Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think NHS Staff have got amazing terms and conditions?

211 replies

backoffice · 03/09/2021 11:59

I've left the NHS to go back to the private sector after 15 years. I've been reflecting a lot on my time in the NHS and something in particular that has struck me time and again are the great terms and conditions that really get people stuck in the service, so they can't leave.

In my organisation over 1/3 of staff were Band 7 or above (40-45k). Many had been in the service for many years. Statistically almost half of NHS staff are earning over 31k (band 6 or above).

The pension accrual at this level is the equivalent of an additional £15-20k contributions on top of the salary if you were buying on the open market (I'm assuming around 1k p.a. for a Band 7 into the defined benefits scheme). So that's around 1/2 NHS staff with a package of around 50k.

These benefits are really significant - especially outside of London or other cities. And staff who perform very poorly cannot really be removed from the service - the unions are very strong and the processes are huge. I managed out one person but it ended up with a criminal case - i.e. the person committed a crime and I was still struggling to get rid of them.

I needed to leave the NHS for my mental health - the whole service is so traumatised - but the financial benefits of working there far, far outweigh anything in the private sector. Most staff are, I think, basically trapped. AIBU?

OP posts:
CBUK2K2 · 03/09/2021 16:09

I've said this for year, every few months there will be some campaign that nurses are underpaid and must be paid more. My two standard responses to this are:

1)There pay is on par with other similar professions (teacher, solicitor etc).

  1. If you don't like to pay don't do it, no one is making you.
Bunnycat101 · 03/09/2021 16:07

Most people in the public sector don’t realise the value of their pension. It is a massive benefit but if you’re a 23 year old nurse with high cost of living, you’re probably not going to be valuing the prospect of the pension if you’re struggling day to day.

But… it really is massive and would cost a fortune to replicate with a private pot.

supermoonrising · 03/09/2021 15:58

@Hoowhoowho
Honestly it matters not whether you pay the same, more or less than the private sector or whether the package is excellent or really poor. It only matters whether it’s good enough to attract adequate staff and it clearly isn’t

Same thing could be said for teachers, though etc. Teaching has a crazy staff turnover, something like 50% quit in the first five years. The issue is, the public sector offers the salary and gets the resultant quality which The Public is prepared to pay/vote for.

Millions in the UK are already living hand to mouth/unable to get optheir own house, and so those people will not entertain the idea of further tax increases. Meanwhile no Political Party now has the balls to only raise taxes on high earners ( well, Corbyn was entertaining a small top rate increase, raising the top rate from 45%-50% or something, for which he was labelled a communist and told that everyone making 50k+ would Flee the Country rather than pay an extra grand or so in annual income tax to pay for schools with better teachers/ smaller class sizes/ hospital beds / non burned out staff etc)

ElephantOfRisk · 03/09/2021 15:50

I agree re T&Cs but actually the pension is a bit shit, but then newer private pensions are also a bit shit. Holidays and parental leave are good as is paid sick leave etc.

My DH is top of his scale on about £25k though so pay can be pretty poor. A lot of staff have never worked in private sector so don't really have anything to compare it to.

Blossomtoes · 03/09/2021 15:41

A few high earners will be bumping up the average for all the porters etc

Exactly this. Consultants are on well in excess of £100k, they bump the average up massively.

Gingernaut · 03/09/2021 15:40

Ward clerks have a massive responsibility.

Receptionist, responsible for the care and security of files, having to message and contact relatives, consultants, physios, SALT, discharge teams and keep an eye on wandering patients who may be confused and aggressive.

They have to book follow up appointments, admit and discharge patients, print out letters and information and keep on top of a never ending pile of paperwork and requests from staff.

That job is full on from the get go.

Toddlerteaplease · 03/09/2021 15:31

@Onandoff I don't know where you get that idea from. Our ward receptionist is the most important person on the ward. She's indispensable. She's only a band 2. If we are short of nurses we just get another. We really struggle without our receptionist!

joolzfromyork · 03/09/2021 15:30

I think perhaps you have this whole thing 'arse about face'

Conditions in the NHS are not fabulous ...

Conditions in private industry suck ... big time fucking suck

(I spose I could post a long piece about how much better things are - generally speaking - in the EU but cant be arsed dealing with the Sovereignty/Borders/Refugees/illegal immigrants shit that would be posted in response).

