Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think NHS Staff have got amazing terms and conditions?

211 replies

backoffice · 03/09/2021 11:59

I've left the NHS to go back to the private sector after 15 years. I've been reflecting a lot on my time in the NHS and something in particular that has struck me time and again are the great terms and conditions that really get people stuck in the service, so they can't leave.

In my organisation over 1/3 of staff were Band 7 or above (40-45k). Many had been in the service for many years. Statistically almost half of NHS staff are earning over 31k (band 6 or above).

The pension accrual at this level is the equivalent of an additional £15-20k contributions on top of the salary if you were buying on the open market (I'm assuming around 1k p.a. for a Band 7 into the defined benefits scheme). So that's around 1/2 NHS staff with a package of around 50k.

These benefits are really significant - especially outside of London or other cities. And staff who perform very poorly cannot really be removed from the service - the unions are very strong and the processes are huge. I managed out one person but it ended up with a criminal case - i.e. the person committed a crime and I was still struggling to get rid of them.

I needed to leave the NHS for my mental health - the whole service is so traumatised - but the financial benefits of working there far, far outweigh anything in the private sector. Most staff are, I think, basically trapped. AIBU?

OP posts:
whoopsnomore · 03/09/2021 17:19

@Zilla1 yes, there's the "social Care " Plan which was supposedly ready 2 years ago, now about to be announced and funded by a 2% NI increase.

Which will provoke upset as it affects younger and lower paid people than a tax rise.

Then the government say "ah well the NHS is such a drain we could make it more efficient by ..."
Then sell off and "outsource" more of it to their paymasters and the US financed Big Business...who then employ people like PP's son on exploitative contracts...

bogoffmda · 03/09/2021 17:18

Blossomtoes - most consultants are not on 100K +

Starting salary is 82K and will take 15 yrs to get to 100K for the majority

That is after 6/7 yrs med school 10+ yrs of specialist training and few higher degrees thrown in. Most are in the range of a Band 8d manager to put it in context. Our band 8d manager is 34!

Gingernaut · 03/09/2021 17:09

Like @DobbyIsAFreeElf, I have a hard time understanding the discrepancies between the different jobs, even at the same level.

Band 2 cleaners are on the same band as me - while I work in a clean environment, in layers of protective clothing, sterilizing and cleaning pharmaceutical production rooms, setting up the next day's production lines, they're in polo shirts, doing regular cleaning.

HCAs have tough routines and are paid the same as the cleaners and catering staff

Ward clerks are also Band 2, but do so much more than the average admin assistant.

Health records clerks are no in charge of clinics, instead of just collecting, replacing and picking files for clinics and wards.

The unfairness of some of the pay bands creates resentment.

WombatChocolate · 03/09/2021 17:04

People in both private and public sector don’t understand the differences between the defined benefit pensions (public sector) and defined contribution pensions used in private sector.

In the NHS, the employee will be paying in around 8% and the employer around 24%. The employer figure is significantly more than most private sector employers pay.

The key though is what you get out. £27k salary a year in NHS boosts the yearly pension by £500 per year. Lots of people hear that and aren’t impressed. But what they don’t realise is the cost of buying that in terms of a defined contribution ones in pot…..it would require contributions to the pension pot of about £15-20k…..and very few people add that to their pensions each year and certainly not those earning £27k.

This difference in pension provision is VAST.
Someone who earns £27k and works 40 years will have £20k pension. That assumes no inflation or pay rises….but because these will exist, the pension will be far higher.

Someone needs over £500k in their pension pot to generate this. The average pension has about £70k in their pot when they retire.

The sick pay, death in service pay and holiday pay are also very good. There will also be compassionate leave and other flexibilities, including ability to work part-time and flexibly in some jobs.

None of this is saying it’s undeserved for the job itself isn’t bloody hard. It’s just a comment in the terms and conditions of employment.

Civil servants, teachers, fire workers, etc all have similar pension provision which is excellent in relation to the private sector.

People generally have very poor knowledge about pensions in all sectors. Those in the public sector don’t realise how good their pensions are. Those in the private sector often don’t realise how poor theirs are, or the amounts they would need to put into them to have anything like the pension someone in a fairly low paid public sector job could generate.

People also don’t realise how valuable some of the other terms are…such as death in service, or index linking of pensions.

