Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the proposed NI increases for social care are unfair?

998 replies

shouldbeworkingmore · 03/09/2021 09:39

I recognise that social care needs funding but think that this proposal unfairly targets the younger generations. Plus we already have income taxes by stealth as the thresh holds have been frozen & wage stagnation is likely to continue for the next decade.

OP posts:
user1497207191 · 03/09/2021 12:21

@Petronius16

As an 84 year old who pays a bit of tax, I think everyone should contribute. Government doesn't want to tax the elderly because that's where they get a lot of votes - not mine I hasten to add. It's political.
It's not political along party lines. Labour increased NIC twice, and since they don't get the core Pensioner vote, they didn't do it to protect pensioners.
OnlyFoolsnMothers · 03/09/2021 12:21

@Coogee

Younger working people have always paid for the elderly.

Why should today’s younger people be any different?

Because the elderly didn’t want to help the young- did they object to uni fees, piss poor early years provisions- the boomers took and took and took!
shouldbeworkingmore · 03/09/2021 12:19

Younger working people have always paid for the elderly.

Why should today’s younger people be any different?

No one is arguing to not pay any tax or NI though so I'm not sure why you think younger people don't think they should pay for the elderly?

OP posts:
NekoShiro · 03/09/2021 12:19

As a young person I'd rather pay extra into social care now so that I can rest assured that the elderly in my family are being taken care of if they need to be, instead of me having to stop my life to care for them fully.

Booknooks · 03/09/2021 12:17

I do think that the system needs an overhaul, whilst there are companies operating purely for profit, and a real disparity in the care available depending on postcode and income, increasing funding won't actually do as much as it could do if it was in conjunction with changes.

Not sure what the answer is, I'm happy to pay more to ensure everyone receives the care they need, but I'm not sure just adding £££s into an ineffective system is the best way.

Bagamoyo1 · 03/09/2021 12:17

@Puzzledandpissedoff

Dementia is seen as a cash cow for care home owners

No doubt, but folk can't have it all ways. Far fewer suffered dementia years ago because they didn't live long enough to get it, but now they're kept alive way beyond what would have been a natural lifespan it's become an epidemic

Nobody's suggesting actually killing off the elderly, but in a society where death's become something to avoid at all costs there'll be consequences

This is so true. The death of someone over 100 is now seen as a medical failure. It’s madness.
meltingmyhead · 03/09/2021 12:17

Yanbu, this combined with the cut to universal credit is just going to make things worse for the lowest paid

Seasonschange · 03/09/2021 12:16

[quote EstuaryBird]**@JaneKing75

I don't know if that's true, I left home at 16, worked in a call centre at night and went to university in 1994. I wasn't the only one at all. Very few on my course had parents chipping in for anything at all

You’re talking about 1994, I’m talking about 1972. They’re not comparable. Different times, different experiences.[/quote]
My father , working class , went in 1964 . He claimed JSA in holidays and lived off his grant otherwise. He said he was pretty broke but it was more money then he’d ever had before.

My mother went in 76. As did her two sisters . Middle class but my grandmother has told me she couldn’t afford to contribute. They all lived of their grants and worked through the holidays (and paid board at home!) They were unusually progressive parents which no doubt helped all 3 get to uni but the idea that in the days of grants people couldn’t afford uni isn’t accurate. Social attitudes I’m sure held working class people back but the money was there.

And for the person comparing the high tax wage at the time with student loans now… Comparing a high tax on a job you did for a few years to £40,000 debt at 21 with 6% interest which effectively leads to a career long 9% tax is just apples and oranges .

Coogee · 03/09/2021 12:14

Younger working people have always paid for the elderly.

Why should today’s younger people be any different?

Petronius16 · 03/09/2021 12:14

As an 84 year old who pays a bit of tax, I think everyone should contribute. Government doesn't want to tax the elderly because that's where they get a lot of votes - not mine I hasten to add. It's political.

Disneycharacter · 03/09/2021 12:14

You pay NI until you retire so all workers, especially higher earners (who tend to be older) will pay more. So this young persons impact only, is nonsense.

DynamoKev · 03/09/2021 12:13

IR35 had little impact on most true contractors.
That is a straight out lie.

LindyLou2020 · 03/09/2021 12:13

@tattymacduff

Can there not be a calm, sensible debate without this language?

Someone upthread talked about "oldies" rattling around in their big houses. Others are saying that pensioners should be hit harder with council tax to force them to downsize. That is not a calm or sensible debate, it is bigoted though.

IMHO ageism is alive and very, very well, and gets nowhere near as much acknowledgement and action as other forms of discrimination. Older people can be easy targets because many can't speak up due to frailty, illness, etc. I used to work in Social Services, and local authorities used to own their own care homes until sometime around the 1980's. They weren't always the best places, but at least there was no profit element involved. I'd love to see residential care brought back into NHS and/or local authority control, but this is as likely to happen as Boris Johnson becoming celibate.......
Plumtree391 · 03/09/2021 12:13

@thereisonlyoneofme

Where do you think the money should come from then ? People keep moaning about the state of social care and the NHs but dont want to pay for it. Why does it unfairly impact younger generations, people over 30 do work as well you know.
I expect the op meant people of working age.

It isn't just pensioners who may require social care, however it mainly is. I am a retired person and paid my whack in my working life, still pay a little income tax. I haven't needed any help and hope I never do but I wouldn't think it unfair to access it if I did. I certainly don't begrudge any of my contributions going towards helping others. Having said that I do not trust the government to manage our contributions fairly or wisely but that's nothing new.

Gallowayan · 03/09/2021 12:13

The retired population tend to vote Conservative. The younger working population tend not to. HTH

RosesAndHellebores · 03/09/2021 12:12

I am pleased with the decision but feel a tax increase may be more appropriate.

caravanman · 03/09/2021 12:12

I know this is a little off topic. However, my son is in supported accommodation, having lived for three years in residential care, and my mother (in her nineties) has a carer every day. The carers and support staff are dedicated and highly skilled people (you need a specialised skills set to talk down a seriously mentally ill young man or to dress an elderly lady in a way that retains her dignity). However, the staff who perform these roles are on the minimum wage.

Both companies who provide the support are private, but my son's funding comes from a joint health and social care budget. However, I do not think the carer's pay would be greater if they were employed by the LA.

Caring and support work needs to be valued so much more. I work and I pay taxes. I would willingly pay more tax if this enabled an increase in the wages of those people who provide the care and support to the most vulnerable in society.

MatildaIThink · 03/09/2021 12:12

@Whycangirlsbesonasty

I really think that some of the biggest questions in the way we run our country should be addressed by coalitions, not the government. The NHS, social care, triple lock pensions, inheritance tax, house prices. These all need addressing for the long term benefit of the country, but won’t be addressed as it is politically damaging to do so.
The problem is coalitions consisting of whom? We already have the problem that too many people only act in their own short term interest. Getting them to think long term or about other people is nigh on impossible.

The triple lock needs to go, inheritance tax needs to be abolished, the tax system needs to raise much more revenue from a much wider range of people. We need to invest more in education and healthcare. House prices will sort themselves out if we deal with the supply and demand issue, but if we ignore population growth there is nothing we can realistically do.

However Conservative voters will generally vote for taxes not to rise because they do not want to pay more and Labour voters will generally vote for tax rises on people who earn more than them, because they do not want to pay more. Whilst both groups of voters will demand the government spend more on them.

Gimlisaxe · 03/09/2021 12:11

@MatildaIThink

Those are horrific figures.

But we got our borders back.

shouldbeworkingmore · 03/09/2021 12:10

@MatildaIThink that's depressing

OP posts:
shouldbeworkingmore · 03/09/2021 12:10

@Whycangirlsbesonasty I agree

OP posts:
user1497207191 · 03/09/2021 12:08

@CuriousaboutSamphire

I don't get it. I really don't.
  • We, everyone working, need to contribute more to the whole gamut of social care.
  • NI is ringfenced monies specfically for that.
  • OP thinks that paying more via NI is somehow unfair

How else should we pay it?
Via general taxation, where it won't be ringfenced?

What about those who aren't "working" but have higher incomes than those who are?

I.e. pensioners with gold plated occupational pensions?

People living on investment income, such as from property rentals, share portfolios, etc.

Lots of "non workers" have incomes higher than average earning workers, yet don't pay any NIC.

How is that fair?

Recent "taxes" have disproportionately hit workers, i.e. workplace pensions, NIC, student loan repayments, child benefit clawback.

Whycangirlsbesonasty · 03/09/2021 12:08

I really think that some of the biggest questions in the way we run our country should be addressed by coalitions, not the government. The NHS, social care, triple lock pensions, inheritance tax, house prices. These all need addressing for the long term benefit of the country, but won’t be addressed as it is politically damaging to do so.

MatildaIThink · 03/09/2021 12:07

@Gimlisaxe

I think it should come from the £350million we are meant to be saving from being in the EU.

Because there is no way the government lied, keep lying, breaking promises and get away with it every single time and keep being voted in.

Based on current economic predictions Brexit has had a net cost of between £400 and £700 million per week, a totally accurate figure is difficult as some of it is tied up with Covid at the moment, but the most likely is in the middle of that. So far from saving us £350 million a week, it has cost us £550 million a week, or if we want to use some other metrics the cost of Brexit is the same as building two hospitals a week, 50 schools a week, one weeks cost is enough to house 30k people in nursing homes for a whole year. The annual cost of Brexit is more than the total raised by Council Tax, you could raise everyone's tax free allowance by £4,500 per year etc.

But I suppose people got blue passports and could tell some other people to "go home".

nonono1 · 03/09/2021 12:06

However, I just don't like the argument that "young people shouldn't have to pay for the elderly" as all my peers are certainly happy to pay. It just seems like a lazy argument/an excuse to justify not caring about others. Isn't looking after other people essentially the point of society?!

I agree. One day those young people will be old too!

Swipe left for the next trending thread