We really should all get decent terms and conditions ...

lannistunut · 03/09/2021 15:28

The NHS has a retention crisis currently, so presumably many people don't feel trapped.

Hoowhoowho · 03/09/2021 15:26

If pay and conditions were so good, there wouldn’t be a chronic and ongoing shortage of clinical staff.

Honestly it matters not whether you pay the same, more or less than the private sector or whether the package is excellent or really poor. It only matters whether it’s good enough to attract adequate staff and it clearly isn’t.

A good number of newly qualified nurses and midwives never practice at all. Why would they, they owe the NHS nothing when it fails to support their training and uses them as unpaid labour for three years.
Qualified staff meanwhile leave in droves, those who remain reduce hours or go off sick. Many take early retirement. Some come back and work bank and agency shifts, it would have been so much cheaper to keep those staff.

Pay is just one aspect of this but it does matter. Staff are less likely to jump ship when the pay is too good to lose. Despite what you say clearly few feel trapped by the pay because there is a constant, ongoing loss of staff

Bakewellisntjustacake · 03/09/2021 15:19

I'm band 6 so on 32k, but I'm a highly trained advanced nurse practitioner and can prescribe etc. Most of the nurses on my old unit were band 5, so between 25k and 30k but that's after 3 years of uni and a lot of training. The worst paid are actually non trained HCAs who will be on 18k (actually 18005) who take blood, do observations, feed patients, bathe patients, talk to them etc.

The back bone of the ward is a good hca who you'd trust with your life; I have to be sure my hcas know what a bad set of obs looks like and will tell me if they think anything is 'off' they also stock up so we have everything to hand to do our jobs properly. They are the ones who deserve a proper pay rise.

I really feel for them at the moment working 40+ hours a week back breaking work for less than 9.20 an hour, we've had a massive amount of hcas leave our trust recently because they can get more in Tesco and people in Tesco don't spit at you

Gingernaut · 03/09/2021 15:09

Qualified nurses aren't in that short a supply, but many are burnt out, have family commitments that require part time working or have injured themselves on the job and can't go back to what they were doing.

Student nurse drop out rates are appalling and it's not hard to see why - studying for a hard university degree, working on the wards and trying to keep body and soul together is one very hard slog.

There are no nurses' halls of residence, so rent or mortgages have to be factored in, the work, both academic and physical is gruelling and in spite of the NHS making it financially easier with bursaries, it's a massive shock to a student's system.

Peachee · 03/09/2021 15:07

@watchwithinterest the post above was supposed to be tagged for you sorry..

Peachee · 03/09/2021 15:06

I don’t dispute this. Sorry you’ve had an awful time..
I think there are people that do a lot of good though and I just hope the good outweighs the bad..

ashmts · 03/09/2021 14:56

[quote backoffice]@ashmts I was surprised too but I googled it. There are quite a few spreadsheet breakdowns and FOIs online. On phone atm but if you can’t find it I can look later.[/quote]
I found this FOI request www.whatdotheyknow.com/request/numbers_of_nhs_staff_on_nhs_pay

And it suggests that there are almost twice as many staff on bands 1-5 as on 6+. Average pay might be 34k but that'll be mean. A few high earners will be bumping up the average for all the porters etc. It just doesn't make sense anyway, so much of the NHS workforce are nurses and they're mainly band 5.

Kakser · 03/09/2021 14:40

@NoIDontWatchLoveIsland

Kakser There are lots of responsibility points with extra pay attached in primary schools (lots of teachers in my family) so that's not true. Training up new staff is part of the job in many many occupations
Well in many primary schools it really is true, especially small ones. That was just one example of an extra responsibility. There is simply not the budget so no TLRs available. The biggest TLR in a primary school is generally £2.5k if you're lucky. In a rural school, this is what you'd get for the huge responsibility of being in charge of the school several days a week when the head is not there (in the case of a head with multiple schools). Anyway, off topic but just pointing out pay and conditions isn't always exactly as it seems!
BeenAsFarAsMercyAndGrand · 03/09/2021 14:39

I agree re: the conditions being terrible btw. My pay is decent for the work I do, but the conditions (chronic under-resourcing) are dire and making me ill.

PuppyFeet · 03/09/2021 14:39

The being 'trapped' due to ts and cs can happen in any organisation and is more of a personal state of mind. In my own career I have been in that situation twice and each time have made the decision to take short term pain for longer term gain i.e less salary and benefits as I know the move will help me in the long term regain salary/pension and career satisfaction... it's a hard but personal choice and depends where the balance lands in each person's life.

