clear that she wants the position regardless of her maternity leave. They can fill it temporarily just as they would have had to if she'd gotten pregnant six months after taking up the position.

Until we share parental leave and childcare
responsibilities equally then we will always be in this situation

I do agree with this, but men just can't take on half the load of pregnancy and breastfeeding. And we shouldn't be disadvantaged because of that. Even if men and women took six months each after a baby was born, women would get the physical recovery, establish breastfeeding, deal with colic, reflux and all the rest and by far the worst of the sleepless nights. Then we'd hand a happier baby in a nice routine over to our partners ready for six months of weaning and walks in the pram. The burden of those initial days will fall on women and it's disingenuous to pretend otherwise.

Later on, sure care and household tasks can be split 50/50 but it's not weakness or lack of effort that means the early days overwhelming fall on women.

MrsSiba · 04/09/2021 11:26

I don't believe women can have it all.

You just end up with all the responsibility on your shoulders and life becomes endless organising, nagging, mentally keeping track of everything.

If you have a demanding job, that on top of the household/childcare is too much.

Yes it would be great if men did their fair share but they never do. Once you stop work for mat leave things are never the same again.

Not bitter honest.

NuffSaidSam · 04/09/2021 11:24

'Although just to add. Two babies and neither would accept a bottle, so it's not always as easy as just let dad do it.'

All babies will take a bottle if they have to. If the mum died/couldn't breastfeed the baby wouldn't starve to death and we don't have wet nurses anymore....they take a bottle. It's their instinct to survive!

luckylavender · 04/09/2021 11:23

Well it depends. Not all women can have children. Not all women chose to have 3. You don't need to be on mat leave for 9 months. Men lose out in other ways, pressure to provide, losing out on time with the children / not socialising at work / networking. Conditions are much better now that they've ever been.

BeenAroundTheWorldAndIII · 04/09/2021 11:18

Although just to add. Two babies and neither would accept a bottle, so it's not always as easy as just let dad do it.

ithinkilikeit · 04/09/2021 11:18

*moan

ithinkilikeit · 04/09/2021 11:18

@Shhhhhhhshh agreed. The chose for shared parental leave is taken by few and then they main that their career was impacted. It’s confusing.

BeenAroundTheWorldAndIII · 04/09/2021 11:09

I don't understand all these comments saying men can't have it all either!? Men definitely have the advantage in the workplace because of circumstances just as you've described! Yes, I do think men miss out on the baby stage due to being at work, but given my husband inability to birth or breastfeed a baby it falls to me, naturally.
I'd be feeling very frustrated by the situation too OP. Unfortunately it is just one of those things for women. Your only option would be to put the baby in childcare from the off or to have DH take the 6 months.
I did successfully apply for a promotion when my daughter was 8 weeks old and didn't actually go back and start the role until she was 12 months. But that wasn't a management position or cover. I was very surprised I got it given the circumstances but as I was well know to the team I was more than likely the most suitable candidate.

Shhhhhhhshh · 04/09/2021 09:42

Taking a year mat leave and part time work once you’ve had children are the norm in my social circle.

These same women then moan that they can’t progress their careers in the way their DH can.

Until we share parental leave and childcare
responsibilities equally then we will always be in this situation. This would be a huge cultural shift and honestly I think most women wouldn’t want to sacrifice their mat leave and/or work full time once children arrive. Similarly men don’t want shared parental leave or to work part time.

So women are going to be in this situation forever. Any break from work is going to affect your chances, regardless of what it’s for, especially if you are in a fast moving job.

Hekatestorch · 04/09/2021 09:42

@MindyStClaire

Women going back to work at 6 weeks postpartum so that their careers aren't disadvantaged by their biology is a problem, not a solution.

Despairing at this thread.

OP, that's thoroughly rotten timing. I'd make it crystal clear that you want the role, and shout from the rooftops that they should contact you if the position comes up while you're off even though you're on maternity.

If the pp wants this opportunity, what else would you suggest.

They need cover for the time she is off. The only solution is to not be off.

Of course she should, be invited to apply if that process happens while she is off.

But in this case OP can not take a lengthy mat leave AND have this opportunity. Just like I can't be a sahp and travel 2 days a week for work.

Swipe left for the next trending thread