Zilla1 · 03/09/2021 16:58

@whoopsnomore agreed. Many of my GP colleagues think there is a structured political campaign.

DobbyIsAFreeElf · 03/09/2021 16:56

I'm a HCA in NHS so band 2. Taking observations, personal cares, bloods, ECG's, catheters, yet I'm paid the same as the catering staff who plonk food on the patients table and leave it so they can't reach, or will even press the buzzer for the patient so that us HCA'S go move the table with food on over the patients bed.
I don't quite get how HCA'S with all that responsibility, that could actually put peoples lives at risks if a mistake is made can be paid on the same scale as someone handing out food and mopping floors.

tttigress · 03/09/2021 16:53

I worked for an outsourcing company that had many staff TUPE'd from the former British Rail.

Their Salary/Conditions were way better than people who joined this company directly, these people really were trapped because they new they could never get another job with the same pay/conditions.

whoopsnomore · 03/09/2021 16:45

Call me cynical, but in the context of underfunding and denigrating the NHS in order to justify privatising it bit by bit, I read this as feeding into a wider narrative being created to chip away at public confidence inthe NHS.

silkience · 03/09/2021 16:41

My adult DS applied for a job in our large local hospital, an admin role but advised it was high pressured and "efficiency is key"

I encouraged this, based on the rhetoric above about job security, good terms and conditions, pension, holiday etc.

It was his first job and he was naive, I didn't even think that he may not actually be working for the NHS. He was so thrilled to be offered the job with only a Zoom interview.

Three other in, turns out the company that employs him is based in the USA. HR is only accessible online and responses to queries are automated replies. Minimum wage unless specific targets are met. He has the minimum holiday (bank holidays come out of it) No sick pay at all. Toilet breaks are timed. Pay is directly related to performance (hitting the top hourly rate is only possible if you work like a machine, don't stop to use the toilet, talk to colleagues or make a drink) Culture is bullying, humiliation in front of colleagues if targets are missed (targets are for speed of inputting, amount of papers shredded per day etc)

I feel terrible that I encouraged this, I thought working in an office in a large NHS hospital would be a good step on the career ladder, reality is he would be better off at McDonald's.

ejhhhhh · 03/09/2021 16:40

Plenty of capitalists demand pay rises. They demand them by quitting and moving onto better paid jobs if better paying jobs are available. Or if they're a contractor say, they offer their services at a certain fee and if they don't get the appropriateness fee they don't do the work. I don't really get your argument about capitalism and socialism, as literally everyone "demands" a pay rises if they can and the market allows. I guess that's one of the reasons why the NHS struggles recruit and retain nurses and the like, similarly qualified people choose different careers with (to them) more appealing pay and terms and conditions. If they don't, how do explain the difficulty in recruitment and retention? Last time I checked we weren't a communist country, our employment markets are still market driven, even in the public sector.

1FootInTheRave · 03/09/2021 16:37

Terms are reasonable.

Working conditions are shit. Chronically understaffed with no let up on workload.

Pension is v expensive and I can't retire until late 60's. No where near the deal my older colleagues have.

Pay is stagnant, no decent rise since I qualified. Pay does not reflect the responsibility, workload and expectations. Let alone the unpaid overtime and lack of breaks (also unpaid).

For comparison, dh far outearns me. His t&c are similar minus sickpay. More flexibility, same holidays, company vehicle and fuel card etc. Plus, his qualifications were done and paid for on the job. I have numerous qualifications plus a yearly fee to stay on the nmc register.

Top b6 midwife currently working her notice period.

Fishingforhappiness · 03/09/2021 16:35

NHS worker here. It sounds promising. But as a b7 mixing my clinical with management of a busy team means I have not worked my 37.5hrs a week since obtaining the post. I take work home. Respond to emails at Al hours on average working 55hrs a week. Really, for what I do, the 3 degrees, the student debt, the wage is appalling compared to those who work in private pharma etc

ejhhhhh · 03/09/2021 16:33

If it was that great, compared to comparable professions both in the public and private sector, there wouldn't be a retention crisis. Opinions on this matter not one jot, it only matters in the NHS can manage to be adequately staffed with its current pay and conditions offering. In some roles I'm supposing it can, but in lots of essential roles it most certainly cannot, so you can't really come to the conclusion that the offering is good enough.

