Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think women can't have it all?

240 replies

0Cripes · 03/09/2021 23:30

I'm pregnant with DC3 and due soon. My boss recently announced he was leaving at the end of this month on a 9 month secondment. His role is a natural progression for me and he has been teeing me up for it for 7 years. However, someone will backfill his role and gain experience for 9 months that I won't have a chance to get, therefore when the permanent position comes up (my boss has no intention to return) I'll be at a disadvantage.
If I wasn't going on mat leave I would stand a very good chance getting this role. I am annoyed as I feel I'm now at a disadvantage and my career is suffering because I've chosen to have a child. I appreciate that I still have the opportunity to apply but I'm pretty sure I won't get it knowing I'll be absent for 6 months of it!
I know the timings are nobodies fault but AIBU to be annoyed at this and think it's so hard for women to have kids and a successful career?

OP posts:
PlanDeRaccordement · 05/09/2021 20:02

Take the role now.
I had similar, applied for promotion while pregnant. Got it, then two months later had the baby (12 week maternity leave) and then went right back to the new job.

StrangeToSee · 05/09/2021 19:44

A surgeon is probably one of the very few jobs where it really would be difficult to be flexible but then again, if the surgeon's wife is also a surgeon, they would still have to find a way of managing things between them. Or they would have to buy in additional support.

A surgeon is just one example of someone in a high earning job with a lot of responsibility, who needs to be on site to do that job. Same goes for any hospital doctor, project manager, pilot, military officer… the list goes on. Many careers are not compatible with raising kids unless you have
a) a partner who is a SAHP or fits their work around the family or
b) childcare in the form of a live in nanny or relative.

To progress in many careers you simply can’t regularly request flexible hours, short notice days off, leave early, take holidays that sync with school etc. To get promoted and be at the top of your game you need to dedicate time to work. Because there are other people keen to get the promotions who don’t have kids, or have kids and a SAHP to cover all the holidays, half terms, inset days, kids being off sick from school etc.

It’s a shame there aren’t more high-earning women. But the brutal reality is each pregnancy sets you back in your career (especially if you want a long mat leave) so it tends to be the man who gets ahead career wise while his wife is caring for the baby.

I know a married couple who are both consultants (different fields but full time). They both love their jobs. They have 2 kids and a nanny, and often talk about how nice it would be to see more of their kids.

AlexaShutUp · 05/09/2021 18:54

@StrangeToSee

Sorry, but I don't really buy this. There are very few jobs in which people really couldn't take time out to deal with family emergencies. It's simply that many men don't feel the need

A child with a cut knee or a cough at school isn’t an emergency though. Nor is a child with chicken pox who has to stay off school for a fortnight.

I’m sure men would ask for flexibility if there was a life threatening situation. But not for situations the lower-earning partner has under control, like unexpected childcare or a child under the weather but not seriously ill.

Asking for flexibility in some jobs causes mayhem and repercussions; imagine a surgeon cancelling his theatre list for the day because his son has a cold and his wife doesn’t want to take another day off. Or a project manager who abandons his team before a crucial deadline because he needs to pick his child up early. Being reliable and responsible is a valued trait in employees.

If as a family you depend mostly (or solely) on the career of one person, wouldn’t the lesser earning partner pull out all the stops to ensure his/her partner isn’t disturbed at work?

A surgeon is probably one of the very few jobs where it really would be difficult to be flexible but then again, if the surgeon's wife is also a surgeon, they would still have to find a way of managing things between them. Or they would have to buy in additional support.

The reality is, most people aren't surgeons and most people's jobs could be more flexible. If a manager leaving early one afternoon to collect an injured child causes so much mayhem, I'd argue that they're managing things very poorly. Life happens, people get sick sometimes and unexpected things come up. There should be enough resilience in systems to cope with this... and usually there is.

In fact, many women do manage to deliver in senior roles without a lower earning partner to pick up the slack at home. Men with partners in high earning roles manage to do the same. Reliability and responsibility are important, yes, but employers need to recognise that people at all levels in an organisation will have family responsibilities and sometimes they will need to take priority. We will never achieve real equality in the workplace until this understanding is there.

