Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think NHS Staff have got amazing terms and conditions?

211 replies

backoffice · 03/09/2021 11:59

I've left the NHS to go back to the private sector after 15 years. I've been reflecting a lot on my time in the NHS and something in particular that has struck me time and again are the great terms and conditions that really get people stuck in the service, so they can't leave.

In my organisation over 1/3 of staff were Band 7 or above (40-45k). Many had been in the service for many years. Statistically almost half of NHS staff are earning over 31k (band 6 or above).

The pension accrual at this level is the equivalent of an additional £15-20k contributions on top of the salary if you were buying on the open market (I'm assuming around 1k p.a. for a Band 7 into the defined benefits scheme). So that's around 1/2 NHS staff with a package of around 50k.

These benefits are really significant - especially outside of London or other cities. And staff who perform very poorly cannot really be removed from the service - the unions are very strong and the processes are huge. I managed out one person but it ended up with a criminal case - i.e. the person committed a crime and I was still struggling to get rid of them.

I needed to leave the NHS for my mental health - the whole service is so traumatised - but the financial benefits of working there far, far outweigh anything in the private sector. Most staff are, I think, basically trapped. AIBU?

OP posts:
NoIDontWatchLoveIsland · 03/09/2021 13:45

I think many people in the NHS/education etc on defined benefit pension schemes dont realise just what a huge part of the remuneration they are. My private employer DC scheme is considered good, yet on a high wage (90k basic) the value of pension contributions I get annually is lower than the defined benefit received by someone earning 30k in nursing.

More should be done to advertise just how much DB schemes cost the NHS to provide.

Halfaham · 03/09/2021 13:45

Ex NHS here. It is well paid and the holidays are generous. I couldn't believe back office staff got 7 week's holiday at starting point, even though they don't work bank holidays. But imho you get treated badly. I have opted to earn a lot less somewhere else.

sst1234 · 03/09/2021 13:44

This is the problem with the public sector full stop. Poor performance, attendance is not managed well. And the expectation of endless investment is unreasonable. It is a structural problem rather than anything that individuals can be blamed for.
People working in public sector take offense to this but it not about their individual role.

user823445234 · 03/09/2021 13:43

"NHS hospitals, mental health services and community providers are now reporting a shortage of nearly 84,000 FTE staff, severely affecting key groups such as nurses, midwives and health visitors."

‘Undervalued’ nurses depart, leaving NHS with staffing shortage
www.ft.com/content/f2ace7d9-59ce-406c-9db6-a844e6806e05

At least now you have educated us to what a gravy-train being a nurse is, the service will be inundated with trainees and those returning to practice (NOT)

user1497207191 · 03/09/2021 13:43

@user823445234

Blue Light Card, NHS Black Card, discounts in stores These 'discounts' are no different the discounts available to everyone on Vouchercodes. Just marketing schemes to get people to spend money, just the same as signing up to Vouchercodes/Hotdeals etc. Nothing different or extra at all.
Do supermarkets offer similar discounts enjoyed by NHS workers to others via vouchercodes/hotdeals etc??
Peachee · 03/09/2021 13:42

The integrity in the NHS is second to none and that’s what needs protecting.. too many loop holes and people doing jobs for the wrong reasons (ie greed) in the private sector. That’s what’s so worrying about it being privatised..

Zilla1 · 03/09/2021 13:42

As @user823445234 says, we can't recruit PNs and ANPs which is odd given the amazing pay and benefits on offer. FWIW, I think the English NHS underpays significantly given the training and responsibility which is why we see significant recruitment and retention problems and too many of my colleagues are still working their escape plans for emigration and change of career to leave health entirely. We've seen GP practices hand back entire contacts and close (beyond the small practice retirement) which I've not seen happen before.

user1497207191 · 03/09/2021 13:41

@HarrietOh

Never understand the bashing of admin workers 'back office/pen pushers' etc. Without them the medical and clinical staff couldn't do their jobs.
I think it's the inefficiency/incompetence of SOME of the pen pushers/management that's the problem. We all know that front line staff (in whatever profession) need back office support and management. Unfortunately, there seems to be the opinion from front line medical staff and patients that the admin support in the NHS is actually pretty crap in a lot of areas, that's more of a hindrance than a benefit.
randomsabreuse · 03/09/2021 13:39

Sick leave is the big one. Registrar could not take in that DH was employed but desperate to return to work following a work caused broken arm because he (vet) had 2 weeks of sick pay... Zero idea that once could be employed but get minimal/no sick pay, possibly because he knew that the training/expertise were similar...

NursieBernard · 03/09/2021 13:39

Well done on the propaganda, keep it up and the Daily Fail might pick it up.

user1497207191 · 03/09/2021 13:39

@NotAnotherAlias

“I needed to leave the NHS for my mental health - the whole service is so traumatised“

I think you’ve answered your own question there. No, the remuneration isn’t sufficient given the conditions of work. The package was clearly not enough to compensate for what was expected of you.

I’ve worked as a senior doctor in NHS and private organisations. I’ve always been paid more (including taking account of pension) outside the NHS with more autonomy and fewer day to day hassles.

But just paying someone more, doesn't "cure" the mental health problem does it?

The real answer is to deal with the stress, long hours, culture etc. That way, you'll stop people leaving.

Money alone isn't the answer.

user823445234 · 03/09/2021 13:37

Blue Light Card, NHS Black Card, discounts in stores
These 'discounts' are no different the discounts available to everyone on Vouchercodes.
Just marketing schemes to get people to spend money, just the same as signing up to Vouchercodes/Hotdeals etc.
Nothing different or extra at all.

