Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think NHS Staff have got amazing terms and conditions?

211 replies

backoffice · 03/09/2021 11:59

I've left the NHS to go back to the private sector after 15 years. I've been reflecting a lot on my time in the NHS and something in particular that has struck me time and again are the great terms and conditions that really get people stuck in the service, so they can't leave.

In my organisation over 1/3 of staff were Band 7 or above (40-45k). Many had been in the service for many years. Statistically almost half of NHS staff are earning over 31k (band 6 or above).

The pension accrual at this level is the equivalent of an additional £15-20k contributions on top of the salary if you were buying on the open market (I'm assuming around 1k p.a. for a Band 7 into the defined benefits scheme). So that's around 1/2 NHS staff with a package of around 50k.

These benefits are really significant - especially outside of London or other cities. And staff who perform very poorly cannot really be removed from the service - the unions are very strong and the processes are huge. I managed out one person but it ended up with a criminal case - i.e. the person committed a crime and I was still struggling to get rid of them.

I needed to leave the NHS for my mental health - the whole service is so traumatised - but the financial benefits of working there far, far outweigh anything in the private sector. Most staff are, I think, basically trapped. AIBU?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Crackl3andpop · 26/12/2021 05:05

I love these kind of threads. I’m ex NHS and DH has been there for 15ish years. His pay, pension, annual leave etc are a pretty good package. NHS terms are better than you’ll find most other places (think compassionate leave, dependant leave, maternity etc) but the environment is awful. People are hired where he works because they tick a box or are known to someone senior. Many of the people in the department he works in are incompetent and can’t actually do their job to the standard required… but nobody wants to take responsibility to get rid of them.

I think the problems are the same wherever you go to be honest - I work in the private sector and do more unpaid overtime than him and am expected to perform at a much higher level for less pay than I would if I had the same responsibilities in the nhs. It’s all swings and roundabouts in my opinion .

Letterlike · 25/12/2021 23:06

Reading this thread from Ireland makes me slightly understand how Brexit has happened - your NHS workers are brilliant and are probably not paid enough. Your private sector workers are exploited by ‘big capital’ and are scared to get sick and are looking for someone to blame that on… it’s actually shocking to see this debate. For the PP who said that 20k was the average salary in their town, can you rent/buy a house (you’d want to live in) in that town and live a decent life on that salary?

uneffingbelievable · 25/12/2021 22:40

I pay 12.5% of my salary into my N HS pension that buys me 1/54th of a pension.

You have divided £27k and said that is £500 and that is what you pay into your NHS pension per annum. On 27K and paying 9% per annum into your pension - it is a few pennies more than £500

Spectre8 · 25/12/2021 22:33

I've worked in private and now in public sector. My take home pay was much higher but the benefits less (less holidays, less sick days and contribution based pension) but now in public sector my take home pay is lower that what I could get in private but I've got more holidays, more sick day, defined benefit pension. So really for me its a case of which do you want more? More take home pay or are the benefits more important to you?

For me as I get older the benefits are more important than how much I actually take home.

Wheresmywoolyjumpers · 25/12/2021 22:24

I paid for my own education and as I have to be registered with my professional body to keep my job, I pay all those fees and the cost of my continuing professional development too. Don't know about nursing, so cant comment on that.

Wrongkindofovercoat · 25/12/2021 22:13

A lot depends on where in the service you work, today ( and quite often, this isn't just a festive occurrence ) as a band 5, I have had sole responsibility for a caseload of about 300 people,( probably almost double that if you include supporting another junior colleague in the the same position ) which is fine, I know the caseload really well and have more than enough experience to be able to triage any call outs appropriately. I have more clinical skills than some of my band 6 colleagues, and have the same level of responsibility at key times, but I am paid less.

TheHateIsNotGood · 25/12/2021 21:50

And do the NHS still do that 'professional' development thing where you can get paid to study? One of my sisters did that, converted to a degree and still moaned she lost her London Weighting during her (paid 18.5kpa) of study - living nearly in Sussex and gettting only a 2:2.

That was early 2000s so maybe things have changed since - all i know is the NHS have paid for a crappy nurse to further her career and she's been in charge of really crappy nursing services ever since.

First time I've ever said it, being sacred ground, but it's true.

echt · 25/12/2021 21:38

And staff who perform very poorly cannot really be removed from the service - the unions are very strong and the processes are huge

The processes are there to ensure fairness for all.

sleezeandwineparty · 25/12/2021 21:31

Also for your argument to work it would help if there wasn't a staffing crisis which pretty much blasts your argument people don't move because it's too cushy out of the water....
Also on that note, why is it a negative staff stay? I don't really understand this, you think continuity and experience are a bad thing and where would clinical staff go other than to the private sector...
So are you a Tory troll? Being as talks have been underway with American healthcare companies in the past few weeks.

