Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think women can't have it all?

240 replies

0Cripes · 03/09/2021 23:30

I'm pregnant with DC3 and due soon. My boss recently announced he was leaving at the end of this month on a 9 month secondment. His role is a natural progression for me and he has been teeing me up for it for 7 years. However, someone will backfill his role and gain experience for 9 months that I won't have a chance to get, therefore when the permanent position comes up (my boss has no intention to return) I'll be at a disadvantage.
If I wasn't going on mat leave I would stand a very good chance getting this role. I am annoyed as I feel I'm now at a disadvantage and my career is suffering because I've chosen to have a child. I appreciate that I still have the opportunity to apply but I'm pretty sure I won't get it knowing I'll be absent for 6 months of it!
I know the timings are nobodies fault but AIBU to be annoyed at this and think it's so hard for women to have kids and a successful career?

OP posts:
Gennz18 · 05/09/2021 00:01

I thought I was nailing the work life balance when I just had one child. We have a 3.5 year gap and I thought that after we had #2 after the initial sleeplessness period of about a year (see I was being realistic) we would fall back into the same pattern hollow laughter
We are f*cked 😂
I take my hat off to those of you managing 3+ kids and jobs as well

Recessed · 04/09/2021 23:57

YANBU, it's really not the same for men I'm surprised so many are suggesting it is. I've had to turn down so many amazing opportunities that would be impossible with young DC (fellowships abroad for example).

However I think three children is really pushing it if you want to excel in your career. I would have stopped after one or two max if you wanted to get the balance right for "having it all". Some people with larger families will manage it of course but IME that's very rare as three tends to tip the scales too far in the direction of "kidzone".

Gennz18 · 04/09/2021 23:54

We have a nanny do school runs 3x a week @StrangeToSee, I do one day & DH does the other. I do morning school run. Nanny does extra hours in school hols and/or we WFH to cover gaps.
I am contactable 24/7 and generally do a few hours over the weekend (this weekend I worked on and off all day Saturday including 2 hours of meetings - that’s quite unusual though) so I’m not fazed if I’m not super productive on a Monday afternoon!

Gennz18 · 04/09/2021 23:48

DH and I have equivalent full-time senior jobs (same job title, different company, both lawyers).

I have only recently stepped up to this level - 2DC, youngest is 3.

Here is how we manage:

  • pay a shit ton for childcare (part time daycare, part time nanny)
  • in the 7 years between DC1 and getting this job my career slowed down, I worked various iterations of part time though I tried to keep progressing/keep my hand in
  • outsource everything: cleaning, dog walking, meal boxes
  • I work flexibly - leave work early one day a week so I can pick up DS from school, wfh 1 day a week. Have also forced DH to be more flexible - his ideal would be 45 hours a week min in the office.
  • work, daycare and school are all a 5 min drive from home and I have a carpark
  • i do my best to ensure domestic chores are split 50/50 but in reality I do all the wifework

I realise that most of my “hacks” are privileges - fixing problems with money.
I also only have 2DC and think having a third child makes career harder for women. Not impossible of course, I’ve seen lots of amazing working women with more than 2 kids, I’m just not that capable 😂

LargeBouquet · 04/09/2021 19:19

@StrangeToSee

This is our experience, too. Neither of us ever considered downgrading our work, both of us do childcare and housework, and pick up one another's slack on the rare occasions there's a real issue. Likewise two careers involving multiple postgraduate degrees, and we deliberately didn't have a child until we were at a stage of seniority at which we were both able to be flexible and dictate our own schedules to a large extent

Out of interest, how do you manage day to day? Do you have a nanny to do school runs and look after DC in the holidays?

My issue was partly I’d changed career a few years prior to having DC so was still finding my feet. Whereas DH’s career was well established by then and enough to support all of us comfortably, provided he didn’t have too many distractions. He’s in a senior position but it comes with a lot of responsibility and overtime, so it’s hard to predict when he’ll be able to help and when he’ll be abroad or busy.

I was sad to leave my FT job at first but I also didn’t want the DC feeling I was prioritising my job over them (nursery was ok but once in school they both disliked wraparound care and holiday clubs).