ActonSquirrel · 03/09/2021 16:31

the great terms and conditions that really get people stuck in the service, so they can't leave.

But they can leave, they don't want to. Because they know as much as they moan about the NHS they will be worse off with a private for profit employer.

All this talk of demanding pay rises and strikes: well it is easy to demand pay rises when it is public money.

People are socialists with other people's money but capitalists when it comes to their own.

Moaning about the overtime...I've never had paid overtime in my life.

Wheresmybiscuit3 · 03/09/2021 16:26

Just the area I worked in however and probably not a review of services elsewhere.

Good management is everything!!

Wheresmybiscuit3 · 03/09/2021 16:25

I was a band four for seven years in mental health. I had to leave. We were under staffed significantly. I was having to make decisions above my pay grade. No one cared. Management gave not one f* and were never there when the shit hit the fan.

I work for myself now and I’ve never regretted it. Just the timing with Covid! That has hit my business… but I can now sleep at night without worrying constantly! Priceless.

RedMarauder · 03/09/2021 16:23

@supermoonrising it is more nuance than that.

The government actually found the tax take went up when they reduced the top band of tax to 45% in 2013.

On the other hand Brown was slated for abolishing the 10% tax rate in 2007 even though the personal allowance was eventually raised.

NewYearmorestress · 03/09/2021 16:20

I'm nhs admin and can't qualify for the car leasing scheme due to salary. Not all admin are band 6/7

StrangeToSee · 03/09/2021 16:19

In mental health it’s very hard to progress past B5 unless you’re in an undesirable area that struggles to retain staff (my experience anyway). At B6 you have a lot of people to supervise, regular students, juniors and agency staff. To reach B7 you have to want to go into management. There were very few B7s in the places I worked. Most B7s had reached it by taking jobs they didn’t want (eg crisis team which usually has plenty of vacancies) then using it as a stepping stone.

It’s different in physical. But I know many MH nurses and allied professionals who have been a B5 for over a decade, simply because there aren’t any B6 vacancies in their area. The top of B5 is about £1,650 take home pay a month for 37.5 hrs so it doesn’t go far. Many MH professionals leave the NHS as jobs notoriously don’t fit with school hours, and if their partner is the higher earner it’s not worth paying for wraparound and holiday care on that salary.

ElephantOfRisk · 03/09/2021 16:17

It's hard to get rid of Drs as they stand very firm and support each other however incompetent. Nurses and other staff, not so much...

ChocolateDeficitDisorder · 03/09/2021 16:16

My DH is a band 7 nurse manager on just under £48k (Scotland).

He has most of his MSc and manages about 30 staff - he doesn't have time to do patient care now as he's too busy with recruitment/incidents/management/planning which is enormously stressful. His phone starts ringing at 7am and doesn't stop until 6pm, despite his hours of work being 9-5.

He's been in the NHS for 25 years and works very, very hard for his money. He will absolutely deserve his pension.

CBUK2K2 · 03/09/2021 16:14

@Hoowhoowho Speaking to friends who work for the NHS, they leave because it's a bureaucratic, box ticking, woke hell hole.

A strange misconception that the grass is greener being a smaller factor.

It's also possibly a self fulfilling fallacy, the media endlessly claims nurses are under paid/under valued, despite the obvious.

rc22 · 03/09/2021 16:13

I'm surprised it's difficult to get rid of incompetent staff in the NHS. I work in education and the government have made it extremely easy for head teachers to get rid of poor teachers or manage out staff that they simply don't like. Our unions are still strong in lots of respects but powerless against staff being unfairly bullied or managed out of schools.

RedMarauder · 03/09/2021 16:12

@Bunnycat101

Most people in the public sector don’t realise the value of their pension. It is a massive benefit but if you’re a 23 year old nurse with high cost of living, you’re probably not going to be valuing the prospect of the pension if you’re struggling day to day.

But… it really is massive and would cost a fortune to replicate with a private pot.

Having a high value pension pot is no good when you are struggling to pay your rent, bills, eat and travel to work.
Blossomtoes · 03/09/2021 16:11

If you don't like to pay don't do it, no one is making you

Which is why NHS staff are leaving in droves and there’s such a high vacancy rate. People are voting with their feet.