Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think NHS Staff have got amazing terms and conditions?

211 replies

backoffice · 03/09/2021 11:59

I've left the NHS to go back to the private sector after 15 years. I've been reflecting a lot on my time in the NHS and something in particular that has struck me time and again are the great terms and conditions that really get people stuck in the service, so they can't leave.

In my organisation over 1/3 of staff were Band 7 or above (40-45k). Many had been in the service for many years. Statistically almost half of NHS staff are earning over 31k (band 6 or above).

The pension accrual at this level is the equivalent of an additional £15-20k contributions on top of the salary if you were buying on the open market (I'm assuming around 1k p.a. for a Band 7 into the defined benefits scheme). So that's around 1/2 NHS staff with a package of around 50k.

These benefits are really significant - especially outside of London or other cities. And staff who perform very poorly cannot really be removed from the service - the unions are very strong and the processes are huge. I managed out one person but it ended up with a criminal case - i.e. the person committed a crime and I was still struggling to get rid of them.

I needed to leave the NHS for my mental health - the whole service is so traumatised - but the financial benefits of working there far, far outweigh anything in the private sector. Most staff are, I think, basically trapped. AIBU?

OP posts:
wewereliars · 03/09/2021 13:15

Backoffice yes YABU What is it wth these race to bottom threads!

And Unison has no more power than any other union, ie sod all

Feelingmardy · 03/09/2021 13:14

I think it you look at the level of responsibility people at the higher bands have, this will not be such a stark comparison with the private sector. In addition the levels and amounts of training needed to get to higher levels also may compare favourably with the private sector. You may be comparing apples and pears. Many higher band workers could earn mor in private work but they don't leave the NHS due to a commitment to its principles.

NerrSnerr · 03/09/2021 13:13

I work for the NHS as a band 6 nurse. It is hugely stressful right now but do agree that the benefits are good. There is very good sick pay, maternity terms, carers leave etc. Pension is decent too. Private sector nursing is a lot worse when it comes to terms and conditions.

toomuchlaundry · 03/09/2021 13:11

Sick pay and maternity pay are better than many private sector jobs too, from what I have read on other threads

motheroftwoboys · 03/09/2021 13:11

my DH works half time as a peer support worker in mental health services. He is - and can never rise above - a Band 3. His job is massively important and stressful and yet he earns buttons. He works way and above and is always there for his clients. Good terms and conditions? Utter rubbish.

ElenaGilbertsDaylightRing · 03/09/2021 13:10

@Kithic nurses are not medical professionals, we are nursing professionals

FizziWater · 03/09/2021 13:10

I agree where it concerns admin and managers and specialist / research nurses, not so much with nurses, cleaners, porters HCAs etc.
I worked in a hospital in the NHS for years, in admin. Managers were untrained and unskilled, recruited internally, often from clinical roles. Often totally out of their depth but taking refuge in talking in cliched management speak.
Research nurses were paid huge amounts, worked strictly 9 to 5 and seemed to be somewhat under employed.
My own working conditions were super flexible and the pay and pension were decent for what I did.
On the other hand, clinical and other staff on wards run ragged day and night with zero flexibility and that was pre-covid.

NotAnotherAlias · 03/09/2021 13:10

“I needed to leave the NHS for my mental health - the whole service is so traumatised“

I think you’ve answered your own question there. No, the remuneration isn’t sufficient given the conditions of work. The package was clearly not enough to compensate for what was expected of you.

I’ve worked as a senior doctor in NHS and private organisations. I’ve always been paid more (including taking account of pension) outside the NHS with more autonomy and fewer day to day hassles.

backoffice · 03/09/2021 13:09

@kithic Doctors are medical. Nurses are clinical.

OP posts:
LegendaryReady · 03/09/2021 13:09
Grin

Are people really going to argue that pay being so good they can't leave their job is a problem?

traintraveller · 03/09/2021 13:09

I think the NHS offers a fair salary and that the annual leave, sick pay and other leave policies are brilliant. The pension while poorer than in previous years is still good. However the conditions to work in, workload and stress etc are awful. I don't think people are trapped as such but they are very aware that the package they get is unlikely to be replicated in the private sector.

salviapages · 03/09/2021 13:09

This is such a weird way to look at it. These kids of benefits are to incentivise people to work for the NHS because it is such a tough job. It's a reward not a 'trap'. If you leave yes you take a pay cut but you'll also be leaving for an easier job that is less demanding and takes less of a toll on your mental health, that's the trade off. Imagine rewarding people for doing a difficult job and then calling that reward a trap...?

Plumtree391 · 03/09/2021 13:07

Ex NHS and private here, now retired. I know what you mean.

You are right to put your mental health first at the moment though.

Kithic · 03/09/2021 13:00

@Onandoff

Admin staff have it good. PAs are paid the same as a staff nurse. There are a great many admin pen pushers, supervisors and managers on band 6/7/8 pay.

