Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I know I am probably BU but

106 replies

beinglikedisoverrated · 03/09/2021 20:08

Cost at moment to charge an Electric car overnight for 1 year us in excess of 3k. News today says fuel prices are going to hike. And, what happens to all the used electric batteries. Landfill? Aibu to love and want to keep my 'dirty diesel'? Ironically, diesel was supposed to be the ' cleaner fuel'.

OP posts:
Selkiesarereal · 04/09/2021 18:20

Op, whilst I am no conspiracy theorist but clearly am the resident nutter 🤪 somehow offending ev drivers all I am saying is that you can research into the battery a little more.

The mining of cobalt is causing huge devastation in the DCR as it is so valuable that wars are carried out to gain access to these mines.

There are some companies that are better at knowing their supply chain than others but all will admit it is difficult.

If you are buying an ev ask about the battery and if it does contain cobalt what assurances can they give that it has been ethically mined as by consumers asking these questions can help to secure change.

When I was looking into an ev car bmw came out better but this was a few years ago and things change.

To all those who think I’m mad I think that you should really take a look at yourselves and why you feel the need to attack someone who raises concerns over the mining of these materials, surely it’s in everyone’s interest to try to do what little we can to help the not just our own environment but those countries where we source the materials?

TheVolturi · 04/09/2021 16:11

I agree with you @notmycat, I can't see how it will work for everyone. I have said before, in the future, if ev is to totally replace fuelled engines, every parking space at services will need to have a charger. It's coming but not fast enough.
I had my first ev in 2016 and there were very limited chargers around here. Now they are at 3 of our local supermarkets, on street in town and other places as well, but there don't seem to be any extra at services.

NotMyCat · 04/09/2021 16:03

I'm on the "fine for other people but won't work for everyone"
I can't have a charge point, and neither can any of my neighbours as we are in an apartment with allocated parking, and my parking space is nowhere near where I live
How are people with on street parking going to charge?
Blocks of flats with car parks?

ithinkilikeit · 04/09/2021 15:51

Most people don’t drive 150miles a day so would not spend any where near that on charging. There is your answer.

Youcanchangeyournamebut · 04/09/2021 15:48

If you're so concerned about the environment,why are you driving 150 miles a day Confused

TheVolturi · 04/09/2021 15:42

Some chargers can charge in 20 mins. Would you really do a 5 hr journey without stopping anyway? My car has a lower mileage range than a lot of others, dh has one that does almost 350 miles on a charge. In the future it will be far more. If the amazon driver is only getting 70 miles they must be driving an older first generation ev, a lot only did 80 miles on a charge when new.
I did a 200 mile trip last week and the kids needed the loo on the way home, plugged in at the services for the ten mins that it took them all to have a pee, it gave me another 50 miles and cost £3. Wasn't exactly a hardship.
I don't understand why people have to be so snippy about it.

RickJames · 04/09/2021 15:34

We are getting an EV. We have to get a charge point put in on the drive but we'll get a tax refund on most of the cost. Then we can run it from the solar panels on the roof - might have to put a few more on to accommodate the extra usage but the big costs of the system set up are already paid.

We got an 1% interest loan for the solar system so although the set up costs were high its paying back the loan and cutting our bills. Again, got a good tax rebate on the outlay. Have you thought about getting solar panels? Cheap power and not so much worry about the source/ impact of the electricity you're using.

We put panels on another house 12 years ago and they paid for themselves in 10 so now its just profit (not mega bucks obviously but every little helps). Its a bit of an investment but maybe the government has some schemes or rebates where you are.

I too love our diesel but I think there's some strong arguments for going EV now.

PinkiOcelot · 04/09/2021 14:59

170 miles on a charge is absolutely nothing. My brother lived in Eastbourne ani live in the North East. Couldn’t have visited him on 170 mile charge. Then how long does it take to charge sat at a services? I’m guessing longer than filling with petrol.

DH was talking to an Amazon driver the other day. She told him she gets about 70 miles on a charge and some days doesn’t even get all her deliveries done. Fab, definitely the way forward!!

motherofawhirlwind · 04/09/2021 14:50

@WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll

I'm also concerned about the decreasing in efficiency in the batteries, as happens to every type of rechargeable battery (AFAIA) in existence now. It's all very well quoting the mileage you get per charge when the battery is brand new, but what happens 2, 5, 10 years down the line, when an overnight charge gets you 25 miles?

And that's assuming they never glitch or let you down and/or start showing 'full charge' then suddenly power off after two minutes - as several phones that I've had have done?

Even if you buy one outright, with the expected lifespan of a battery, it's still going to be kind of like leasing it for its useful life, with an otherwise perfectly-working car after a few years but an expensive 'lease renewal' for the next few years with the new battery.

Ours is 8.5 years old and no degradation in the battery capacity so far. Also never had a glitch or been let down.
TheVolturi · 04/09/2021 12:17

But 200k miles, you don't see many cars on the road still running well that have done that? Isn't 10k miles a year about average anyway, so 200k miles would be 20 years.
Ev cars do not use any battery sat in traffic. I sat in mine outside school yesterday with it on, with my phone plugged in it charging while I watched a movie on my phone, it didn't use any battery %.