We have always relied mainly on my income as a family, but it would never have occurred to me to expect DH to pick up all of the slack, and it wouldn't have been fair to his employer either. I wanted to do my fair share and I wanted to be a hands on parent, so yes, I did take time off for minor illnesses etc. That's part of being a parent. It didn't stop me from doing a cracking good job, nor did it get in the way of my career progression or my ability to provide for my family.

notthemum · 05/09/2021 18:49

@TrippingFlip.
Of course there is a choice as to when the baby comes along. Maybe not always exact but pretty much in nine months time.
OP , When I was caring for children the first baby that I ever took came to me when they were 3/4 months old.
I took one when they were 5 months, one at nine months. I also took one baby at the age of eight weeks, the last baby i took came to me when they were 4 weeks old. Mum had to return to work.
So if you want this job can't DP arrange for some paternity leave ?

Jangle33 · 05/09/2021 17:41

I think it helps to earn as much or more than your partner. If you contribute the same then it is more logical to both manage the risk of annoying your employer. I think the pity is how backwards the U.K. is at this…

BalloonSlayer · 05/09/2021 17:22

@Randomlondoner it is illegal in the UK to return to work within 14 days of giving birth, for a start.

saladcreamwitheverything · 05/09/2021 17:06

I have two kids and both times I was back at full time work when they were two weeks old. Husband was the SAHP as I earn more than him.

StrangeToSee · 05/09/2021 16:59

Perhaps your dh isn't pushing back against his employer's sexist approach too hard because, deep down, he believes that the children are primarily your responsibility?

Or he’s been conditioned by society to believe his responsibility is to provide for his family, so he focuses on his career in able to progress as breadwinner?

StrangeToSee · 05/09/2021 16:55

Sorry, but I don't really buy this. There are very few jobs in which people really couldn't take time out to deal with family emergencies. It's simply that many men don't feel the need

A child with a cut knee or a cough at school isn’t an emergency though. Nor is a child with chicken pox who has to stay off school for a fortnight.

I’m sure men would ask for flexibility if there was a life threatening situation. But not for situations the lower-earning partner has under control, like unexpected childcare or a child under the weather but not seriously ill.

Asking for flexibility in some jobs causes mayhem and repercussions; imagine a surgeon cancelling his theatre list for the day because his son has a cold and his wife doesn’t want to take another day off. Or a project manager who abandons his team before a crucial deadline because he needs to pick his child up early. Being reliable and responsible is a valued trait in employees.

If as a family you depend mostly (or solely) on the career of one person, wouldn’t the lesser earning partner pull out all the stops to ensure his/her partner isn’t disturbed at work?

RandomLondoner · 05/09/2021 16:09

Honestly finding these comments suggesting you return after a matter of weeks completely bizarre. Are they being facetious? Have any of these posters had children??

The first page google brought up on the subject told me that a quarter of American women return to work within two weeks of having a baby. I'm not commenting on the desirability of this, just pointing out that it's not far-fetched, it is being done by millions.

MMMarmite · 05/09/2021 16:05

Where's your partner in all this? People can't have it all, but no reason that should inevitably fall on the woman. Can your partner take parental leave and you go back to work?

Flyingantday · 05/09/2021 16:00

@AlexaShutUp

While in theory DH has more flexibility than I do (an unlimited holiday time policy) the attitude when he requests time to take care of the DC is "can't your wife take care of that?" whereas if I ask, I get somewhat more understanding.

So what do they say when he explains that, no, his wife cannot do that because he is an equal parent who needs to share the responsibility for his children?

I'm sorry, but if men really wanted to work flexibly enough to take on their fair share, then they would make it happen. There are very few jobs in which this genuinely isn't possible. Perhaps your dh isn't pushing back against his employer's sexist approach too hard because, deep down, he believes that the children are primarily your responsibility? And you seem willing to accept that, so perhaps you agree?

It's funny how the men who are genuinely committed to challenging sexism and sharing the responsibility always seem to manage to negotiate with their employers successfully.