Non medical clinical staff have a terrible deal, especially nurses the vast majority of whom are stuck on band 5 pay. Soon after the first job the pay performs terribly alongside other graduate professions. The NHS is a monopoly employer so for the majority you accept the pay or leave the profession. Yes there is paid sick leave but no one wants to go off sick alongside terrible staffing and a bullying culture. The pension has been eroded and the government are only just responding to the unlawful changes they implemented. Staffing is awful, if the t&c were that great why are we desperate for staff?

DH (graduate, private sector, non medical, far fewer quals) is now on 4 x my pay and when we graduated we earned the same, perhaps I out earned him. He would agree his job is far easier than mine with a lot fewer hours and less responsibility.

please excuse my ignorance, Non medical clinical staff have a terrible deal, especially nurses how are nurses non medical?
legoriakelne · 03/09/2021 12:58

@backoffice

I don't mean this as a NHS bashing thread at all - just that I think a lot of people are really stuck: the service is currently horrible to work in, but the pay cut needed to leave is really stopping people from leaving.

(Although I would recommend it!!)

I disagree with the notion that we should feel pity for people "trapped" by their fantastic employment terms. Hmm

That's actually quite offensive.

Auroreforet · 03/09/2021 12:58

@HowToMurderYourLife

I disagree with your point on not being able to get rid of useless staff due to strong unions. Generally they don’t get rid of useless staff as no one can pull their finger out and follow the correct procedure in a timely manner. I seen people be suspended for investigation on full pay and 6 months later absolutely nothing has been done, meaning any dismissal would then be unfair. You could say that they are also incompetent.
Absolutely. My manager pointed out, very accurately, that it's easier to get rid of a verruca than a member of staff. I was asked to retrain someone who was quite honestly useless. She's still there, 12 years later doing half a job.
3cats4poniesandababy · 03/09/2021 12:53

Thing with the pension arguemebt is many in the private sector put in the same percentages but in private sector they are typically paying into defined contribution pensions whereas most NHS (and many public sector in general) are paying into defined benefit pensions. So while paying the same percentage on is much better than the other - defined benefit is far superior in almost all circumstances.

I don't think the NHS packages are always bad. Some could do with tweaking but many of the issues are nothing to do with the package.

Someone mentioned a bullying culture and of course that is wrong. But many private sector companies have a bullying culture and no amount of money fixes that. Raising my salary by £5k a year doesn't make it okay to be bullied.

legoriakelne · 03/09/2021 12:52

Don't forget the incredibly generous sickness pay that is exquisitely rare in private sector.

I mean, which patient doesn't love their NHS healthcare professional going all Marie Antoinette on them and telling them to "just take sick leave" to attend appointments or to take longer off work with the good ol' "your health is more important than a job". Yeh, mate, but unlike you for me that means not being able to pay the bills and potentially becoming homeless, which has pretty poor health outcomes.

The package is far far better than anything the vast majority of private sector workers will ever come close to seeing.

Any NHS worker claiming otherwise needs a swift reality check.

Ivory towers.

Gardenwalldilema · 03/09/2021 12:51

I don't see it as a trap that the terms are good, it's just a fact.
I'm a band 8, and could probably earn 10k more in the local private hospital, but my package would be worth less. The private job may well appeal to someone younger and carefree who wants more money in their pocket each month. As I'm a boring middle aged woman with dc I'm more concerned about pension, sick pay, job security etc.
Horses for courses

JudgeRindersMinder · 03/09/2021 12:51

I’m public sector although not NHS, and I think there are a lot in the public sector in general don’t know they’re born, when compared with the private sector(massive generalisation obviously!)

jimmyhill · 03/09/2021 12:47

I think a lot of people are really stuck: the service is currently horrible to work in, but the pay cut needed to leave is really stopping people from leaving.

Or... It can be a horrible stressful place to work. So the NHS offers salaries which compensate for that in order to retain staff???

You are not exactly describing a problem here

jimmyhill · 03/09/2021 12:45

Good. They deserve it.

backoffice · 03/09/2021 12:41

I don't mean this as a NHS bashing thread at all - just that I think a lot of people are really stuck: the service is currently horrible to work in, but the pay cut needed to leave is really stopping people from leaving.

(Although I would recommend it!!)

OP posts:
backoffice · 03/09/2021 12:39

There are a great many admin pen pushers, supervisors and managers on band 6/7/8 pay.

But a 'great many' (if not the majority) or those are clinical staff - so nurses etc. Clinical leadership is the model now - so they are really roles that nurses etc. have moved into, in the main.

OP posts:
backoffice · 03/09/2021 12:38

The average salary for an NHS employee is around £27k with a pension contribution rate of around 20% which is £5400. so total package is averaging around £32k in total.

This isn't correct. Yes, the average pay is 27k+ - outside of London that is very reasonable. Average pay in my town is just over 20k.

The pension contribution is also irrelevant. You add 1/54 to your NHS pension for each year of contribution. For a salary of 27k that is around £500 a year - on the open market, you'd need around 15k to buy that annuity. So the package is still ON AVERAGE worth 42k for the average NHS staff member.

That is HUGE.

OP posts: