Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DS got a job but told he will be self emoyed - is this legit?

59 replies

WitzEnders · 03/09/2021 21:21

DS (18) has been offered a job by a local builder. Great, he's not academic but is good with his hands and a real grafter.

The boss has told him he will be "self employed" and needs to sort out his own tax and NIC.

I've never been in this position so did a quick Google and I don't think DS meets HMRC criteria for s/e. Is this just a way for his boss to avoid paying employers NI, holidays and pension?

Any advice would be much appreciated.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
CovidIsADick · 05/09/2021 11:26

@icedcoffees Also, if you read the OP’s first post again, she has reason to believe that her son doesn’t fit the criteria to be considered a self employed CIS contractor. Her son is most likely yet another person about to be exploited by a tax dodging contractor.

CovidIsADick · 05/09/2021 11:22

@BarbaraofSeville There's also always the risk that HMRC will crack down on the construction industry because while it is widespread, most of the jobbing builders, machine drivers and other tradespeople don't meet the true SE definition. Just like they've done with IT contractors etc with IR35.

IMO this can’t happen soon enough.

CovidIsADick · 05/09/2021 11:20

@icedcoffees if you go back and read my first post I said that the scheme is great when used correctly. I don’t disagree with you.

My point is that most of the time it is not used correctly. The vast majority of contractors use the scheme as a way to dodge their responsibilities as an employer. I am not just making wild claims without proof, I have been dealing with this for the last two years. It is a well known fact and there are thousands of people out there who are being exploited.

BarbaraofSeville · 05/09/2021 11:17

There's also always the risk that HMRC will crack down on the construction industry because while it is widespread, most of the jobbing builders, machine drivers and other tradespeople don't meet the true SE definition. Just like they've done with IT contractors etc with IR35.

Its very common my friend is a nursery nurse and she had this arrangement too

How on earth can a nursery nurse be self employed?

icedcoffees · 05/09/2021 11:14

[quote CovidIsADick]@icedcoffees perhaps that’s how it worked for you but sadly for most it’s just not the case. If my DH and his colleagues behaved like that they would’ve lost their jobs. They had set hours and had no choice when it came to what jobs to do. They were told where to be and what to do. They didn’t get to pick and choose. It sounds like your DH is a legitimate CIS contractor but my point is that most of the time the scheme is used incorrectly and people are working under disguised employment.[/quote]
People may use the scheme incorrectly - and I don't disagree that it happens - but that still doesn't mean that the scheme itself is a bad idea.

DH can take days off as and when he chooses. He doesn't have set hours or times. He's asked to do various jobs but is totally free to turn them down if he wishes. So yes, he has a lot of flexibility, but at the same time, he's often worked late/gone on to site at weekends to get jobs done - it works both ways for him.

They keep him on because he is excellent at his job - so if he needs a last-minute day off to sort his car (or whatever) they allow it because he more than makes up for it the rest of the time.

The fact that some people use the CIS scheme in the wrong way doesn't change the fact that it still works really well for many people.

BarbaraofSeville · 05/09/2021 11:13

OP, if your DS decides to go down this route, which could be a good thing for him to learn a trade and earn decent money without being academic (once he gets more experience, he could start his own firm etc) but he needs to make sure he fully understands the whole CIS/SE system and make sure he knows where he is with tax - CIS takes 20%, which will cover what he owes until he earns around £25k a year, but there will be NI to pay on top and if he earns more than £25k, he needs to save extra to pay more tax and NI.

He needs to register with the CIS scheme, and as self employed, and do a tax return on time each year or else he will be fined heavily.

He also needs to start his own pension as there's no employer's pension and he will get tax relief on this. He needs to put 10-20% of his earnings into his pension.

He should also save some money in case he can't work if he's sick, injured, the weather is bad, or his 'employer' has no work for him or the site he's working on is closed, eg it could close for 2 weeks at Christmas.

So counting tax, NI, pension and some money to cover times when he's not earning, he should regard only around 50-60% or so of the gross money he gets paid to be available to him to actually spend.

CovidIsADick · 05/09/2021 11:10

@icedcoffees perhaps that’s how it worked for you but sadly for most it’s just not the case. If my DH and his colleagues behaved like that they would’ve lost their jobs. They had set hours and had no choice when it came to what jobs to do. They were told where to be and what to do. They didn’t get to pick and choose. It sounds like your DH is a legitimate CIS contractor but my point is that most of the time the scheme is used incorrectly and people are working under disguised employment.

Thatsplentyjack · 05/09/2021 11:06

My dp has had 2 jobs like this now, although the companies do actually take tax off his wages to put into a tax account. Both companies have had an account that do the guys tax returns at the end of the year for a fee. They have the option of doing their own obviously, bit most prefer to just let the accountants and then their tax bill gets paid using the money in the tax account.
At first I wasn't keen on this arrangement, as I'm self employed and I just couldn't really get my head around it, but it's always worked out fine.

BarbaraofSeville · 05/09/2021 11:04

@icedcoffees

Yes you are technically free to take days and time off, but if you're supplying labour to a builder etc and keep deciding to take time or days off of your choosing, you're at risk of finding that they might decide to stop taking your services which they can do with no notice or reason, because you don't have any employment rights because you're 'self employed'.

It is shit and while some people might be lucky in that they can always find work when they need it, and it's at a decent rate of pay, there's no proper security and you can quickly find yourself out of work in times when the building trade isn't booming like it is now.

drinkingwineoutofamug · 05/09/2021 10:59

My son has finally managed to get a job doing house clearance (social housing) and cleaning.
The company want him to register as self-employed, dbs, insurance. He has to buy his own uniform.
Been an arse ache to sort
His insurance has to be public liability up to a certain amount and we included personal insurance on top

icedcoffees · 05/09/2021 10:52

No paid holiday or sickness, no pay if there isn't any work/it's raining. No employers NI contribution, no working place pension, no job security, the offset on reclaiming your workwear etc does not compensate.

But that's not the only benefit, is it?

If you work under the CIS scheme you are free to be much more picky as to what jobs you do. You can choose when you take your days off and time off, what time you come home etc. DH earns more than enough to cover sick days, holidays, early finishes to take the dog to the vet etc.

It might not work for everyone but it does work really well for some. Too many people aren't clued up on their rights and responsibilities, though, and that goes for employers, employees and subcontracters.

AwaAnBileYerHeid · 05/09/2021 10:51

I'm a nurse and got a job working for an agency (a good few years ago now). I was offered two options- be employed under PAYE, or use an umbrella company who sorted everything out for me. I went PAYE as I thought it would be a hassle otherwise however some of the other nurses I met said it worked out that they made slightly more being under the umbrella company.

Anyway, my point is that he can employ a company to do all the hard work for him. I won't comment on the legitimacy of being self employed in the building trade as it's not a sector that I know anything about.

Ireolu · 05/09/2021 10:44

Call HMRC for advice. Lots of differing opinions on here best to get it from them. Will be a long wait in the phone but I have always found the advisers helpful.

ittakes2 · 05/09/2021 10:41

Its very common my friend is a nursery nurse and she had this arrangement too.

Ozberry · 05/09/2021 10:31

You need to check that it is CIS scheme and not just casual cash in hand. Has he got his CSCS card?

Iwanttobeapaperbackwriter · 05/09/2021 10:28

[quote CovidIsADick]**@Whinginadeville* and @icedcoffees* In our case it was totally exploitative and unethical. That is very often the case. The lawyers and courts that we’ve been working with must agree as we’ve just been paid a £30k settlement. Very often people are taken on as CIS contractors but work exclusively for one company. Wearing their uniform, driving their vehicles, working set hours and answering to a boss but without any of the perks of employment. I’ve started an anonymous forum online and I would say at least 80% of the subcontractors that are coming forward with their stories should be employed for tax purposes. Not CIS. When the scheme is used correctly it is great but most of the time it is not used correctly and contractors use it as a way to get out of the hassle of being an employer.[/quote]
Completey agree.

AnnaMagnani · 05/09/2021 10:25

This is how my job works - not construction. Yes I am totally unable to send someone else in my place but it's how the industry works.

It's been a massive win for me apart from the absence of sick/holiday pay - hang on to every receipt, work out exactly what is tax refundable (loads!), pay private pension and at the end of the year I have a tax refund. Has been better for me than employment and I was employed by an industry known for having good conditions.

Iwanttobeapaperbackwriter · 05/09/2021 10:22

@copsford

Whilst common it's still shit
It is shit. No paid holiday or sickness, no pay if there isn't any work/it's raining. No employers NI contribution, no working place pension, no job security, the offset on reclaiming your workwear etc does not compensate.
CovidIsADick · 05/09/2021 10:14

@Whinginadeville and @icedcoffees In our case it was totally exploitative and unethical. That is very often the case. The lawyers and courts that we’ve been working with must agree as we’ve just been paid a £30k settlement. Very often people are taken on as CIS contractors but work exclusively for one company. Wearing their uniform, driving their vehicles, working set hours and answering to a boss but without any of the perks of employment. I’ve started an anonymous forum online and I would say at least 80% of the subcontractors that are coming forward with their stories should be employed for tax purposes. Not CIS. When the scheme is used correctly it is great but most of the time it is not used correctly and contractors use it as a way to get out of the hassle of being an employer.

bellabasset · 05/09/2021 08:26

Good luck to your ds, he also needs to look at health and accident insurance.

icedcoffees · 05/09/2021 08:10

@AhDiddums

While this is completely normal in the industry it’s not right at all. Contractors get away with this shit all the time. Your DS won’t be doing anything wrong, it’s up to the contractor to determine his employment status for tax purposes. It’s just shit and it’s exploitative. Google Pimlico plumbing employee court case, it’s very interesting reading. CIS rates of pay might be slightly higher but the lack of job security, paid leave, paternity pay, pensions, sick pay etc etc, is just not worth it.
It's not exploitative at all and it's totally 100% worth it for many people.

DH earns way way over the regular employed wage - even if you factor in sick pay, pension (which he pays into privately) and holiday pay, he's still financially much better off than people on the same site who are employed.

It also means he has much more flexibility with regards to jobs, time off and much much more.

He's been employed and self-employed in the same industry and would never go back go the former.

Cheeseplantboots · 04/09/2021 20:58

Yes as others have said he’ll be CIS. His boss will deduct 20% for tax. He’ll do his own tax return and usually get a rebate. National insurance is usually paid quarterly.

icedcoffees · 04/09/2021 20:52

Totally normal in the construction industry - DH is in the same position and it's perfectly legitimate.

They pay 20% tax for him and writes it on his tax forms when he does his expenses. Some years he gets money back, some years he owes money depending on his expenditure.

He gets a higher rate of pay to compensate for lack of holiday/sick pay.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 04/09/2021 20:48

If nobody else has mentioned it, one of the first he'll have to do is pass his Health and Safety test. His boss might guide him through it and book the test on his behalf, but if not, you'll be able to help him. It's not hugely difficult, but it is absolutely vital that he has it.

Whinginadeville · 04/09/2021 19:57

While this is completely normal in the industry it’s not right at all. Contractors get away with this shit all the time. Your DS won’t be doing anything wrong, it’s up to the contractor to determine his employment status for tax purposes. It’s just shit and it’s exploitative
No it really isn't.