No, no nanny. He goes to afterschool club, and one of us always manages to drop him in the morning we've chosen to live in a city centre very close to his school and both our workplaces for this reason. Holidays, we take annual leave and combine it with holiday camps/clubs etc. I'm an academic, so I can work from home fairly flexibly outside of contact hours and meetings, and we just calendarise very carefully if DH or I are travelling, so that we don't overlap absences. DH is CEO of a big organisation, but makes up for travel and the need to take calls at midnight with a pretty flexible day to day pattern not presenteeist.
StrangeToSee · 04/09/2021 19:03

This is our experience, too. Neither of us ever considered downgrading our work, both of us do childcare and housework, and pick up one another's slack on the rare occasions there's a real issue. Likewise two careers involving multiple postgraduate degrees, and we deliberately didn't have a child until we were at a stage of seniority at which we were both able to be flexible and dictate our own schedules to a large extent

Out of interest, how do you manage day to day? Do you have a nanny to do school runs and look after DC in the holidays?

My issue was partly I’d changed career a few years prior to having DC so was still finding my feet. Whereas DH’s career was well established by then and enough to support all of us comfortably, provided he didn’t have too many distractions. He’s in a senior position but it comes with a lot of responsibility and overtime, so it’s hard to predict when he’ll be able to help and when he’ll be abroad or busy.

I was sad to leave my FT job at first but I also didn’t want the DC feeling I was prioritising my job over them (nursery was ok but once in school they both disliked wraparound care and holiday clubs).

grey12 · 04/09/2021 17:00

Not 3 weeks, but also not necessarily the 6months you're talking about. 3/4 months may be a good idea, no? Depending of course on what you want in the long term, says the "dropped the job to be a sahp" person Wink a friend at 4months had to fly to another country to do a final masters presentation!

Miseryl · 04/09/2021 16:53

The minimum legal maternity leave is something like 2/3 weeks isn't it? And your partner/the father can take time off now as well.

StrangeToSee · 04/09/2021 16:49

You needed to do that, but others don’t. We don’t. We both work full time in professional expat roles. The house is always in a reasonable state, we home-cook all our food and the DC have plenty of time to read with us before bedtime and at weekends. We both pull our weight at home because neither of us is prepared to step back in careers we studied for years to access (PhDs in science, MBA). We’re organised and we make it work. And if anything happens to one of us, we’re safe in the knowledge that the other one’s income can fully support the family. Women absolutely don’t have to sacrifice their careers if they don’t want to (a supportive partner makes this easier, though).

I’m glad it works for your family.

DH and I are both postgrads too, both studied for many years, but his career really took off when I was pregnant with first DC. By the time second DC came along I didn’t ‘need’ to work thanks to his salary but I was reluctant to give up my career as I’d worked so hard to establish it. So I ploughed on FT until youngest started school.

DH does his best but he’s often away for long periods of work or needs to work evenings/weekends. His availability varies according to the project he’s in so it’s hard to predict how much he can support eg with school runs.

Maybe ‘sacrifice’ was the wrong word; although plenty of women (and men) have no choice if childcare is unaffordable and they have no family support nearby. The lower earner either becomes a SAHP or they reduce their hours to school hours only, with school holidays off etc.

I feel like I missed a lot of my DC’s childhood when they were in wraparound care, as they were out the house 7am-6pm then often fell asleep on the way home from nursery. When other kids were enjoying half term at home I was taking mine to holiday club which they hated. I also missed so many school plays, concerts, and at weekends they were clingy as they rarely saw me. Mornings were a rush to get ready for nursery/school/work. I was on a rota so missed most Christmas Days, DH and I could rarely take a day off together etc as it was constant tag teaming. For me, FT work sucked all my time and energy.

I realise not everyone has the option to just quit and wait for the ideal wfh school hours job to come up. I feel really sorry for women (and men) who have to give up their careers completely due to lack of childcare. There also seems to be the fear that once you leave a profession you’ll never get back in, though once I left I had so much time to research jobs and prepare for interviews, and a few months gap doesn’t seem to bother employers.

Cocomarine · 04/09/2021 16:28

My company is trying to promote a level gender playing field, including making managers like me aware of different career behaviour between men and women. Obviously NAMALT / NAWALT…

But what jumped out at me was you saying you’ve been teeing up for this for 7 years. For one level up. My training says that more men than women would have said - fuck that, and not waited around for the dead man’s shoes for 7 years anyway.