Zilla1 · 03/09/2021 13:37

I'll lket others judge whether you've pitched anecdata and estimates bundled under an 'amazing' badge but to look at it in the roune, you might want to state:
the % full time and % part time as you seem to be putting out FT figures and I thought the NHS has a significant PT workforce;
the mode and median AfC band of NHS staff (need to check but was this around Band 5 and 6 - was this Band 5 NQ to Staff nurse with experience, Band 6 nursing specialist having done additional training)
the employer's contribution rate (was this 20%?);
the average pension payment to retirees which I thought was less than £5000 the last time I looked. Skewed to reflect the PT and actual careers I expect.

Amazing.

user823445234 · 03/09/2021 13:35

And it were so super duper, why are there tens of thousands of unfilled positions?
Could it be that the working conditions are totally horrendous and actually for these posts you need to be highly skilled and highly qualified.
Staff shortages don't occur if the positions are overpaid.

Gingernaut · 03/09/2021 13:33

The terms and conditions, the pensions and staff 'perks' (Blue Light Card, NHS Black Card, discounts in stores) are better than in the private sector - definitely

However, what's being asked of medical staff is a huge difference to the workplaces of private staff.

It can be wearing, harrowing and deeply upsetting on a daily basis.

The point was, that the staff employment conditions would be better, because the pay and working conditions were shit.

Many of the lower band support staff are on the very bottom of Band 2, part time and sometimes on fixed or zero hours contracts

HR departments are notoriously poor - slow recruitment times, lack of accountability and poor mentoring and anti-bullying procedures

The expectation that someone from a clinical background is also a good mentor, tutor and manager is laughable - yet senior clinical staff are expected to be on boards, in upper management, lead teams and lay down policies as well as mentoring in their specialism.

The NHS is not, overall, a good employer for many of the lower bands, clinical or support.

No mentoring, very little training and managers absent in meetings a lot of the time.

HarrietOh · 03/09/2021 13:33

Never understand the bashing of admin workers 'back office/pen pushers' etc. Without them the medical and clinical staff couldn't do their jobs.

FrownedUpon · 03/09/2021 13:32

The pension is extremely valuable. Amazingly I know NHS staff who have opted out of the pension which is crazy. Stress levels are really high though.

user823445234 · 03/09/2021 13:31

YABU - those band 7's and above whose salary you are begrudging will either have a masters or will be working toward one.
They will have very significant clinical responsibilities and/or very significant management responsibilities (managing huge budgets or huge numbers of staff).

For their qualifications and experience, they are vastly underpaid compared to teachers will the same levels of qualifications and the same levels of extra responsibilities.

Nurses do not get paid extra for every extra responsibility they take on, unlike teachers (e.g. in addition to their normal role, a senior nurse might also be responsible for recruitment, teaching, supplies or the whole department's rota, for no extra money).

Plus some of them get to risk their lives treating highly infectious Covid patients in inadequate PPE (which is lower grade than the general public have to wear to the supermarket in Germany, and in the USA they must wear FFP3 masks, while in the UK FFP1 is all you get).

Plus the added bonus of a dose of PTSD for many after treating thousands of Covid patients, seeing hundreds die, in the past 18 months.

Plus the opportunities to acquire every new variant of Covid, but that's OK because you are vaccinated so hopefully fingers crossed you will be OK, after all if you weren't one of the 1500 health and social care staff who DIED from Covid in the past 18 months, your chances are not too bad, just don't mention the Long Covid...

YABVVVVVU

CarrotTops · 03/09/2021 13:29

I would say the benefits are reasonable. Just because employers don't offer it in the private sector doesn't mean that they are excessive

The pay is not particularly great. You have to take into account unsociable hours, risk involved amount of work done, qualifications etc

Personally I could earn a lot more in the private sector. A nurse in my area would earn less but that does not mean the NHS benefits are fantastic, more that a lot of private companies take the piss.

bogoffmda · 03/09/2021 13:29

backoffice - wtf
doctors are medical and nurses are clinical

No - doctors, nurses physios ots etc are clinical

And this is absolutely an NHS bashing thread.

QueenHofScotland · 03/09/2021 13:28

It’s the same in local authority social work. People get stuck because the third sector pay far less with less benefits.

backoffice · 03/09/2021 13:27

@motheroftwoboys I think the PSW roles are immoral, tbh. Without wanting to out myself, I got into some significant fights about this. They shouldn’t be employing people as Band 3s in those roles. So much wrong with it.

OP posts:
elbea · 03/09/2021 13:21

@Onandoff PA’s get paid quite a lot, NHS or not. I worked as a PA for a high net worth despite being qualified as a surveyor. My salary was £60,000pa in my 20s. I’d imagine if I’d stayed I had the potential to earn a lot more.

Emmacb82 · 03/09/2021 13:20

The pension is a joke. Unless I want to work ragged until I’m 68, I will lose 40% if I take it early. So no, not a brilliant benefit for everyone.

Biolo · 03/09/2021 13:16

Yabu! Okay, some staff are a waste of space but you get that in private companies too (usually the ones with the gift of the gab).

You know how much extra work to keep up with HCPC registration and further education we are made to do?? And membership of professional bodies. I can’t progress to the next band without spending all of my spare time studying to achieve some piece of paper they want.
It’s very underpaid for the amount of responsibility you have and education/training you need.
When I was band 3 it took me a year to be trained because the job was so complex, and it was also an unofficial requirement to have a degree - they never hire anyone without one.