Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To contact her sister? Urgent. Not sure what to do.

143 replies

Feltedsheep · 03/09/2021 21:05

Im looking for some advice and it’s quite a specific situation.
I made friends with someone online a couple of years ago, through a mutual support group. We stayed in contact outside of the group and we’ve spoken on the phone and message most days - although we’ve never met and live several hours apart. I count her as a friend but I don’t have any real insight into her life because of the distance. I know her, but I don’t really know her. I feel like we’ve been penpals (email pals?) and our situations have been very similar at times.

However she has gradually become more and more depressed over recent months and has made comments about taking her own life - but it’s hard to judge the tone and how serious she is. If she’s venting or means it.
But I am worried tonight. She’s messaged to say her partner isn’t there and her kids are at her parents’ and she’s asked me to take care of myself and told me it’ll all be alright as well as some stuff about it not mattering when we die if we’ve ever been alive and she’s going to do what she needs to for her children.
It’s not totally out of character but I’m concerned she’s on her own. I have her sister’s name and could contact via fb but I doubt her sister even knows I exist and I don’t want to make things worse or cause trouble. On the other hand I am worried.

I don’t know what to do. It feels like meddling and I’m in a weird situation where I know some things about her but having never met her I don’t know her family or friends or day to day life.
Do I message her sister? Do I leave it? I’ve asked outright if she’s planning on harming herself and she’s said no but then she would say that. She’s told me not to worry and that she’s having an early night.

I don’t want to make things worse for her... but what if she harms herself?

OP posts:
VenusTiger · 04/09/2021 01:13

@memberofthewedding

I would not interfere.

I strongly believe that when people make a decision to end their lives then they should be allowed to do so without inteference from others.

That really depends on the circumstances. I had to "interfere" more than once when my DH (then my BF) attempted it. Me, all by myself. I had no idea what I was doing, but it's instinct as well as love. He made a full recovery. There are some depressions that are circumstantial and you can overcome them. There are some depressions that are not helped by lifestyle and diet i.e. chemical imbalance. Neither of us regrets the actions I took. It's all in the past now.
Mamanyt · 04/09/2021 01:10

@Mamanyt

If you think that having the police go round is adviseably, call them. They can reverse-trace the number and get the address.
advisable, dammit. I do my best proofreading after hitting "post message."
Mamanyt · 04/09/2021 01:09

If you think that having the police go round is adviseably, call them. They can reverse-trace the number and get the address.

XenoBitch · 03/09/2021 23:57

@memberofthewedding

I would not interfere.

I strongly believe that when people make a decision to end their lives then they should be allowed to do so without inteference from others.

I agree to a point. It depends on context. Some people make that decision because they are mentally unwell. In that case, they need help. Some people pay a lot of money to go to places like Dignitas... and they will have been assessed and judged that it is the right decision for them.
Sunshinesandice · 03/09/2021 23:51

I hope all
Is ok with your friend xx

tensmum1964 · 03/09/2021 23:51

You have definitely done the right thing. I would be surprised if your friend is angry with you as her conversation is worrying and even if she is very depressed she knows what she is implying. She would be hard pushed to blame you for contacting her sister given the things she has said.

SeoultoSeoul · 03/09/2021 23:50

memberofthewedding
Really?
Even though depression can be very treatable?

memberofthewedding · 03/09/2021 23:46

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

SalmonEile · 03/09/2021 23:45

You’ve done the right thing. I’ve been in this situation, it’s so hard when you know someone “virtually” and can only go on what they type and you’re asking yourself are they in genuine danger or just venting

eeek88 · 03/09/2021 23:44

TW SUICIDE
Trust your intuition.

It’s easy to dismiss behaviour like this as attention-seeking, not serious. But sometimes it is serious.

I once went to bed thinking there was nothing more I could do about my partner’s MH crisis. I was tired, and if I’m honest, I was also scared for my own safety if I continued to try to intervene. He’s insanely strong and had made it perfectly clear that I wasn’t to go near him… I’d have been foolish to push it… As I tried to get comfortable and go to sleep, a voice in my head very forcibly told me I had to act. I put a coat over my pyjamas, went out into the freezing night, watched him silently from a safe distance and realised I needed to call the police without delay. By the time they arrived he was standing on a barrel with his head in a noose.

If I hadn’t listened to that little voice saying, ‘I’m afraid you need to get out of bed and deal with this,’ and if the police hadn’t come when they did, I don’t think he’d be here now .

MollyBloomYes · 03/09/2021 23:43

You've done the right thing OP. When I made my attempt I was acting oddly enough that in the end two of my friends ended up contacting my parents (I was at university). I still feel guilty that I put them in that position but they are still my friends to this day and I am forever grateful to them. I genuinely meant to go through with it (or at least, wanted everything to 'stop' which is a common feeling) but perhaps subconsciously had enough survival instinct left to breadcrumb with weird messages that alerted them to the fact that all was not ok.

Your friend might be angry for a while. She might not (I wasn't but many are). That's ok. Please please believe that you absolutely have done the right thing, you had enough concerns to act on them and that is never something you should blame yourself for. Depression can do ridiculous things to a person's brain and perception so if she is angry please try not to take it to heart. I and everyone else on here know that you are a very good friend and person indeed Thanks

Starseeking · 03/09/2021 23:42

You did the right thing in contacting the sister.

Not quite as immediate as on the same night, but I had a friend who would often go awol for a few days. I didn't know anything about depression then, or just how bad it could be.

One particular week, I'd said to myself if I hadn't heard from friend by the Monday, I'd contact her sister. Friend actually sent me a text on the Monday indicating she'd be at an event on the Friday, so I never made the call. My friend never turned up on the Friday, then on the Saturday morning, I got an urgent FB message from her sister asking to call, when I did, she said she'd found my friend dead the previous evening.

As someone upthread said, overreacting is far better than underreacting in this scenario. My circumstance happened 7 years ago, and I still think about the 'ifonlys'.

Lalliella · 03/09/2021 23:35

Sorry, didn’t read the full thread, you did the right thing OP.

Cringingjustthinkingaboutit · 03/09/2021 23:34

You’ve absolutely done the right thing. Worst case scenario in this situation now (assuming sister is on the case) is you lose a friendship. If it were the other way round and you hadn’t contacted the sister and your worst fears came to pass then someone may have lost their life. Hugs to you OP and I hope all is well Flowers

Lalliella · 03/09/2021 23:34

I would try to contact her sister, but if you’re using Facebook messenger and you’re not friends she may not see it. So if she doesn’t reply straightaway I would contact the police. They can look up addresses for people.

VillanellesOrangeCoat · 03/09/2021 23:30

@ThankYouStavros I’m so sorry for your loss FlowersFlowers

Alternista · 03/09/2021 23:30

You absolutely did the right thing.

aquashiv · 03/09/2021 23:27

Definitely did the right thing well done

XenoBitch · 03/09/2021 23:23

@Darbysmama

Only ever use the police as a very last resort. They have very little training regarding mental health, if the person denies being suicidal and there is no concrete proof they are then they can do nothing, and if they do admit or there is proof they will be put on a psychiatric hold which is almost never helpful and typically quite traumatic.
I would always call the police. I have done it several times for people I was concerned about. They have more mental health training than someone's relative would, and they have their own mental health team that can touch base with the person too.

Sadly, I did contact a relative of someone I was concerned about and they told me that they hope their sibling went through with it. Just because they are related, it does not mean they will give a shit. I always call the police now.

VenusTiger · 03/09/2021 23:21

It was definitely the right thing to do OP. It may be that your friend has only ever told you her real feelings about her current state of mind, and I believe that's for a reason.
She's been telling you how she feels as she needs to talk to someone and wants that someone to know she's struggling. She may not be suicidal now, but who is to say she won't be if she continues along this thought path.
She needs help and you've done the right thing here OP.

Whattfit · 03/09/2021 23:21

You have done the right thing.

TheChip · 03/09/2021 23:16

It was definitely the right thing to do. Hopefully all is okay. It could have been something she has been keeping from her family, so you may have also just added an extra level of support for her. I hope you're feeling a bit of weight lift off your shoulders now, too!

Feltedsheep · 03/09/2021 23:15

I sent quite a bare bones message - I just said I was a concerned friend and I was particularly worried about her sister being on her own when she sounded upset. I didn’t go into any extra detail because it’s not mine to share. I just hope my friend isn’t too horrified by me contacting her sister but it has to be the least worse option overall.

OP posts:
Footprintsonmyfloor · 03/09/2021 23:14

You’ve absolutely done the right thing.

JustBrowwsing · 03/09/2021 23:13

Just saw your update OP, well done, definitely better safe than sorry.