I appreciate that if this is your third child, you’ll say some of that 7 years was mat leave, but it’s still a long time to wait to profess.

Versus some men, they’d have jumped ship for the same promotion round about your first pregnancy.

So yes, it is harder for a woman, in general, if they want children.

But you had other options - your husband taking a better share, securing that promotion before children, or getting the progression before a third. Or moving to a company like mine where I regularly see women return from Mat leave into promotions.

Elephantsparade · 04/09/2021 16:24

3 months is somewhat different that 2 or 3 weeks. I mean i had to start my mat leave for my second, 3 weeks before my child was born as i was medically signed off and in hospital. With some of these mats leaves i'd have been back at work before the delivery!

LargeBouquet · 04/09/2021 16:13

[quote FloconDeNeige]@StrangeToSee

You needed to do that, but others don’t. We don’t. We both work full time in professional expat roles. The house is always in a reasonable state, we home-cook all our food and the DC have plenty of time to read with us before bedtime and at weekends.

We both pull our weight at home because neither of us is prepared to step back in careers we studied for years to access (PhDs in science, MBA). We’re organised and we make it work. And if anything happens to one of us, we’re safe in the knowledge that the other one’s income can fully support the family.

Women absolutely don’t have to sacrifice their careers if they don’t want to (a supportive partner makes this easier, though).[/quote]
This is our experience, too. Neither of us ever considered downgrading our work, both of us do childcare and housework, and pick up one another's slack on the rare occasions there's a real issue. Likewise two careers involving multiple postgraduate degrees, and we deliberately didn't have a child until we were at a stage of seniority at which we were both able to be flexible and dictate our own schedules to a large extent.

sst1234 · 04/09/2021 16:11

What do you expect OP? Not fill the position while your off? Or not let someone else with more experience it? You are unreasonable to annoyed, no one is forcing you to have children. Life goes on for other people.

AlexaShutUp · 04/09/2021 16:06

Women absolutely don’t have to sacrifice their careers if they don’t want to (a supportive partner makes this easier, though).

Completely agree.

FloconDeNeige · 04/09/2021 16:00

@StrangeToSee

You needed to do that, but others don’t. We don’t. We both work full time in professional expat roles. The house is always in a reasonable state, we home-cook all our food and the DC have plenty of time to read with us before bedtime and at weekends.

We both pull our weight at home because neither of us is prepared to step back in careers we studied for years to access (PhDs in science, MBA). We’re organised and we make it work. And if anything happens to one of us, we’re safe in the knowledge that the other one’s income can fully support the family.

Women absolutely don’t have to sacrifice their careers if they don’t want to (a supportive partner makes this easier, though).

StrangeToSee · 04/09/2021 14:56

I agree OP.

I think it’s very difficult to work FT, let alone progress your career, unless your partner is the lower earner/SAHP and can do the school/nursery runs and holidays, pick kids up when they’re ill etc.

I tried to ‘have it all’ but felt my DC were suffering being put into wraparound childcare. The house was always a mess, and every half term or holiday caused conflict over who would take annual leave, should we use holiday club (which DC started to fight against). As the main earner my DH’s job is vital to our financial security. Mine contributed to the family income and childcare but wasn’t vital.

So I gave up my FT job and found a similar one with greatly reduced hours that allows me to drop off and pick up at the usual times, is flexible with wfh options so holiday childcare is nolonger needed. I have enough time to cook, clean and listen to DC read during the week instead of getting home exhausted at 7pm. DC love it. DH loves it and has since been promoted twice as he’s spinning less plates.

Be careful not to prioritise work over family. Back when DC were younger I thought the only way to keep my foot ‘in the door’ of my profession by was by working FT. But the stress of doing that plus all the arranging childcare, home life, DC who missed me nearly led to burnout. I still have my foot in the door but won’t go FT until they’re much older.

Is your DH’s job the one that earns more/has the capacity to earn more? Or yours? Because I think one of you will have to sacrifice their career to some extent.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 04/09/2021 14:39

I know what you mean, and you’re kind of right, but I also agree with pps that it depends what you consider to be “it all”.