Bonbon21 · 25/12/2021 21:26

So, I will retire in 2 years at 66 years of age... 22 years service, band 3 with £6000 per annum pension. Knackered now!! 37.5 hours per week, but usually work 45....

sleezeandwineparty · 25/12/2021 21:23

Nope, I am a registered nurse and during covid first lockdown I went back and got paid a band 5 (for 30 years experience, 20 in my specialty which was key during the pandemic) doing the same job I do in the private sector. I left in 2008 and was a band 6. my replacement (went back to my old department) was a band 5 so not only pay freezes but bands have been reduced as well. I did my 3 month contract and haven't gone back since, I earn twice as much in the private sector and pay an extra pension on top. I take holidays when I want and I am off for 2 weeks at the minute. I had utterly shocked at how badly paid my colleagues where compared to the private sector and how badly they are treated by hospital management. The only plus is sick pay but as I have one years salary in savings having been better paid, and no debts, I expect this is a moot point.

In 2008 I would have agreed with you and didn't want to leave the NHS. Not know, I don't think I will ever go back.

Wheresmywoolyjumpers · 25/12/2021 21:22

Overpaid!!!!!

Wheresmywoolyjumpers · 25/12/2021 21:21

I am a band 7. I have 3 degrees and a post grad certificate in order to do my job, plus costs from my professional development courses which I pay for myself. I was making similar to my current salary 20 years ago when I worked in the corporate world. But I wanted to feel more fulfilled at work and undertook a lot of expensive education in order to work in my field. So no, I dont feel I am underpaid.

EbonanzaScrooge · 25/12/2021 21:16

@Onandoff I would LOVE to know where you are! I’m a band 4 ‘pen pusher’ as you call it and considered to be very well paid while many of my other pen pusher colleagues are a band 3. The only band 6/7 or even 8 in my department are extremely qualified people who may not be front line but work horrifically hard behind the scenes.

I don’t know any PA’s who are above a band 4 whereas any nurse role in my health board starts at a band 5.

notanothertakeaway · 25/12/2021 21:14

@SpiderinaWingMirror

The benefits are fair. What has changed is that they are no longer offered in the private sector.
In the past, public sector jobs tended to have lower salaries but better benefits, whilst private sector had worse benefits but higher salaries

In many fields, private sector salaries have not kept up with inflation and benefits remain poor

TheHateIsNotGood · 25/12/2021 21:12

Do the NHS still do that accumulated sick leave thing? Seems most gripes here are interdeapartmental and not an actual comparison with the t&c's of many low-grade non-public sector workers.

Depends where you live really - round these parts (far SW) NHS and public sector jobs are very much sought after, for the working T&Cs that are far better than most jobs on offer - some of these jobs in other areas probably seem to be very unappealing compared to the many other jobs available.

One thing I've noticed is that, rather than train up the local workforce here, the best paid public sector jobs tend to go to the newcomers cashing in their properties and moving to a cheaper area, and getting these jobs based on 'work experience'.

Leaving the locals to the arse-wipe zero hours type jobs.

Notgoodpt · 25/12/2021 21:07

I would also like to mention that for clinical staff all this non sense of family friend job doesn’t apply. Children are off school for a week on Christmas, Easter or midterm and you have no family in the country? Too bad! We are short staffed on those dates so to be fair, everyone is only allowed to take 1 day parental leave. The rest of the days? It’s not our business. Your child is sick? You can only get 1 day carers leave once or twice a year, depending on your manager. The rest comes from your annual leave but you will be pushed to return to work ASAP.

In paper, it looks like we have a lot of benefits, special leave and flexible working but in real life, you cant have them as they are all at the discretion of you manager and they will always tell you that they have to look after the needs of the service. I wouldn’t mind making this sacrifice for my personal and family life if I was earning big bucks and hoping for a promotion. But to be stuck at 38k max I might as well work somewhere else with less stress.