On the topic of the NHS particularly, I cannot comment as have never worked for them... but I am currently undergoing treatment for cancer and the care, support, and personal engagement I have received during this journey has been remarkable and everyone who I have been in contact with from admin support to specialist nurses to oncology specialists has been worth their weight in gold... (and I imagine their ts and cs).

NotAnotherAlias · 03/09/2021 14:38

@user1497207191 I agree money isn’t the whole answer to that problem, however you can’t claim someone is paid generously when the conditions they work in are sufficiently intolerable that people leave and work elsewhere and there are huge staff shortages despite the level of the compensation on offer.

BeenAsFarAsMercyAndGrand · 03/09/2021 14:37

@backoffice

According to this: digital.nhs.uk/data-and-information/publications/statistical/nhs-staff-earnings-estimates/march-2021

Average pay across the NHS is actually now nearly 34k. (44k in CCGs!!)

I'm not sure why the shock about average pay in CCGs. CCGs don't have many low-paid staff because of the nature of the organisation and what they do. They don't need porters or HCAs.

Similarly, NHS England will have a vastly different staffing profile to a hospital trust.

Hospital Trusts have a huge workforce of band 5 nurses and HCAs - the average pay is therefore lower than the bits of the NHS which deal with law/contracting etc.

godmum56 · 03/09/2021 14:34

@backoffice

Tbf I would like to go back - but I want a few years elsewhere first, and wouldn’t take on capability management/change management on a large scale again.
I quite enjoyed it (capability management/change management) would have stayed on had I been younger and not had family responsibilities (not children, oldies)
Whoopy · 03/09/2021 14:32

I agree with you op, but would also put local government employees in the same bracket as nhs employees. The terms and conditions are so much better than in the private sector and in many cases the wages are much better too. I was a nurse and worked very hard for okay wages, but the incentive to stay in the nhs was the great maternity, special leave and sickness benefits (not that I ever needed the sickness part).

The job security is another bonus as well, though not for those of us that had to work with sub standard colleagues! I had an alcoholic manager who, when reported as under the influence of alcohol at work, was moved into another non patient position and kept on the same wage band (despite her new colleagues being 2 grades below). Don’t think that would have happened in the private sector!

herecomesthsun · 03/09/2021 14:31

So well paid and such good conditions that they can't get staff?

watchwithinterest · 03/09/2021 14:30

@Peachee

The integrity in the NHS is second to none and that’s what needs protecting.. too many loop holes and people doing jobs for the wrong reasons (ie greed) in the private sector. That’s what’s so worrying about it being privatised..
This simply is not true. There have been appalling scandals in the NHS and utterly disgusting, inhuman official responses by the NHS to these.

Did you read the evidence gathered in the Staffordshire Hospital scandal? Or hear the doctor who whistle blew on the scandal of babies dying in heart operations due to an incompetent surgeon - he had to move abroad to find work as he became unemployable in the - his actions literally saved the lives of the babies and small children and that made him unemployable. No organisation with an ounce of integrity would treat such a person like that. Did you hear the official response of the hospital were a man with mental health problems died of dehydration in hospital and his distress at being terribly thirsty was seen as challenging behaviour instead of giving him a drink. Instead of falling over themselves with apology and committing to learn lessons, they simply asserted what a great hospital they are and how most people get really good care.

I have had terrible treatment at the hands of the NHS with a chronic condition and, when I was told my baby was non-viable and a termination was being arranged for ( turns out they had failed to record my dates correctly that's all), and I can tell you that the NHS is an organisation obsessed with never admitting fault regardless of the distress this causes to already distressed people, and regardless how this leads to them failing to learn and improve.

We have to stop this ridiculous lionisation of the NHS so that we can actually take a hard look at its faults and work to improve them.

I worked in social care for years. I saw brilliant services in the private sector, terrible ones in the third and charitable sector and vice versa.
It really taught me that it is not the ownership, public, private or third sector which leads to an organisation being a good or bad provider.

backoffice · 03/09/2021 14:30

According to this: digital.nhs.uk/data-and-information/publications/statistical/nhs-staff-earnings-estimates/march-2021

Average pay across the NHS is actually now nearly 34k. (44k in CCGs!!)

OP posts: