Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to be really upset that DH complains we are overspending on my birthday

60 replies

freckles20 · 03/09/2021 09:09

Brief background : DH earns more than me. My family business went into voluntary liquidation 2 years ago and I am now self employed. Covid and my 14yo sons poor MH (he hasn't been able to be left alone sometimes) have meant that my business hasn't been as profitable as I hoped but it is now improving.

DH has always encouraged me in my work.

DH is not DS' dad.

We are comfortably off. I am very conscious that I'm not bringing in as much money as I should and I try not to spend more than necessary. Just for context, and not for a pity party as examples I cut my own hair, keep social spending to a minimum, no new clothes and absolutely no unnecessary spending on myself.

DH is a kind, caring, generous man usually.

Today is my birthday. He had insisted that we go out with some friends for dinner. He knew I wasn't too bothered but kept mentioning it so I asked a friend, her DH and DD and we are going out for some Tapas.

My friends are going away for a catch up overnight this weekend. When they invited me I declined because I didn't want to spend the money and also my sons MH is very tricky atm so it's hard it's hard to leave him. When DH found this out he arranged for me to join my friends and paid for my share of hotel. He also organised for my mum to have my son as he will be working. I was really pleased but already felt guilty.

Fast forward to my birthday today and he asks me if my friend's DH paid for everyone's food when we went out for my friends birthday. I said that he did and that I would put the meal on my credit card.

He snapped at me that "we are spending money like water". I feel really upset, he acknowledges that it was a thoughtless thing to say but he's cross with me as he feels I'm totally overacting and I've blown things out of proportion.

I am very tearful. I feel guilty and frustrated. I work outside and he was going to join me as he's off work today but I just want to be alone because I can't seem to pull myself together. He's now angry at my overreaction.

Am I being unreasonable to be so upset? And if I am how am I supposed to be 'less upset' and not 'overreact'?

OP posts:
IWasBornInAThunderstorm · 03/09/2021 12:40

But it does sound like he has worries about your financials.

IWasBornInAThunderstorm · 03/09/2021 12:39

He snapped at me that "we are spending money like water". I think he could have said something different if he was worried about paying for your friends. Like "we can't afford to pay for them, do you think they'd pay for themselves?"

LegendaryReady · 03/09/2021 12:35

I think it's possible to be concerned about "spending like water" without actually begrudging the thing that brought the worry to a head.

He was worried, he said something he shouldn't have and he's apologised.

Yes, I think needing a day to cry about it, especially when he clearly wants to spend your birthday with you is overreacting.

Sandinmyknickers · 03/09/2021 12:17

When I go out for a meal for a friends birthday, I don't expect expect to pay for me. If anything, I expect that we will all split the bill to also cover the cost for the birthday girls meal between us
To me, it sounds like you have a lovely DH who was trying to do a nice thing for you, and then snapped a little because he suddenly realised it would cost more than he bargained for and he's feeling stressed and under pressure to provide
Yes he probably shouldn't have snapped and yanbu to feel a bit upset...but I don't think he's been an arsehole or gaslighted you. You are both stressed and trying your best. Can you both calm down, and discuss your budget?

Also, happy birthday

DogFoodPie · 03/09/2021 11:32

You can't invite everyone for a birthday meal and then not pay for it all unless you arrange it that way from the beginning and everyone knows. It's like he thinks it might be fine for your friends to turn up at the meal and you suddenly say oh btw we are splitting the bill. No-one does that.
Snapping is a sign of stress, he's prob just had a load of things to pay for and is feeling the burden right now.
No HIBU because he knows OP is being very careful with money because she is very aware of the financial situation, and never asked for any of these treats because of the expense but he insisted and went to the extent of secretly arranging the hotel for her. If he thought it was too expensive he didn't need to arrange it. To bring up it being too expensive when it's too late to change is just nasty.

znaika · 03/09/2021 11:16

I don't think this is a marriage breaker. I think a lot of MNers are SAHM or work part time and don't realise the immense stress and burden it is to be the sole earner or the only one whose income can relied upon. Esp if your job is stressful and you fantasize about quitting. MNers always say their husbands love their jobs but even if that is generally true there can be times when you just want the relentlessness of it to end. Snapping is a sign of stress, he's prob just had a load of things to pay for and is feeling the burden right now.

That is not to say that if feela you or your son are a burden but being the one who keeps the show on the road and the family ATM can suck at times.

Seeingadistance · 03/09/2021 11:10

Is it possible that his own job is under threat and he is worrying about money? If he’s not usually like this, then he might have financial worries that he’s not sharing.

girlmom21 · 03/09/2021 11:05

I genuinely think he's probably just spent more than he'd planned to and he's a bit stressed by it.

Bluntness100 · 03/09/2021 10:58

I’m not really aligned with the other posters, who hasn’t snapped at their partner ever? I mean cmon really?

It’s not normal to be crying all day becayse he simply said you were both spending money like water. I think that’s more to do with your self esteem and confidence in the situation you’re in financially.

freckles20 · 03/09/2021 10:51

Thank you all for replying. Lots to think about.

OP posts:
PercyPiginaWig · 03/09/2021 10:05

@SpacePotato

Why would he arrange it, pay for hotel etc THEN moan about money?

Is he usually such a dick? Making you feel shit so you either don't enjoy it or don't go?

I don't understand why you would pay for everyone else's food on your birthday though? My friend's have always paid for themselves, but then none of us could afford to pay for everyone else too.

He would arrange it so he looks like a nice guy.

It actually comes across to me that he is a horrible cunt who has done such a good job of gaslighting the OP that she actually thinks he's nice.

I am usually more subtle because the OP will read a comment like mine and probably dismiss it completely, but I'd bet a lot of money on the fact that he is controlling and abusive and she tries to keep the peace because she's grateful he throws crumbs of affection her way, and more importantly doesn't want to rock the boat with her son's mental health issues.
Any chance living in this environment could be contributing to them?

OverTheRubicon · 03/09/2021 10:00

The whole situation sounds difficult, as you are clearly very aware and trying hard about.

If a woman posted on here to say that her DH and his DD were living together, and that he hadn't earned any money for many years after losing his business and then more recently investing in a new one that wasn't really profitable, and that she'd snapped after organising a birthday thing but then discovering that they'd be paying for their friends for dinner too... People would be speaking very differently.

If he truly is otherwise decent, then he's behaved badly but it is forgivable.

You do need to fix your financial situation. Either he's a decent bloke who behaved badly because he's stressed about money, or he's an arse and you need financial independence.
If your 14 year old's MH is so bad that they can't be left alone, have you looked into support available as a carer? Are you getting maintenance? Does your child have another parent or involved family member who can support so you can put proper time into your business or find a more stable paying job?

Cam77 · 03/09/2021 09:56

@freckles20
feel really upset, he acknowledges that it was a thoughtless thing to say but he's cross with me as he feels I'm totally overacting and I've blown things out of proportion

So he acknowledges he was a dick. If his apology is genuine that’s all there is to it surely? Decent people do act like dicks occasionally. As long as they acknowledge it afterwards and it doesn’t become a habit, it’s all good. There’s no such thing as the “perfect” partner, any more than there is the “perfect” person. People used to accept this fact was true for both men and women, without the first reaction being “he’s gaslighting you!!”.

Quartz2208 · 03/09/2021 09:48

He married you with your son OP I think you need to have a proper conversation really about all of this because I dont think the current situation is working for you

freckles20 · 03/09/2021 09:47

@girlmom21

YANBU to feel a bit upset about what he said and the way he said it but has it been an expensive month?

Has DS had new school uniform/shoes etc?

Just playing devils advocate really but maybe he's just a bit stressed about cash at the moment and he'd forgot about this expense or hadn't budgeted for it?

Yes it has been quite expensive as we had a uk holiday.

I try to pay fior DS specific stuff myself so I bought his uniform....

OP posts:
Cam77 · 03/09/2021 09:46

Everybody occasionally snaps when under pressure and everybody is unreasonable sometimes. It’s unfortunate his 1% strop was on your birthday but if he’s a decent person the other 99% of the time, as you say he is, he probably feels bad about it already. Probably nothing more to it than that and I’d ignore the “he’s a terrible man”, “gaslighting!”, “LTB! ” comments.

Quartz2208 · 03/09/2021 09:38

So presumably this is your own credit card.

It is very hard @freckles20 to wade through here what is your DH and what is your guilt about

Brief background : DH earns more than me. My family business went into voluntary liquidation 2 years ago and I am now self employed. Covid and my 14yo sons poor MH (he hasn't been able to be left alone sometimes) have meant that my business hasn't been as profitable as I hoped but it is now improving.

And what is you being worried about your son

What is your communication normally like?

billy1966 · 03/09/2021 09:35

Well you don't spend a penny because he has clearly communicated to you that you shouldn't.

He doesn't have to say it outright, just complain about how ye are "going through money like water".

How long are ye together?

What is he like to your son?

Has his meanness and gaslighting been a contributing factor in your sons problems?

I think you need to stop gaslighting YOURSELF and be honest about this man.

He has effectively ruined your birthday.

And you think he is kind?
Flowers

girlmom21 · 03/09/2021 09:32

YANBU to feel a bit upset about what he said and the way he said it but has it been an expensive month?

Has DS had new school uniform/shoes etc?

Just playing devils advocate really but maybe he's just a bit stressed about cash at the moment and he'd forgot about this expense or hadn't budgeted for it?

freckles20 · 03/09/2021 09:29

@username40683

I am concerned at the fact that as a family you are financially comfortable but that you can't buy anything for yourself or even get your hair cut. You also seem too concerned that you are not contributing enough. When I was on maternity recently I contributed alot less to the joint bills. DH picked up gap and whilst I had to be abit more careful due to us having less money. DH did not expect me to give up buying things I needed for myself or getting my hair cut. Sorry but I sense abit of financial abuse/control here.

With regard to the comment I agree with PP he was gas lighting you.

I guess it feels different as DS is not DH's son. DH has a stressful job and earns well and I feel guilty for not doing my bit hence me trying to keep my spending down- he doesn't encourage me to do this, I create my own guilt but then t feels very justified after his comment today
OP posts:
billy1966 · 03/09/2021 09:28

Unfortunately OP he doesn't sound the least bit kind.

He sounds mean spirited and tight.
He was very unkind in his comment.

He did a "nice" thing but begrudges you this gift.

Mean, not kind.

And you know it.
Your gut is screaming it to you and that is why you are tearful.

He also is annoyed you are upset?

Controlling too.

Your post reads to me that YOU are trying to convince yourself your husband is a good kind man.

I can tell you he doesn't read like that.

He reads as mean, unkind, controlling.

You are comfortably off but you don't feel you can afford a haircut.

Kindly...ffs wake up.

Kind? My arse.
He sounds like a right bully.

Happy birthday OP.Flowers

freckles20 · 03/09/2021 09:26

@SpacePotato

Why would he arrange it, pay for hotel etc THEN moan about money?

Is he usually such a dick? Making you feel shit so you either don't enjoy it or don't go?

I don't understand why you would pay for everyone else's food on your birthday though? My friend's have always paid for themselves, but then none of us could afford to pay for everyone else too.

He's not usually a dick.

I agree with you about not needing to pay for everyone. I guess it felt like we should this time though.

OP posts:
Shoxfordian · 03/09/2021 09:25

He doesn’t sound too lovely to me

freckles20 · 03/09/2021 09:24

@WomanStanleyWoman and @Quartz2208 sorry to have confused you.

So when DH asked me if my friends husband had paid when we went out for her bday I instantly felt guilty. Hence me suggesting I paid on my credit card. I guess I had assumed DH would pay until he mentioned it.

My friends birthday meal was similar- the three of us joined the three of them. Friends DH snuck off and paid before we had a chance to see the bill.

OP posts:
Sundancerintherain · 03/09/2021 09:23

How does he usually act on your Birthday? Christmas? Anniversary?