Notgoodpt · 25/12/2021 20:53

Most people you worked with were above band 6, and the work wasn’t very stressful (only when you had to do your manager duties and sack someone)... It sounds like you are non clinical. In fairness, I think there should be a different pay scale for clinical and non clinical staff. Non- clinical non patient facing usually work at higher bands, can have flexiwork, work from home some days. Another poster saying that 27 days + 8 bank holidays is nearly 7 weeks of holidays a year also show how little they know about clinical work. We cannot take holidays when we want, we work on weekends and bank holidays. Which means, I may take a week off but my manager needs me to work on the weekend there for I only get 7 days off, whereas if you were an office worker you would get 10 days off in total. I could only take 2 days off this Christmas, which didn’t suit me at all. But I have 15 a/l days left, so I am told I will have to spend them in January or February, when it suits the service, not me.
In a normal ward or community team you have a band 7, a few 6s and a lot of 5,3,2. Same applies for allied health professionals. We are accountable for a lot, if you have ever dealt with physical/emotional abuse, a complaint or had to give evidence in court (even if it’s not your fault, the lawyers there do not feel pity that you are just a band 5 who saw the patient just for one session of physio, they will rip apart your notes!).
Somebody said that the issue won’t be fixed by throwing more money to us clinical staff but ibbwg to differ. Maybe me and my colleagues are selfish but I know of many excellent nurses who have recently left my trust to retrain in higher paid roles (IT mostly) or left to other countries were their knowledge if appreciated. Having worked in Australia in the past I can tell you that, no matter the stress, when I saw a lovely pay check, I felt more motivated to do more, I wanted more challenge and I felt everything was worth it. I’m back in U.K. for family reasons 5 years ago and I’m looking into retraining something non clinical. The shitty pay just makes me wonder why do I stress so much and do all the extra bits, if I will never be able to be a band 7. I started moaning and finding myself less proactive, it’s just not worth the trouble. Maenwhile my closest friends earn +50k and they are not at the top of their professions.
I keep lookin for a non clinical job in the nhs at my same band (6) to enjoy 9-5 hours and possibilities of promotion however they all ask for qualifications (finance, IT, business, etc). Can somebody point out which non clinical posts can clinical staff apply for? I am a physio (and before somebody asks, I have failed many band 7s interviews despite interview training, they want great examples in leadership and quality improvement, my examples are mediocre but at the same time I am not allowed to do anything else since we are always short staffed seeing patients on the ward non-stop).

NHSWoes · 04/09/2021 14:04

@StrangeToSee I know it frustrates and baffles me that individuals who are getting paid 2x as much are often not in the way of physical violence or managing complex risk in the same way.

StrangeToSee · 04/09/2021 13:58

The disparity between the responsibility of a Band 2/3 HCA or OT assistant is phenomenally different to admin on that (although they still have to work very hard!)

It tends to be the band 2/3 HCAs, PT and OT assistants who deal with the brunt of violence on MH wards, or de-escalate situations.

And for OT assistants they’re often running activity groups single handed and back to back, or taking patients outdoors (another big responsibility and risk) and that’s on top of assisting the OTs. From my experience in MH HCAs often get bodily fluids thrown or spat at them, have to help patients wash in the shower, dress, empty commodes, sit and chat to listen to their worries, plus keep up with their checks. If they get a check wrong (say the patient appears asleep, HCA doesn’t want to wake them so shines a torch from the door, then later it’s discovered patient tragically ligatured but hid it with the bedcovers. The HCA will be hauled up before coroners court and most likely be dismissed).

Same with community MH; if that HCA is the last person to see a patient alive they will have fo explain themselves. Eg patient may have seemed settled and content on their visit, but later taken a lethal overdose.

NHSWoes · 04/09/2021 13:39

I think that the overall package from the NHS is genuinely quite good but the problem as others have pointed out is the inconsistencies in AfC pay bands. The disparity between the responsibility of a Band 2/3 HCA or OT assistant is phenomenally different to admin on that (although they still have to work very hard!). I've name changed for this, but I have worked as an assistant psychologist in NHS Services and whilst I Ioved it, a Band 4 for a job that expected me to have a degree, postgraduate degree and a lot of experience and responsibility felt undervalued.

StrangeToSee · 04/09/2021 13:24

And staff who perform very poorly cannot really be removed from the service - the unions are very strong and the processes are huge

Not true everywhere. I’ve seen people swiftly put through the disciplinary process or capability (even on long term sick) then dismissed. They can appeal but rarely do. But then our trust has watertight policies for things like disciplinary, unauthorised lateness, excess sick leave etc. If sick long term they can claim you’re unable to do your job safely and offer redeployment, but that could be anywhere and isn’t pay protected; but if you decline they terminate your contract.

I’ve seen so many excellent staff leave due to rigid policies and procedures like this.

StrangeToSee · 04/09/2021 12:33

Band 2 and 3 salaries are ridiculous compared to the amount of skill and knowledge people need to be a HCA or OT/Physio assistant! Not to mention the responsibility.

cptartapp · 04/09/2021 08:59

Not all NHS nurses are on the AFC payscale or have the benefits of the terms and conditions, annual leave, sick pay etc you state.
I'm employed by GP's who set their own. There are thousands like me.

I kept the pension though. It's the only reason I'm still working as can go at 55 without penalty due to special class status. Maybe then all those Christmas days on my knees on urine soaked carpets washing ulcerated legs whilst my young DC were at home will be worth it.

malificent7 · 04/09/2021 08:56

Friend just left 1st nhs clinical job because of bullying...now going private. I'm just starting out after being bullied on 2 of 3 clinical placements...hoping i last!