Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do I tell bf about what he ate?

337 replies

troobleflooble · 03/09/2021 19:55

I'm in a new relationship and he is vegan. While I'm not, I understand and appreciate his viewpoint and want to be respectful of his choices so I've become quite thorough at checking labels on things to make sure they are suitable for him.

Was at his place recently and noticed he had something in his fridge I've never tasted before so I picked it up to have a look. Out of habit I checked the label and noticed that it isn't vegan, in fact it's not even vegetarian! I don't think he has realised as, while he isn't militant about it, I'm sure he wouldn't want to eat it if he knew. The jar was half empty so he has definitely been eating it.

I don't want to make him feel bad by pointing it out but if you were vegan would you want to know? Should I say anything?

OP posts:
oakleaffy · 04/09/2021 19:43

Being Vegan seems quite hard work, and I commend those who can do it.
DS has a vegan GF, and it makes you realise exactly what items have animal products in them.
Soldering requires tallow as a flux, so a strict Vegan couldn't technically even have a traditional stained glass window or door in their house.

However, I do know a vegan who owns rocking horses with horse hair {on hide} manes and tails on them..and leather saddlery, which seems a bit odd.

WinTheNight · 04/09/2021 19:42

I couldn't be bothered with the hassle of dating a vegan.

Lol. Just read this out to my partner who eats meat and he says he loves me being vegan as I don’t steal his food off his plate when we go out for dinner like other women. 🤣
I’m sure I have other good points too. Hmm

ERFFER · 04/09/2021 19:39

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

oakleaffy · 04/09/2021 19:37

Please say it wasn't pickled eggs.

TheStudyOfLife · 04/09/2021 19:36

@speakout

TheStudyOfLife

But then why do you want to wear that badge of moral superiority by calling yourself a vegan? Why the need?

Grin

No one brought up moral superiority, but I'm flattered you think that!

It's not a 'badge of moral superiority' though, even if you do see us that way- it's just an easy way to label food, toiletries etc which takes up less room on the menu or back of the packet than saying "this doesn't contain meat, dairy, beeswax, crushed insects, etc etc".

Honestly, I've never really understood why anyone would be upset that another human chooses not to eat something. You don't have to call yourself vegan, and you can eat what you like. Confused

Unless it's that you don't like feeling morally inferior- but that's an issue intrinsic to you, because no vegan has brought that up or even insinuated it! Smile

WinTheNight · 04/09/2021 19:32

The thing is if someone wants to say I’m not a vegan because I have a phone or whatever, I don’t really care. For the sake of discussions like this or to explain my dietary requirements for an event I’d call myself a vegan. But other than that I don’t really give it a thought. I do everything I can to avoid animal cruelty. I have to have a phone for my job involving animal welfare. There’s not really an alternative. But where there is an alternative like food, toiletries, clothing, household items, I will use the alternative.

speakout · 04/09/2021 19:32

TheStudyOfLife

But then why do you want to wear that badge of moral superiority by calling yourself a vegan? Why the need?

speakout · 04/09/2021 19:29

What animal derivatives are in phones?
Stearates used in adhesive, screens contain animal cholesterol, metal production uses animal additives.
If you are using a smart phone you are using dead animal parts.
mobile-phones.ie/are-smartphones-vegan/

Tealwarrior · 04/09/2021 19:28

What animal derivatives are in phones?

Bits from an elephant perhaps in case a person wants to make a trunk call.

TheStudyOfLife · 04/09/2021 19:27

@speakout

You wouldn't call yourself either because you eat meat and dairy.

No.
And vegans consume animals.

Would love to know what you mean by this.

If it's that you once met someone who said they were vegan, but then ate an ice cream- you can't seriously extrapolate that to mean that everyone who says they are vegan also eats ice cream. That's just nonsense.

If you're still meaning smart phones, I thought I made the reasoning clear, but perhaps not. Veganism is not about perfection. It's about avoiding all animal products as much as is practically possible. For example, meat and dairy are easy to avoid and replace. Likewise animal products in toiletries, and leather shoes. Leather steering wheels are almost impossible to avoid, but vegans still need to be able to work, so most would consider that an unfortunate necessity.

Very happy to answer genuine questions, but this line seems to be getting a bit ridiculous.

CBUK2K2 · 04/09/2021 19:23

I couldn't be bothered with the hassle of dating a vegan.

TowandaForever · 04/09/2021 19:23

@speakout

So you can be a vegan and use a smartphone which contains dead animal derivatives? Can I identify as vegan because I only eat a ham sandwich once a month?
What animal derivatives are in phones?
speakout · 04/09/2021 19:23

You wouldn't call yourself either because you eat meat and dairy.

No.
And vegans consume animals.