Good points here, my DH had to assert himself and marginally inconvenience a few clients so he could shift around his diary to be there reliably for childcare reasons - this was during covid when wraparound wasn’t on and I was doing 10 hour shifts. Magically he managed to do this when it was an absolute necessity, the world didn’t end and his work didn’t think any the less of him (he’s a team player, already goes above and beyond but can be a bit of a people pleaser). I’m hoping this will be a lesson learned for the future for him. We have equal levels of responsibility at work and my team is smaller so it is actually more inconvenient for my employer than his if the kids need something. Weird the perception that it’s always mums job because men’s work is automatically more important.
IcedPurple · 05/09/2021 15:19

If I wasn't going on mat leave I would stand a very good chance getting this role. I am annoyed as I feel I'm now at a disadvantage and my career is suffering because I've chosen to have a child. I appreciate that I still have the opportunity to apply but I'm pretty sure I won't get it knowing I'll be absent for 6 months of it!

Your career isn't suffering because you've chosen to have a child.

You may not get a promotion because you will not be at work for several months at a time when the position needs to be filled. That would be the same if you took time off to travel or for medical reasons. You can't expect them to put the position on hold until you decide to return to work, can you?

Also, as others have pointed out, you don't have to take 9 months off. That is your choice. Your employers aren't obliged to work around your family choices.

Heliachi · 05/09/2021 15:17

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Heliachi · 05/09/2021 15:12

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

AlexaShutUp · 05/09/2021 15:07

While in theory DH has more flexibility than I do (an unlimited holiday time policy) the attitude when he requests time to take care of the DC is "can't your wife take care of that?" whereas if I ask, I get somewhat more understanding.

So what do they say when he explains that, no, his wife cannot do that because he is an equal parent who needs to share the responsibility for his children?

I'm sorry, but if men really wanted to work flexibly enough to take on their fair share, then they would make it happen. There are very few jobs in which this genuinely isn't possible. Perhaps your dh isn't pushing back against his employer's sexist approach too hard because, deep down, he believes that the children are primarily your responsibility? And you seem willing to accept that, so perhaps you agree?

It's funny how the men who are genuinely committed to challenging sexism and sharing the responsibility always seem to manage to negotiate with their employers successfully.

Shehasadiamondinthesky · 05/09/2021 14:59

I had it all with one child and went back to work when he was 6 weeks old (single parent), but three - no way.

gwenneh · 05/09/2021 14:56

@AlexaShutUp

Women with kids do get more flexibility than men in senior roles. I have seen it amongst my female friends - in several cases they work in the same industries and earn the same money as their husbands but seem to get a lot more leeway when it comes to holidays / wfh / flexible working etc. I guess it’s because ‘senior’ women are still less likely to be team managers or have multiple responsibility sets.

Again, I'm convinced that women get more flexibility simply because they ask for it. Very few men ask.

The few men I've known who have asked have successfully managed to negotiate the flexible working that they require.

I'd disagree with that. While in theory DH has more flexibility than I do (an unlimited holiday time policy) the attitude when he requests time to take care of the DC is "can't your wife take care of that?" whereas if I ask, I get somewhat more understanding. As a consequence I wind up being the one doing all of the doctors visits, sick days, quarantine schooling, etc. It's not that he doesn't ask, it's that there seems to be genuine unwillingness to grant it.

Perhaps it's unique to the sector the tech sector has been called out on threads here before for advertising these "unlimited holiday" clauses that turn out to be quite limited in actual fact but it is not unique to the current employer.

Hekatestorch · 05/09/2021 14:40

Women with kids do get more flexibility than men in senior roles. I have seen it amongst my female friends - in several cases they work in the same industries and earn the same money as their husbands but seem to get a lot more leeway when it comes to holidays / wfh / flexible working etc. I guess it’s because ‘senior’ women are still less likely to be team managers or have multiple responsibility sets.

Women are less likely to be team managers or have multiple responsibilities?

Are you serious?

I have been recently promoted to director by my employer. We all have teams and multiple responsibilities, which employers pay women the same as men, but give them less work? Or decide to give them roles where they don't have teams? I would like to work for one one them. I will apply today.

Women, get the flexibility because they ask for it or use the flexibility that is available in the role. As a director I can work from wherever I want, when I want. So I plan around my family life. Non of the men do that. Often many of them make sure they are doing the opposite and their wives have no idea how flexible they could be.

And that's across the 3 big UK companies I have worked in. Women use the flexibility, men don't.

AlexaShutUp · 05/09/2021 14:23

Women with kids do get more flexibility than men in senior roles. I have seen it amongst my female friends - in several cases they work in the same industries and earn the same money as their husbands but seem to get a lot more leeway when it comes to holidays / wfh / flexible working etc. I guess it’s because ‘senior’ women are still less likely to be team managers or have multiple responsibility sets.

Again, I'm convinced that women get more flexibility simply because they ask for it. Very few men ask.

The few men I've known who have asked have successfully managed to negotiate the flexible working that they require.

AlexaShutUp · 05/09/2021 14:18

Maybe in some cases, but in others the main earner can’t afford to take sudden days off or abandon his work responsibilities on a regular basis, especially if he’s going for promotions. Or has lots of colleagues relying on him, the weight of responsibility for providing etc.

Sorry, but I don't really buy this. There are very few jobs in which people really couldn't take time out to deal with family emergencies. It's simply that many men don't feel the need.

We need to get to the point where being an equal and responsible parent won't stop you from getting promotions, providing for your family etc. It should just be an accepted fact of working life, as it is already for many women and for the minority of men who do their fair share.

I'm pretty sure that a lot of the men I manage would tell their partners that they couldn't possibly have the time off work to deal with childcare issues because they are far too busy, have too many important commitments and too many people relying on them. I presume that this is why they never even ask for flexibility despite having young children at home. As their manager, I know that their female colleagues are equally busy, have just as many important commitments and just as many people relying on them, and yet they somehow manage to juggle domestic responsibilities as well. Because they have to. And as their manager, I also know that I would be happy to accommodate requests for flexibility from those male members of staff, if they would only ask, and that I would never hold this against them in terms of their career progression. And yet they rarely even ask.

MyMabel · 05/09/2021 14:11

Could you use your KIT days to show willing and introduce yourself to the new role? Make it clear to whoever you need to that your maternity leave won’t impact how you approach the job when maternity ends.

Ozanj · 05/09/2021 14:08

I often wonder if it's easier to fall into these stereotypical roles when the man is the higher earner. I am the main earner in our family, and bring in several multiples of DH's salary, but it never occurred to me that I shouldn't do my fair share of looking after dd when she was ill etc. Tbh, it was always easier for me to be flexible in a more senior role in any case

Women with kids do get more flexibility than men in senior roles. I have seen it amongst my female friends - in several cases they work in the same industries and earn the same money as their husbands but seem to get a lot more leeway when it comes to holidays / wfh / flexible working etc. I guess it’s because ‘senior’ women are still less likely to be team managers or have multiple responsibility sets.

Cazziebo · 05/09/2021 14:06

It takes up to a year for a woman’s body to properly recover from childbirth and pregnancy

Everyone is different. My sister had a baby on Wednesday and was back at work on the following Sunday (a chef, not a desk job). Lives in a country with no paid mat leave.

And looking after a baby can be far more wearing on the body than many jobs.

StrangeToSee · 05/09/2021 14:01

I often wonder if it's easier to fall into these stereotypical roles when the man is the higher earner. I am the main earner in our family, and bring in several multiples of DH's salary, but it never occurred to me that I shouldn't do my fair share of looking after dd when she was ill etc. Tbh, it was always easier for me to be flexible in a more senior role in any case

Maybe in some cases, but in others the main earner can’t afford to take sudden days off or abandon his work responsibilities on a regular basis, especially if he’s going for promotions. Or has lots of colleagues relying on him, the weight of responsibility for providing etc.

Whereas I could walk out of my job and it wouldn’t really matter as far as family finances are concerned, it certainly wouldn’t make any difference to bills/mortgage. I only work because I like it and want to keep that door open.

I know plenty of couples who sadly can’t afford to have both parents FT, as they can’t afford childcare and before/after school clubs or holiday clubs.

Swipe left for the next trending thread