Bellringer · 04/09/2021 12:03

I think a hybrid charges from some internal system? I'm furious about London emission zone, was hoping for another couple of years from my 12 year old diesel, now forced to trade in. Ecoablism at its finest, thanks sadiq

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 04/09/2021 10:08

Used batteries can be sent to Tesla (even if not Tesla cars), when batteries past their life for the car, they do still contain something like 20% charge.

But what is the life of the car? A good, well-made car should last 25 years before it's ready for scrapping. A PP said 200K miles - I can't believe that they work at 100% capacity for 200K miles and only then suddenly drop to 20%.

Even if that is the case, 20% is basically useless for a functional car, unless you only ever drive around your local area - probably the kind of short journeys that many people say you should consider cycling anyway - and even then, what if you get held up in traffic or have a lengthy diversion because of roadworks or an accident?

MyMummyHasGotABigBottom · 04/09/2021 09:40

@PlanDeRaccordement

YANBU OP

EV is not what we should be moving to. The carbon footprint of production of the EV plus the carbon footprint behind the generation of the electricity, mean it is only marginally better than a diesel with current emissions technology.

We should be moving to hydrogen cars. Much better for environment and much lower carbon footprint.

Yes definitely hydrogen. We have hydrogen buses and I’m sure that will be the next technology.
Brogues · 04/09/2021 09:28

Mumsnutters out in force at the moment Hmm

Selkiesarereal · 04/09/2021 09:14

No it’s not hysterical it is happening and all the manufacturers know this, some are better at their supply chain knowledge than others.

As I said, you an not t against electric cars but we as consumers are being sold a bit of a lie on how green they are and we as consumers should be aware of this to demand change so that we don’t contribute to the horrors elsewhere.

So it will s not hysterical to make people aware. You called me a david ike conspiracy theorist for saying that it happens and I have pointed you in the direction of credible source so maybe do some research before calling me names and making yourself look a bit ignorant.

TheVolturi · 04/09/2021 09:07

If you are talking specifically about cobalt, ev manufacturers are phasing out the use of this. But it will still be used in other batteries like it always has. Your argument about it here solely against evs is a non starter. The countries that use children in the collection of cobalt will always use children for labour for other things, stopping using cobalt will not stop this. Stating that children are raped for ev batteries to be made is hysterical and ridiculous.

Selkiesarereal · 04/09/2021 08:59

@TheVolturi no just the 2019 Nobel peace prize winners and their work putting children back together who have been used in the war in securing cobalt mines.

So don’t be so bloody ignorant about the suffering caused for our cars, phones etc.

Flatdisco · 04/09/2021 08:51

The reason people are correcting you on your milage and the estimated cost @beinglikedisoverrated is because it seems like you are exaggerating for dramatic effect.

TheVolturi · 04/09/2021 08:44

🤦🏻‍♀️🤦🏻‍♀️🙄 Children are raped for the raw materials ev batteries! You'd have to go down a fair few David Icke style rabbit holes to get to that one.

Selkiesarereal · 04/09/2021 08:36

My great concern with this and all the other batteries for things like our smartphones/tablets is where the raw materials come from and the damage this can do to communities in these areas to secure mines, think along child soldiers, rape for people of all ages, yes that does mean very young children, and the impact on the environment in such places.

I do think that electric cars are the future but we need to be a bit more demanding in terms of better supply chains so that we are not contributing to the misery of others.

And yes our governments and businesses g tech companies are very aware of all of this.

Firstbornunicorn · 04/09/2021 08:26

I’ve had an EV for 4 years and it doesn’t cost anything like that. It’s not more than £250 a year and we charge every night.

ElvisPresleyHadABaby · 04/09/2021 08:19

www.nature.com/articles/s41467-019-11654-3

Here is the study detailing how they know it crosses the placenta into unborn babies, and the health consequences that arise.

ElvisPresleyHadABaby · 04/09/2021 08:16

Here is one about the causation of heart disease in adult life attributed to air pollution during gestation:

particleandfibretoxicology.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s12989-019-0301-9

ElvisPresleyHadABaby · 04/09/2021 08:14

particleandfibretoxicology.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s12989-014-0074-0

A study about the effects of diesel particulates on the immune system, will find the one that outlines how these particulates cross the placenta during pregnancy and affect babies before they've even left the womb.

lurkermum · 04/09/2021 08:05

We have electric . It is very cheap to charge. You don’t need to charge it daily and it’s more economical on long distances. We don’t charge at home . But there are so many places you can charge it doesn’t matter . It can take up to an hour to get to 80% ( recommended charge - we have a large battery ) so we go shops or a park with a charger ( car tells you where they all are so do many apps)

As for landfill and batteries . Still better for the environment - batteries are recyclable and can last years - there are no other engine parts that need replacing. At the end of the day cars in general are not a great thing. But the reality is that we need them or are very used to them .

My only argument is that they should be more affordable for everyone to access . I mean much more affordable - they are currently really mostly accessible to wealthier people or better or people . Which is stupid and annoying given they are so cheap to run I think it would make life easier for those that need to run a car but can’t afford one. It is unfair.

Also -stop being weird about diesel - such a non argument - of course electric is better ( even marginally ) …