Booknooks · 04/09/2021 19:21

I rarely eat dairy or meat, I wou;dn;t drean of calling myself a vegan or a vegetarian. So much posturing and flouncing about, when most vegans are carrying about dead anmal parts in heir phones.

You wouldn't call yourself either because you eat meat and dairy.

TheStudyOfLife · 04/09/2021 19:18

@speakout

So you can be a vegan and use a smartphone which contains dead animal derivatives? Can I identify as vegan because I only eat a ham sandwich once a month?
Hang on, I thought we were allowing vegans to set the standard for veganism?

There's plenty of really great reading online that explains why veganism is a valid label, despite the impossibility of absolute perfection. Your argument is akin to saying 'well, can't avoid all cruelty to animals, so might as well kick a kitten every hour' or 'well, can't avoid all oil usage, so may as well leave every appliance and car running 24/7, and burn a pile of plastic while we're at it'. Bit ridiculous really.

Honestly, vegans are very, very aware that nothing's perfect. We do our best. Feel free to try yourself, or not- fully your choice- but don't bash those who are trying their hardest whilst also trying to be functioning members of society, without harming you.

speakout · 04/09/2021 19:11

So you can be a vegan and use a smartphone which contains dead animal derivatives?
Can I identify as vegan because I only eat a ham sandwich once a month?

TheStudyOfLife · 04/09/2021 19:08

*set by those same vegans, my apologies

TheStudyOfLife · 04/09/2021 19:07

@speakout

think people that say they are vegan who knowingly eat some animal products would come under flexitarian who eat a small quantity. I think we come under that but personally wouldn't use the term because as far as I'm concerned we still do eat some so why would I need a name for it? Vegans and vegetarians need a term for it for when they go out so they have a better chance of finding what they can eat.

Maybe call themselves human?

I rarely eat dairy or meat, I wou;dn;t drean of calling myself a vegan or a vegetarian. So much posturing and flouncing about, when most vegans are carrying about dead anmal parts in heir phones.

I assume you wouldn't call yourself vegan because you do eat meat and dairy, so don't meet vegan standards. Makes sense.

Vegans who do meet vegan standards- which you said yourself are set by those same standards- are welcome to label their diet correctly.

Anitarest · 04/09/2021 19:05

If he bought it and is eating it, it’s his choice.
I’d say nothing. If you don’t mention having noticed it, he can’t ask why you didn’t mention it or take offence at you questioning his food choices. If you were vegan, that’s a different matter.

TheStudyOfLife · 04/09/2021 19:04

@speakout

it's a little unfair to expect vegans to be 100% perfect in every tiny aspect of their lives, or not at all- we're not perfect,

Your own rules though. You vegans set the standards. Why call yorself vegans if you use smartphone or watch TV? I could equally call myself a vegan then because I only eat meat once a month, or sometimes take milk in my coffee. Am I also a vegan that is not 100% perfect?

Great, so if we set the standards- and I agree that makes sense- it's a little odd for omnivores to say that someone who meets vegan standards (avoiding, as far as practically possible, all animal products) isn't vegan.

So I guess we both agree that we can call ourselves vegan- glad that's cleared up!

speakout · 04/09/2021 19:03

think people that say they are vegan who knowingly eat some animal products would come under flexitarian who eat a small quantity. I think we come under that but personally wouldn't use the term because as far as I'm concerned we still do eat some so why would I need a name for it? Vegans and vegetarians need a term for it for when they go out so they have a better chance of finding what they can eat.

Maybe call themselves human?

I rarely eat dairy or meat, I wou;dn;t drean of calling myself a vegan or a vegetarian. So much posturing and flouncing about, when most vegans are carrying about dead anmal parts in heir phones.

speakout · 04/09/2021 19:00

it's a little unfair to expect vegans to be 100% perfect in every tiny aspect of their lives, or not at all- we're not perfect,

Your own rules though. You vegans set the standards. Why call yorself vegans if you use smartphone or watch TV? I could equally call myself a vegan then because I only eat meat once a month, or sometimes take milk in my coffee. Am I also a vegan that is not 100% perfect?

Allinadayswork80 · 04/09/2021 18:58

@GreenTortoise

Maybe he is like Pam from Gavin and Stacey and stuffs his face with ham when no one is looking Grin.

No, in all seriousness just tell him. I'm sure he'll get the vegan equivalent once he knows.

Grin
Beeinalily · 04/09/2021 18:53

You should tell him, and offering to make him a vegan version would be lovely.

wildchild554 · 04/09/2021 18:53

I think people that say they are vegan who knowingly eat some animal products would come under flexitarian who eat a small quantity. I think we come under that but personally wouldn't use the term because as far as I'm concerned we still do eat some so why would I need a name for it? Vegans and vegetarians need a term for it for when they go out so they have a better chance of finding what they can eat.