Nobody can have everything, it’s true, but women’s situation is different to men’s because we physically bear the children.

Mybobowler · 04/09/2021 14:32

@Kite22 I was specifically referring to posters suggesting she take "a few weeks" of maternity leave before returning to work - by "a few" I would assume 3 or 4 weeks. I'm sorry for my incredulity, but I don't believe any mother would gladly and willingly leave her newborn baby to return to work within that time frame. Obviously, many women are forced to by circumstance but I don't think many (any?) would choose to do so.

There's so much lowest common denominator BS in this thread, it's depressing. Yes, the UK has comparatively good maternity leave provision but it still falls woefully short of what studies show would be beneficial for children, families and wider society. We could do much better, and many other countries do. Where is the use-it-or-lose-it paternity leave? Where is the universal early years provision? Other countries manage it, why not this one? And why are so many posters - presumably, many of them women - in this thread being so snidey?

Wriggleon · 04/09/2021 13:29

Nobody can have it all, but 3 children and a 9 month mat leave are choices that you have made and not events that are out of your control

Hekatestorch · 04/09/2021 13:24

As I said, I think she should make it abundantly clear that she wants the position regardless of her maternity leave. They can fill it temporarily just as they would have had to if she'd gotten pregnant six months after taking up the position.

You are missing a huge point in op post.

That she wont be there for the temporary cover and so, the person who will do the temporary cover will have an advantage when it comes to filling it permanently.

This is not about applying for the permanent job, it's about the op missing an opportunity to do the hob and go into the interview with a slight advantage. Instead someone else will had the advantage.

And she won't be there during the period that job will be temporarily filled.

If a job needs filling for 9 months, they can't fill it with someone who won't be in work, for the majority or all of those 9 months.

So back to my point. If op wants this opportunity and to do the temporary cover of this role in preparation for permanently filling it, the only alternative is a short a Mat leave.

Op, physically can not take her planned 9-12 month Mat leave and cover the job which (initially) is a 9 month secondment, during the same period.

So it's take the Mat leave or don't take the Mat leave for this opportunity. She can certainly still apply for the permenr role.

But she can't do it all in this case.

Booboosweet · 04/09/2021 13:22

I don't think I have it 'all' but I'm very satisfied with what I have. We have a nice house in a really excellent area. We have one DC and both have good professional jobs and are comfortably off. I think for me, having it all would be maybe having three kids and a dream job in the arts or journalism which I don't have. So I don't have it all but what I have is very good.

bluegreygreen · 04/09/2021 13:21

*points

bluegreygreen · 04/09/2021 13:21

OP hasn't returned so we don't know her views on many of the pints raised.

One thing that hasn't been mentioned - she says that her boss has been 'teeing her up' for this role for years. This suggests the boss (and by extension the company) has been supporting her career aims. They may also feel some frustration at the timing ...

user1487194234 · 04/09/2021 13:20

I would definitely apply for it
They then have the decision to make as to whether to offer it to you
A lot of employers would not want to be seen to be discriminatory
Don't make it easy for them

Kite22 · 04/09/2021 13:02

Honestly finding these comments suggesting you return after a matter of weeks completely bizarre. Are they being facetious? Have any of these posters had children??

Well, I can't speak for anyone else, but I've had 3 dc. At a time when UK maternity leave was 3 months, so that is what I took, and then I went back to work. As did the overwhelming majority of my peers. We all have fully grown children who are healthy, well adjusted, competent, loving adults.
When they woke at night, dh and I took turns to deal with it whilst the other one slept.

The OP has made lots of choices, all of which might have been the right choices for her. I'm not criticising anyone taking a longer maternity leave. I'm glad there is now more choice. However, that is what it is, a choice.
Of course you can't expect an employer to give you a job that you aren't going to be there to do. It is quite bizarre to think that anyone would. It would be completely unfair on those folk that chose not to have dc (let alone 3)..... who chose not to take 9 months or a year out each time they did so.....who not only have a lot more recent experience, but will actually be there to do the job.

As if any man has to choose between his 3rd child or his career?!

@DrBlackbird My dh has done on several occasions as have so many others that I know well

Swipe left for the next trending thread